Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 3
The reason I asked you is because I am the other detective. I trust you are one now after I investigated kkck. If I got the same result as you did (he was mafia), that would have confirmed to me that you were Mafia and I would have voted to kill you. I did not which is why I am putting my trust in you. Before i begin the reason i am putting this all out in the open, is because we are almost done for. The Mafia is about to win, and there would be no point in keeping this to myself so late in the game.
Remaining players:
Me
Geshode
Xadyu
Bugzee
scav
kkck
Hystzen
We had two night phases and here are my results:
kkck - Townie
Scav - Townie
If I am insane or not does not matter as it shows one fact. kkck and scav are both in the same group. They are either both innocent or both mafia. Including me there are 7 players remaining which means three of them are mafia. The possible scenarios by using mine and Geshodes results:
If we kill kkck and he is mafia, then we have another target (scav) for the next round (they are either both innocent or both mafia). We also would know that Geshode is not insane and Hystzen is a townie. So narrowing down the last possible mafia member between two of the last remaining members (Bugzee and Xadyu).
If we kill kkck and he is not mafia, then we know that Geshode is insane, Hystzen is mafia and scav is innocent. So we have confirmed target for the next round (Hystzen), which will leave the last two mafia members being the remaining 2 (Bugzee and Xadyu). It will be useless as we would have lost.
If we assume Geshode is insane, and lynch Hystzen and he is a Mafia member. That would mean kkck and scav are both innocent. And the other two members are Xadyu and Bugzee.
If we lynch Hystzen and he is not a mafia member. Then we have two confirmed Mafia members being kkck and scav. While the last member being between Bugzee and Xadyu. Which will be useless as we would have lost.
This is me trusting Geshode is a detective. If he isnt or - I concede I can be suspicous - I am not. We are fucked. The thing is if we dont trust each other, we are fucked. We have this phase as our last one. We need a fool proof system or as close to one as we can get. IF we dont kill a mafia in this round, we lost. Our choices are between kkck and Hystzen i believe. Now who strikes you as more suspicious? kkck being mafia would mean scav is aswell. Im not sure because Hystzen is damn suspicious with all his behaviour, but i am going with my gut instinct and do what i should have done in the last phase.
Vote kill kkck