- Joined
- Aug 23, 2013
- Messages
- 14,180
- Reaction score
- 6,982
- Gender
- Male
- Country
-
The Nue's Exorcist chapter art must be why we aren't getting color pages, this is some next level epic stuff. So frickin cool.
lol i was literally going to comment that, the last chapters are having such a great art that i'm starting to think maybe it's the reason why it's not getting any color page for a while so Kawae doesn't overwork himself, and yeah i know some color pages are outsourced but at the very least Kawae has to draw the actual illustration.The Nue's Exorcist chapter art must be why we aren't getting color pages, this is some next level epic stuff. So frickin cool.
Kagurabachi backlog has been incredibly consistent these past few days (Every volume being in the top 30 each day not counting new releases) and it only seems to be growing!13 9784088838199 Kagurabachi 1 集英社 外薗健 2024.02.02
16 9784088841168 Kagurabachi 3 集英社 外薗健 2024.07.04
17 9784088838809 Kagurabachi 2 集英社 外薗健 2024.05.02
Holy
How dare you forget the swordsHarem Light Novel on every new volume, ergo, every new arc brings in a new heroine that's interested in our MC, that's how they're usually written.
Following this logic, Kagurabachi is secretly a harem manga.
Sojo: All this time, you've been on my mind.
Hakuri: What I need in my life is a samurai! That's you!
Uruha: I-I can fight for your sake again! Mr Rokuhiraaaaaa!
It's just that it's a gay harem manga.
What is frustrating is that nobody tells him how to construct a plot, how to structure a story. That's the role of the editor to shape a young artist into an artist that produces good work. It's not a matter of being a genius or whatever, it's a matter of mastering narrative techniques.What an utterly baffling final chapter of Necromance. That felt like a series starter first chapter than a last chapter with a more interesting plot line. You’d think the first chapter would've ended with the marriage proposal as the definitive story hook. I almost cannot believe Naba didn’t go with this premise from the beginning.
You can even see how the story revolved around this specific plot line. It's in the name of the series (nec romance instead of necromancy), how the Uno family curse impacts all the men in his family line, Shishi always holds a rose, Chitari is called the Love Phantom, the low level shiryo called Chitari out by name. All he had to do was rework it around and you can still tell a similar story but with the marriage plot as the leading hook for the premise.
I like Naba but he frustrates me because I want him to succeed. He’s got some great ideas, but absolutely botches the execution. Shame because I think the Kaoru and Chitari angle could've had some legs to it.
What about Girls meet rock? Would be kinda cool if it get a boost too13 9784088838199 Kagurabachi 1 集英社 外薗健 2024.02.02
16 9784088841168 Kagurabachi 3 集英社 外薗健 2024.07.04
17 9784088838809 Kagurabachi 2 集英社 外薗健 2024.05.02
Holy
In and around the 80s, which unless I'm mistaken is a more typical boost for Tsugimanga.What about Girls meet rock?
Exactly. And I have a hunch that Saito is cut from that same breed of editors.What is frustrating is that nobody tells him how to construct a plot, how to structure a story. That's the role of the editor to shape a young artist into an artist that produces good work. It's not a matter of being a genius or whatever, it's a matter of mastering narrative techniques.
I don't know who is his editor and I don't care because we are all humans and make mistakes and we should give some slack to these people who are overworked and don't have time to do it anymore, but an editor should be a good coach too, a technical coach as well as a coach that can handle artists' psychological perception of work (that's not the same as editors/commercials etc even if they all work in publishing).
He should be somebody who can analyze the weaknesses of his mangaka and find a training regime suited to them. He should be a plot doctor that can analyze stories and decipher what is needed to be worked on (structure/characters/world building etc etc.).