Games Mafia Game 94 - Magi: The Crests of Magic - END GAME

[Asako]

Here the results of everything

 

[Erinyes]

Psych, Banshee, PO, Avenger. Lot of new role claims...

Maybe the hosts wanted to test them all in one game joke aside, if all or most of those claims are true, i doubt hosts wouldnt test mafia new roles too.

edit typo

 

[GrySun]

Because my aim is bad. You remember my Bomb tower upgrade? I would rather be killed at night and take the killer with me, than pick someone from 20 people every night.

But that makes you mediocre not the role

Idk to me this doesn't fit your hint, but I'll give you + points for claiming it before other people that are stalling. It's a decent cover role for a red that wants to avoid being nightkilled.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 28, 2021 ---

Not like I'd call Det a mediocre role because I'm bad at it, for example. Weird train of thought.

 

[Evil3ye]

But that makes you mediocre not the role

Idk to me this doesn't fit your hint, but I'll give you + points for claiming it before other people that are stalling. It's a decent cover role for a red that wants to avoid being nightkilled.

What makes desin's Noble role boring? The adjective to describe each ones roles is subjective and situational at best. I said mediocre because it's a late game role and being killed night 1 won't do me any good. To not be instant mafia target and get some milage on the role I said that. Had to self-block on D2 though, so missed a night, but together with today's night, I am sure there will be some mafias on it, so I feel more confident now to die with it.

I'm neither red nor orange, normal green, so really don't see any use getting back into this dabate at this point, but in progression of the game these kind of debates will be more valid than right now for sure.

 

[shinobi]

Votekill Shubo Idk what successful choices a passive role can make and I didn't like his last vote on Bel.

 

[Demonspeed]

Anyone exploring Dungeons tonight?

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 28, 2021 ---

I equipped my MV BTW.

 

[Evil3ye]

Anyone exploring Dungeons tonight?

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 28, 2021 ---

I equipped my MV BTW.

Does that mean you can prove you're sickly D5?

 

[Demonspeed]

Does that mean you can prove you're sickly D5?

I should, right? @SonOfDaws @Asako @Purity of Magi

 

[GrySun]

What makes desin's Noble role boring? The adjective to describe each ones roles is subjective and situational at best. I said mediocre because it's a late game role and being killed night 1 won't do me any good. To not be instant mafia target and get some milage on the role I said that. Had to self-block on D2 though, so missed a night, but together with today's night, I am sure there will be some mafias on it, so I feel more confident now to die with it.

I'm neither red nor orange, normal green, so really don't see any use getting back into this dabate at this point, but in progression of the game these kind of debates will be more valid than right now for sure.

But that's not a good comparison, something boring vs something weak. The role was boring to him, and boring is subjective. The strength of some roles is not a subjective thing.

It's like you calling Vigilante mediocre because you don't have faith in your shots. I don't think you'd ever do that.

Your self blocking on N2 makes no sense with your current words either. You call it a lategame role that doesn't do much with just the N1 target and needs more targets, but then you proceed by not increasing your number of targets. Just to be in a dungeon when you have a fully active role?

You'll likely be around until later but I'll never fully trust you as your words don't fit. But right, not something for now. We'll see to that another day.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 28, 2021 ---

Anyone exploring Dungeons tonight?

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 28, 2021 ---

I equipped my MV BTW.

Does that mean you can prove you're sickly D5?

Didn't everyone say it only finishes equipping at the end of the Day? Back when we had all the Assassin MV talk? And you and Evil still say this?

 

[Baka Taichou]

Votekill Shobu second to Gry in who I distrust most. Mostly because of all his dodging when questioned.

@Evil3ye now that Gry has claimed, will you?

where did gry claim?

 

[Demonspeed]

But that's not a good comparison, something boring vs something weak. The role was boring to him, and boring is subjective. The strength of some roles is not a subjective thing.

It's like you calling Vigilante mediocre because you don't have faith in your shots. I don't think you'd ever do that.

Your self blocking on N2 makes no sense with your current words either. You call it a lategame role that doesn't do much with just the N1 target and needs more targets, but then you proceed by not increasing your number of targets. Just to be in a dungeon when you have a fully active role?

You'll likely be around until later but I'll never fully trust you as your words don't fit. But right, not something for now. We'll see to that another day.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 28, 2021 ---

Didn't everyone say it only finishes equipping at the end of the Day? Back when we had all the Assassin MV talk? And you and Evil still say this?

I am confused by the wording.

I PMed that I want to equip it this DP. So maybe I can cast the EM this night.

 

[Evil3ye]

But that's not a good comparison, something boring vs something weak. The role was boring to him, and boring is subjective. The strength of some roles is not a subjective thing.

It's like you calling Vigilante mediocre because you don't have faith in your shots. I don't think you'd ever do that.

Your self blocking on N2 makes no sense with your current words either. You call it a lategame role that doesn't do much with just the N1 target and needs more targets, but then you proceed by not increasing your number of targets. Just to be in a dungeon when you have a fully active role?

You'll likely be around until later but I'll never fully trust you as your words don't fit. But right, not something for now. We'll see to that another day.

Meh, that's your opinion. I said it before as well, it's not a crucial role for townies to use every night in order to win. It really depends on analysis and good grasp of player pool, which just isn't the case especially early game. I prioritised the strategy to reduce the possible Assassin pool over putting an other name on the list and don't regret it.

You seriously comparing Vigilante to this role now? Do they also have to limit themselves to the night targets, kill with a delay of a whole phase, and actually have to die in order to kill? Sure, yeah, that's the same category of mediocrity.

 

[Baka Taichou]

so you guys think both gry and evil are town? I can't believe both are :|

but Shobu I guess might be a safer choice for today mostly cuz of his snipe vote, Idk tho, are the votes updated?

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 28, 2021 ---

Meh, that's your opinion. I said it before as well, it's not a crucial role for townies to use every night in order to win. It really depends on analysis and good grasp of player pool, which just isn't the case especially early game. I prioritised the strategy to reduce the possible Assassin pool over putting an other name on the list and don't regret it.

You seriously comparing Vigilante to this role now? Do they also have to limit themselves to the night targets, kill with a delay of a whole phase, and actually have to die in order to kill? Sure, yeah, that's the same category of mediocrity.

did you mark me Evil?

 

[Evil3ye]

did you mark me Evil?

No.

 

[GrySun]

Meh, that's your opinion. I said it before as well, it's not a crucial role for townies to use every night in order to win. It really depends on analysis and good grasp of player pool, which just isn't the case especially early game. I prioritised the strategy to reduce the possible Assassin pool over putting an other name on the list and don't regret it.

You seriously comparing Vigilante to this role now? Do they also have to limit themselves to the night targets, kill with a delay of a whole phase, and actually have to die in order to kill? Sure, yeah, that's the same category of mediocrity.

It's a kill. It could have a YuGiOh effect of banishing 5 townie active roles from the graveyard and still be a top tier town role. But alright, difference in opinion. We'll see about this more later.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 28, 2021 ---

so you guys think both gry and evil are town? I can't believe both are :|

Do you have any logical reason why we both can't be? In Kingdom Rush game both you and Evil were town and were severely fighting each other. This is like the 3rd time you insinuate that 2 people in conflict can't be from the same team. Said it with me and Hardy before too. You have many past examples of 2 people simply fighting because they distrust each other and both being town, so I'm not sure why you think there's always a scum in every argue-pair.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021 ---

but Shobu I guess might be a safer choice for today mostly cuz of his snipe vote, Idk tho, are the votes updated?

No. My votes are, but shobu should have 3 and Pompom 2. Rest unchanged.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021 ---

The 4th Dungeon
Element: Lightning - Negate

Why is this dungeon still around btw? Did nobody go here?

 

[Baka Taichou]

did anyone notice how all the night kills were done on ppl who were in dungeons in the first night?

 

[Hardy]

Woke up, we slept like absolute shit.

Just gonna point out that I posted a line that was wrong about Farf-Shobu and it got 4 likes and yet my read on Gry that took actual effort got only Brandish's like and he surely didn't even read it.

 

[Belserion]

where did gry claim?

He claimed Freeman some* pages back but it would be a bit hard to unearth. Maybe wait for Erin's recap?

Edit typo.

 

[Hardy]

I need to catch up but.

Nah I haven't killed, yet. I am Avenger. EH there it is lol.

You just shot yourself in the foot. My Vessel is Avenger (Unskilled Mafia). Liar.

 

[Brandish μ]

You just shot yourself in the foot. My Vessel is Avenger (Unskilled Mafia). Liar.

So if there's a MV skill(?) that role cannot be in the game? Lool

 

[Hardy]

So if there's a MV skill(?) that role cannot be in the game? Lool

That's how it's been yes. Including the Hiders yesterday. It's a really fucking specific role too.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 28, 2021, Original Post Date: Jul 28, 2021 ---

Fwiw I tagged Gry N2 then tried to shoot him last night. Did you even say what you did?