This is how the "Shut up!" Scene should have looked like

[Artanis]

Yep, another collab between me, Pokefreak(Dynamic Dragon) and Si Style. We really hated the Shut up scene of the anime, so we decided to remake it together and make it look better and similar to the manga. Hope you like it!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vQyQZMsx1OE

Enjoy! 8)

Update: 10/25/07

Version 2:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JFHXD-_qOwk

 

[Dynamic Dragon]

yeah! anotherone!!! XD

 

[lee-nus]

you mean to say there are scenes you dont hate about the shippuuden...?

 

[kunai-knight]

Good one lee-nus lol. 1st episode and 'puppet massacre' episodes were awesome though. Nice job on the remake too

 

[lee-nus]

well, in my opinion they might as well call it the shit-uuden or whatever... wonderful avatar u got btw, kunai! where's it from?

perhaps i should add though, that i by no means intended to belittle the art in question here. its all nicely done!

 

[Qbanboi]

Well done. Maybe the anime should hire u guys to paint the anime of Naruto, because it sucks.

 

[Dralaquan]

Man, I love what you guys are doing Nice work man !

 

[Saifi]

ya , good work , but.... i actually didnt find anything wrong with the scene, plus the redone one isnt really that different from the on in the anime

 

[sarutobikun]

I think that the Pierrot should collab with you for the Anime major scene !

POKEFREAK AND ARTANIS AT PIERROT <3 !

 

[weixiaobao]

look much better .. Great job..

 

[big_p]

This is exactly why i do not watch the anime, that and fillers and dragging things out. Great work.

 

[C4animax]

I fully agreed on last time remake of naruto two tails! (because that was too much seriously!!!) But i'm affraid that this time the anime version is better than yours, nothing wrong here in my opinion...

In your version you show naruto while chyoba finish talking, which is a mistake because naruto is supposed to "lose" it and cry at the same time (so quick reaction, something that will surprise us), here, it give the impression that naruto is waiting her to finish to say "shut up"!

What was more important here was naruto's feeling, not the flashy color you added (yeah the color seems to be different from the anime) or the "quality drawing" (still the anime was ok) and that's probably why the attention is focused on chyo...i remember that in the manga you have that "lines" effect, so it's cool they left it there.

You're also missing the hair animation which make the biggest difference between your version and the anime version. (if you're using flash it's easy to do)

Ok it's fan made, it's well done but you screwed the sentiment here.

 

[Artanis]

Version 2:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JFHXD-_qOwk

 

[yopakfu]

Cool man, but somethings not right. :|
When naruto shouts 'urusei!' you can see his head protectors tails (dunno how to explain it sorry) like flapping/waving in the wind. Then a second later, the close-up, it disappeared XD. Just a small mistake I think, but overall it's pretty good

 

[chibistar6]

Yeah...I hated that scene too -- good job =]

 

[destinator]

The original scene isnt that bad but your version looks even more sentimental, so awesome work!

 

[C4animax]

The edit looks better!