Games Mafia Game 142 - McHelpers - Game End

[Holt]

Really not liking Nash so far. There’s never really been any sort of consideration where someone isn’t killed for being new. A lynch maybe but even that isn’t really a think. Target choice and reason also don’t really follow through. There are bonus points for not lynching Kako tho…

 

[Natasha]

Really not liking Nash so far. There’s never really been any sort of consideration where someone isn’t killed for being new. A lynch maybe but even that isn’t really a think. Target choice and reason also don’t really follow through. There are bonus points for not lynching Kako tho…

Non optimal play != evil
I'm drawing attention, claiming actions, claiming a role befor I understand the game. Really think if anything I've done has helped an evil agenda cause if I'm hiding anything a spy/det will just clap me.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

I just found it alarming that DD & Nash seemed to immediately assume that those 3/4 roles must be in the game.

Okay so I assumed quack was in cause Lori literally claimed it.
I assumed spiritbomb was in cause 2 people claimed passive roles.
I discussed if Samurai is in or not with lawl and DD.

You've misrepresented that situation too.

Not particularly. Nash disappeared & that's about it.

Also you made sure to toss some shade my way for good measure.

Pidge are you evil or just out for my blood

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026 ---

Lori here is Stylether. Accidentally used his nickname soz.

Okay so I assumed quack was in cause Lori literally claimed it.

 

[Erinyes]

@NashSilver what do you think of sam ?

what are the most suspicious for you and based on what ?

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

@Lawl Po Bia who are your most suspsicious ?

a lot of people but i also dont know most of them either so i might be being biased here

 

[Erinyes]

a lot of people but i also dont know most of them either so i might be being biased here

ok then who do you trust the most ?

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

@Marmalade @Brandish μ @AnimePigeon sorry if i missed did you used your orle, any new info/hints to share who are the ones you suspect the most

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

havent seen anything yet worthy of trusting someone more than the other solely based on the previous day maybe later this phase the picture will be more clear

 

[digitaldude]

vote kill grysun

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

im thinking grysun/james/erinyes right now

 

[Marmalade]

Hello, I just got here today. A little low activity warning for this phase; the timing is a bit unlucky for me (I just got out of a long shift, have to work again super early in the morning till the end of the phase).
I'll catch up and try to be active rn, and during break/before work tomorrow - I'm quite honestly not feeling very well so I'm not sure how that goes. Tomorrow morning should be better I think (I hope?)

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

I'm still reading, but Sam & Erin, can I just ask you to try not to tunnel on each other please If needed just ignore the other for a bit and take some time to cool off and think about other people

 

[Brandish μ]

Hey Erin I used my role last night. I wouldn't get feedback so can't tell if it's blocked.

Think poisoner is the issue (for no death), included on the roster to bypass the samurai. So if we have a samurai they might need to factor who could've been poisoned the previous night so they don't seppuku.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

He's one of the few ppl I can be confident isn't mafia and I assumed newbie gets to live N1 unless maf is truly evil

You chose doc lol, newbie or not that's a prio kill. Only samurai fear saved yo ass.

At this point you shouldn't hide, you'll only add to the kill count.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026 ---

@Stylether why did you choose Holt? I don't mind the choice, would be thinking similarly, but want to know why you did (apologies if you said so and I missed it)

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026 ---

Think poisoner is the issue (for no death), included on the roster to bypass the samurai. So if we have a samurai they might need to factor who could've been poisoned the previous night so they don't seppuku.

Hmm protection on Holt might be top or on lar with poisoner (as a likelihood of explaining no dead town)

Is poisoner too contrived for a game that has possibly included a samurai and spirit bomb as specials on the menu?

 

[Erinyes]

@Marmalade im not tunneling i explaned my vote, the last minute train attempt on me, is more than suspicious, and see him siding with nash who has a pretty questionable claim , sam and nash for now are my highest suspects, mostly by default, i dont have enough good readng on everyone else. that doesnt help.


someone asked why i havent used my role, I havent because it was no use. confitions were not met

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

its a pain I'm soon going to bed and i feel as if i dont know anything, I will try to stay awake as much as possible,. But saying straight, I wont be online tomorrow coz o working hours (aka mornng in my time zone till end of the phase)

 

[Brandish μ]

its a pain I'm soon going to bed and i feel as if i dont know anything, I will try to stay awake as much as possible,. But saying straight, I wont be online tomorrow coz o working hours (aka mornng in my time zone till end of the phase)

Good night, you've got your vote up so it's all good.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

Same to you Marm rest up, and have a vote ready tomorrow

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026 ---

I'll be offline for the next 5hrs

 

[Marmalade]

I'm so frustrated, I literally accidentally deleted a part while typing this aaahhhh.

@Marmalade @Brandish μ @AnimePigeon sorry if i missed did you used your orle, any new info/hints to share who are the ones you suspect the most

I did not use my role last night, not because I didn't want to, but because I can't.
Nash lowkey comes across as a bit stressed, but I'm not sure if that's me and I also don't want to put too much weight on that. That with the combination of things I typed here below is a bit hmmmm, I don't know. In contrast to that, Gry seems somehow very relaxed and laid back and that does tend to set me off on him a little bit. I'm also aware it's still relatively early in the phase, so that can definitely change still.
Regarding Sam, I think he's just town-Sam last minute jumping on some of his favorite lynch targets. He tends to do that as town, I've been a victim of this too many times, but perhaps he's upgraded his mafia play.

I honestly don't think my brain can produce anything useful at this moment, I've been flip-flopping on Lawl a bit, and still am. Reasons he can be either town or mafia. I want to believe he's town but at the same time also feeling paranoia. Teubier feels a bit different than before. Could be getting used to the game more, could be something else.

@Marmalade im not tunneling i explaned my vote, the last minute train attempt on me, is more than suspicious, and see him siding with nash who has a pretty questionable claim , sam and nash for now are my highest suspects, mostly by default, i dont have enough good readng on everyone else. that doesnt help.

No I know, and it's good to question those things. I don't disagree with that. I'm just asking to be wary and please prevent it this time oki Let's keep an open mind.
And yes it was weird, given Kako did claim bomb I get wanting to lynch someone else... Like that's not strange at all. Just still wondering why you and not every other player (as you just didn't really have the chance to really stand out much imo, not enough to lynch for me personally). Esp since you were one of the only players that didn't have a vote on them.

Really not liking Nash so far. There’s never really been any sort of consideration where someone isn’t killed for being new. A lynch maybe but even that isn’t really a think. Target choice and reason also don’t really follow through. There are bonus points for not lynching Kako tho…

I'm not sure if I fully agree with that, I do think new players tend to not get killed till at least midgame. Whether that's not lynching or not getting night killed. There are exceptions (like the prosti vs escort mix up we had some games ago). I do agree that's it's odd to hide behind a claimed doctor, new or not, mafia is probably not uninterested in a player with that sort of claim.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

Sorry for the wall '-' I dislike walls myself and now I'm torturing others with it. I'm going to sleep I think, I literally can't think and hopefully the morning will do me some good.

 

[AnimePigeon]

ok then who do you trust the most ?

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

@Marmalade @Brandish μ @AnimePigeon sorry if i missed did you used your orle, any new info/hints to share who are the ones you suspect the most

Hey @Erinyes

ok then who do you trust the most ?

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

@Marmalade @Brandish μ @AnimePigeon sorry if i missed did you used your orle, any new info/hints to share who are the ones you suspect the most

@Erinyes this is where I would love to say I do something, but would be a lie.

I didn't do anything, I couldn't decide on an appropriate selection, so I opted to give it another day.

Still mainly suspect Nash & Teubs

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026 ---

Ops astupdi phone doing double ping/qoure

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026 ---

I'm gonna have to go to bed because I fell asleep on the bog for a bit Good night

@digitaldude did you do anything last night?

Happens to the best of us

 

[digitaldude]

@Marmalade im not tunneling i explaned my vote, the last minute train attempt on me, is more than suspicious, and see him siding with nash who has a pretty questionable claim , sam and nash for now are my highest suspects, mostly by default, i dont have enough good readng on everyone else. that doesnt help.


someone asked why i havent used my role, I havent because it was no use. confitions were not met

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 14, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 14, 2026 ---

its a pain I'm soon going to bed and i feel as if i dont know anything, I will try to stay awake as much as possible,. But saying straight, I wont be online tomorrow coz o working hours (aka mornng in my time zone till end of the phase)

I'm guessing you are one of mortician/sprit medium/investigator then

 

[AnimePigeon]

damn... sorry @Erinyes



seconded

You pushing Erin/Kako is the Equivalent of me pushing DD almost everygame.

When looking for inconsistentcies or issues, it can be easy to see some that might not be entirely true.

Admittely, I'm still stuck in Nash with how open they were Day 1 with there claim & there voting towards the end - as well as Teubier's strangely early vote & soft push in Gry.

 

[GrySun]

please consider that the fact you don't believe I'm hider is literally proof that the claim might've worked to trick mafia last night if they think so too lmao

Nope, at most they mafia det you while trying to lynch you D2

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 15, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 15, 2026 ---

He's one of the few ppl I can be confident isn't mafia and I assumed newbie gets to live N1 unless maf is truly evil

I wanna believe you but who would ever hide behind a Doc claim N1..

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 15, 2026 ---

Gry seems somehow very relaxed and laid back

Sorry but if this is your takeaway after early D2 then I can disregard the rest of your wall as a low quality observation or just a mafia fakepost.

 

[digitaldude]

Marm also one of the death investigating roles it seems.

 

[GrySun]

You pushing Erin/Kako is the Equivalent of me pushing DD almost everygame.

When looking for inconsistentcies or issues, it can be easy to see some that might not be entirely true.

Admittely, I'm still stuck in Nash with how open they were Day 1 with there claim & there voting towards the end - as well as Teubier's strangely early vote & soft push in Gry.

Should you be boxing yourself into such few choices? If they're both town not only are you losing 2 lynches but also ignoring everyone else and starting off of 0 after those 2 are gone

 

[Natasha]

I wanna believe you but who would ever hide behind a Doc claim N1..

Who would admit to doing it too without being asked.

Marms was right on me being stressed but it's not game related. It also took until brand saying "stop hiding now you'll just screw town" to realise yeah I've missplayed and neutered my own role.

Sorry.

Sharing my reads in a sec, need to go back since I only skimmed.

 

[SirSamuel016]

I'm still reading, but Sam & Erin, can I just ask you to try not to tunnel on each other please If needed just ignore the other for a bit and take some time to cool off and think about other people

Where was I tunnelling on Erin? I thought I've been level-headed in dismissing her paranoia over my attempt to save Kako yesterday. If anyone is looking like tunnelling atm it is her being wound up by that incident.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 15, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 15, 2026 ---

Wasn't sam safe to stay on Kako cause he wasn't the last vote?

Yes lol