Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2021] - Discussion and ToC Talk

[SeileM]

I Tell C is surviving for now

Why? They have to end two manga.
Can someone give a link to read Neru?

 

[Discomusic]

Why? They have to end two manga.
Can someone give a link to read Neru?

They have to end just one because Dolphin is ending already. It is supposed that the other manga to end will be Nine Dragons (in my opinion it can be either one).
I was also thinking that the second manga may not need to end immediately, due to the hole that Jujutsu is leaving for a number of weeks.

 

[SeileM]

They have to end just one because Dolphin is ending already. It is supposed that the other manga to end will be Nine Dragons (in my opinion it can be either one).
I was also thinking that the second manga may not need to end immediately, due to the hole that Jujutsu is leaving for a number of weeks.

Well, yes, two counting Dolphin, but why is he so sure that i tell c will survive this round

 

[Aeneas]

Read the Red Hood one-shot. Definitely walking a thin line. Feels like it could easily go the way of something like Bone Collection.

Seems like Neru will at least have entertaining fight scenes.

 

[Neala897]

And how exactly they are doing it? It will be redone or just publish previous digital chapters? Overall its kinda feel they a bit desperate for new successful series.

 

[Jovan]

To add to the above, Magu will recieve a color spread for the anniversary.

 

[animeexpert]

This serialization batch is just 2 series. I Tell C is surviving for now.

Please let those 2 survive, they speak to me as: the new age of shonen. Red hood one shot was very well done, as how an one shot should be

 

[Hermit]

@Brandish μ

 

[Teennitro]

Read the Red Hood one-shot. Definitely walking a thin line. Feels like it could easily go the way of something like Bone Collection.

Seems like Neru will at least have entertaining fight scenes.

Bones collection that's harsh it's not going to be that bad at best it can be like guardian of the witch just boring

 

[tirakai]

Well, yes, two counting Dolphin, but why is he so sure that i tell c will survive this round

It seems like the more likely one to continue, Ball Parade has been rushing very fast in the past few chapters while i tell c has just finished a normal arc and hasn't shown any signs of ending yet. Granted some series don't show indications they'll end until the final chapter, but there's not really any way Balls Parade could continue long term if they let it survive this round and it managed to gain some popularity while i tell c could has plenty of room to do more arcs.

We should know next week though (unless they wait an extra week to end it at the same time as the other new series starts, I think that's happened before a few times).

--- Double Post Merged, Jun 16, 2021, Original Post Date: Jun 16, 2021 ---

I wonder what Balls Parade will do story-wise if it does end in two issues.

The past two chapters have essentially finished a round each but it's only at round 3 of 6 of Koshien, so I'm curious to see if it speeds through three rounds in one chapter next week and allows a full chapter for the finals, ends with them losing before the finals, or does 2 matches each chapter and doesn't give any much time. Or if it'll do a Build King and just keep the ending for the last volume.

Has there been other cancelled series like Build King that had the actual main story finale be a volume-only chapter? Plenty of series include a final epilogue with the last volume to provide extra closure, but I can't think of any I've read that outright stopped mid-story when axed then finished it in the volume release.

I guess Shaman King's ending was volume-only but that's a bit of a different situation.

 

[Pietro]

And how exactly they are doing it? It will be redone or just publish previous digital chapters? Overall its kinda feel they a bit desperate for new successful series.

It's really difficult. With mashle, blue box undead, yozakura, sakamoto, elusive, witch watch, Hsf, roboco and magu chan, the magazine is very full... We just need to see if Candy flush will go on bottom and if will end either I tell C or kowloon, so for now two series will be a cuscinion

 

[Mammo]

well, new round means it's time for my tradition

Yuuki Kawaguchi's fav manga: Majin Tantei Nougami Neuro, Hinomaru Zumou

Hiraga Minya's fav manga: Hoshin Engi, Real, Kingdom etc

And how exactly they are doing it? It will be redone or just publish previous digital chapters? Overall its kinda feel they a bit desperate for new successful series.

this isn't something new or "desperate"
Higuma, ne0, Beast Children, Invade You, Momiji no Kisetsu, and most famously Jujutsu Kaisen were all miniseries
the story for the series will be different from the pilot

 

[NeeNeen]

Bones collection that's harsh it's not going to be that bad at best it can be like guardian of the witch just boring

Am I the only one who liked Bone Collection better? Sure, it was weird, but at least you could laugh at how awkward it was. Guardian was just a drag after the first chapter.

Has there been other cancelled series like Build King that had the actual main story finale be a volume-only chapter? Plenty of series include a final epilogue with the last volume to provide extra closure, but I can't think of any I've read that outright stopped mid-story when axed then finished it in the volume release.

KoLD8: King of the Living Dead stopped right before the climax, and had "Vol 3, including the newly written epilogue depicting a fierce battle, will be on sale..." written at the bottom of the final chapter, but I think that was in Jump+.

MANGA Plus by SHUEISHA

mangaplus.shueisha.co.jp

 

[SharkBait]

I think both new series will struggle. Though the martial arts road one may benefit from The Elusive Samurai pre conditioning current jump readers for the time period.

Red Hood looks too similar to heroaca and also the one shot was nothing special.

 

[tirakai]

I'm curious since i tell c may be surviving this round, did i tell c v1 sell more than HSF v2? I remember it being more than people expected (not well, mind you, but better than most quick flops).

 

[Rain Spectre]

Jump only serializes about 11 new series a year, no? We've already had six, so it makes sense to delay I Tell C's exit for a time when it can be more easily disposed of.

 

[tirakai]

There was 18 new series last year including Burn the Witch but it was a record year.

I think we'll maybe see 10 this year, with just the one more batch also of two series happening around 41-42 and the next after that would be in the first few 2022 issues.

 

[lgrmjauffre]

I'm curious since i tell c may be surviving this round, did i tell c v1 sell more than HSF v2? I remember it being more than people expected (not well, mind you, but better than most quick flops).

No, it didn't. i tell c volume 1 sold an estimated 2,650 per Shoseki in 3 days, and High School Family volume 2 sold an estimated 3,312 in the same time span.

 

[tirakai]

Didn't i tell c get a second week on the chart though?

 

[KagamiKuroko]

Shoseki 6/14:

2. JJK 16
3. OP 99
18. Dr Stone 21
128. Ayakashi Triangle 4
202. Witch Watch 1
253. Sakamoto Days 2

Shoseki 6/15:

2. JJK 16
3. OP 99
24. Dr. Stone 21
124. Ayakashi Triangle 4
181. Sakamoto Days 2
185. Witch Watch 1
498. Build King 2