What?!
I mean i respect your opinion and i could agree with you to a certain extent. Irene has been trashed and it makes sense that a capable Dragon Slayer should be able to one shot her (in Dragon Form) if a no-bones-left Erza was able to with close to no power in that sword slash.
So i could see where you're coming from with Gajeel > Irene, eventhough i disagree.
But when you're saying that Irene can't touch Gajeel because he can turn into a shadow... You lost me entirely.
Even GMG Gajeel was able to grab Rogue when Rogue was in shadow form. SInce when have turning into shadow become top tier?
Is Rogue a top tier character because of this ability? Of course he's not. Having this ability doesn't automatically means you won. Or are you implying that Rogue would also beat Irene because she wouldn't be able to hit him?
It might be a great advantage when dealing with an opponent that's close to him in terms of power level. That's not the case here.
Plus, how would turning into a shadow help Gajeel against Irene who can just fly and drop spells from above?
Now don't get me wrong, im not here to start an argument, in fact i don't really care about the tournament anymore. And i've always despised Irene. But saying she can't hit Gajeel because shadows, is extremely far fetched.
Well, Gajeel was able to grab Rogue because they were both in shadow form. So a shadow can grab another shadow, that makes sense.
But Gajeel's shadow form will grant him a fair amount of intangibility against Irene's physical attacks. So Dragon Irene's claw swipe would miss Gajeel completely if he's in shadow form.
Deus Sema and other blasts could injure Gajeel in his shadow form, but then again, Gajeel can merely tank those.
Especially since an exhausted 95% broken boned Erza tanked Irene's strongest enchantment spell.
Technically, Rogue's shadow was the whole reason why Sting even won against Larcade..
So being in shadow form makes quite a bit of a difference if you ask me.
It doesn't automatically give somebody the victory, but its intangibility effect will definitely be a major factor for dodging physical attacks, such as Dragon Irene's claw swipe.
I mean, really..
Gajeel's performance against a Spriggan was
a lot better than Irene's performance against a young girl + her own daughter.. The winner is obvious here.
What's really far-fetched in my eyes is how much people are overhyping
-- Universe One, Battlefield Removal, Enchantment Blasts, Deus Sema, and Claw Swipe
--
How the hell is
one claw swipe going to win the battle for Irene?
Erza
still destroyed a damn meteor
after tanking a claw swipe.
Erza
still destroyed the almighty Deus Sema
after having all her bones crushed.
At this point, Irene's feats are getting massively extrapolated and ridiculous.