- Joined
- Jan 5, 2012
- Messages
- 2,946
- Reaction score
- 2,385
- Gender
- Male
- Country
The Tenryubito are the descendants of 19 of the 20 families that defeated the Ancient Kingdom. They have the supreme authority over the World and their words are absolute. However they are complete goofballs, aside from Doflamingo and Rosinante that grew up outside of Mariejois for the larger part of their lives. Even their father was very naive, so much that it lead to his own demise. None of them seem to care about politics at all.
The Gorosei are the Five Political leaders of the World. According to Akainu, they are "Puppets of the Tenryubito". However, that creates a couple of questions.
1. The first involves another very popular theory, the theory that the Gorosei are very old due to Bonney's power. They looked the same over 20 years ago, which is very odd considering Oda usually creates different looks for almost every character, even if it is a much smaller timespan. Bonney is also much older than she looks like, as hinted by an SBS.
So if the Gorosei got the gift of "eternal life", why would the Tenryubito allow that for their "puppets?", but apparently not for themselves? We know they don't because the Donquixote Family is no longer among them after Homing and his children left. If they would have "eternal life" there should be some Donquixote grandfathers and grandmothers, and great-grand..., etc, around.
2. The Marines are clearly not pro-Tenryubito, at least Akainu isn't, and Sengoku is a man who follows and believes in orders, but has a good heart so he most likely wasn't pleased with them as well. It is very likely that others before them had similar thoughts, especially considering the marines premise (Justice) and the timeframe of 800 years of Tenryubito rule. There apparently has never been a military coup d'etat and the reason for that I think are the Gorosei, which represent a more normal political system beneath the Tenryubito, with laws and actual politics. And that system works, there is war in the One Piece world, but the status quo is quite acceptable.
3. The Gorosei seem to be aware of the lost History. Again, why would the Tenryubito allow that?
4. In the real world absolutist monarchies, there was no way people in such a high office would not be aristocrats themselves and I think the office is so important that only the highest ranked aristocrats would get it. See Saudi Arabia, most of the important positions are shared among the royal family.
5. Who are the Gorosei anyway and why is their identity such a big deal? Oda names even the most minor characters and I'm pretty sure he's got tons of letters asking for the Gorosei names, but that topic never pops up in SBS.
6. The Tenryubito are braindead retarded. While their ancestors likely were not, how could they become like this? It is because they could give away their resposibilities and enjoy their high lives. If you had absolute power, wouldn't you give away your responsibilities only to someone you definitely can trust?
I had another argument but I forgot it while writing this -.-
So anyways I think the Gorosei are secretly Tenryubito themselves and actually their leaders. They pretend to be normal governemnt officials to create a progressive image and fool the public that there is actually some constitutional part in their government, thus protecting the Tenryubito due to creating an acceptable status quo for the public.
The Gorosei are the Five Political leaders of the World. According to Akainu, they are "Puppets of the Tenryubito". However, that creates a couple of questions.
1. The first involves another very popular theory, the theory that the Gorosei are very old due to Bonney's power. They looked the same over 20 years ago, which is very odd considering Oda usually creates different looks for almost every character, even if it is a much smaller timespan. Bonney is also much older than she looks like, as hinted by an SBS.
So if the Gorosei got the gift of "eternal life", why would the Tenryubito allow that for their "puppets?", but apparently not for themselves? We know they don't because the Donquixote Family is no longer among them after Homing and his children left. If they would have "eternal life" there should be some Donquixote grandfathers and grandmothers, and great-grand..., etc, around.
2. The Marines are clearly not pro-Tenryubito, at least Akainu isn't, and Sengoku is a man who follows and believes in orders, but has a good heart so he most likely wasn't pleased with them as well. It is very likely that others before them had similar thoughts, especially considering the marines premise (Justice) and the timeframe of 800 years of Tenryubito rule. There apparently has never been a military coup d'etat and the reason for that I think are the Gorosei, which represent a more normal political system beneath the Tenryubito, with laws and actual politics. And that system works, there is war in the One Piece world, but the status quo is quite acceptable.
3. The Gorosei seem to be aware of the lost History. Again, why would the Tenryubito allow that?
4. In the real world absolutist monarchies, there was no way people in such a high office would not be aristocrats themselves and I think the office is so important that only the highest ranked aristocrats would get it. See Saudi Arabia, most of the important positions are shared among the royal family.
5. Who are the Gorosei anyway and why is their identity such a big deal? Oda names even the most minor characters and I'm pretty sure he's got tons of letters asking for the Gorosei names, but that topic never pops up in SBS.
6. The Tenryubito are braindead retarded. While their ancestors likely were not, how could they become like this? It is because they could give away their resposibilities and enjoy their high lives. If you had absolute power, wouldn't you give away your responsibilities only to someone you definitely can trust?
I had another argument but I forgot it while writing this -.-
So anyways I think the Gorosei are secretly Tenryubito themselves and actually their leaders. They pretend to be normal governemnt officials to create a progressive image and fool the public that there is actually some constitutional part in their government, thus protecting the Tenryubito due to creating an acceptable status quo for the public.