Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[MangAniMY]

some fun(?) extras for now

series

1577295 鬼 KNY
1029632 ブ BC
*885590 ド DBS
*834321 食 Souma
*811983 ワ WT
*761224 呪 JJK
*637762 Ｓ Slam dunk
*606504 ぼ WNL
*566529 ア AA
*499896 る RRK
*472088 Ｄ Stone


current batch charts will be later

managed to get a full LTD for JJK

maybe more if can find more interesting stuff to do

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Act-age having more sales than Dr.Stone makes me happy.

 

[Ctkk]

Are the numbers for last week out?

 

[Jovan]

Are the numbers for last week out?

35085 *520925 僕 MHA 23
16841 *250198 鬼 KNY 15
-
11227 *260142 鬼14 KN5 14
10880 *313202 鬼4 KNY 4
10874 *152262 呪 JJK 5
10843 *320326 鬼3 KNY 3
10414 *328457 鬼2 KNY 2
*9468 *281947 鬼11 KNY 11
*9448 *274025 鬼13 KNY 13
*9378 *276849 鬼12 KNY 12
*9344 *302196 鬼6 KNY 6
*9197 *286861 鬼7 KNY 7
*9189 *307766 鬼5 KNY 5
*9117 *341003 鬼1 KNY 1
*9059 *285050 鬼8 KNY 8
*9011 1924206 Ｏ OP 92
*8679 *279413 鬼9 KNY 9
*8609 *279789 鬼10 KNY 10
*8518 *101233 ア AA 6

 

[Vizard]

 

[Ctkk]

35085 *520925 僕 MHA 23
16841 *250198 鬼 KNY 15
-
11227 *260142 鬼14 KN5 14
10880 *313202 鬼4 KNY 4
10874 *152262 呪 JJK 5
10843 *320326 鬼3 KNY 3
10414 *328457 鬼2 KNY 2
*9468 *281947 鬼11 KNY 11
*9448 *274025 鬼13 KNY 13
*9378 *276849 鬼12 KNY 12
*9344 *302196 鬼6 KNY 6
*9197 *286861 鬼7 KNY 7
*9189 *307766 鬼5 KNY 5
*9117 *341003 鬼1 KNY 1
*9059 *285050 鬼8 KNY 8
*9011 1924206 Ｏ OP 92
*8679 *279413 鬼9 KNY 9
*8609 *279789 鬼10 KNY 10
*8518 *101233 ア AA 6

-MHA is on par with the last volume of HQ if I recall correctly. If TPN doesn't overtake them both now, it'll be just sad.
-Kimtesu still going at it, I see. Totally gonna be on the top 10 for the year.
-One Piece STILL going at it, I see. It isn't gonna reach 2M before the next one comes out, is it? How long did the previous one take?
-Act Age officially past 100K. If the anime gives Stone even the most minimal boosts it'll get there too, so that would make what, 11 series on the magazine at that level or above?

 

[Scruffy8642]

Captain Tsubasa feels. Enough said about this... No idea as to how someone can look at this and actually read the manga.

I’d seen the memes before, but when I was watching it recently, I was so shocked to see that after the 3 year timeskip, the author literally just shows the character’s physical growth by making their legs longer. No facial or torso changes, just the legs. Looks like he continues that trend for the rest of the series. What makes it so dumb, is that he draws characters that were adults from the start normally lol.

It’s disgusting, and absolutely fucking hilarious.

 

[Jovan]

I’d seen the memes before, but when I was watching it recently, I was so shocked to see that after the 3 year timeskip, the author literally just shows the character’s physical growth by making their legs longer. No facial or torso changes, just the legs. Looks like he continues that trend for the rest of the series. What makes it so dumb, is that he draws characters that were adults from the start normally lol.

It’s disgusting, and absolutely fucking hilarious.

Also based from this pic, I feel like there are maybe two face types overall, as they all seem like they are each other's brothers or something. Haven't seen an art style this bad in quite a while.

 

[tirakai]

That's the reason I was so happy to get a new Tsubasa anime, it's a classic and I've always wanted to read it but the manga art is just not pretty, and it gets worse as they get older.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

2020 will be an interesting year for Jujutsu and Act-age. Jujutsu is rising way more quickly than Black Clover or Kimetsu. I imagine an anime adaptation could make Jujutsu beating at least Black Clover in sales. And I hope that also helps with Jujutsu main problem aka Western world not knowing it. I swear in Spain almost nobody knows Jujutsu even exists.

I can see Act-age beating WNL in the mid-term too. And maybe Shokugeki.

PD: Is not that Act-age and Jujutsu are already beating Dr.Stone. The freaking Kenshin spinoff (that I thought was going to sell poorly because it started selling after the Watsuki scandal) is beating Dr.Stone despite the big push Jump does to it.

PD2: Please, Ivrea, Norma, Planeta. Bring Jujutsu already to Spain. Manga needs to be known in West.

 

[Jovan]

That's the reason I was so happy to get a new Tsubasa anime, it's a classic and I've always wanted to read it but the manga art is just not pretty, and it gets worse as they get older.

The page I posted up there was remade in anime (the old one, slightly different) and looks actually normal.

 

[Ctkk]

2020 will be an interesting year for Jujutsu and Act-age. Jujutsu is rising way more quickly than Black Clover or Kimetsu. I imagine an anime adaptation could make Jujutsu beating at least Black Clover in sales. And I hope that also helps with Jujutsu main problem aka Western world not knowing it. I swear in Spain almost nobody knows Jujutsu even exists.

I can see Act-age beating WNL in the mid-term too. And maybe Shokugeki.

PD: Is not that Act-age and Jujutsu are already beating Dr.Stone. The freaking Kenshin spinoff (that I thought was going to sell poorly because it started selling after the Watsuki scandal) is beating Dr.Stone despite the big push Jump does to it.

PD2: Please, Ivrea, Norma, Planeta. Bring Jujutsu already to Spain. Manga needs to be known in West.

Shokugeki is probably not going to last enough for Act-Age to surpass it. It'd be hilarious if it happened, though.

 

[OtterBrigade]

Crunchyroll has Dr. Stone and subbed the PV

 

[Jovan]

Shokugeki is probably not going to last enough for Act-Age to surpass it. It'd be hilarious if it happened, though.

Seeing how (for now) it already outranks 2 newbies and probably more with some these 3 (Futari, Tokyo and Beast), wouldn't be that shocked for it to last a bit longer.

 

[Ctkk]

Seeing how (for now) it already outranks 2 newbies and probably more with some these 3 (Futari, Tokyo and Beast), wouldn't be that shocked for it to last a bit longer.

But wasn't it heading for the ending? How many volumes could it have left?

 

[Jovan]

But wasn't it heading for the ending? How many could it have left?

It is speculated that this tournament may go for that awaited Soma vs Erina match, but it doesn't have an actual "I am ending!" type of feel for now. They could always prolong the manga with more enemies, arcs, etc.

 

[MangAniMY]

MHA is on par with the last volume of HQ if I recall correctly. If TPN doesn't overtake them both now, it'll be just sad.

technically, you can say it already did

 

[101nemesis]

Also based from this pic, I feel like there are maybe two face types overall, as they all seem like they are each other's brothers or something. Haven't seen an art style this bad in quite a while.

To be fair even some of the best out there seem to struggle with variations. All "slim" women in One Piece are basically the same person just different hair and costume.

--- Double Post Merged, May 29, 2019, Original Post Date: May 29, 2019 ---

technically, you can say it already did

Hmm, don't know if we should considering adding the LE volumes as well since there would be those who bought both. Next volume of TPN should provide a good understanding of where TPN stands in relation to these 2.

 

[Jovan]

To be fair even some of the best out there seem to struggle with variations. All "slim" women in One Piece are basically the same person just different hair and costume.

I have yet to read OP, but that sounds kinda hillarious (in a good way). Though I assume they are not the focus of the manga, right?

 

[MangAniMY]

To be fair even some of the best out there seem to struggle with variations. All "slim" women in One Piece are basically the same person just different hair and costume.

--- Double Post Merged, May 29, 2019, Original Post Date: May 29, 2019 ---

Hmm, don't know if we should considering adding the LE volumes as well since there would be those who bought both. Next volume of TPN should provide a good understanding of where TPN stands in relation to these 2.

buying both is a possibility but looking at other series, we know for a fact that LE took away sales from the regular edition

so it might not be that far off either

but yeah, 14 will tell a better picture