- Joined
- Jun 17, 2018
- Messages
- 4,056
- Reaction score
- 7,766
- Country
-
It seems you still don't understand about my intention, that is why you keep bringing this up. I already ask you to reread it, remember?See the bold part? That's speculation - by Workshop, Karaka, and you.
This was the edit:Reread my post, it has beed edited.
I didn't not claim you were wrong, I just claimed that it is incomplete. There are a lot of information from what Karaka thought was the case, one of them is that only irregular can use the thorn. I wanted to pointed out that this one is confirmed by SIU. I didn't mean to deny that it was Karaka's thought or workshop's theory. Now move on from this.If you don't consider it invalidating, then consider it as completing
King's contract is a contract with administrator. Irregulars are free from contracts, so they don't need to use the thorn to nullify the contract (as long as they don't bind themselves to the contract such as signing it).Only you don't know that. The Thorn could be integral in overcoming the King contract for all you know, which only Baam can levy via the Thorn.
It clearly gives many benefit. One them is he can establish test system. I guess it also give him much privilage that is useful to run the empire.Why does Zahard need a King contract when he is ALREADY IMMORTAL AND INVULNERABLE TO ALL IN THE TOWER (to include his irregular 10FHs)?
I'm going to devil's advocate here and argue on his behalf - Baam only has nominal, fractional usage of Levi. If he has more of a complete access to the White PU, then it's theoretically possible he's right - for now.Levi PU is a literal manisfestation of a FH memories and emotions vs White PU is from at best a High Ranker that got wrecked by a Zahard Princess. There is no way the White PU is stronger.
What purpose is the Thorn for Gustang? Even if he can use the thorn, he cannot use it to kill Zahard or other FH as he signed the contract. So better give it to Baam.And, you haven't explained why Gustang cannot use the Thorn for purposes other than killing Zahard.
JH is not Khun's friend, and Cha is at most, an acquaintance. You must have pulled a muscle with that stretch.Yes, the friends (plural) that are working with... the traitor. Those friends. The ones that left the hotel early by sneaking out. THOSE were the ones that Rei was talking about.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I think Gustang won't use the thorn because it might break some of his spells.What purpose is the Thorn for Gustang? Even if he can use the thorn, he cannot use it to kill Zahard or other FH as he signed the contract. So better give it to Baam.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Baam has full access to Levi but only brings out a fraction of it because Levi is something "he must not let out" less some cataclysmic event befalls the whole tower.I'm going to devil's advocate here and argue on his behalf - Baam only has nominal, fractional usage of Levi. If he has more of a complete access to the White PU, then it's theoretically possible he's right - for now.
You're glossing over the actual question - WHY does he need one that keeps him immortal if it is seemingly redundant? Why the notice by SIU that is the function of the king's contract? Seemingly just immortality upon immortality that he already had from 100F. Why? Your response is 'dat bureaucracy tho' - no. The function explicitly mentioned was to keep him immune from attack.King's contract is a contract with administrator. Irregulars are free from contracts, so they don't need to use the thorn to nullify the contract (as long as they don't bind themselves to the contract such as signing it).
It clearly gives many benefit. One them is he can establish test system. I guess it also give him much privilage that is useful to run the empire.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Can Gustang use the Thorn - in ANY function? That is the question.What purpose is the Thorn for Gustang? Even if he can use the thorn, he cannot use it to kill Zahard or other FH as he signed the contract. So better give it to Baam.
King's contract do not contain immortality. I already explained it last month.You're glossing over the actual question - WHY does he need one that keeps him immortal if it is seemingly redundant? Why the notice by SIU that is the function of the king's contract? Seemingly just immortality upon immortality that he already had from 100F. Why? Your response is 'dat bureaucracy tho' - no. The function explicitly mentioned was to keep him immune from attack.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
No, he didn't. He sign a shinsu contract that give him shinsu from admin. He also has the ability to draw shinsu not from admin. The one that is limited is the one from admin.Btw, Baam has been systematically binding himself - "shackles" - on every floor. Do you know how much that will limit him? Nope. Do you know how the Thorn affects that? Nope.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
And what change? He still cannot use it to kill FH. He is already too strong for towerborn.It's immensely powerful, why wouldn't he want to have it? He's going to war against other FHs after all.
Ah, the inevitable reach to abuse semantics. Yet, again, where are the BHs near the portal? Why would Rei need to send BH's storming into a hotel he controls a room away (so he thought)? Where are they? Why the long dispatch time? Why would he think he needs to stop them from reaching the portal, personally?JH is not Khun's friend, and Cha is at most, an acquaintance. You must have pulled a muscle with that stretch.
Or, put another way, can't access the full power. As I stated.Baam has full access to Levi but only brings out a fraction of it because Levi is something "he must not let out" less some cataclysmic event befalls the whole tower.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
King's contract do not contain immortality. I already explained it last month.
The admin POINTEDLY told him that's what he's doing with the shinsoo contract. So, you're wrong. And, he'd have to do that on every floor he went to after 2F with yet another shinsoo contract, which presumably he did.No, he didn't. He sign a shinsu contract that give him shinsu from admin. He also has the ability to draw shinsu not from admin. The one that is limited is the one from admin.
Yeah, FH's don't like to collect OP weapons at all. Good point!And what change? He still cannot use it to kill FH. He is already too strong for towerborn.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Now who is "abusing semantics?" The 2 BH don't have to be near the portal in the hotel because Rei was right there. They are probably at the other end of the portal waiting for the exit of the regulars. Why would Rei assume that Khun would be friends with 2 very ancient high rankers? That makes no f--king sense what so ever. Especially since one of those "friends" is JH, who hates all the great families? Rei anticipated that Khun might be playing a trick on him and in the event that Khun's ACTUAL REGULAR friends escaped through the portal.....Boom...BH ready to pounce.Ah, the inevitable reach to abuse semantics. Yet, again, where are the BHs near the portal? Why would Rei need to send BH's storming into a hotel he controls a room away (so he thought)? Where are they? Why the long dispatch time? Why would he think he needs to stop them from reaching the portal, personally?
Beyond clearly Rei is lumping anyone opposing him into a group of 'friends' or acquaintances, etc - and that includes the same HJ that he used once as bait for Baam.
Obviously, a 2 vs 2 battle is about to ensue. I'll tag you Sunday lol.
Or, put another way, can't access the full power. As I stated.
A fair answer to the question posed.I think Gustang won't use the thorn because it might break some of his spells.
You actually accept Wangnan's shallow knowledge as truth? The history known to towerborn is fabricated, even Hwaryun is suspectible as it is a matter concerning irregular. Furthermore, in that conversation, they also talked that irregular can bypass that contract which is contradicting your claim. The real history was later revealed from Arlene's pocket, the immortality actually comes from separate contract.Wangnan specifically talks about the king contract doing just that. HWR agrees.
Nope, you are wrong, reread Season 1 Episode 29.The admin was saying he ALREADY had the ability to use shinsoo
Note that admin said "climber of the tower", so it wasn't specific to irregular, this shackle also apply to towerborn. Just because Baam is shackled in terms of shinsu from admin doesn't mean he is shackled in terms of shinsu he can get by himself. Being an irregular is like having your own power generator, you can buy electricity from power company via contract but you can also generate your own electricity.The admin POINTEDLY told him that's what he's doing with the shinsoo contract. So, you're wrong. And, he'd have to do that on every floor he went to after 2F with yet another shinsoo contract, which presumably he did.
Gustang is smart, he know the Thorn would be better in Baam than himself.Yeah, FH's don't like to collect OP weapons at all. Good point!
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Leaving out the part that contradict your claim. Very convenient. Just like the conversation between Wangnan and Hwaryun that you only take partially.Admin says "for YOU... this [contract] is not a strength, it is shackles" (and then the contract is executed) @Yelnats
Yes, indeed, Baam has been "shackling" himself with every shinsoo contract he signs. Which is - hmmm, what I said.
another theory I have on why Gustang doesn't use the thorns is because he gave one to FUG long before Zahard issued the 3 orders during the Hell Train Arc. Gustang was already prepping for war and was going to use FUG as a proxy.. It could also tie in to Arlene and whatever "prophecy" about Enryu and "the child"(Din Grogu) Garam and the denizens of the floor of death talk about. Or he could just be that much of a baller and pull out a whole pack of cigs and call it a day.A fair answer to the question posed.
So, using the Thorn automatically nullifies all spells? What, in the vicinity? There is no cap or control on this function?
Curious how you think this plays out.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
The Admin said "You..................You look tasty"The admin was saying he ALREADY had the ability to use shinsoo, and shinsoo contracts are just that, "shackles." Unless Baam hasn't made a single shinsoo contract since then...
So, putting aside the beyond clearly implied 2 vs 2 battle of HRs that would make infinitely more sense from SIU's standard playbook of facing them against each other, let me get this straight:Now who is "abusing semantics?" The 2 BH don't have to be near the portal in the hotel because Rei was right there. They are probably at the other end of the portal waiting for the exit of the regulars. Why would Rei assume that Khun would be friends with 2 very ancient high rankers? That makes no f--king sense what so ever. Especially since one of those "friends" is JH, who hates all the great families? Rei anticipated that Khun might be playing a trick on him and in the event that Khun's ACTUAL REGULAR friends escaped through the portal.....Boom...BH ready to pounce.
They’re not normal regulars. None of themNot...really? It's still just him and a bunch of Regulars. Replace them with anyone else and the overall power dynamic doesn't change much.
Like, it doesn't matter much whether the supplementary members can hit damage in the thousands or ten thousands when the main guy can casually dish out millions.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Vincente said he will owe a life debt to Baam. I think he’ll stay. But I guess we’ll seeThe chances of Aria getting out of the Poe Bidau mothership and following Baam in the next arcs aren't that high imo, for Vicente, i don't think he will work together with Baam often and i doubt Baam trusts him enough to keep him around. So while they could be part of his team, for now i would keep their "member status" on hold.
I don't even think Baam has a proper team as of now, aside from Khun, Rak, Hwaryun. Maybe Cha, Hockney, Elaine qualify.
Teem Leeso, Ran and SnS are different imo, even if Endorsi or Ehwa for example could join the group under certain circumstances.
Dowon is also a question mark
HWR networks with Luslec who would know better, is a guide that's never been wrong, and does in fact know what she's talking about. She was even impressed that Wangnan knew as much.You actually accept Wangnan's shallow knowledge as truth? The history known to towerborn is fabricated, even Hwaryun is suspectible as it is a matter concerning irregular.
WHICH CONTRACT? Oh, the king contract. Yeah, that is my claim. Please explain how I'm somehow contradicted here.Furthermore, in that conversation, they also talked that irregular can bypass that contract which is contradicting your claim.
Funnily enough, the other FH's don't have the king contract. SIU says that Zahard received his kingship from an admin contract, the same contract discussed by Wangnan. BOTH can offer immortality. Only one offers kingship. Which really is mostly useless if you are already the strongest being in the tower that cannot be killed. It simply put it to paper. He already could enforce himself as king to anyone and everyone. Even White had multiple kingdoms. It was mostly ceremonial at that point.The real history was later revealed from Arlene's pocket, the immortality actually comes from separate contract.
Literally the chapter I *just* posted that shows that's exactly what was being communicated? Wow.Nope, you are wrong, reread Season 1 Episode 29.
Holy shit. Dude. The admin JUST looked into Baam and could tell what he was (an irregular, obviously) - and was visually shocked. Are you seriously telling me that the admin cannot tell that Baam is an irregular? Are you willing to go that far just to be contrarian? He was saying for YOU, this is unnecessary. For Towerborn, it is only helpful, for irregulars it is not. holy shit holy shit, how hard is this to understand?Note that admin said "climber of the tower", so it wasn't specific to irregular, this shackle also apply to towerborn.
Ah. You don't know what an irregular is. Now I understand. lol, go back to chapter 1.Just because Baam is shackled in terms of shinsu from admin doesn't mean he is shackled in terms of shinsu he can get by himself. Being an irregular is like having your own power generator, you can buy electricity from power company via contract but you can also generate your own electricity.
So you concede he could use it, albeit with unknow effects?Gustang is smart, he know the Thorn would be better in Baam than himself.
You......You look tasty is code for "Oh My goodness, you are an irregular! what are you doing here get off my lawn?"Holy shit. Dude. The admin JUST looked into Baam and could tell what he was (an irregular, obviously) - and was visually shocked. Are you seriously telling me that the admin cannot tell that Baam is an irregular? Are you willing to go that far just to be contrarian? He was saying for YOU, this is unnecessary. For Towerborn, it is only helpful, for irregulars it is not. holy shit holy shit, how hard is this to understand?
We both know you read ittl:dr
The same Rei that got outplayed in the WW flashback and again under his nose with the last time towerborn fucked with a teleporter? The same Rei that keeps getting outplayed by HJ throwing a wrench in his plans? The same Rei that had to do a shitty rush job at the Nest because Gustang moved when he didn't expect him to? Nah.but it is silly to think that Rei, apparently a better tactician than Gustang(certainly better than Khun)
Ummm, but he SAID they were sent to capture the traitor - who can't be in two places at the same time (Shroedinger's Traitor!). So, they're AT LEAST going after the traitor - who remains outside the hotel at an entirely different location.would send 2 of his remaining branch heads to *checks notes* capture a traitor
He cares about the traitor - it's a family matter he brags about knowing about (kind of the whole point about getting the traitor really). He cares about who the traitor is networking with hence wanting to see what the traitor's moves are. He's not just going to let the facilitators go free and clear. Regardless, his goal was the traitor by his own admission.and 2 very super powerful high rankers that he really doesn't care about(traitor includedso lets say 3 high rankers)
Then WHERE ARE THEY? The hotel is locked down - they are totally unnecessary in the adjacent room, and Baam was never thought to be able to even escape due to Rei thinking he still had time. How could they be capturing Baam somewhere Baam wasn't and wasn't thought to be??OR...now here me out... OR send the 2 BH to capture the hEiR hE cHoSe tO tAkE oVeR his whole entire family?
Stalling for time is one thing - finishing before the buzzer is another. He thought he still had time, and moved swiftly for that very reason. The first time we've seen a brotha walk.He knew Khun would stall for time so he worded it that in the event that Khun's scheme worked he had a back up to his back up.
So, Rei LET Baam escape is your theory? Just to capture him... again? Like, on purpose? Wouldn't it have been more dramatic and harrowing for Khun to see Baam not even get through the portal - not to mention less risky? He expected Khun to see sad face Baam.Lo(Po Bia) and behold while he stepped out expecting to see Baam, Khun planned, and Rei laughed(not really though) and told khun he was going after his friends. the way i see Lo Po Bias portals working is that there are TWO of them. since the 2 BH were shown to be riding their Shinheuh, clearly the other portal is outside.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I mean... ofc the admin knew exactly what Baam was and was giving him a warning specifically tailored for what he is, an irregular. That anyone can argue anything otherwise is absurd.You......You look tasty is code for "Oh My goodness, you are an irregular! what are you doing here get off my lawn?"
Have we had anymore interactions with admins since? I think I remember a brief one in second season but I could just be mistaken.
Baam could control Shinsu in the floor of death when Urek could not. Urek is an Irregular with far more power than Baam(not potential obviously) so there is that.
Yes because Khun's plan worked, or so he thought. are you trying to tell me that Khun gives two f--king frog farts about the fate of JinsungCha and a traitor?Rei was visually confused that no one was there. This wasn't a part of his plan.
Interesting, but I don't know if I agree. The Thorn is too special, particularly if Gustang knows about the prophecy and how it can help his goal (he does). The potential to lose one is too great to just gift it out anywhere. Hence, why he hid his fragment in the spirit waterfall where no one could get to it. It's very special, and he ONLY wants it in Baam's hands. He watched over Thorn 1 to make sure that happened at the workshop games. He personally handed over Thorn 2 to Baam on FoD. If there is a 3 and a 4 rest assured he'll be there feeding them to Baam, or behind the scenes. Baam getting the full Thorn is too central to the plot at large and the prophecy from Gustang's perspective.another theory I have on why Gustang doesn't use the thorns is because he gave one to FUG long before Zahard issued the 3 orders during the Hell Train Arc. Gustang was already prepping for war and was going to use FUG as a proxy.. It could also tie in to Arlene and whatever "prophecy" about Enryu and "the child"(Din Grogu) Garam and the denizens of the floor of death talk about. Or he could just be that much of a baller and pull out a whole pack of cigs and call it a day.
I think the most logical explaination though is that it is harder to fight many enemies than it is to fight one. Giving the thorns out enured that weapons that are capable of killing things like admins and immortals were in the hands of different enemies of Zahard so that he would have to fight on muliple fronts and stretch his resources and those of his allies(Chadavan corps and Lo Po Bia are perfect examples)
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I agree that Rei cares (mostly) about Baam.Yes because Khun's plan worked, or so he thought. are you trying to tell me that Khun gives two f--king frog farts about the fate of JinsungCha and a traitor?
Rei only cares about one thing. Baam. That's it. It used to be Zahard but this whole arc has been about Baam. Rei didn't let Baam go. Baam got away. simple as that.
Rei doesn't give two squatting squirrel shits about JinsunCha either because he has more important things to deal with. Gustang being one of them