Re: Do you want a repping system at all?
I voted "I don't care"; it depends on the system. I wouldn' t mind it being back if it could be tweaked in such a way that not only are you required to leave a reason why you're giving that person rep but the boards also record the person who gave it.
No. I don't like an auto-name-sign thing. That will only encourage rep wars, IMO. If someone sees their neg-repped, they could just neg-rep the person who gave them the neg-rep back and then the original neg-repper will neg-rep the recipient again and it will become an endless pattern. Based on when that was enable for Senior Members at the Naruto Forums (I've heard the stories), I'd rather it have the option for being anonymous (one similar to the original rep system here).
P.S. Why have an "I don't care" option, when those will just be counted as no votes anyways? Seems kind of redundant IMO. The I don't Care votes shouldn't be counted for either side, IMO. In the event that there is a tie, the mods should decide of course. And whichever one, Yes or No, has the most votes, should be how things should go. And if Yes and No end up being tied, and I don't care has the most votes, then I think it should be up to the staff to decide. At least that's what I think...