Ah man, reading all those good arguments it does seem Philia is Mafia after all if the priorities is rightly told by Ustegius (see, I wrote your full name this time) and Pirate steal is thus not possible and ofc if we don't have a troll prostitute (which I really hope we don't...). If some of our inactive ones are dets and docs then that sucks, nothing we can do about it.
Still, I think Utsune (not Ustegius) is also Mafia. Maybe Red Mafia has 4 members with 1 being in the blue team whereas the Blue Mafia has only 2 with a Serial Killer or Lone Mafia running around amok. Or we were unlucky with an insane doc but then we might have somebody claiming insane doc by now as Mafia usually take their chances with insane doc and hope for the best of insane doc killing townies and not them at night.
If Philia and Utsune are the last mafias of red (that is if red mafia isn't the sole mafia with like 5-6 members, but with 3 kills per night that would be imba as hell) then it might be best to get them killed to reduce the killings at night.
Also as for the gift:
Can we agree on sending that gift to either xnut or me or any other mason who comes out of the closet and reveals himself before the end of the day/early game phase? Sure it is just an extra vote, but better have that extra vote in the townies hand than in the mafia/third role hands, right?
Honestly, me and Xnut are masons and there are more of us in this game. Us having the gifts by majority no matter if blue or red wins is better than randomly voting and thus giving mafia the chance to snatch some mysterious gifts for themselves. Like avoiding to get lynched for example. I bet they really want that one.
Still, I think Utsune (not Ustegius) is also Mafia. Maybe Red Mafia has 4 members with 1 being in the blue team whereas the Blue Mafia has only 2 with a Serial Killer or Lone Mafia running around amok. Or we were unlucky with an insane doc but then we might have somebody claiming insane doc by now as Mafia usually take their chances with insane doc and hope for the best of insane doc killing townies and not them at night.
If Philia and Utsune are the last mafias of red (that is if red mafia isn't the sole mafia with like 5-6 members, but with 3 kills per night that would be imba as hell) then it might be best to get them killed to reduce the killings at night.
Also as for the gift:
Can we agree on sending that gift to either xnut or me or any other mason who comes out of the closet and reveals himself before the end of the day/early game phase? Sure it is just an extra vote, but better have that extra vote in the townies hand than in the mafia/third role hands, right?
Honestly, me and Xnut are masons and there are more of us in this game. Us having the gifts by majority no matter if blue or red wins is better than randomly voting and thus giving mafia the chance to snatch some mysterious gifts for themselves. Like avoiding to get lynched for example. I bet they really want that one.


nvm