by desin, panda and evil
Last edited:
Sanity not confirmed yet.well the game is pointless if we don't come out. but ok your choice.
if people said what they did it'd be easier to turn our focus to the more suspicious ones, which would be the passive claim roles, as there are, in my opinion too many passive roles.
ofc it's easy for mafia to claim active roles too since no one claimed what exactly the role is (except me) and no one can contest any claims.
But anyway, I'll reveal who I targeted, I targeted Shad and my investigation ended with no results. As Shad already knew I would target him, he did not use his action, but with this at least, I confirmed if I'm paranoid or not? I guess.
You joking? You are joking right. I sleep.The one I trust the most ATM is Gajeel.
I think Shad is probably Town too, he seems more enthusiastic(?) In this game compared to the previous one where he was Mafia. Will have to reread a bit about Holt but I distrust Marm and Gry the most. Not a fan of the potato pass and Gry saying that he trusted lawl D1 is hard to buy.
His post.You joking? You are joking right. I sleep.
He is the mafia....he is gonna kill us...
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
how is shad playing different from last game where he like me was mafia (but from the start)Caught up, had to read the last part of D1 aswell since I couldn't participate on it and from what I read I didn't like Gaj and Sam one bit. The lynch on lawl was very artificial. Sakura is most probably town and Shad is playing way too different to be scum, I would expect him to hide a lot more if he were to repeat.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Also Gry is right this eternal recap is shameless and advances absolutely nothing.
Because he is way bolder, last game he played the timid lamb till later when he had no way out and it worked wonders for him, why would he change the playstyle if he wasn't something that allows him to speak freely aka town?how is shad playing different from last game where he like me was mafia (but from the start)
well he might just as well be bolder because he has more experience. But I'm town and I think I'm bolder too, difference is I splattered my role out in the open...Because he is way bolder, last game he played the timid lamb till later when he had no way out and it worked wonders for him, why would he change the playstyle if he wasn't something that allows him to speak freely aka town?
Reading you two's argument feels like two players being short-sighted with the others pov and focusing only in one aspect to burn each other.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
People dont change playstyles that radically from first game to second unless they changed allegiance, its not because he's different but that he's too different this time.well he might just as well be bolder because he has more experience. But I'm town and I think I'm bolder too, difference is I splattered my role out in the open...
Taku-chi ma boiiWell, as i said, i'll be off now and won't be here when the phase ends. So i'll cast my two votes now.
The day phase hasn't been really fruitful at least for me. Right now, i trust sakura - and Gajeel somewhat. I have no opinion on those who didnt participate a lot, obviously. I also trust Shad more than previous phase, he's greener in my eyes. Also Demon, i can never fully trust Demon but for now he seems alright...
The ones i'm distrusting most are Gry and DD.
Weird that Lambu still didn't jump on my face, is he ignoring me? At least he's not trying to rub me the right way like in the previous game.
I'm voting for Gry and DD; they are most likely not in the same team, but i feel like one of them has to be mafia.
There's also the inactive ones... Though that'd be hypocritical of me since i haven't been that talkative either, especially D1 was awful. I might vote for one of them next phase.
Votekill Gry
Votekill DD
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
There is a point and i'm not sharing until everyone states if they used their night action or not.
So far only 8 people mentioned, out of which active were 1 the passing of the potato and me investigating. That means that out of 7 people with claimed active roles, 1 confirmed using (me) and 4 to not have used, which leaves 3 who did not claim at all . And there were 5-6 actions taken last night which means 3-4 people used their role last night.
Out of the 8 confirmed to not have used their role, Sam and Takuan claimed to have a passive roles which makes me ask the question, why mention you did not use the role unless you have an active role?
Roles are as follows:
1 active role used
Demonspeed Active gnut UNKNOWN Gajeel Passive Erinyes Active Holt UNKNOWN Lambu Passive GrySun Active MarmaladeSky Passive Organizized Active Moegara Passive Sakura-Aneki Active SirSamuel016 Passive Shad Active Takuan Passive SonOfDaws Active xnut Active
1 potato used
left 3-4 actions
People who claimed to not use roles (and have active roles)
People with active roles who did not mention using them:
SHAD NOT USED DEMONSPEED NOT USED XNUT NOT USED ORGANIZIZED NOT USED
Now, I'd like to hear from @Erinyes @GrySun and @SonOfDaws if you used your role or not.
Erinyes NO CLAIM GrySun NO CLAIM SonOfDaws NO CLAIM
Also, @Holt and @gnut please specify if active or passive.
After that, it'll be easier to determine towards who to turn our gaze.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
and after that I'll reveal my target.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Don't care if I appear shady.
Will share before the day ends.
Revealing to be plain townie seems like recruitment bait to me, but at the same time, I don't know when it would ever be a good time to reveal as a plain townie. So, I can't blame you too much for it, assuming you're legit.Why am I the only townie, am I death miller again...
While I am among that list, I don't think that's a terrible place to start looking. Maybe not a vote today, but looking.The people who said nothing about whether they‘re active or passive on Day 1 are: Takuan, Holt, Samuel, Daws, xnut and gnut.
I‘d assume fishing in this group should lead to a mafia lynch, would be pretty impressive if all mafias boldly claimed active or passive so early. Some certainly did, but not all.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Ok I didn‘t target anyone. Happy?
--- Double Post Merged, ---
I honestly find you all strange, this isn‘t the core part of mafia and all you‘re doing is gathering useless data for the sake of it which you won‘t do anything with.
then what about me? I changed allegiance and I'm playing the same as before ...Like, if it came to you @sakura-aneki or Shad I would choose Shad sure but people like Daws, Holt, G or Sam or even Taku-chi are way shadier and you are having tunnel vision.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
People dont change playstyles that radically from first game to second unless they changed allegiance, its not because he's different but that he's too different this time.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
You had a town role to shield yourself, there's a degree of confidence coming from that.then what about me? I changed allegiance and I'm playing the same as before ...
I realize I might have tunnel vision right now, but I'm calling it a hunch, anyway if we decide on one of the other shady people I'll go with it, so no harm done, not trying to convince you guys of voting Shad or anything
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
DD likes to claim D2 both as town or as mafia so its very hard to tell if he's just messing around or legit trying to help lol.Revealing to be plain townie seems like recruitment bait to me, but at the same time, I don't know when it would ever be a good time to reveal as a plain townie. So, I can't blame you too much for it, assuming you're legit.
DD also liked to point out he's "Death Miller" which he can't possibly know.Re-reading again and for the record people I "dont distrust" for now:
- sakura: claimed spy, seems legit and frustrated at the situation, weird that scum didn't kill her and went for Hardy but could be a cheap set up, maybe they didn't even fear her for the action retriction we imposed ourselves.
- Gry: has his ups and downs, went for Sam over lawls artificial lynch which gives him points. Doesn't want to grab much attention but isn't being sneaky.
- Moegara: His D1 impression still has effect on me.
- Shad: explained before
- Orgz: He looks like saying what he wants to say, a little too "polite" tho, in the sense that looks like not wanting to catch much attention.
There's a bunch in the grey area like demon, marm or dd, very hard to read for different reasons. The rest are worth my vote.
You had a town role to shield yourself, there's a degree of confidence coming from that.
And its fine if you want to pursue your hunch, its a part of the game, but what I wanted to say is we need to look and doubt everyone and not just one guy.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
DD likes to claim D2 both as town or as mafia so its very hard to tell if he's just messing around or legit trying to help lol.
The claim is convenient too, can deviate for almost anything, while revealing nothing.
Depends, by default for 20 players I would put 1 sane and 1 insane, but that implies there are not many defensive roles like bp, bomb...