Games Mafia Game 142 - McHelpers - Game End

[SirSamuel016]

@GrySun
Either Nash or Sam for their strange vote on Erin when they had several 1 vote targets to actually meaningfully save Kakoha's life but condemning somebody else to day 1 lynch.

Otherwise, I don't know. I don't feel too strongly about the rest of the players here.

You sus me, which makes me trust you more than when you are cooperative with me. Plus you poke a lot and keep poking which feels more up to Town gry than Mafia Gry throwing shade at 3-4 different people.

DD is like ADHS, running in, posting 1-2 lines, leaving. What am I supposed to read in that except it being annoying?

Erin is not doing her usual list but Sam seems to have picked up that habit instead.

Style feels so green to me I wanna give him candy and praise him for what a good job he does.

Teubs revealed BD. Marm's feels town to me. Holt feels his usual self.

AnimePigeon/Brandish/Lawl - no idea, I feel nothing off about them but at the same time nothing that makes me feel like trusting them.

Gotta eat dinner in peace now, I'll come back before day ends, like 30-15 minutes before it ends.

Given you're not revealing for some reason, is there a category that your role falls under that you'd divulge?

 

[Marmalade]

James:
- Active claim
- Targeted you N1
- Feels inauthentic, lacks some substance, mech posted in a mechless game for a while
- Just hasn't convinced me that he's town

Obviously there are others that I doubt too, but I think too much lines up for James to not be scum. That's me though; I know others like @Stylether have "AP, Teub, dd" as their top 3 suspects.

As Gry said though, go with what you think, not what you feel.

You cant ask someone who has been in and out of migraines for over a week to think, thats not a good idea ‘-‘

Do we know what he targetted me with? That would help a lot maybe

I dont think AP is scum tbh, not nervous enough

 

[SirSamuel016]

You cant ask someone who has been in and out of migraines for over a week to think, thats not a good idea ‘-‘

You should try drinking more water mate

Do we know what he targetted me with? That would help a lot maybe

Yeah nah he hasn't said what with; I just asked him about the category.

Should I ask you who your top 3-5 suspects are atm or is the head too strained?

I dont think AP is scum tbh, not nervous enough

I can see him being on either side atm. I liked his day 1 more than his day 2; some of the back and forth with Nash left me with some doubt.

 

[Teubier]

Could you walk me through your reasoning, since I'm personally not a huge fan of "trust me" and prefer explanations I can follow.

That aside, this:



Makes me sad to hear. Not enjoying the game?

I’m not asking anyone to trust me. I’m just saying I outed the whole maf team two games ago, and rightly suspected CoPan early on last game (Nash too, James knows from Mason pad). So I’m not totally full of shit.

Well, as host, I would put, for 4 non-towns, two influential figures with two more lowkey figures. Well, for 4 mafia at least, third party existing makes it a bit different.
So right now, I’d have some influentials in: Gry / Nash / Sam / Brandish / James.
And some (supposed) lowkeys in: Lawl / AP / Holt / DD.
I don’t know what to think of Erin and Marms at this point.

Therefore I make a choice. Am I wrong? Possibly, but Gry have been discussing, debating alright. But not claimed, nor pushed toward lynching me when he had the chance before I revealed my role despite clearly wanting to. That’s suspect in my book.

Dunno if I’m enjoying the game to be fair. But me dying at night early means job done, and I’d like that.

 

[GrySun]

I’m not asking anyone to trust me. I’m just saying I outed the whole maf team two games ago, and rightly suspected CoPan early on last game (Nash too, James knows from Mason pad). So I’m not totally full of shit.

Well, as host, I would put, for 4 non-towns, two influential figures with two more lowkey figures. Well, for 4 mafia at least, third party existing makes it a bit different.
So right now, I’d have some influentials in: Gry / Nash / Sam / Brandish / James.
And some (supposed) lowkeys in: Lawl / AP / Holt / DD.
I don’t know what to think of Erin and Marms at this point.

Therefore I make a choice. Am I wrong? Possibly, but Gry have been discussing, debating alright. But not claimed, nor pushed toward lynching me when he had the chance before I revealed my role despite clearly wanting to. That’s suspect in my book.

Dunno if I’m enjoying the game to be fair. But me dying at night early means job done, and I’d like that.

What the F

 

[SirSamuel016]

I’m not asking anyone to trust me. I’m just saying I outed the whole maf team two games ago, and rightly suspected CoPan early on last game (Nash too, James knows from Mason pad). So I’m not totally full of shit.

Well, as host, I would put, for 4 non-towns, two influential figures with two more lowkey figures. Well, for 4 mafia at least, third party existing makes it a bit different.
So right now, I’d have some influentials in: Gry / Nash / Sam / Brandish / James.
And some (supposed) lowkeys in: Lawl / AP / Holt / DD.
I don’t know what to think of Erin and Marms at this point.

Therefore I make a choice. Am I wrong? Possibly, but Gry have been discussing, debating alright. But not claimed, nor pushed toward lynching me when he had the chance before I revealed my role despite clearly wanting to. That’s suspect in my book.

Dunno if I’m enjoying the game to be fair. But me dying at night early means job done, and I’d like that.

So who is the mafia team in your eyes that we should be lynching?

 

[GrySun]

Teub the roles and teams are randomized

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 15, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 15, 2026 ---

nor pushed toward lynching me when he had the chance before I revealed my role despite clearly wanting to. That’s suspect in my book.

This should be the other way around..

 

[Teubier]

Teub the roles and teams are randomized

Is it? You did so last game? Are PanFalla doing the same? Gosh, than what is the point of me thinking then?.. Okay let me sweat in peace.

 

[SirSamuel016]

I don't know whats going on rn js, genuinely bamboozled

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 15, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 15, 2026 ---

Is it? You did so last game? Are PanFalla doing the same? Gosh, than what is the point of me thinking then?.. Okay let me sweat in peace.

Everyone and their aunties rando it yeah

 

[Natasha]

I’m not asking anyone to trust me. I’m just saying I outed the whole maf team two games ago, and rightly suspected CoPan early on last game (Nash too, James knows from Mason pad). So I’m not totally full of shit.

Well, as host, I would put, for 4 non-towns, two influential figures with two more lowkey figures. Well, for 4 mafia at least, third party existing makes it a bit different.
So right now, I’d have some influentials in: Gry / Nash / Sam / Brandish / James.
And some (supposed) lowkeys in: Lawl / AP / Holt / DD.
I don’t know what to think of Erin and Marms at this point.

Therefore I make a choice. Am I wrong? Possibly, but Gry have been discussing, debating alright. But not claimed, nor pushed toward lynching me when he had the chance before I revealed my role despite clearly wanting to. That’s suspect in my book.

Dunno if I’m enjoying the game to be fair. But me dying at night early means job done, and I’d like that.

Tubbs...

Meta-gaming on the strength of players being placed in specific roles is going to be both wrong and against the spirit of the game. What the hosts think of us as players isn't what we're here to solve for, nor will it be accurate.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 15, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 15, 2026 ---

Ok Gry arleady hit you with it good good

 

[Stylether]

Is it? You did so last game? Are PanFalla doing the same? Gosh, than what is the point of me thinking then?.. Okay let me sweat in peace.

 

[Teubier]

Okay well don’t bother with me then everybody. Just let me do my job tonight.

 

[Holt]

Damn I would’ve missed the rest. Going to catch up

 

[SirSamuel016]

Ratio

 

[Stylether]

With only like 25m left, I should probably set my first vote at least.

Vote: AnimePigeon

I had been on the fence whether I should go for AP or join AP on my 2nd pick, but what just transpired felt very genuine and Teub was pretty forthcoming, so AP it is.

That being said, I'll be here till day end to consider alternatives.

 

[Farfalla]

A bit more than 20 mins left~

Players that still gotta vote: @Brandish μ @Holt @James Rye @Marmalade @Stylether​

 

[GrySun]

22 minutes hm

 

[Stylether]

A bit more than 20 mins left~

Players that still gotta vote: @Brandish μ @Holt @James Rye @Marmalade @Stylether​

Hihi parried that "still to vote" frame-perfect

 

[SirSamuel016]

Oh fuck I thought there was another hour to this day phase

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 15, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 15, 2026 ---

With only like 25m left, I should probably set my first vote at least.

Vote: AnimePigeon

I had been on the fence whether I should go for AP or join AP on my 2nd pick, but what just transpired felt very genuine and Teub was pretty forthcoming, so AP it is.

That being said, I'll be here till day end to consider alternatives.

Can you explain this one again for me please?

 

[Natasha]

With only like 25m left, I should probably set my first vote at least.

Vote: AnimePigeon

I had been on the fence whether I should go for AP or join AP on my 2nd pick, but what just transpired felt very genuine and Teub was pretty forthcoming, so AP it is.

That being said, I'll be here till day

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 15, 2026, Original Post Date: Jul 15, 2026 ---

Phone missinput, was gonna quote Sty saying I'm was just about to lock James because AP is getting no tracktion