I was surprised there wasn't another thread for King besides this one, since he's such a good character. First of all, all his backstory, especially the fight with Helbram it led up to, seemed great to me. I didn't like him mind-wiping Diane, but other pieces of his backstory are just good enough to make up for it IMO.
All his combat is extremely entertaining to watch for me. Simply his way of fighting at long range seems much more creative than magic users in other manga. Instead of just firing projectiles he can manipulate them continuously and keep using the same object. Finally a mage has a weapon which works, allowing them to have something durable they use instead of constantly seeming vulnerable whenever they aren't casting a spell. And of course since he can regenerate it from almost nothing that just makes it all the more frustrating to deal with. When an enemy is forced to stay on the defensive against it, it is practically impossible for them to win in the long run. As long as they are only attacking Chastiefol, they might as well be attacking an immortal enemy like Ban, their attacks are going to do zero lasting damage. And since Guardian is a remote controlled melee fighter that is also immune to melee hits that aren't slash or pierce based with its rubbery nature, he can essentially do a normal melee fighting style with a puppet that can also bypass human limits. Plus he could use Yggdra Cloth if he wants to melee in person, although it seems that is still not enough to let him truly block attacks with his own strength, strangely, even though he gets enough strength from it to strike pretty powerfully. He's basically like a mosquito, but with all his magical defenses and methods of attack, a lack of personal durability isn't the end of the world.
Unlike certain other sins(Looking at you, Ban), his fighting style really changes massively as he gets stronger and it's much more than a mere increased power level number. And unlike Merlin, we have a mostly clear estimate of his capabilities at any given time, so there is no need to worry about him making some ridiculous asspull. You can see his weaknesses in his previous fights clearly. Here are some examples:
When he 1v1'd Guila, he was dominating quite easily until the end, where he was too lazy, thought she was dead, and accidentally let her get past his spear's position to use an explosion up close, and since he can't have multiple at once, he can't have a piece of chastiefol always in position to turn into a barrier right next to him. In his 1v2 against Guila and Jericho, he just keeps up with them using one form at a time, since his flight advantage and stronger magic makes it too difficult for the two of them to overwhelm him. And even then he has to think a little in first defending both of their attacks, and only afterwards counterattacking.The reason he has to let Helbram knock him around in their 1v1 is because he can only use one form of Chastiefol at any time, he can't heal Diane and defend himself at the same time, if he moved near her and used Pollen Garden as a shield it would be destroyed too quickly for him to stabilize her. Against Gloxinia, he gets rekt the moment he tries to attack Gloxinia's Guardian with increase, since it puts his only weapon too far away to defend with when Guardian evades. Not that a Guardian vs Guardian battle would've been too much better though. Against Chandler, the one form limit wasn't so big of an issue because he has teammates backing him up, although that time when he gets hit by Full Counter showed the weakness still. Against Mael, it is once again a big issue:He gets shot in the arm by Arrow of Salvation because he can't simultaneously defend himself while he's hitting Mael with increase. After his powerup, well, that's the end of that weakness.
He lacks the tool Gloxinia had of an instant massive heal, as if he had one, he would have probably used it on Diane in the Helbram fight instead of using Pollen Garden. At least Pollen Garden is consistently usable at all times. Meanwhile, Fossilization means that he can never automatically lose to a regenerator, as long as he can get an opening to restrain/stun them and then petrify, if their defense is low enough to pierce the skin. Melee opponents without the ability to fly are at a massive disadvantage, he probably only got nearly exploded by Guila because he was too lazy to consider taking some distance from the ground at the start of the battle as a precaution, which would make a surprise approach impossible. His main weaknesses in an open fight are mostly ranged attacks that can pierce his defense/outspeed his evasion and melee attackers who also fly and can outmatch his magic. Assassination is also a viable option if you can surprise him like with Ban's invis and how it rekt Merascylla.
Meanwhile he can read minds, and while this doesn't seem to tell him their exact next muscle movements, it is enough to see at least Estarossa's thoughts. So, if that works against powerful enemies in combat, even if their mind is not deranged, then it'd be a pretty overwhelming advantage, although this may be something Nakaba forgot about or decided not to include because it'd be too op.
Now that he's powered up, he can constantly have defense ready even while attacking, seems impossible to catch off guard, and can even attack at ultra long range with remote control to mitigate his physical vulnerability. It's a real shame that he never got a chance to go all out with several forms at once against a strong enemy when the DK would have been the perfect opportunity. Imagine King having a multitude of Increase swords near him as he flies around, while conducting 3 chastiefols at once with his hand gestures like some orchestra conductor, combo'ing the forms in the most annoying way. Like, use 2 Guardians to gang up on the enemy, while having increase swords wait nearby to attack the enemy if they try to escape those two, and immediately turn one Chastiefol into fossilization if the enemy gets pinned. But his power up instead is just wasted on someone who is way too weak to withstand it, and only used later for long range attack which is the same in its style as normal basically.
Overall, King's main weakness is his body's physical durability, but he is OP in nearly every other aspect, whether it be Evasion, Defense for himself or the whole team, Attack at ultra long range, medium range, AOE, or even close range, Healing allies,or even capturing opponents with petrification, to the point where he is almost entirely self sufficient by the end of series, and with even one durable teammate like Diane to have support him defensively while also giving him a proper target to heal, it's hard to imagine how he could lose when he has so many options to win with. To me he is often the most fun Sin to watch fight. The only disappointing thing about King to me was that he just never got to use his power up well, and more importantly, he left Diane in the dust which made his relationship to her hardly matter towards the end with him fighting Sinner and Zeldris without her help and hardly doing anything in the final DK fight while diane did essentially nothing.
I'm pretty satisfied with how his personal arc as a character went, though. It's too bad his romance with Diane led to her character being undermined somewhat but all in all it turned out alright to me.