Fantasy Ishgar Mages Power Rate - [FINISHED]

[Takuan]

Really? REALLY?! HOW THE HELL is Rufus coming out before freaking ICHIYA ?!

I understand the running joke about Ichiya but there's no way at all, NO WAY, that Ichiya deserves a higher note than Rufus or Orga.

I'm to blame i guess, since i didn't give a high mark to Rufus due to his lack of appearance, but what Rufus has shown is still definitely way better than anything Ichiya has ever shown thus far. I'm EXTREMELY disappointed to see him come out now.

I'm just ashamed of myself, i should have given him a way higher mark in order to prevent him from being out at #29... Out before Ichiya really? Ridiculous.

I'm expecting Orga to come next then, since his feats are even worse than Rufus...
Rufus before Ichiya.

 

[Static]

Wtf @Takuan ? Aren't you going TOO overboard?!

Please elaborate to me how Ichiya can be below even Acnologia, I'm waiting.

 

[Takuan]

Wtf @Takuan ? Aren't you going TOO overheard?!

Please elaborate to me how Ichiya can be below even Acnologia, I'm waiting.

Yeah... Kappa is the key word. Seriously though, now that Rufus is gone and Orga probably will be gone soon as well, i'm really hoping to see Ichiya VERY soon. Otherwise the running joke is going too far.

But yeah fuck me... I should have been more generous with Rufus. Im so dumb.
Rufus #29. Damn

 

[BluePegasus]

#27

Racer
Score: 4,76785714

Highest score: 7 x 1 (@Belserion)
Lowest score: 1 x 1 (@DiMaria Yesta)
My score: 6,5/10

You can say whatever you want about Racer, but he's still top tier mage when it comes to the level of speed. Slowing Magic is pretty impressive you know, you can see it as a limited version of Age Seal. But well, it kinda lost its hype after Jellal outsped Racer. Fine, but that's more a show-off of Jellal's own power. Time-related magic types like Racer's are still powerful as hell, to be honest.

But yeah this seems like a good time for him to go.

Overview
Magic: Slowing Magic
Affiliation: Crime Sorcière

Seriously though, now that Rufus is gone and Orga probably will be gone soon as well, i'm really hoping to see Ichiya VERY soon.

Not yet, my friend. Not yet.

#26

Juvia Lockser
Score: 4,94642857

Highest score: 7 x 1 (@Belserion)
Lowest score: 2 x 1 (@Gryffindor)
My score: 6/10

FINALLY Fairy Tail loses one of their participants. Surprisingly enough, Juvia left after Rufus. Not getting too far into that again though.

Okay, so apparently Juvia doesn't use Water Magic but a variation of it called Water. Aha! Anyway, Water Body is a pretty good defense feat; it basically means that you just can't defeat her with physical attacks. Overall I don't think Juvia is that impressive. Well, at least when it not rains..

Overview
Magic: Water, Water-Make
Affiliation: Fairy Tail​

 

[Kouichi]

I still think Rufus over Ichiya or Juvia. Pre-TS Gray had a hard time beating him though.

I am sorry but Racer over Hoteye? Should it be in the other way around?

Edited: Sorry I thought Hoteye is on the list. I'm drunk again. |D

 

[Doughboy]

Sorano ≥ Rufus > Juvia > Racer. In that order, Racer is weak sauce like his nose and shades.

 

[BluePegasus]

TOP 25

Fairy Tail (10/11)
Natsu
Gray
Lucy
Erza
Wendy
Gajeel
Laxus
Mirajane
Freed
Gildarts

Sabertooth (4/6)
Sting
Rogue
Minerva
Orga

Lamia Scale (1/2)
Lyon

Mermaid Heel (1/2)
Kagura

Blue Pegasus (1/4)
Ichiya

Quatro Cerberus (0/2)

Crime Sorcière (4/6)
Jellal
Meredy
Midnight
Cobra

Wizard Saints (4/4)
Hyberion
Wolfheim
Warrod
Jura​

 

[Linali]

As for Rufus' low score: I guess we should blame his irrelevance, after GMG we didn't see him fighting even once, he and Orga are throwing just some random comments here and there. But still Orga should be on the same train and yet he's higher in ranking. Even tho last time we saw him fighting, he was one shoted by Jura's bare hand

 

[Ebony Maw]

Damn, one of my boys from ST out already????

He has such cool magic too, I guess irrelevance killed him. RIP Sabertooth hype.

If Orga is next.....

 

[Takuan]

Damn, one of my boys from ST out already????

He has such cool magic too, I guess irrelevance killed him. RIP Sabertooth hype.

If Orga is next.....

Orga should have been right next to Rufus though. They have exactly the same relevance (aka zero relevance) and Rufus's feats are above Orga's. I dont really understand how Rufus came out and Orga still is not.

Anyway, I'm not surprised about Racer and Juvia. I just wonder where is Orga considering Rufus is out, and more importantly, why is Ichiya still here.
I'm gonna laugh my ass off when seeing the marks given to him.

 

[Axiomus]

Rufus is weakest of Sabertooth other than Yukino. Even in the GMG, Orga has the highest MP. Sting had the best feats. Minerva was considered the ace. By the time Tartarus rolled around, Sting and Rogue could take out a demonized Jiemma - whom was stronger than the 9 demon gates. Rufus lagged behind. In the current arc, WSD Sting is without a doubt the strongest in Sabertooth by far. Then Rogue and Minerva for being able to take out Spriggan Historia. Then Orga for supposedly having the highest MP prior to the timeskip. Then Rufus, then Yukino.

That said, it's a crime that Meredy hasn't been eliminated yet. So I have a problem with the rankings. Nobody struggling against pre-TS Zancrow should be high on this list.

 

[Demon Hunter]

lol I didn't even vote.

I already know who will be the #1.

 

[Takuan]

Rufus is weakest of Sabertooth other than Yukino. Even in the GMG, Orga has the highest MP. Sting had the best feats. Minerva was considered the ace. By the time Tartarus rolled around, Sting and Rogue could take out a demonized Jiemma - whom was stronger than the 9 demon gates. Rufus lagged behind. In the current arc, WSD Sting is without a doubt the strongest in Sabertooth by far. Then Rogue and Minerva for being able to take out Spriggan Historia. Then Orga for supposedly having the highest MP prior to the timeskip. Then Rufus, then Yukino.

That said, it's a crime that Meredy hasn't been eliminated yet. So I have a problem with the rankings. Nobody struggling against pre-TS Zancrow should be high on this list.

Gray has always been portrayed as equal to Natsu, and he won high diff against Rufus, whereas Natsu solo'd both DF Sting and DF Rogue. I'm not saying Rufus was stronger than both of them combined, but at the very least Rufus was stronger than both Sting and Rogue individually.
Actually i would even say that during GMG, Sting and Rogue were the worst out of the top mages of Sabertooth (without Yukino ofc). Their popularity was due to them being Dragon Slayers and their awesome synergy. Individually they were not as good as Minerva, Orga or Rufus.
That's just my opinion. ANd that's only during GMG. I admit that Rufus and ORga didnt get new feats so it's only natural they fell behind in power rankings compared to the Twins and Minerva.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

Glad I didn't vote so I can be completely impartial.

And it's also funny watching the salt

I'm looking st this and thinking the ones who are being voted out are the ones who haven't done much this arc + popularity.

So like Ichiya sand Freed fought fake Wharl. While Yukino hasn't even summoned one spirit since arc has started. Angel has done nothing except walk around and orgasm. Quadro Cerberus disappeared after Bacchus was shown that one panel. Rufus has been fodder backup.

Meredy hasn't done much but she's popular.

To me it will be interesting to see where people put Lyon, Freed, Orga, Cobra, Midnight because these are all respectable characters but have questionable power levels because of less panel time and little to no recent feats.

 

[Axiomus]

Gray has always been portrayed as equal to Natsu, and he won high diff against Rufus, whereas Natsu solo'd both DF Sting and DF Rogue. I'm not saying Rufus was stronger than both of them combined, but at the very least Rufus was stronger than both Sting and Rogue individually.
Actually i would even say that during GMG, Sting and Rogue were the worst out of the top mages of Sabertooth (without Yukino ofc). Their popularity was due to them being Dragon Slayers and their awesome synergy. Individually they were not as good as Minerva, Orga or Rufus.
That's just my opinion. ANd that's only during GMG. I admit that Rufus and ORga didnt get new feats so it's only natural they fell behind in power rankings compared to the Twins and Minerva.

I would argue Natsu was portrayed as superior than Gray in the GMG due to lightning mode. Tartarus arc evened the odds again with Devil Slaying, maybe even gave Gray an advantage because of Silver's MP. Sting managed to temporarily solo Natsu and Gajeel, and he blasted a hole in Jiemma. Rogue and Minerva considered him to be their strongest once he thought Lector was dead due to his power of feelings. Rogue may not have been on the same level, though by the time Tartarus rolled around he and Sting was capable of slugging it out with Mard Geer and killing demonized Jiemma.

But yeah, GMG portrayals are irrelevant. WSD Sting defeated Larcade, whom was considered to be the strongest after August and Irene. None of the other Sabertooth members really would stand a chance against even an average Spriggan.

 

[Takuan]

I would argue Natsu was portrayed as superior than Gray in the GMG due to lightning mode. Tartarus arc evened the odds again with Devil Slaying, maybe even gave Gray an advantage because of Silver's MP. Sting managed to temporarily solo Natsu and Gajeel, and he blasted a hole in Jiemma. Rogue and Minerva considered him to be their strongest once he thought Lector was dead due to his power of feelings. Rogue may not have been on the same level, though by the time Tartarus rolled around he and Sting was capable of slugging it out with Mard Geer and killing demonized Jiemma.

But yeah, GMG portrayals are irrelevant. WSD Sting defeated Larcade, whom was considered to be the strongest after August and Irene. None of the other Sabertooth members really would stand a chance against even an average Spriggan.

Yeah, i'm not taking Tartaros into consideration when comparing the Twins to Orga or Rufus, since they didnt appear in Tartaros. I was entirely basing myself on GMG events. Also about the PoF thing, i believe Rufus or Orga would have been portrayed as strongest if they had a reason to fight in order to save a friend or something similar. That kind of "power-up" that Sting was hyped up to have gotten isn't a Sting only thing. I'm not changing my point of view about Sting just because he was temporarily more motivated.
Yup, in this arc Rufus and Orga unfortunately never appeared, aside from when they were shown crucified... That's lame. So much potential wasted. I genuinely believe they should be still comparable to Sting and Rogue and even Minerva now that she's Rogue level. But yeah... side characters.

 

[Axiomus]

Yeah, i'm not taking Tartaros into consideration when comparing the Twins to Orga or Rufus, since they didnt appear in Tartaros. I was entirely basing myself on GMG events. Also about the PoF thing, i believe Rufus or Orga would have been portrayed as strongest if they had a reason to fight in order to save a friend or something similar. That kind of "power-up" that Sting was hyped up to have gotten isn't a Sting only thing. I'm not changing my point of view about Sting just because he was temporarily more motivated.
Yup, in this arc Rufus and Orga unfortunately never appeared, aside from when they were shown crucified... That's lame. So much potential wasted. I genuinely believe they should be still comparable to Sting and Rogue and even Minerva now that she's Rogue level. But yeah... side characters.

I consider Tartarus and GMG to just be X791, because there was only a 2 week timeframe difference between the two. Sting and Rogue surpassed Minerva then, judging by their respective interactions with Mard Geer. The power of feelings may only be temporary, but Sting and Rogue have grown stronger than Rufus anyways over the 1 year timeskip that this is pretty much irrelevant.

 

[Takuan]

I consider Tartarus and GMG to just be X791, because there was only a 2 week timeframe difference between the two. Sting and Rogue surpassed Minerva then, judging by their respective interactions with Mard Geer. The power of feelings may only be temporary, but Sting and Rogue have grown stronger than Rufus anyways over the 1 year timeskip that this is pretty much irrelevant.

That's the main problem though, how can you be certain that Sting and Rogue are now stronger than Rufus or Orga? There is nothing to back this up since Rufus and Orga have no feats at all and never appeared. For all we know they might still be around the same level.
I'm not saying that Rufus and Orga should be ranked equal to Sting and Rogue, because we can not do that. We don't know what they are currently worth. But that also works the other way around, we cant claim that they are worse now.

 

[Laxus chan-yo]

TOP 25

Fairy Tail (10/11)
Natsu
Gray
Lucy
Erza
Wendy
Gajeel
Laxus
Mirajane
Freed
Gildarts

Sabertooth (4/6)
Sting
Rogue
Minerva
Orga

Lamia Scale (1/2)
Lyon

Mermaid Heel (1/2)
Kagura

Blue Pegasus (1/4)
Ichiya

Quatro Cerberus (0/2)

Crime Sorcière (4/6)
Jellal
Meredy
Midnight
Cobra

Wizard Saints (4/4)
Hyberion
Wolfheim
Warrod
Jura​

I'm interested to know if anyone else has any predictions on how the top 25 will go. My predictions on the rankings:

1. Laxus
2. Gildarts
3. Natsu
4. Jellal
5. Erza
6. Gray
7. Hyberion
8. Gajeel
9. Mirajane
10. Wolfheim
11. Warrod
12. Jura
13. Kagura
14. Sting
15. Rogue
16. Wendy
17. Minerva
18. Ichiya
19. Midnight
20. Lyon
21. Lucy
22. Cobra
23. Orga
24. Meredy
25. Freed

Note this is not my list but my prediction.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

I'm interested to know if anyone else has any predictions on how the top 25 will go. My predictions on the rankings:

1. Laxus
2. Gildarts
3. Natsu
4. Jellal
5. Erza
6. Gray
7. Hyberion
8. Gajeel
9. Mirajane
10. Wolfheim
11. Warrod
12. Jura
13. Kagura
14. Sting
15. Rogue
16. Wendy
17. Minerva
18. Ichiya
20. Midnight
21. Lucy
22. Cobra
23. Orga
24. Meredy
25. Freed

Note this is not my list but my prediction.

Are you missing someone? For number 19.