Discussion Magellan Discussion Thread

[Kaiser Will]

You mean the marrow? It makes blood cells, but Brook has no blood (Yohohoho!). It could be a interesting way to solve the Magellan problem.

Yeah, the marrow produces the blood cells and the anti-bodies.
I know that he didn't have blood but he does make poo and fart, eat and drink and stuff like that, so we don't know if he could be affected by Magellan poison.
If he has that kinda stuff he definatelly will be poisoned.

 

[Truefan21]

maybe magellan will appear at marineford

 

[bittman]

Random thought, but I must say it was actually something I pondered much earlier on. Like what if the gates were opened because Magellan was on the chase, but on the other hand he had a lot of cleaning up to do in house with Shiryuu on the loose (and Blackbeard, though he may not be aware of that).

It would still be unbelievably epic of Magellan appeared, however I doubt we'll ever see him again outside of a quick one shot back to Impel Down and a cover story (I'd almost bet a house on the fact that Impel Down wardens will get a cover story. Hannybel, Magellan, Sadi-chan, Demon Guards and Domino were far too good a collection of characters to leave to a small arc).

 

[ScratchmenApoo]

Random thought, but I must say it was actually something I pondered much earlier on. Like what if the gates were opened because Magellan was on the chase

If Magellan was on the chase, then he would most likely want to keep the gates closed, don't you think ? Or maybe I just misinterpreted you ?

Right now, I also agree that Magellan is fighting Blackbeard and co.

 

[chess4]

i think magellan will gather his forces at impel down and sail to the new world. with impel down's reputation ruined and it destoyed, he will seek his revenge

 

[Diablos]

Magellan is like a really though bastard dont forget he made everyone run from him in Impel Down... Even Jinbei, Ivankov, Croco.. They didnt wait to face him they were on their boots... Yes they were in hurry but even so I dont think they'd have the balls to face him XD... He even made BB almost perish without bothering much, just an hydra and done.. lol if that's not badas* tell me what it is ;P

I think he just aint in admiral level because they are logias and he's not, even so I'd put him in top ranks of shishi top top..

 

[ScratchmenApoo]

It doesn't matter that he's not a logia. I think poison man is the most powerful paramecia of all. If he attacks you, you are done for, no doubt. If you attack him, close combat, then you are done for too. If he wasn't a warden, he would be a vice-captain, but most likely he doesn't want to be one.
But I also think that Magellan and Luffy will have a rematch some day, this seems to be unfinished business. Whether he appears in Marinford and it happens now or some time later in the New World, is something hard to predict.

 

[NoLimit89]

Magellan's fruit feels like a logia

Where does it say that he's a paramecia?

I just watched episode 436 again and Luffy's attack seemed to pass through him.

Could he be a logia?

 

[kkck]

Re: Megellan's fruit feels like a logia

Where does it say that he's a paramecia?

I just watched episode 436 again and Luffy's attack seemed to pass through him.

Could he be a logia?

He is a paramecia, things have never once passed through him. He also has never converted his actual body to poison. Luffy was even shown physically hitting him several times. There is nothing logia about magellan lol. I don't watch the anime but in the manga luffy never did anything close to phasing through him. Magellan is as much as a logia as luffy (surprisingly people still argue he is a logia though).

 

[Uriel]

Re: Megellan's fruit feels like a logia

It's just an overpowered Paramecia. Kinda like Whitebeard.

 

[Gcat88]

Luffy did punch Magellan and it didnt go throw him but rather look like a real punch!! So i think that unless we got an official calling on it we wont know, but i lean towards Paramecia.

 

[Fox666]

Well, I understand the question, he does looks like an Logia in the anime.

The way the animators did it is very strange, since the according to the manga he is supposed to be just a Paramecia.

 

[Poneglyph420]

Luffy's attacks penetrated Magellan's poison I think, he's a Paramecia for sure.

But now he's gonna be lucky if he still has his job..
But He Prob. will, I mean he is scary strong...

 

[BetaRuler]

He looks quite paramecia to me.

I'd say he's almost Admiral level as well.
Its a shame I can't see any chance of him leaving Impel Down either, as much as I'd like to see more of him and Saldeath.

 

[Bugzee]

Magellan possesses one of the best and most deadliest df abilities in the OP world. I like his character traits, tbh I can't imagine a better person to be head of Impel Down lol. I wonder who the head of ID was before Magellan..?

Anyway, that "Venom Demon: Hell's Judgment" attack fricking owns! I love the look of it. I can't wait to see that in the anime! At first I thought he had a logia ability too but it makes more sense that his a paramecia. Logia poison ability would've been a bit overkill lol to say the least.

 

[Lord Rayleigh]

We don't know if Magellan is a paramecia or a logia. I have to say that the fact that Luffy managed to punch Magellan and his fists did not go through him does not mean the warden is a paramecia : he could be a solid poisonman - as Ao Kiji is a solid iceman - while his poison attacks can be gaseous and liquid.

And it's right that what has done the anime is very confusing. When I watched the episodes you guys are talking about, I was sure he was a paramecia and yet I could not understand what happened with his DF, which was suggesting he was a logia.
There is also the moment when Luffy talked about his poison cloud, and Magellan answered that it was not a simple poison gas but actually a living thing and a part of him - I don't know if it's only in the anime or not. Anyway, it's a characteristic peculiar to the logias

In the manga itself, at this page his legs clearly disappeared, as if he turned a part of his body into poison to produce his Hell's Judgement. Not to say that he needed to make some movements to make the monster move in the same way.
There is also the time when Magellan tooks several cannonballs at the same time at full shot and did not get injured at all. Oda did not let us see what truly happened in this moment because Magellan was hidden by the explosions around him.

A simple question, have we ever seen Magellan blooding ?

 

[Franckie]

A simple question, have we ever seen Magellan blooding ?

http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/534/18-19/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/535/04/

Luffy drew blood and had Magellan feeling some pain. Had Magellan been a Logia, Luffy's attacks wouldn't have caused any damage. In conclusion, the Doku-Doku no Mi is a Paramecia-type Devil Fruit.

 

[Fox666]

On that image you posted, I can see both Magellan's legs. He is moving, and has tiny legs, but if you looks closely, you can see his shoe behind his butt.

Magellan bleed from Ivankov fight, but it was not shown at all. I don't remember exactly if Luffy made Magellan bleed, but he surely hit him bad.

Although it should be noted that when his hydra ended in the flames, it disappear. So I guess Luffy using Gear second would injure Magellan even if he was a Logia...

 

[Dice]

We don't know if Magellan is a paramecia or a logia. I have to say that the fact that Luffy managed to punch Magellan and his fists did not go through him does not mean the warden is a paramecia : he could be a solid poisonman - as Ao Kiji is a solid iceman - while his poison attacks can be gaseous and liquid.

I think Aokiji's case is a little bit different since ice is always solid. While I understand that you mean he might be a solid type of poison he never used a solid type. Though there is still a chance that he might be a solid logia type I think it's unlikely.

But I agree with you that attacks not passing through somebody is by no means an argument against logia since there at least two examples.

 

[Zehahaha]

A simple question, have we ever seen Magellan blooding ?

Here it is : http://media.onemanga.com/mangas/00000002/000188722/13.jpg
After Ivankov's Newkama Kenpo attack

Crap, Franckie got me here