Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015-2016] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Silverblade]

Koisome Momiji was terrible (Pajama no Kanojo too, and what do you know, fanservice had nothing to do with them being terrible) and was rightfully cancelled at four volumes. Hopefully this new manga follows in its steps.

Enough of bad manga. Sesuji wo Pin just won the Next manga award from DaVinci and NicoNico. Here is the full list. Yoko has made it.

 

[Stark700]

ESJ isn't doing the Yuragi manga. Presumably because it will be ecchi with nudity.

 

[ElJin]

Koisome Momiji was terrible (Pajama no Kanojo too, and what do you know, fanservice had nothing to do with them being terrible) and was rightfully cancelled at four volumes. Hopefully this new manga follows in its steps.

Enough of bad manga. Sesuji wo Pin just won the Next manga award from DaVinci and NicoNico. Here is the full list. Yoko has made it.

Nice see Sesuji and Black Clover doing well! Both of them have so much hype in their future, maybe with an anime (in a few years) they can reach 200K and 450K respectively in first week of sales!

 

[TyVip]

Is this the longest time One piece has gone without a break in the last couple of years or is it just me? I keep thinking there will be one this week but there isn't. Not that I'm complaining, mind you since the manga is actually pretty interesting right now.

There was a new year break on 1/4/16 ( correct me if i'm wrong ) . One Piece is usually 5 weeks and 1 week break. It only been 4 weeks for far after the break .

 

[ShenGao]

There was a new year break on 1/4/16 ( correct me if i'm wrong ) . One Piece is usually 5 weeks and 1 week break. It only been 4 weeks for far after the break .

The last time One Piece was the only series with a break was in Issue #2, this came out on the 14th December last year.
There is nothing saying about a break for next week, but i guess the week after that could be one.

 

[SharkBait]

There are some awful tropes in the harem ecchi genre alright. I hate "opening endings" in romance, it's basically an author not having the guts to make a good story because we have to praise everyone and MC can't pick a "waifu". But execution is all that matters at the end of the day imo so if the author does a good job with them I am ok. Also yeah I agree with Torca I don't get why a panty flash is such a big deal when we have shows like Free! that are filled with so much manservice. It's an ugly double standard.

How is it a double standard? Showing skin is natural for the sport of swimming, changing clothes in a locker room and showing some skin is a synergetic reaction in a boys sports series, a panty flash is not an organic response to the wind blowing or to characters diving downwards to the floor in a school hallway.

 

[Bomber D Rufi]

There was a new year break on 1/4/16 ( correct me if i'm wrong ) . One Piece is usually 5 weeks and 1 week break. It only been 4 weeks for far after the break .

I thought it was three weeks and then a break. So essentially OP was off once a month.

The last time One Piece was the only series with a break was in Issue #2, this came out on the 14th December last year.
There is nothing saying about a break for next week, but i guess the week after that could be one.

That's what I thought. So it has been a little while. Maybe Oda's health has improved enough for him to draw OP semi-regularly? Though I feel like with him working on the new movie, we'll be seeing more breaks more often soon...

 

[ShenGao]

After taking a look at the raws of the first chapter from "Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san" i have to find a new word for "generic harem cliche fanservice".
"Exorcist boy exorcises uncountable normal ghosts, encounters a female one he doesn't exorcise for whatever reason and now protects her from other exorcists." It's like the author knows the idea is terrible for a story and therefore puts every harem member into the story in the first chapter, with the hope the fanservice can somehow safe it.

 

[Xzone]

Agree, still need the english version(or 2 or 3 chapter) but the raw look bad, very bad.
Hight spec lover was better option to make a series, was a cliche romcom yes, but has a interesting story....

 

[kobester11]

Man, that was bad... Like, real bad.

I'd take Buddy Strike over this piece of cliche anytime. I mean holy mary mother of jesus.
When someone tells you to not base the content by it's cover, don't always believe on that. Sometimes, the cover tells you all.

 

[Mammo]

"oh no! I tripped & accidentally grabbed this girl's boobs!"
"oh no! it happened again!"
"oh no! she punched me & I flew & fell into the women's hot springs"

such magnificent writing! what a masterpiece! that sure showed me how wrong my initial judgment was!

 

[TyVip]

It was pretty mediocre . I think it try to inspire from To Love ru ( accidental trips and boobs grab) + Love Hina ( every harem member in the beginning and accidental trips + boobs grab) but failed.

But Nisekoi is ending and lack of ecchi/harem make me think this will survive .

Also, i heard from a source that say Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san artist is Saeki Shun old teacher ? Can someone confirm that for me please ?

edit old assistant . Thanks ShenGao

 

[ShenGao]

Also, i heard from a source that say Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san artist is Saeki Shun old teacher ? Can someone confirm that for me please ?

I only found this from the last page of Koisome Momiji:

Spoiler

 

[TyVip]

I only found this from the last page of Koisome Momiji:

Spoiler

I see . So Shun was an assistant for Jump magazine . Nice find . Thank you .

 

[Deathinteresse]

I think it's absolutly fine - the art is very good and the main heroine is cute
nothing original but I don't mind as long it's enjoyable

 

[SharkBait]

Ill never understand why people fool themselves into thinking an ecchi manga will be good and then end up dissapointed when it isnt. The genre is just a blackhole of rubbish.

 

[saef1234]

damn i was hoping the author behind the peach pluck and garden one shots would get serialized

 

[Pietro]

The first chapter of the author of Koisome Moimiji:
http://mangahead.com/Manga-Raw-Scan/Yuragi-sou-no-Yuuna-san/Yuragi-sou-no-Yuuna-san-1-Raw-Scan

--- Double Post Merged, Feb 8, 2016, Original Post Date: Feb 8, 2016 ---

P.S: I REALLY liked it, its much better than Nisekoi

 

[Ecchi Boy]

I can already see the butthurt in this thread but then again this thread is always butthurt when their mangaka does a series they don't like.

Like me with Best Blue.

 

[SharkBait]

I can already see the butthurt in this thread but then again this thread is always butthurt when their mangaka does a series they don't like.

Like me with Best Blue.

How does one dislike Best BLue? Its up there with Haikyuu for best jump sports manga.