I think once a 1v1 reaches high diff or above, the matchup should be judged by who wins the majority out of 10 fights rather than just one.
I don't see a character beating someone 10 times in a row if every fight is high diff. At that point, the characters are clearly close enough in strength that small differences in decisions, circumstances, or even luck could change the outcome.
Low and mid-diff fights have a more consistent winner, but if someone can push you to your limits, there's no reason to assume you'd beat them every single time. Winning a close fight doesn't mean you're guaranteed to win the next one.
I would say Traumerei beats Gustang 7 out of 10 times.