- Joined
- Jan 20, 2006
- Messages
- 4,418
- Reaction score
- 4,334
- Gender
- Male
- Country
-
There are several issues which make it close to impossible to determine a characters fighting prowess exactly only by the Balor numbers. For example not all three stats progress in the same fashion. Strength and Power can easily jump into the territory of double-digit k. However the Spirit stat rarely exceeds 4000 even among the Commandments. It is however an equally important stat which possibly also affects durability (physical and mental) or by how much a character can temporally strain and overcome the limits determined by the numbers on the other two stats.Well, the point made in the manga is that galan went over 40k. By how much exactly is unknown but he should still have a comfortable lead over dolor in strength. Also worth noting, galan seemed to have what appeared to be actual named techniques when it comes to his.... spearmanship, something which is rather unusual in nanatsu so far. So it seems probable that galan not only outclasses dolor in terms of physical combat but is also the superior physical fighter as a whole which could end up making a fair bit of a difference. I guess I need to frame my question differently. We have galan, whose strength is greater than either dolor's own strength or magic but but obviously inferior to their sum. So how exactly is the consideration made in regards to how this compares to galan? Is it a simple addition? As in, dolor's combat capacity would be merely the sum of his strength and magic? Gloxinia does seem like he should simply vastly overwhelm galan though. An entirely magical arsenal powered up by his vast amount of magic.... On the other hand perhaps magic itself is not quite as straightforward as a power. Take king and meliodas vs the albion. Meliodas was able to slash it apart while king's chastiefol could not cut the albion.
Next thing is, the age-old comparison between the all-rounder and the specialist. If stats are more or less evenly distributed vs someone who has a high numerical value in a single stat, doesn't necessarily mean that the specialist loses in a direct comparison. Why? Because the Balor levels do not take into account things like experience and technical skill. Or to use an example with Galan and Dolor - Galan is highly specialised in physical combat. He is also very old. His power might have degraded over time due to his age and is maybe inferior to his prime strength but in exchange he has gained experience. And since his forte is physical strength, we can assume that he has absolutely polished his skills and techniques to a point where he is a master. Dolor also has a very high physical strength value but that is mostly coming from his genetic advantage as a giant. Since his numbers are more evenly distributed between Strength and Power compared to Galan's speciality, we can assume that Dolor would be able to hold his own for a while but ultimately he would be outfought by Galan even if we combine both of Dolor's values. It gives him an overall higher level but Galan is a specialist - Dolor is a jack of all trades in comparison. I exaggerate a bit to emphasize what I mean but you don't reach mastery in something if you dedicate your time and energy to several skills compared to a person who dedicates all his time to a single one.
Mind you, a lot of this is very circumstancial but just because character X has overall lower stats than character Y, doesn't mean he outright loses if all of his stats are focused on one attribute compared to several.
Not to mention that things like individual powers and current state of mind also come into play which aren't reflected by the Balor values at all. Or circumstancial factors like surprise attacks (cough Mel vs Derrie last chapter cough)
Nakaba was actually smart even if a lot of people hate him for his power level shenanigans. Because he had Gowther voice the in-verse explanation that these stats are not absolute and are to be considered more as guidelines. That's Nakaba telling the readers to not overthing this stuff.
