Games Mafia Game 145 - Vampire Crawlers - Day 3

[Lady pompom]

I guess I have trouble believing a green would vote and reason like this. Either Pomcha lives, or she gets counterclaimed by the actual doc, which they then kill. Tough

I’m the actual doctor. Your red panda disguised as panda!

 

[Copy Panda]

If you're green, potentially you've been MDetted Kako, which is why they want to kill you now

--- Double Post Merged, Today at 12:51 AM, Original Post Date: Today at 12:50 AM ---

No other explanation cropped up, poison would be annoying if it kept going but if we lynch mafia then that's a 1/3 of hitting a poisoner and resolving that.

Tatsu mentioned traitor but I don't see it unless maybe all 3 mafia roles (2 maf + 1 town traitor) are stacked cause starting with 2 maf is a nasty setup even if there's a traitor.

Blocker? BP? No one is gonna claim this, so the best we can do is now kill another Mafia and if anyone but Pomcha dies at night, we know the next target

 

[Lady pompom]

If you're green, potentially you've been MDetted Kako, which is why they want to kill you now

Yeah, which is why I keep saying he has an agenda and that he is suspicious, but you’re not dong yourself any favors pushing for town doc’s lynch to glean something from it. I’m sure we can learn more by lynching you or kako today.

 

[Copy Panda]

Yeah, which is why I keep saying he has an agenda and that he is suspicious, but you’re not dong yourself any favors pushing for town doc’s lynch to glean something from it. I’m sure we can learn more by lynching you or kako today.

What do you plan to learn from killing a plain townie following a train effort? Lawl placed a vote on me, and you and Sam jumped on the opportunity to do it. Especially the reasoning for your vote following the Kako vote just 10 posts earlier just doesn't make sense to me.

--- Double Post Merged, Today at 12:54 AM, Original Post Date: Today at 12:52 AM ---

None of your reasoning makes sense to me, except you planted these doc hints, which speaks to your case somewhat. Hence we can wait and see if you die or not next night. I'd rather kill Sam I think; his gameplay has turned from aggressive to memish/haughty, so he must be smelling blood

 

[Lady pompom]

And what do we glean from killing town doc? We glean that town doesn’t have no doc anymore.

--- Double Post Merged, Today at 12:56 AM, Original Post Date: Today at 12:56 AM ---

If I’m the lynch*

 

[Hardy]

pseudo caught up

Upon reflection, we'll be able to see who defended her hardest, who agreed, who disagreed. This kind of thing.

That's for every person, why her?

 

[Copy Panda]

And what do we glean from killing town doc? We glean that town doesn’t have no doc anymore.

--- Double Post Merged, Today at 12:56 AM, Original Post Date: Today at 12:56 AM ---

If I’m the lynch*

My thesis rests on the fact I don't think you're a doc, naturally.

--- Double Post Merged, Today at 12:58 AM ---

pseudo caught up

That's for every person, why her?

I've been making a case against her all night Inexplicable votes and reasoning therefore, in a nutshell

 

[Kakoha]

sorry panda, you make some good point but sadly they are placed in the wrong situation. your arguments would have been right if it weren't for the doc reveal, yet instead of trying to find actual mafia you keep trying to push for a doc lynch
votelock panda @GrySun

 

[SirSamuel016]

What do you plan to learn from killing a plain townie following a train effort? Lawl placed a vote on me, and you and Sam jumped on the opportunity to do it. Especially the reasoning for your vote following the Kako vote just 10 posts earlier just doesn't make sense to me.

I'd been suspecting you prior to Lawl's vote, but his vote did give me more confidence to back my theory and gut in on pursuing you

I take more issue with you still sussing Pom though than I do with you sussing me tbh

 

[Copy Panda]

Okay so lets say the doc thing is believed, who would we go for

 

[Hardy]

My thesis rests on the fact I don't think you're a doc, naturally.

--- Double Post Merged, Today at 12:58 AM ---

I've been making a case against her all night Inexplicable votes and reasoning therefore, in a nutshell

But you were using "her death will clear things up" as an argument. It won't, at this point it will provide as much info as pretty much any other player except for the fact that she's claiming a protective role lol

 

[Copy Panda]

sorry panda, you make some good point but sadly they are placed in the wrong situation. your arguments would have been right if it weren't for the doc reveal, yet instead of trying to find actual mafia you keep trying to push for a doc lynch
votelock panda @GrySun

oof

 

[Kakoha]

I've been making a case against her all night Inexplicable votes and reasoning therefore, in a nutshell

it's more believable that she just screwed up than claiming a bold doc claim as mafia
I'll be sad if I'm wrong

 

[Copy Panda]

But you were using "her death will clear things up" as an argument. It won't, at this point it will provide as much info as pretty much any other player except for the fact that she's claiming a protective role lol

That wasn't an argument, just a statement. My arguments were prior. But listen, I understand with her claim this isn't happening. I'm willing to entertain other options, as I reassure you of my plain townieness

 

[Hardy]

sorry panda, you make some good point but sadly they are placed in the wrong situation. your arguments would have been right if it weren't for the doc reveal, yet instead of trying to find actual mafia you keep trying to push for a doc lynch
votelock panda @GrySun

top ten anime betrayals

--- Double Post Merged, Today at 1:02 AM, Original Post Date: Today at 1:01 AM ---

That wasn't an argument, just a statement. My arguments were prior. But listen, I understand with her claim this isn't happening. I'm willing to entertain other options, as I reassure you of my plain townieness

statement argument wtv it's the same. It's on the game and it can convince someone

 

[Copy Panda]

We had enough time to talk it out @Kakoha

Who are the remaining people who have yet to place a vote? Marms, Nashy?

 

[SirSamuel016]

top ten anime betrayals

I'd place it 11th

 

[Kakoha]

Okay so lets say the doc thing is believed, who would we go for

you tell us
since you really think you're town, in a world where pom is actually town, who would you go for ?

 

[SirSamuel016]

Who are the remaining people who have yet to place a vote? Marms, Nashy?

yes

 

[Marmalade]

sorry panda, you make some good point but sadly they are placed in the wrong situation. your arguments would have been right if it weren't for the doc reveal, yet instead of trying to find actual mafia you keep trying to push for a doc lynch
votelock panda @GrySun

I don't think a doc reveal should throw away everything that's been said/done before tbh. To me it only adds to the existing weirdness, and I'm not liking it.