Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2012] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[kewl0210]

You would think with it being an already established authour and having done so well in the TOCs that they would print a LITTLE more. But obviously, volume 1s usually get a small first printing, then it gets reprinted a lot. Definitely good news for the series.

 

[vampire killer]

nisekoi is rom-com after 10 volume or less it will bit the dust

 

[Pirulito]

And what is important about that?

 

[Drmke]

nisekoi is rom-com after 10 volume or less it will bit the dust

Do you base that on all the rom-com's that have ended before ten volumes or the numerous examples of rom-com's that have gone on much longer than that?

 

[Kaiten]

Everyone knows that rom-con can only last ten volumes so that they can be canceled quickly so that more action mangos can be started so that the fanboys can be happy. Science has proven it

Sports mangos can only last 12 volumes unless it is Eyeshield 21. Kuroko doesn't really exist. It was made up online.

 

[Negative Syndicate]

Sports mangos can only last 12 volumes unless it is Eyeshield 21. Kuroko doesn't really exist. It was made up online.

Why do you think sport manga only last 12 volumes?

 

[RocketWobbuffet]

meh...As much as I loved Rurouni Kenshin, I'd rather Watsuki just stick with Embalming :/

Has this happened before? where an author just drops a series they're working on so they can work on a series that's been long since completed? :/ I'd rather they just left RK alone, it had a good and satisfying ending.

Yukito Kishiro dropped Aqua Knight to work on Gunnm / Battle Angel Alita Last Order.

 

[Schabrak]

Why do you think sport manga only last 12 volumes?

Because he says so? It's an obvious joke, I hope you aren't joking too... Slam Dunk is a comedy drama, not sports manga also. Damn all genre generalisations!

 

[vampire killer]

well rom-com start to get very boring after 20 or so.At first they can be very popular but then somting happens and they are gone. For the sport manga nice joke

 

[Schabrak]

So you just extended it another ten volumes to not look as bad as you did before? Of course it's not easy to make them last for more than a decade, but how do you imagine they could extend their romance much longer? That's same same problem as with every other manga too. Action/adventure tend to prolong their end with an endless amount of fights, do you want romances crushed and broken numerous times in a manga?

 

[Oberon]

635 名前：ohana ◆IR7jauNn4E ：2012/05/09(水) 19:20:06.30 ID:9G58MBpTP
GW楽しかったよー　ばっかるこーん！！

表紙　斉木
デカデカとナルト映画情報（巻頭みたい）
巻頭　斉木
ナルト
ワンピ
銀魂
ハイキュー
トリコ
恋染　C
べるぜ
ニセコイ
めだか　C
スケット
パジャマ
いぬまる
黒子
こち亀
リボン　C
ブリーチ
クロガネ
マジコ
ぬらり


25号　戦星バルジ巻頭
斉木　C
パジャマ　C
ハイキュー　C

Jump #24 (14/05) :
PSI Kusuo Saiki (Cover & Lead Color Page, New Series, 26 pg.)
Naruto
One Piece
Gintama
Hq!!
Toriko
Koisome Momiji (Color Page, 25 pg.)
Beelzebub
Nisekoi
Medaka Box (Color Page, Third Year Anniversary)
Sket Dance
Pajama na Kanojo
Inumaru Dashi
Kuroko no Basket
Kochikame
Reborn! (Color Page)
Bleach
Kurogane
Magico
Nurarihyon no Mago
Hunter x Hunter (Hiatus)

#25:
Lead CP: Sensei no Balge / Horikochi Kouhei (New Series)
CP: PSI Kusuo Saiki, Hq!!, Pajama na Kanojo

 

[vampire killer]

amm.... where is bleach(just saw it)? and why is a color page in the bottom 5? Bleach in the bottom 5 again. This dosent look good...

 

[kewl0210]

Bleach is 4th from the bottom. See?
HQ certainly doing well. And Nisekoi. I may try reading those.

 

[crimsonlink310]

NO!!! Bleach and Kurogane are at the bottom 20.

Other than then that, the rankings are decent I guess. Happy for Gintama being in the top 5. Naruto chapters starts the beginning of

Spoiler

Uchiha bros vs Kabuto -8 chapters ago which explains the #1 ranking imo plus Tsunade actually doing something for once.

 

[wintercry]

Koisome's first chapter was fairly good. It somehow reminded me of Ichigo 100%.

 

[Teeba]

Beelzebub chapter 147/148 ranked fifth? Oh wow that's amazing, though kind of unexpected.

Are Pajama and HQ ranked yet?

 

[wintercry]

Yes. Pajama's latest chapter is 11. HQ is in 12.

 

[TXC]

Pajamas's getting a cp, nisekoi doing well and now a new romcom... Is jump going back to the past?

 

[crimsonlink310]

Beelzebub chapter 147/148 ranked fifth? Oh wow that's amazing, though kind of unexpected.

Are Pajama and HQ ranked yet?

It would make things so much easier if they had a chapter number next to the ranking so that readers would know which chapter did good or bad. All this -8 chapters crap makes things complicated when you factor in color pages and whether or not to include them when you count back -8 chapters.

 

[Kaiten]

Sad to see Bleach so low, it's been pretty good lately. One Piece should be ahead of Naruto, but that is what it is. Even Sabaody could not compete with the Uchiha brothers, at least not in rankings.