Discussion Mael and Meliodas

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
Mael vs Meliodas (Leader of 10C version)
 

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
Feel free
 

Arjuna

The Emperor Who Rules the World
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2015
Messages
16,366
Reaction score
25,476
Age
31
Gender
Male
Country
India

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
Alright people who wants to discuss this match up should come here
 

Eiyuu Yami

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2018
Messages
739
Reaction score
1,593
Age
30
Country
Austria
Only "The One" version of Mael can beat AM-Meliodas, every other version of him gets clapped.

Mel has still his indura form and innate magic so it's only a matter of time until even "The One" will be useless against Meliodas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ger

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
Mael wins with sunshine near noon.

Meliodas wins in every other situation.
I've already debunk why this is not the case. So first of all if mael was stronger why did Jelamet implied demons were winning was because pf meliodas? When he left and betrayed them they were attacking DC. So gowthers statement clearly proves more points towards the narrative of the manga. Provide an evidence to support your claim. All you used was opinions without looking at narrative stand point. Also when Ludoshel states that mael was only stronger than him when the sun almost hit the noon. So you just got debunked when meliodas is that far stronger than ludo himself which he was wary when meliodas tried to help Elizabeth on the flashback. So cite yoyr sources to prove your claim.
 

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
I've already debunk why this is not the case. So first of all if mael was stronger why did Jelamet implied demons were winning was because pf meliodas? When he left and betrayed them they were attacking DC. So gowthers statement clearly proves more points towards the narrative of the manga. Provide an evidence to support your claim. All you used was opinions without looking at narrative stand point. Also when Ludoshel states that mael was only stronger than him when the sun almost hit the noon. So you just got debunked when meliodas is that far stronger than ludo himself which he was wary when meliodas tried to help Elizabeth on the flashback. So cite yoyr sources to prove your claim.
Ludoshel: Your power is the same as my brother's Mael.

Manga 232: Escanor at full noon easily overpowers Meliodas.

You: Mael and Meliodas are equals! Despite the manga proving that Escanor with sunshine at it's peak easily overpowered Meliodas!

Please stop, you're being biased. I've said it countless times but you should rejoice at the fact that it takes one of the Four Archangels with an extremely situation and very powerful God power to even stand a chance against Meliodas.

Even the most stubborn Meliodas fanboys accept this, why are you refuting it? I'm not going to present evidence to you that's already in the manga, you'll just not read it again.
 

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
Ludoshel: Your power is the same as my brother's Mael.

Manga 232: Escanor at full noon easily overpowers Meliodas.

You: Mael and Meliodas are equals! Despite the manga proving that Escanor with sunshine at it's peak easily overpowered Meliodas!

Please stop, you're being biased. I've said it countless times but you should rejoice at the fact that it takes one of the Four Archangels with an extremely situation and very powerful God power to even stand a chance against Meliodas.

Even the most stubborn Meliodas fanboys accept this, why are you refuting it? I'm not going to present evidence to you that's already in the manga, you'll just not read it again.
That does not refute my points?? the fact you brought up escanors fight with meliodas which ALL OF US here knows that's not his peak at all lol. You might want to reread 233-241 you missed so many infos why that meliodas is not even comparable at all. So your argument is moot as a soft jelly that can easily be squashed.

So you cant prove your claim with these BS headcanon hypothesis battle assumption to prove why your point is valid??? Your proof "escanor beat meliodas therefore mael beats" already suffice your argument and I already debunk why that argument is terrible.

So address my points why did jelamet, gowther says that meliodas betraying the clan was like the most shocking and as jelamets statement goes meliodas leaving was a dream come true, which suggest DC were winning due to meliodas oen strength once he left they were pushed back. This was DC vs all clans too which had strong fighters other than GD.
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
That does not refute my points?? the fact you brought up escanors fight with meliodas which ALL OF US here knows that's not his peak at all lol. You might want to reread 233-241 you missed so many infos why that meliodas is not even comparable at all. So your argument is moot as a soft jelly that can easily be squashed.

So you cant prove your claim with these BS headcanon hypothesis battle assumption to prove why your point is valid??? Your proof "escanor beat meliodas therefore mael beats" already suffice your argument and I already debunk why that argument is terrible.

So address my points why did jelamet, gowther says that meliodas betraying the clan was like the most shocking and as jelamets statement goes meliodas leaving was a dream come true, which suggest DC were winning due to meliodas oen strength once he left they were pushed back. This was DC vs all clans too which had strong fighters other than GD.
You're making too big a deal about Mel switching sides, it doesnt really imply all that much power, its more about his reputation. Goddesses are simply cowards, when Mel joined them they saw it as an opportunity to commit to the war with demons, but when the demons replaced him with Estarossa they gave up, that means to the goddesses, Meliodas was worth about as much as Estarossa was. Besides, the demons werent winning because of Mel, even when Mel left them and joined the goddesses, who also were working with the fairies and the giants, they still werent defeated.

AM Meliodas is fodder to The One, but against normal use of Sun he wins easily, we saw it clearly in the manga.
 

Arjuna

The Emperor Who Rules the World
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2015
Messages
16,366
Reaction score
25,476
Age
31
Gender
Male
Country
India
If Mael wins it is only "One".Other situations he gets destroyed.
 

Ger

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2018
Messages
1,752
Reaction score
805
Age
26
Country
Canada
You're making too big a deal about Mel switching sides, it doesnt really imply all that much power, its more about his reputation. Goddesses are simply cowards, when Mel joined them they saw it as an opportunity to commit to the war with demons, but when the demons replaced him with Estarossa they gave up, that means to the goddesses, Meliodas was worth about as much as Estarossa was. Besides, the demons werent winning because of Mel, even when Mel left them and joined the goddesses, who also were working with the fairies and the giants, they still werent defeated.

AM Meliodas is fodder to The One, but against normal use of Sun he wins easily, we saw it clearly in the manga.
OMFG you clearly didnt read what jelamet meant.

DEMON CLAN WAS WINNING THE PREVIOUS WAR AND THAT WAS BEFORE MELIODAS BETRAYED THEM. once he did Jelamet on quite "Him betraying them was like a dream come true" you clearly did not deal my argument. Actually when meliodas left goddess clan and all other clans were winning due to the fact that they had more confidence on taking them on since they dont have their leader. In fact case by case scenario without meliodas commandments are nothing to Archangels. So this clearly debunks your claim so please provide me MORE evidence and supporting factor to your argument.

Yeah they replaced meliodas using Mael cuz the balance was tipped and Mael WAS STATED BY GOWTHER HIMSELF ON QUOTE "You, a warrior has a power enough to match meliodas" gowther never stated "You, a warrior has a power to beat meliodas". Clearly you have no rebuttals to the claims I have made.

The fact that u said meliodas got beaten by The One when I already told otaku his claims are not even backed up by the narrative sense at all so let me post a panel why that's the case.
This panels suggested that even aftermath Merlin states that meliodas is going back to meliodas of old which was the leader meaning even when he fought escanor he was still not at his old self and still progressing there. Also the quote "previous levels" that applies to what meliodas throughout chapter 1 till 233 that says as his emotion gets robbed his strength surpasses his each previous levels. And the other panel supports that fact that Elizabeth tries to stop meliodas from progressing to his old self, as she said it would ben early impossible for him to go back to his emotional state since his emotions are gone but she should atleast resist the progression. This is backed up by DK that when he saw escanors fight he said "a little more". So this DEBUNKS ANY CLAIMS YOY USED TO MAKE MELIODAS WEAK
 

Shadowlord123

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 20, 2018
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
5,158
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
Okay, let's see. It was already stated that Mael had the power to match Meliodas, which means he should be compàrable if not equal to him for the sake of the power balance. When I say that Mel and Mael are equal, I'm not taking into account Mel's innate magic (we don't know anything about it) and Indura (until more information about it gets revealed, it is confirmed to be suicide move for the demons).

Mel and Mael can't be equal during all day. Why? We know the mechanics of Sun/Sunshine in which the user gets more powerful by daytime until noon comes. That means that Mael's power level was different during all day, meanwhile Mel's power was constant. So, the only way this statement can make sense is that in some hours Mel was stronger than Mael and in some other hours, Mael was stronger than Mel.

In what hours Mel would be stronger than Mael and Mael stronger than Mel? We don't know since we haven't seen too much of Mael to even know. If I had to speculate: Late Morning (11AM and above) Mael is stronger than Meliodas. During the rest of the day, Mel has the advantage.

I've seen people here saying that the only time of the day Mael can beat Mel is noon and also going as far as to say that for the rest of the day he would get beaten easily. The power balance would make zero sense if that was the case.

Mel wasn't at his full power when he fought Escanor since it was already stated by the DK himself that he had only a little more to go there. All the narrative implies that Mel had a boost, but it also implies that the boost wasn't too great since the DK's words implied that he was almost at his prime in his fight with Escanor. Going as far as to imply that he could equal or beat The One because he got a little bit stronger is a massive leap in logic. I'm a big fan of Mel, he's probably my favourite character in the series, but some of the wank here is unreal.
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
OMFG you clearly didnt read what jelamet meant.

DEMON CLAN WAS WINNING THE PREVIOUS WAR AND THAT WAS BEFORE MELIODAS BETRAYED THEM. once he did Jelamet on quite "Him betraying them was like a dream come true" you clearly did not deal my argument. Actually when meliodas left goddess clan and all other clans were winning due to the fact that they had more confidence on taking them on since they dont have their leader.
Calm down dude, no need to freak out. Why dont you point out exactly where Jelamet says the demons were winning, you babbling about "Meliodas leaving the DC was a dream come true" doesnt tell me anything other than that the goddesses were happy to see him go. Even when Meliodas actually joined the goddess clan, killing 2 commandments on his way out, the demons were still going strong. So demons with 3 of their strongest warriors missing, including Meliodas, could still put up a fight against the goddesses, fairies, giants and even Meliodas himself, them winning the war before Mel defected and killed those commandments wouldnt be a surprise, but then again you havent provided the quote saying that they were winning.
In fact case by case scenario without meliodas commandments are nothing to Archangels. So this clearly debunks your claim so please provide me MORE evidence and supporting factor to your argument.
Or maybe you should provide more evidence for your claim right here, because last time i checked Tarmiel said he and Sariel are worth 2 commandments each, not that "without Mel the commandments are nothing to them". In fact the demons would have succeeded in sealing off the goddesses and unleashing the demons on Stigma if it wasnt for Gowther and old Gowther doing their own plan, so i guess there goes your whole theory of "Mel switching sides=goddesses win", demon infighting was a bigger hindrance than Meliodas' defection lol.
Yeah they replaced meliodas using Mael cuz the balance was tipped and Mael WAS STATED BY GOWTHER HIMSELF ON QUOTE "You, a warrior has a power enough to match meliodas" gowther never stated "You, a warrior has a power to beat meliodas". Clearly you have no rebuttals to the claims I have made.
The fact that a 60k character like Estarossa was seen as a fitting replacement for Mel is already enough to say that the impact of Mel switching sides had more to do with his reputation than his actual strength.
The fact that u said meliodas got beaten by The One when I already told otaku his claims are not even backed up by the narrative sense at all so let me post a panel why that's the case.
This panels suggested that even aftermath Merlin states that meliodas is going back to meliodas of old which was the leader meaning even when he fought escanor he was still not at his old self and still progressing there. Also the quote "previous levels" that applies to what meliodas throughout chapter 1 till 233 that says as his emotion gets robbed his strength surpasses his each previous levels. And the other panel supports that fact that Elizabeth tries to stop meliodas from progressing to his old self, as she said it would ben early impossible for him to go back to his emotional state since his emotions are gone but she should atleast resist the progression. This is backed up by DK that when he saw escanors fight he said "a little more". So this DEBUNKS ANY CLAIMS YOY USED TO MAKE MELIODAS WEAK
Haha, you sure like the word "debunked", don't you? Too bad you haven't done anything more than say it. And no, the fact that i said Meliodas was beaten by The One means i've read the manga. Merlin also said that Meliodas had become as he was as the leader of the 10C back at the start of his fight with Escanor. And besides, in the panel you just gave it says Mel is growing even stronger than his previous levels, why wouldnt Mael be able to beat him if he was even weaker back then?
 

Tristan

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 25, 2013
Messages
2,725
Reaction score
2,376
Country
Germany
AM Meliodas is fodder to The One, but against normal use of Sun he wins easily, we saw it clearly in the manga.
I would say he was "fodder" to the One if he lost his cool and confidence in himself after his attack on Escanor failed, but NO ... he was still smiling with confidence, which means he was still holding back at that time. When Escanor reached the state of 11:30, Estarossa suddenly felt his huge boost in power and started to cower in fear. Meliodas saw the One, and nothing changed in him. He was just caught up by that attack in which Escanor put all he's got, and that's all. Long story short, we haven't seen that (weak / incomplete) version of Meliodas using his power seriously, let alone unleashing ALL of his power at once as the One did.
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
I would say he was "fodder" to the One if he lost his cool and confidence in himself after his attack on Escanor failed, but NO ... he was still smiling with confidence, which means he was still holding back at that time. When Escanor reached the state of 11:30, Estarossa suddenly felt his huge boost in power and started to cower in fear. Meliodas saw the One, and nothing changed in him. He was just caught up by that attack in which Escanor put all he's got, and that's all. Long story short, we haven't seen that (weak / incomplete) version of Meliodas using his power seriously, let alone unleashing ALL of his power at once as the One did.
Galand was still pretty cocky too as Mel beat his ass, but i suppose he at least lasted 10 seconds unlike Mel who didnt even last 1...
 

Tristan

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 25, 2013
Messages
2,725
Reaction score
2,376
Country
Germany
Galand was still pretty cocky too as Mel beat his ass, but i suppose he at least lasted 10 seconds unlike Mel who didnt even last 1...
It's not me who said that ... It's actually the Sins who told us that Meliodas was merely TOYING with him! Do you really think someone would use the "PEAK" of his power while toying with his opponent?! Logic please :facepalm
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,567
Age
31
Country
Australia
It's not me who said that ... It's actually the Sins who told us that Meliodas was merely TOYING with him! Do you really think someone would use the "PEAK" of his power while toying with his opponent?! Logic please :facepalm
So? I didnt say Mel wasnt toying with Escanor back then. As for the "peak" of Mel's power, who cares? Escanor can oneshot him, am i supposed to be impressed by the imaginary power you think Mel has when i've seen Escanor put the man down with a swipe of the hand? Escanor beats Mel at noon and Mel beats Escanor the rest of the day, I dont know why you guys cant be satisfied with that.
 
Top