Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump (2024) - News and Discussion!

Status
Not open for further replies.

BelTL

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2024
Messages
1,564
Reaction score
1,493
Country
Gotei 13

I like that whoever made this one kept the joke of Neru having to share his U19 with Red Hood going.
oh come on, is that astro part necessary
 

Shinuki no Reborn

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
15,810
Reaction score
40,890
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
oh come on, is that astro part necessary
It gives the false idea that the manga was supposed to be a sacrifice and never survive when it was simply a massive flop in the rankings.
 

BelTL

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2024
Messages
1,564
Reaction score
1,493
Country
Gotei 13
It gives the false idea that the manga was supposed to be a sacrifice and never survive when it was simply a massive flop in the rankings.
also it couldn't even break 5k mark ...
You can say it's under expectation for a veteran with a big hit but at least Astro is currently 30k club
 

Renvent

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
May 3, 2023
Messages
212
Reaction score
379
Age
31
Country
United States
Chapter 34https://imgur.com/a/mamayuyu-ch-34-tl-93OvsDm
Thanks so much! I appreciate it. Interesting the implications of chapter 34 and Corleo's power. It suggests that Corleo's dream space might have some temporal powers. In the original timeline Corleo dies after the fight with Grisha but because of his conversation with Evan, Evan somehow remembers to get to know End more causing the tineline to change and the events of the manga to be averted. I actually like the idea even if it's a bit of a bummer of an execution since it means that Corleo never got to meet the other heroes and demons and helped them with their problems. Hopefully, they all retain some memory of the original timeline. One of the consequences of being cut short I guess.

MMYY had a lot of potential and was the one I liked best from its batch. Shame the author never really capitalized on it. Hopefully the author will come back after working on those aspects and improving.
 

Inumaru

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2011
Messages
417
Reaction score
286
Gender
Hidden
Country
Brazil
Between MamaYuyu and Fabricant 100 authors, which one do you guys think has more potential to find success on their second try?
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,099
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
Alright, I finished the chapters for the week. Here is my review. And also, I will give my thoughts on Necromance. Not that much, but enough of what I remembered and what Naba needs to do for the future.

-Jujutsu Kaisen: And with that the fight is over. As well as the other fight that took the majority off screen. I mean I do feel let down that that side fight could have been shown, but then again it would have shown both evenly matched fights with not that much of a connection for me to care. But to the main fight, as much as people complain that it is a bit rushed, I think the end result still works in terms of his final words. But to see that the fight is over and to make sure that things are resolved along with one casualty that is in question on their survival, I’m for it. But with 3 chapters left, let’s see how Akutami will close it (in less than 4 weeks). Probably will give him enough time to say hello and goodbye to Usazaki since they came out together the same year.

-Mission: Yozakura Family: Even though the fight was off screened as well, it did make up for it with that good back and forth with our combatants over stuff that should have been talked about so their bond would be more tightened. But I also found it hilarious in some parts of the conversation along with Goliath fighting the Octopus in the background. Now that that is settled, I need to know what is going on with Nanao and Mozu in their fight. Even though that was off screened as well to some extent, I will agree that it has been easy so far. I can’t tell but I am glad that Gondaira is somewhat self aware and I think he has need more surprises in store.

-Undead Unluck: I think that this, Yozakura, and JJK each have delivered compelling messages as veterans along with others that will be discussed. But to see the fight between Andy and Unruin is epic and how it has reached a new strata to make this fight worthwhile and hopefully going forward as we will reach the final stretch of the series now that the recruitment is over (thank Tozuka for finishing it, I don’t know how he could have gotten all of it done during his time after finishing the first loop, but he did it). But if this next chapter will be the end of this fight, I hope so so we can get to 2 no 3 major things in order to deliver the final climax and end of the series. The first is getting everyone’s memories back. Second it is getting those specific artifacts. And finally the fight with God, and that is it.

-Sakamoto Days: So some nice training and then going into a prison break arc…..”What?!” Okay in all seriousness I don’t mind it as it helps to under how the law and order of this world works. But I have to say, I am interested but it is also something I need more research on. For non anime based stuff, I have seen The Shawshank Redemption, Chicken Run, and Toy Story 3 as they had a good prison break story, and Avatar the Last Airbender with The Boiling Rock episodes from Book 3. Along with me needing to see The Great Escape and the first few seasons of Prison Break (but I know that there were some problems with things after season 2 so I know I have to keep my eye on that). But there is the anime and manga stories that have done prison break arcs like One Piece with Impel Down which I was captivated than anything a long with the pacing of all things, as well as how elaborate it was. I know the manga had the standard black and white due to it being in ink, but the anime really told me everything through the color palates. I would also say that Naruto movie Blood Prison is another one that catches my interest (unless there are people that tell me to stay away, please let me know). So knowing what this entails, the real challenge is going to have to be needing it to stand out on its own in terms of enjoyment with new characters and a question of how they will get out along with achieving their goals (especially for Shin as this is his arc). But all I know is that this arc is starting very unexpectedly but had some good humor and a clever concept and I will trust Suzuki to the fullest. But another aspect I would like to ask, do you think the art has gotten cleaner this chapter? It’s not as rough or scratchy and has the characters looking as if I am seeing the anime in terms of readability. Just asking as I am a very observant person.

-The Elusive Samurai: So an epilogue to this arc and the cool down after what happened. It is very much needed. But also it shows Takoyuki is in a very precarious state with the Daigo (I think I am saying it wrong). But after seeing all of this fallout is nice but I hope that we see where this is going cause I have no clue when it comes to history series compared to something fictional and I don’t want to guess what happens next.

-Witch Watch: A nice backstory for Charmi. I like it. But it also helps explain the birth of Slump. I like Slump and I can’t wait to see what more this duo will bring in helping Nico along with being affiliated with the group. And hearing Charmi talking about her ability with Magic and putting it in acting called Visualization, that is something I recognize, especially due to me and her come from the same field of Filmmaking (albeit in different ways due to her being an actress and me being more of the person who is behind the camera who either writes, directs, edits, ect.). But now that the introduction is over, let’s see where this goes.

-Blue Box: A nice chapter that focuses on the side cast again. I am interested in this festival arc (again). But I do think we need to spend some time away from our main couple a bit so we can have this fleshed out more. But the thing that got me was Saki and how she went to Kyo. But the thing that I don’t want to do is accuse due to how I remembered Kyo spoke of his relationship with her. But something about Saki I need to ask is, is she a tease that leads people on? I don’t want to assume that mainly due to this current boy and how he “stalked her”. I mean if this guy is terrible I will back Saki up but I am neutral until I get more concrete evidence and know who and what these characters are about. Because there wasn’t enough shown and for me to be an accurate judge, I can’t pick a side. Although seeing Saki say she likes Kyo, is it true or an escape? It also doesn’t help that Ayame is right below them looking at the drama unfold. This is really making this relationship a mess if not careful cause you need to build on communication and with the bad, it can be a mess and a pain if done incorrectly. Other than that, decent but need to really pack a punch soon. Also, the stamp reward for Taiki to take part in, please do so for your reward. But I think this envy from the other boys could get annoying pretty quickly. But the way this relationship is coming across to me is very similar to Studio Ghibli’s Whisper of the Heart when the other students make it a big deal due to it being the talk of the class.

-Akane-banashi: Shiguma’s story telling is reaching new depths that I should have anticipated. The one thing I forgot to mention was the great foreboding it was showing last chapter when we only got a lit candle in darkness as the final panel. But to see that played out in this chapter and its meaning, gives me fears and yet it reminds me of this Jewish story regarding candles and life (similar to this until we know more of the connection). Let me tell you the story. It takes somewhere in Israel (I think). A man enters this place where a man has lit a lot of candles with oil. But those lights represent the lives of people alive in this world. And when a light is extinguished, that means that person is dead. And the man who came in saw their light was nearing its end. He couldn’t add oil as it wouldn’t work, so they gave some of his oil to another to help them live longer. I forgot the rest, but I think the message behind it was giving life to others and helping others will help you live longer. And I think for Akane, those candles represent the dead as the man in the story has evaded death for so long that the darkness will consume him. That is my best guess what the story is. But by giving that will make you live. Otherwise in darkness and with a cruel heart, you become taken and sent to hell, like in Tales from the Crypt (not with the Crypt Keeper, but from an old movie that was 5 stories into one that involved a woman killing her husband only for a mental institution patient with murderous instincts dressed as Santa has surrounded her home but can’t call the police due to incriminating herself for her husband and risking herself and daughter. A man who dreams his own death and comes back as a zombie to fully realize he will actually live out that death [not by choice]. A man who was cruel to another man who had love but to come back as a zombie and tear out his heart due to him having none. A man who died while also being cruel and got what was coming to him due to getting “The Monkey’s Paw,” and came back to life through the paw only to suffer for eternity due to the embalming. And my personal favorite, a man who was cruel running a clinic for the blind but makes them suffer cold nights and hunger only for him to eat high end warm food and for taking care of his dog, only to have the patients turn on him and trap and starve the man and his dog only to be placed in a tunnel made from wire mesh and wood, along with a passage made of razor blades, only for the end to be as more cruel than anything. But the end you have to see to believe).

-Kill Blue: Seeing that conversation really shows that these Unicorns have no regard to life. But what was hilarious was when we saw the Home EC club set up some tea to assess the situation. I like that part of Fujimaki’s writing to make it as funny as possible. But there is a question that does linger in my head about how he writes, especially during this series. I think he is giving social commentary about the world’s political climate in some parts of the world (especially my own). Just something about it feels like a commentary especially ever since that chapter with Oka 2 weeks ago (and if you have questions why I feel that way please feel free to DM me so we can talk about it so I won’t bring that talk or energy in here so I can be respectful). I’m sorry if I am getting political but that is what it feels like. So back to the chapter, I am glad that the Home EC club is starting to catch on but know that they will give Ogami some space in order to not risk their lives as that was a big deal in those previous arcs. But this challenge regarding horseback riding and taking out someone reminds me of that small arc in Assassination Classroom when they had to play a similar game like this, albeit there were no horses. I am glad that we are getting help to tackle this problem, but the one thing that caught my attention was this guy with the same hair scheme that is similar to Oka’s. Is that his son or did he take the de aging drug, as well as that is one bold risk to have the grown up cast age down to take on Ogami when they are really old people (though middle age). And it is confirming my joke from last year which is now my suspicions of Noren to be correct.

-Nue’s Exorcist: I think I am seeing where Kawae’s artistic strengths lie. But as for improvements I do think some of the male designs are getting there as I think Gakuro’s features are being more rounded out. But one thing I constantly complain about is seeing their teeth, mainly Gakuro when he isn’t gritting them when he is ready or going into a fight.But you can see in that portal and through their abilities (even before this chapter), it is like Kawae is showing horror with teeth. Just something about that portal reminds me of the fleshy level in Super Ghouls & Ghosts on the Super Famicom/SNES (from the Capcom Franchise Ghosts and Goblins). But to see this fight now reach apolitical levels with massive Kaiju battles that are Eldridge horror that led to stuff that Zeno is experiencing is really unsettling like the plagues of Egypt. But a part of me is wondering the history of Nue and this Spirit as this goes beyond our knowledge and I want to know what happened Centuries ago.

-Kagurabachi: First off, love the color page despite the same color palette for the major LCP. But the one thing I didn’t realize once I looked at the chapter again is that we now have the name of the new arc, “The Sword Bearer Assassination Arc”. It shows that Hokazono is being more aware of what people call their arcs and is being very deliberate. Also with the colors of the different sword bearers, he is giving them a uniform shade in a similar manner to how David Fincher does with his movies when we are set in a present location that represents the themes or subject manner of his movies (despite him not being a colorful director). Isn’t Hokazono a fan of David Fincher movies? I remember that his favorites (aside from the John Wick franchise) he is a fan of Quinten Tarantino, Christopher Nolan, and David Fincher? Was that right? Anyways let’s talk about the chapter, I do like this new character, despite him being a fan of Chihiro’s father, there is also a great amount of debt to him which is understandable cause of his reasons. So it makes sense and he isn’t fanboying out. He is reasonable and I want to know more about him and his time in the war. But one of the things that makes this chapter special is that Hokazono is really thinking about blocking. One panel had Chihiro behind the door where we as the readers know that he is behind the members of the Hishaku when trying to defend Yoji. That is some clever blocking I have seen in a manga that isn’t in a movie or prestige series on tv or streaming. So he is utilizing it very effectively. So far the arc is starting off well and I am excited to see if Chihiro will save Yoji.

-Super Psychic Policeman Choji: First off another great color page involving our girls from the series with Ippongi, Lily, and Haruka. But to see another Haruka chapter was both unexpected but also the best chapter of Chojo in a while as it was so funny. Seeing the stalking and assumptions that Chojo and Ippongi are an item is way off base and yet Chojo is questioning it, I like it. Also I like how there were 2 slap scenes where Chojo hit himself thinking he likes Ippongi, and one from Ippongi herself where she slaps Chojo for the idea of a marriage proposal. Great timing and use of the page turn from Numa that it was exactly what I needed to feel invested in this series again. Please keep it up. Also when Lily came in and then Haruki assumed her and Chojo as an item, a part of me wonders, how old are the girls so far and how old is Chojo? I ask that cause I think Lily is a third year in high school or 1st-2nd year of college, mainly due to what she is wearing and how it is a uniform but relaxed cause of the way she is wearing the shirt, and how I feel she is a bit juvenile she can be sometimes. If Numa gave stats on these characters ages please let me know. Anyway, funny chapter and I want more Chojo side characters please.

-Astro Royale: A climatic end to the fight by suddenly ending it, nice way to build up our anticipation. I do like the inner conflict with Shio, but I am just wondering where are we going next? I mean the action is cool and it is delivering the tone in how I want it, but like I said, I don’t know where we are going next.

-Psych House: With one more chapter left, this feels like a good way to say goodbye. I like how we are getting insight on the mom and that she is dreaming of that perfect family again, but unfortunately she was avoiding her problems than facing them with her daughter together. I won’t say it is bad, but it gives more depth on her as a character. But I also like the idea of having your younger self as the catalyst than yourself serving as the wake up call that will wake the mom. I do feel sad that it is ending, but all I have to say is that it was a fun read and I hope this mangaka returns again.

-Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi: It was a fun chapter seeing Kiyoshi trying to complete his bucket list in making friends, I won’t go into the “leak” talks. But the bowling chapter was fun and to see that Kiyoshi is hitting it up with that popular girl who is probably the best and not stuck up like most that I have seen. But to see her possessed and then freed and to hold her hand, priceless. I hope for another good chapter whether it is comedic or serious as this was good.

-Hima-ten!: A great date chapter that gave insight on Iemori and Honoka in terms of them as characters individually and how they feel about each other. All I have to say, it feels very mutual. All I have to say, I like what Honoka wore cause it was both casual and a bit conservative in a good way where it exudes personality. By the way the color page is displayed it shows what I said before but also how these girls are contrasted in terms of their individual personalities. Honoka is dressed in a more covered way that is very reserved and nice. Himari is a bit on the revealing side which is displayed in her more out there personality in terms of making herself a part of the public. Anyways, the date starts off good at the cafe, but then the standup show starts and I was a bit confused but also told me about Honoka in her comedy sensibilities. But the end of the date was nice and you would have expected to just end it there. But then to see Himari sick and Iemori feeling responsible goes to her in that time of need. I do like where it is going, but I for some reason feel like it is rushing a bit. I don’t know, since I haven’t experienced this genre that much to know when it is a real flop (except for Tokyo Demon Bride Story), I will see how the readers felt about Hima so far.

-RuriDragon: I am glad that we are actually dealing with something that I questioned since Witch Watch and this, and that is the whole bullying aspect, cause in reality (and trust me, the world has been more surreal than you can believe it is reality when it is on steroids or cocaine), it is revealed that our leads are exposed to being different from the majority of the students. But in Ruri, it is actually addressing it that Ruri is different and the girls that are teasing her as well as calling her a freak is what I would expect when dealing with a story like this or in real life. I am glad that Maeda is helping stick up for Ruri, but with this horn thing in taking them out, why, how is this supposed to get back at those 2 girls. Well we have less than 3 weeks to find out than the regular 2. So let’s see.

And that is my review. Overall, a good week. But I would like to apologize on behalf of my comments on Kill Blue. Fujimaki is really pushing it and it will be hard to not talk about it without derailing the forum. I hope next week he will pull back and focus on this challenge to keep Noren safe in this horse mount challenge. So with that said what were my thoughts on Naba, and his series Kyokuto Necromance. I dropped it by the time we see our lead on the ship. But to hear that it was a missed opportunity, a part of me wonders if it is indecisiveness or it was the plan? If it was the latter, the problem stems from how Naba has awkward dialogue moments with the cast along with how it is in riddles than just getting to the point to feel engaged. I do think his art was significantly better, but Naba has to take time to work on their writing as that has been his biggest weak point. If he practices, I know he will get there, but it will take time.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Between MamaYuyu and Fabricant 100 authors, which one do you guys think has more potential to find success on their second try?
Fabricant 100.
 

Pietro

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2012
Messages
2,410
Reaction score
824
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
Between MamaYuyu and Fabricant 100 authors, which one do you guys think has more potential to find success on their second try?
MamaYuYu... Just slightly
 

chareveleuv

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2023
Messages
210
Reaction score
240
Age
25
Country
United States
Between MamaYuyu and Fabricant 100 authors, which one do you guys think has more potential to find success on their second try?
Fabricant. It was a competent plot even if a bit generic. Can’t say that about MamaYuyu. Too all over the place.
 

Shinuki no Reborn

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2011
Messages
15,810
Reaction score
40,890
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
Between MamaYuyu and Fabricant 100 authors, which one do you guys think has more potential to find success on their second try?
For me Fabricant was quite a better series but i think Mama author has more potential to "popularity", if he plays the cards right.
 

Newkerzy

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Nov 22, 2008
Messages
7,619
Reaction score
5,437
Age
35
Gender
Male
Country
Indonesia
Between MamaYuyu and Fabricant 100 authors, which one do you guys think has more potential to find success on their second try?
For me Fabricant was quite a better series but i think Mama author has more potential to "popularity", if he plays the cards right.
MamaYuyu’s. I think he has all the right ingredients for a breakout hit, he just needs a good, thought-out plot as a binding agent to make a great recipe for success.
 

tirakai

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Aug 7, 2016
Messages
5,343
Reaction score
7,426
Age
33
Country
Scotland
I think Fabricant. Fabricant was the better series with decent storytelling, consistent characters, and such. It's main issue imo is that the author went for too general of a tone so it failed to stand out, if they can lean harder into a particular tone or theme for their next series I think they could do well

Mamayuyu had a bunch of scattered hints of great stuff, but the plot was a total mess and the author was too unsure of themself in the action and such. I think both could return with success, but Mamayuyu's author has a lot more they need to work on.

Honestly, I think even Fabricant could've been a success (or at least hit a year) if it had a more distinct tone, like leaning harder into the horror or the tragedy instead of having a little of everything.
 

Phantom RPG

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2020
Messages
1,136
Reaction score
1,262
Age
28
Country
Brazil
To me Daisuke Enoshima has potential to do something great, same for Mamayuyu's author but only if he learned to stay consistent and play his card right.
 

KrenKren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2024
Messages
1,492
Reaction score
3,901
Age
21
Country
United Kingdom
Between MamaYuyu and Fabricant 100 authors, which one do you guys think has more potential to find success on their second try?
I'm still of the mind Hayashi would have produced an instant hit had he have just gone full drama like his one-shots.

He's definitely got the character designs and general artistic talent to make something that stands out, and even MMYY despite its many faults performed decently on shelves, so as long as he doesn't fall forwards again and get caught up in deciding what he wants to write while he writes it I think he stands a good chance of finding some success on his second try.
 

pennycryman

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2023
Messages
1,210
Reaction score
3,481
Age
26
Country
United States
It's 50-50, depending on what each of them go with. Fabricant was miles better storywise, while MamaYuyu was miles better art wise. Even till the end, I don't think the Fabricant author ever really understood how to do a fight scene, it was worse at the start, but even till the end he still never really got how to position, panel, or even frame much impactfully. Art errors abounded all the way through, and the art style was also far too cartoony in general, so there's that. There's also the fact that this series has 0 fanbase, so he won't really have a following going into his second work. However, he can make an interesting premise, so if he learns from his mistakes here, he can make it the proceedings less generic and really lean into what makes the premise special. And maybe not make a battle manga, he's just not good enough at them to stand out in the magazine.

MamaYuyu pretty much did nothing right plotwise, like 3 things right characterwise, but he could still pull out a hit. Once he started doing fight scenes, they eventually turned out alright, and his paneling is distinctive. The series also had a fanbase, so he won't be starting from scratch. He also can draw waifus, so point for him.

I'm 100% certain they'll both return though.
 
Last edited:

tirakai

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Aug 7, 2016
Messages
5,343
Reaction score
7,426
Age
33
Country
Scotland
On a similar note, do you think Naba Fusai will be back for a third try?

I feel like, the times we've seen authors return after two cancellations, generally at least one of their series showed some promise surviving a round or two first, but Necromance got U19'd and Aliens Area was also cancelled first opportunity at ch 20. If a series survives even just one round that gives them at least something to build on, to figure out why people liked it over the other flops in that moment and see if you can design a series around those strengths, but there's very little to work on after two instant flops.

Not to mention it'd be incredibly disheartening for a mangaka, to spend years working out hard to get two different series published in Jump only for neither to even make it to half a year.
 

SharkBait

MH Senpai
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2013
Messages
14,180
Reaction score
6,982
Gender
Male
Country
United States
On a similar note, do you think Naba Fusai will be back for a third try?
Actually surprised we have this discussion about him (how did he build a fanbase?), but the same wasn't held for Kento Terasaka, will he try a third sports series? Or Kento Matsuura, after both Phantom Seer and Tokyo Shinobi Squad ended we haven't seen him on a serializing series in jump in a non assistant position for years.
 

Newkerzy

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Nov 22, 2008
Messages
7,619
Reaction score
5,437
Age
35
Gender
Male
Country
Indonesia
On a similar note, do you think Naba Fusai will be back for a third try?

I feel like, the times we've seen authors return after two cancellations, generally at least one of their series showed some promise surviving a round or two first, but Necromance got U19'd and Aliens Area was also cancelled first opportunity at ch 20. If a series survives even just one round that gives them at least something to build on, to figure out why people liked it over the other flops in that moment and see if you can design a series around those strengths, but there's very little to work on after two instant flops.

Not to mention it'd be incredibly disheartening for a mangaka, to spend years working out hard to get two different series published in Jump only for neither to even make it to half a year.
How long did it take for Horikoshi to return with MHA after Barrage? Two years?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top