Theory What if Alluka is not the missing brother?

[Uriel]

See this?

You actually think it's Alluka? They look QUITE different. Thoughts? Not much of a theory, but I think there is someone else on the Zoldycks who wasn't mention.

 

[Zvane]

mmm...he's black haired...like Kikyo, Illumi, Milluki and Kalluto...plus, flashbacks show him in those same clothes...
what I do think, he might not be a true Zoldyck, maybe they found him/her somewhere...I mean, every Zoldyck is trained as an assassin as soon as they are born, but Alluka is just a normal child (with freakish powers)

there's also the name thing

IlluMilluKilluAlluKalluto

 

[TheAmericandream]

I want to say it was Alluka but Togashi hadn't settled on a character design for him yet. But you might be right, I just want to know Kalluto's whole deal with Alluka.

 

[Pi3]

Well, Alluka wasn't considered as the part of family, but as a thing, so she wasn't included in five Zoldycks brothers, right?

http://www.mangafox.com/manga/hunter_x_hunter/v29/c321/16.html

So it seems to be that the missing one is the one that made Kalluto join Ryodan. As far as I remember it was mentioned before - somebody even guessed that his name would be something like Allua to fit beetwen Killua and Alluka

 

[Zvane]

I think what Kalluto means by joining the Ryodan is pretty much the same thing Killua's after: getting rid of Nanika and turning Alluka into a normal child

 

[heron bpv]

I'm with TheAmericandream in this one. It's possible Togashi hadn't have anything planned for Alluka's design back then. And Kalluto's motives are just so much more hazy since Alluka's appearance that I prefer to not touch the subject right now, in fear of an imminent troll. <_<

 

[Uriel]

Thing is that Kalluto joined Ryodan to get his brother back. If He's talking about Killua, it doesn't make much sense. If He's talking about Alluka it also doesn't make sense. Why joining the Ryodan would be a big deal to find HER SISTER which is on HER OWN HOUSE? Or why it would help him to find Killua if He has a wonderful useful ability that allows him to find almost anyone? And Kalluto and Illumi seems close as any Zoldyck, so if Kalluto was after Killua it doesn't make sense that He wasn't there in the whole Alluka situation.

So there must be someone else.

 

[Zvane]

Thing is that Kalluto joined Ryodan to get his brother back. If He's talking about Killua, it doesn't make much sense. If He's talking about Alluka it also doesn't make sense. Why joining the Ryodan would be a big deal to find HER SISTER which is on HER OWN HOUSE? Or why it would help him to find Killua if He has a wonderful useful ability that allows him to find almost anyone? And Kalluto and Illumi seems close as any Zoldyck, so if Kalluto was after Killua it doesn't make sense that He wasn't there in the whole Alluka situation.

So there must be someone else.

well...Kalluto did say bring back his brother....it doesn't necessarily mean that he's missing

 

[Uriel]

Then tell me how Ryodan helps him to get his brother back? It's not Alluka because She's already on the mansion. So we can discard that. But Ryodan is the way to get Killua back? Wouldn't be more effective to be with Killua? How Ryodan can help him to CONVINCE Killua to come back? It doesn't make sense.

Therefore, is someone else.

 

[Zvane]

Then tell me how Ryodan helps him to get his brother back? It's not Alluka because She's already on the mansion. So we can discard that. But Ryodan is the way to get Killua back? Wouldn't be more effective to be with Killua? How Ryodan can help him to CONVINCE Killua to come back? It doesn't make sense.

Therefore, is someone else.

Well...get someone back probably means about Alluka's(this is debatable) split personality...I doubt that is something as simple as finding someone who's missing...with the Zoldyck's resources, that should be a piece of cake (plus, they find people to kill all the time, no matter how well hidden they are...i.e. the Ten Dons)

I think Togashi would make the reasons for Kalluto joining the Ryodan much more complicated and mental than just "finding someone"

 

[Uriel]

The splitting personality is between Nanika and Alluka but neither of those act NEARLY manly (Nanika acts disturbed but no gender wise) And the guy in the picture doesn't look AT ALL like a girl. AT ALL. And is bigger than Kalluto there. Perspective wise He's more and less the same stature of Illumi. Maybe is a twin of Milluki. (?)

Can't know. But now I'm SURE THAT is not Alluka.

---------- Post added at 10:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:01 PM ----------

Looking better, that eyes of that guy should at least be in the same line of Milluki shoulders.

 

[Zvane]

In flashbacks, Alluka is wearing those clothes....I agree, the character design is a bit different, but Togashi could change it

 

[Uriel]

Which flashbacks? >_>

 

[heron bpv]

The ones that show Alluka's abilities being unveiled.

 

[Sea Hunter]

The way i see it it's Alluka, Illumi told Hisoka the zoldyecks have another brother so even if they say it's an "it" and not human he still referred to Alluka as brother.

 

[HelixEpsilon]

Well alluka wasn't missing, while killua was. But maybe her family hid the truth from her about alluka, saying she had disappeared while her room was really just next floor.

But in any case it was pretty bad timing for poor karuto, signing up with the genei ryodan litteraly days from killua coming back on his own... And even getting alluka out of her room in case it was about her

 

[weo1weo1weo1]

I think maybe they will get kuroro lucifer to steal alluka's ability and then they will try to kill him to get rid of nanika for good.... but i'm not sure about his ability though what if all the stolen abilities return to their original users after he dies...

 

[Kanmuru]

Well, togashi clearly f*cked up with allukas size, she is a lot smaller than killua in the flashbacks, but here she looks taller xD
When Illumi tells Hisoka about nanika, they show us the picture, it's pretty clear, that's alluka