- Joined
- Jul 14, 2017
- Messages
- 501
- Reaction score
- 697
- Country
This thread is about 2 things :-
1) So i am not a believer of ZKK . However , few days ago i came across the following argument by someone which gave me second thoughts. Still not believing in ZKK. Morj also recently made a video against ZKK which was quite convincing to me.
But i am making this thread to see what response do you guys have about the following argument. And here it comes ->
""And i will dare this Morj or any Anti-ZKK to answer this very simple question
If you ask any One Piece Reader who is currently in any Arc, whether they are still in East Blue Saga or close to catching up
Ask them do you think Samurai Arc could happen without Zoro fighting a Samurai/Swordsman?
Not a Single Soul will answer "Yes", everyone will say "That's impossible, Zoro will definitely face a Samurai/Swordsman in Wano"
Well guess what, we are currently in +110 Chapters of Wano & Zoro have No Samurai/Swordsman Opponent !!!
Why? Why is Oda missing this Chance? Land of Swords & Samurai & Swordsmen but no Swordsman Fight for Zoro? That's rediculous
The Answer is very simple, because Zoro is gonna Kill the one who "All Samurai" Failed to Kill/Defeat
Oda didn't need to make Shogun some Legendary Samurai, didn't need to give Zoro a Samurai Fight, because the Story is about this Monster crushing all Samurai & brought Wano to it's Knees. By making Zoro Slay this Demon, he already proves himself Greater than all of these Samurai !!
Saying ZKK won't happen = Zoro won't prove himself Future Swordsman to Land of Samurai
Which is Dumbest Statement ever
They think Zoro will leave & those Samurai will remember him as the guy who Defeated BDSM Bird who fights with anything he finds .""
2) Most ppl started reading One Piece after having heard about the hype around MF arc. One Piece manga sales in Japan also skyrocketed at that time. Before this amongst the Big 3 , Naruto & Bleach were considered better than One Piece by most shonen fans coz most of them hadn't even read op coz it seemed too childish to them & had read Bleach & Naruto only & i remember the constant battles between naruto fans & op fans .
So my point is that most of these op fans read all of these pre ts arcs in one go & not on a week to week basis. But for the post ts arcs they read them on a week to week basis.
This is my personal observation & opinion that the experience of reading an arc in one go is much better than reading it on week to week basis because while reading weekly (with breaks too) we forget a lot of things that happened even 15 chapters ago & more importantly the flow of the story is lost completely.
Say a battle is going on ; then the flow of the battle will shift from protagonist's side to anatogonist's side back & forth but none of this will be visible to a weekly reader because whenever he picks it up a week later , all the tension set up by last 7 chapters is gone . (a soft reset is at play when we read a chapter after week or two)
Even if you were to reread the post ts arcs (despite of knowing all the spoilers coz we have read it already) you would in all likelihood be able to get a much better experience than when you read it weekly which would only imply that if you hadn't read them weekly initially & would have read it in one go then your experience would have been even better.
There is some personal ancetodal evidence i have seen at a personal level as well as via my friends'/cousins' reaction who started reading it this year only , but the following anectodal example is something which is publicly out there for you all & is underway (coz the following 2 guys are in FI only right now):-
There are 2 booktubers out there who generally are into fantasy fiction novels like Wheel Of Time , Malazan etc kind of stuff and they very rarely review any anime/manga. This in my opinion provides a fresh take of OP (a manga) by people who are not anime/mangatubers but more of classic fantasy fiction novel guys.
They (Merphy Napier & Daniel Greene ) recently picked up One Piece & have arrived in Post Ts right now. Daniel just finished FI & agrees that it was bad but would still place it above Thriller Bark.
In the next few months they would have caught up with us & having had the experience of reading post ts arcs in one go , it would be interesting to see their opinion on post ts arcs.
None of this is to say personal opinion ,likes & dislikes does not matter. Of course they do. All i am saying is that ->
Your hypothetical version who read post ts arcs in one go would definitely have a much better experience than the one that read it weekly.
Post TS arcs have been read weekly & Pre Ts arcs were read in one go & therefore post ts arcs are massively underrated. (for most of us). Try this out by bringing in friends who have similar likes/dislikes to you in terms of what kind of story/genre they like & get them to read this manga & see for yourself.
Just reread the post ts arcs to get a better experience of the series that we all love. :P
1) So i am not a believer of ZKK . However , few days ago i came across the following argument by someone which gave me second thoughts. Still not believing in ZKK. Morj also recently made a video against ZKK which was quite convincing to me.
But i am making this thread to see what response do you guys have about the following argument. And here it comes ->
""And i will dare this Morj or any Anti-ZKK to answer this very simple question
If you ask any One Piece Reader who is currently in any Arc, whether they are still in East Blue Saga or close to catching up
Ask them do you think Samurai Arc could happen without Zoro fighting a Samurai/Swordsman?
Not a Single Soul will answer "Yes", everyone will say "That's impossible, Zoro will definitely face a Samurai/Swordsman in Wano"
Well guess what, we are currently in +110 Chapters of Wano & Zoro have No Samurai/Swordsman Opponent !!!
Why? Why is Oda missing this Chance? Land of Swords & Samurai & Swordsmen but no Swordsman Fight for Zoro? That's rediculous
The Answer is very simple, because Zoro is gonna Kill the one who "All Samurai" Failed to Kill/Defeat
Oda didn't need to make Shogun some Legendary Samurai, didn't need to give Zoro a Samurai Fight, because the Story is about this Monster crushing all Samurai & brought Wano to it's Knees. By making Zoro Slay this Demon, he already proves himself Greater than all of these Samurai !!
Saying ZKK won't happen = Zoro won't prove himself Future Swordsman to Land of Samurai
Which is Dumbest Statement ever
They think Zoro will leave & those Samurai will remember him as the guy who Defeated BDSM Bird who fights with anything he finds .""
2) Most ppl started reading One Piece after having heard about the hype around MF arc. One Piece manga sales in Japan also skyrocketed at that time. Before this amongst the Big 3 , Naruto & Bleach were considered better than One Piece by most shonen fans coz most of them hadn't even read op coz it seemed too childish to them & had read Bleach & Naruto only & i remember the constant battles between naruto fans & op fans .
So my point is that most of these op fans read all of these pre ts arcs in one go & not on a week to week basis. But for the post ts arcs they read them on a week to week basis.
This is my personal observation & opinion that the experience of reading an arc in one go is much better than reading it on week to week basis because while reading weekly (with breaks too) we forget a lot of things that happened even 15 chapters ago & more importantly the flow of the story is lost completely.
Say a battle is going on ; then the flow of the battle will shift from protagonist's side to anatogonist's side back & forth but none of this will be visible to a weekly reader because whenever he picks it up a week later , all the tension set up by last 7 chapters is gone . (a soft reset is at play when we read a chapter after week or two)
Even if you were to reread the post ts arcs (despite of knowing all the spoilers coz we have read it already) you would in all likelihood be able to get a much better experience than when you read it weekly which would only imply that if you hadn't read them weekly initially & would have read it in one go then your experience would have been even better.
There is some personal ancetodal evidence i have seen at a personal level as well as via my friends'/cousins' reaction who started reading it this year only , but the following anectodal example is something which is publicly out there for you all & is underway (coz the following 2 guys are in FI only right now):-
There are 2 booktubers out there who generally are into fantasy fiction novels like Wheel Of Time , Malazan etc kind of stuff and they very rarely review any anime/manga. This in my opinion provides a fresh take of OP (a manga) by people who are not anime/mangatubers but more of classic fantasy fiction novel guys.
They (Merphy Napier & Daniel Greene ) recently picked up One Piece & have arrived in Post Ts right now. Daniel just finished FI & agrees that it was bad but would still place it above Thriller Bark.
In the next few months they would have caught up with us & having had the experience of reading post ts arcs in one go , it would be interesting to see their opinion on post ts arcs.
None of this is to say personal opinion ,likes & dislikes does not matter. Of course they do. All i am saying is that ->
Your hypothetical version who read post ts arcs in one go would definitely have a much better experience than the one that read it weekly.
Post TS arcs have been read weekly & Pre Ts arcs were read in one go & therefore post ts arcs are massively underrated. (for most of us). Try this out by bringing in friends who have similar likes/dislikes to you in terms of what kind of story/genre they like & get them to read this manga & see for yourself.
Just reread the post ts arcs to get a better experience of the series that we all love. :P
Last edited: