Games Mafia Game 79 - Marvel Cinematic Universe - END GAME

[Asako]

Will post them soon and update everything at the same time that needs to be updated...

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 16, 2020, Original Post Date: Apr 4, 2020 ---

Teams
Team captain America
Holt
MarmaladeSky
Seraph
James Rye
DigitalDude
Gajeel
Copy Panda
Buffynut

Team ironman
Farfalla
Takuan
Knightmare of heaven 0
Sonofdaws
belserion
desin24
benomaru
Hardy


Team thanos
Grysun
Crescent Jinx
Erinyes
demonspeed
juviii
goodboy_lawlett
Lady pompom
Lambu

Players that have the power stone
Day 1
Demon form Team Thanos
Day 2
Hardy form Team ironman
Day 3
DigitalDude form Team captain America, dies
Erin form team thanos
Day 4
Bel form Team IronMan
Day 5
Seraph form Team Cap
Day 6
Erin Form Team thanos
Day 7
Bel form team ironmam
Day 8
Erin form team thanos

Actions:
Day1:
Law/gambler >>>>Gambling on holt to vote knightmare>>>> coin flip>>>>> fail

Night 1
Priority 1:
Crescent Jinx/escort >>> block Lambu

Priority 2:
Lambu/mortician >>>> investigate pompom >>>get blocked
Erinyes/sickly >>>infect james
Gry/insane det>>>>>>>Investigate digitaldude >>> get guilty

Priority 3:
Benomaru/boss>>>>kill grysun >>>success
Sonsofdaws/burden >>>kill knightmare >>>get recruited

Night 2:
Priority 1:
(〜￣△￣)〜

Priority 2:
Hardy/sane det >>>>>Investigate law>>>>gets guilty
Taku/bodyguard >>>>>> Protect farfalla

Priority 3:
Belserion/insane doc >>>>use on farfalla>>> coin flip >>>> kill taku cuz bodyguard protection
Benomaru/boss>>>>kill DD >>>success
Sonsofdaws >>> kill panda >>> success

Night 3
Priority 1:
Crescent Jinx/escort >>> erin

Priority 2:
Lambu/mortician >>>> investigate panda
Erinyes/sickly >>>infect gajeel >>>get blocked

Priority 3:
Benomaru/boss>>>>kill lambu >>>success
Sonsofdaws >>> kill farfalla >>>success

Night 4:
Priority 1:
♪(((#^-^)八(^_^*)))♪

Priority 2:
Hardy/sane det >>>>>Investigate juviii>>>gets innocent
Belserion/insane doc >>>>use on hardy>>> coin flip >>>> protect Hardy

Priority 3:
Benomaru/boss>>>>kill bel>>>Recruit Her Instead
Knightmare >>> kill holt >>> success


Night 5:
Priority 1:
Marma/Prostitute >>>> block knightmare

Priority 2:
James/sane doc >>>>use on hardy>>> fail Cuz Strongman

Priority 3:
Bel >>>Kill Juviii
Seraph/Strongman >>>>Kill Hardy

Night 6:
Priority 1:
└(=^‥^=)┐

Priority 2:
erin/sickly >>>>use on James>>> success

Priority 3:
beno/boss >>>Kill desin
Sonofdaws/burden >>>>Kill marma

Night 7:
Priority 1:
╭(°ㅂ°)╮╰(°ㅂ°)╯
Priority 2:
╭(°ㅂ°)╮╰(°ㅂ°)╯

Priority 3:
Bel >>>Kill seraph
Sonofdaws >>>>Kill beno

 

[Gajeel]

Speaking of not making sense, Gajeel, investigator is easy to fake, especially with the Mortician dead.

Besides:

• "Investigator (Townie): The Investigator can investigate a dead player whose role is hidden(shows as ???). He uses his ability by sending a PM to the host at night so that only he get to know the unknown role. (GAME 24)"

The roles don't appear as "???", only Janitor kills appear like that.

That is why I stated that my role is not at its full potential, but whatever, I could have proved it at the beginning if I had the stone which I would have done if I had gotten a result but my words have no meaning at this point of the game I guess.

 

[desin24]

That is why I stated that my role is not at its full potential, but whatever, I could have proved it at the beginning if you wanted but my words have no meaning at this point of the game I guess.

If you could prove it back then can you also prove it now? No need to give up yet.

 

[Juviii]

That is why I stated that my role is not at its full potential, but whatever, I could have proved it at the beginning if you wanted but my words have no meaning at this point of the game I guess.

Not having the stone has nothing to do with the potential of your role. I fail to see how is that even a hint about that role.
I think you were thinking of claiming something else when you said that.

 

[Gajeel]

Not having the stone has nothing to do with the potential of your role. I fail to see how is that even a hint about that role.
I think you were thinking of claiming something else when you said that.

I meant that we already know which faction the dead player is with these mechanics while we wouldn't have known that in a normal set up game (since it's ???). That's the whole potential I was talking about.

 

[Erinyes]

@Gajeel if you were really an investigator, you would have shared your role and your stone yesterday with nor risk, you hadnt the stone, plus we had 2docs claims, 1 det plus investigator, for sure mafia would have gone for, them before you.

and investigator doesnt fit your claim... unless you ve been recruited, we ve got one kill only tonight maybe a cute Mentor has recruited you instead of performing a kill ?

--- Double Post Merged, Mar 29, 2020, Original Post Date: Mar 29, 2020 ---

"plus we had 2docs claims, 1 det plus investigator, "
* i meant prostitute sorry

 

[James Rye]

Beno, Daws, Knight and James are those that I don't trust that much.

Beno simply because we trust Hardy and his results. If Juviii is indeed innocent, then I don't see how Beno could also be one. I highly doubt that we have two witches in this type of game. Honestly, if Beno turns innocent which I'm pretty sure it won't happen, then I tip my hat off to Hardy for being an extremely smart mafia.

Daws, as Hardy said, doesn't really make much sense. Why would they add a Freeman in such a game? It doesn't fit in such a game when we're already at disadvantage like this.

Knight, we put him off for too long and he was a suspect day 1...

And finally James, I can understand that not having the stone makes you not want to play much but he hasn't done that much.. I guess tonight, James could prove himself so I'll rather give him a chance.

Therefore, I'm either going for Beno, Knight or Daws today.

Lol. And how am I supposed to "prove" myself with no spy or mafia ready to claim that I blocked his kill? XDDD
I am a one protection role with several possible targets the mafia could kill. I could protect Hardy our last det claimer (if he is one), I could protect Erin for being confirmed townie due being only one who claimed to make me sick, I could protect Desin for being confirmed Townie aka Innocent child and so on and so on.

Does an Investigator role work only on Janitor kills aka "???" or on this game mechanic aka "Townie/Mafia" @gnut @Asako ? Honestly, if Investigator was your role I have no idea why you didn't came out with it long ago. It's not like this is a role Mafia would die to kill for, neither back then in the older days nor now.

 

[Erinyes]

investigator is nonsensical if theres no janitor, afaik, theres none in this game, and it wouldnt make any sense either coz roles are hidden for people who have no stone, an extra janitor would have been way too favorable for mafia. so the chnaces theres an investigator are 0.

 

[Knight of Stalwart Heart]

I wasn't even in danger that day. Lol And Hardy told his results pretty early.

"Saved" as in cleared. The point is that he cleared you and no one suspects you for the rest of the game untill it's probably too late.

 

[Erinyes]

@Knightmare of heaven 0 what kind of bomb are you again ? time or kamikaze or regular ?

 

[Marmalade]

investigator is nonsensical if theres no janitor, afaik, theres none in this game, and it wouldnt make any sense either coz roles are hidden for people who have no stone, an extra janitor would have been way too favorable for mafia. so the chnaces theres an investigator are 0.

Roles are hidden if one gets killed at night. It just doesn't show as a "??"/janitor kill. Perhaps the hosts interpreted it a more broad. It's probably a bit of a stretch though

--- Double Post Merged, Mar 29, 2020, Original Post Date: Mar 29, 2020 ---

* A bit more broad.

English is hard today

 

[Knight of Stalwart Heart]

@Knightmare of heaven 0 what kind of bomb are you again ? time or kamikaze or regular ?

Regular.

 

[Asako]

Lol. And how am I supposed to "prove" myself with no spy or mafia ready to claim that I blocked his kill? XDDD
I am a one protection role with several possible targets the mafia could kill. I could protect Hardy our last det claimer (if he is one), I could protect Erin for being confirmed townie due being only one who claimed to make me sick, I could protect Desin for being confirmed Townie aka Innocent child and so on and so on.

Does an Investigator role work only on Janitor kills aka "???" or on this game mechanic aka "Townie/Mafia" @gnut @Asako ? Honestly, if Investigator was your role I have no idea why you didn't came out with it long ago. It's not like this is a role Mafia would die to kill for, neither back then in the older days nor now.

It can work for this mechanic

 

[Erinyes]

Knightmare your stone doesnt fit regular bomb. with soul stone you can only be time bomb or Kamikaze or mafia bomb

 

[James Rye]

investigator is nonsensical if theres no janitor, afaik, theres none in this game, and it wouldnt make any sense either coz roles are hidden for people who have no stone, an extra janitor would have been way too favorable for mafia. so the chnaces theres an investigator are 0.

Well, Asako just said it can work with this game mechanic, so Gajeel might be telling the truth. Even if it is a pretty useless role as it could never hope to cover the roles of the dead with hidden roles in this kinda set-up.

 

[Erinyes]

yeah saw it, but i highly doubt, it sill doesnt fit his claim, and the fact he didnt reveal yesterday makes no sense

 

[Knight of Stalwart Heart]

Knightmare your stone doesnt fit regular bomb. with soul stone you can only be time bomb or Kamikaze or mafia bomb

Mafia Bomb (Mafia): If the Mafia Bomb is killed by anybody, the killer dies too. If the Mafia Bomb is lynched, then he kills the person who cast the final vote on him. Other than that he is a regular Mafia Member. (Game 41)

Bomb (Townie): If the Bomb is killed by anybody, the killer dies too. If the Bomb is lynched, then he kills the person who cast the final vote on him. (GAME 7)

How does it fit a Mafia Bomb but not a Town Bomb as you say?

--- Double Post Merged, Mar 29, 2020, Original Post Date: Mar 29, 2020 ---

 

[James Rye]

yeah saw it, but i highly doubt, it sill doesnt fit his claim, and the fact he didnt reveal yesterday makes no sense

Plus still no stone reveal.

 

[SonOfDaws]

Since I know I am doc, for me the list looks like this:

gajeel
seraph
beno
knightmare
son

If Juviii is Mafia Boss as Knight fears we might wanna include her but somehow I really doubt that the hosts would use a MB in a game where dets can at best use their ability every 2nd night. Like a MB ain't really needed for Mafia, they just need to find and kill the dets quickly and they're okay.



Either one kill got blocked or, what is also possible, both killing parties went for the same target. Could have happened with gry as well, if I had been active I would have picked him as well as Gry tends to get a lot of attention in night 1 in most games.



It is there but pretty low. First of all if Juviii is Mafia Boss then there was no need to sacrifice Lawl as Juviii would be seen as innocent by Hardy anyway. Second of all as mafia you want to stay at full strength as long as possible to end the game quicker, the more mafioso die the harder it is to remain hidden in the end. Third Mafia Escort is a really good role to have, even in a game where most roles are blocked each night anyway.



Dunno, Innocent, dunno. XD



I got nightshifts, ofc I sleep most of the time when i get home, woke up half and an hour ago, showered, made food, cleaned the kitchen and came online. Plus this game mechanic is killing my heat! What use is a doctor when he can't doc several nights in a row! It would be different if at least it was the Escort shutting me down each night because that means one less block on other dets, docs and spies but I am naturally blocked each night because I got no fucking power stone!

Also from all the ones mentioned I am the least suspect, I voted for the two mafias to be lynched, for Jinx I was 4th who voted for him. I came out with my stone early, I was one of the earliest stone revealers, and did claim my role relatively early when I realized I will never get the stone anyway, so no use hiding what fits my stone anyway.

Doubleplus I actually listen to what Erin writes down instead of throwing sand and dirt around like some other players do and wait till the dust settles before I vote and so far, two of my votes were good. Although the one with the guilty verdict was very easy to vote for, anyone who didn't back then were already acting weird in my opinion.

Maybe besides claims, reveals and actions we should also include lynch voting behaviour in the Information board. What does Erin-at-work.Inc think about this Info option, @Erinyes ?^^

So, you and Bel are claiming doc then... I would guess and hope that the hosts don't have an insane doc in here. I would ask what your targets are, but Iron Man and Thanos have been too busy playing catch with each other to include poor Capt.

I can't prove anything and lost the ability for a 1 for 1 last phase l, so I get the suspicion.

I'm looking at 3 on team cap

Seraph: He keeps forgetting teams and game mechanics. Don't know if it's intentional or ignorance, either way it's meme worthy.

Gajeel: iirc, last phase he said he didn't mind not getting the power stone. Also, wouldn't reveal much at all of his role.

James: I buy his reasons and perspective for limited activity. Funny is Daws keeps calling out those who are quiet, while he was quiet up until the end of last day phase and won't reveal much.

Leaning Gajeel

As I said before, a person opening their mouth a lot doesn't necessarily mean anything of value was said. In that post of yours, the most you told us are short parroted problems other more trusted townies have had with no elaboration given. To be fair, nobody asked for you to elaborate, but at the same time, people shouldn't always have to ask another for their thoughts when they are expected to give them regardless. If a person wasn't able to be online and posting at all, then that's one thing, but time spent finding and sending angsty Naruto gifs here is time you could have spent here giving us something thoughtful, even if it isn't a good or full claim.

Speaking of, it's entirely possible that Asako and Gnut included two witches in the game. I acknowledge that and I agree, me not outright saying my role is sketchy. However, given Juviii's claim and Hardy's investigation, can you understand why I would find yours suspect?

But that is not really a mistake that Demon would make so early on, judging from all the games I have played with him so far. Starting the train seemed too easy.

There's a lot of mistakes being made all around, but at some point, I think we just have to accept that we could be doing a lot better so we can try to learn and move forward..

 

[Gajeel]

yeah saw it, but i highly doubt, it sill doesnt fit his claim, and the fact he didnt reveal yesterday makes no sense

How does it not fit my hints zzz, and what's the revealing yesterday about? I thought my hints were already saying too much but it seems like no one caught them. Belserion protected Hardy... I know there is another doctor claim and a prostitute but I can't tell what's going through the scums' heads and how they kill. My plan was to reveal once I had gotten a result or if it couldn't wait for today. I clearly stated that to Holt yesterday.

Plus still no stone reveal.

m i n d s t o n e. I believe this is explicit enough even though I thought the bull metaphor was enough.

 

[SonOfDaws]

Lol. And how am I supposed to "prove" myself with no spy or mafia ready to claim that I blocked his kill? XDDD
I am a one protection role with several possible targets the mafia could kill. I could protect Hardy our last det claimer (if he is one), I could protect Erin for being confirmed townie due being only one who claimed to make me sick, I could protect Desin for being confirmed Townie aka Innocent child and so on and so on.

Does an Investigator role work only on Janitor kills aka "???" or on this game mechanic aka "Townie/Mafia" @gnut @Asako ? Honestly, if Investigator was your role I have no idea why you didn't came out with it long ago. It's not like this is a role Mafia would die to kill for, neither back then in the older days nor now.

What do you think about Bel's claim?

How does it not fit my hints zzz, and what's the revealing yesterday about? I thought my hints were already saying too much but it seems like no one caught them. Belserion protected Hardy... I know there is another doctor claim and a prostitute but I can't tell what's going through the scums' heads and how they kill. My plan was to reveal once I had gotten a result or if it couldn't wait for today. I clearly stated that to Holt yesterday.



m i n d s t o n e. I believe this is explicit enough even though I thought the bull metaphor was enough.

Similar to my case, withholding reveals later than most is sometimes the right choice, however, I'm not sure investigator is pivotal enough to warrant waiting until D5 to reveal. That's especially the case with confirmed and near confirmed townies around. Still, I can understand the desire to hold off until you can actually use the role and, again, I get people suspecting me for similar reasons, but by the same sentiment, we still have to be suspicious of you.


@Belserion Who did you target last night?