Games MAFIA GAME 19 END!

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

But it is such a bad move all around. Even if the two of you were in fact masons by saying it you would only put yourself in the eyes of the mafia. Of course, if you are not a mason then the supposed contact the two of you have is even weirder. Why would you trust each other? You were just naming possibilities? You basically retracted from what you originally said. And I bet you did it once you realized how bad a move that was. The whole thing stinks even if you were given a detective role. You seem to be working in tandem with nichan BEFORE the first night when you would hypothetically be able to use your ability. And even if you did use your ability how would you know you are not the insane or naive detective? I mean, to begin with there would be a 66% chance that you are the wrong kind of detective.

well the reason I trust niichan is 'cause he's not acting like in the #18 mafia game (e.g. suspicious) also since we played then I have a remote idea what his thoughts are and am using some of them to base my assumptions on the same.
In my dictionary a person is not mafia unless proven otherwise, since I've played mafia with niichan I kinda know what he'd be if he was a mafia and comapred to that he's not even close right now.

Also last time both Imp and niichan didn't think highly of the masons so I kidna inherited that view and don't find them very important..

Anyway as we know the mafia has a Janitor and it needs a Boss this doesn't leave any other possibilities for different roles, hereby my role can't be a mafiotinisized one.

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

it is questioned,thats why im suspicious of him,same with u...only hardy left

Ah true, but it's my fault there...I was referring to niichan there...it was him that used this train of thought and while he used it his conclusion was that I was more suspicious than wizzard, which is a bit...well...either interesting, or he isn't paying much attention to the actual posts and number of posts

---------- Post added at 06:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:01 PM ----------

well the reason I trust niichan is 'cause he's not acting like in the #18 mafia game (e.g. suspicious) also since we played then I have a remote idea what his thoughts are and am using some of them to base my assumptions on the same.
In my dictionary a person is not mafia unless proven otherwise, since I've played mafia with niichan I kinda know what he'd be if he was a mafia and comapred to that he's not even close right now.

Also last time both Imp and niichan didn't think highly of the masons so I kidna inherited that view and don't find them very important..

Anyway as we know the mafia has a Janitor and it needs a Boss this doesn't leave any other possibilities for different roles, hereby my role can't be a mafiotinisized one.

This kind of argument doesn't hold much ground though...just because you know how one person played once, is not enough to trust...well, I don't think it should be a reason in any case...

Also there is no such thing as proof in this game...so you might have to change your dictionary

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

All I have to say is Wizzard is being really suspicious to me being all contadictory in a game where contradictions are a bad thing.

Vote_Kill: Wizzard

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

That's what you said wtf...or we could be masons...we is plural, and it was obvious you were referring to yourself and niichan...so yeah I was saying exactly that...but I said that you suggested it, which overall is a bad move according to your previous post about the possibility of you being insane or not...

So yeah...my problem with you is what kkck is saying...first you say that you have a role that could be insane, but then you go and suggest how you could be mason with niichan(and that alone is a huuuge stretch), and while you are talking to kkck exactly on this topic, you tell me to go back and quote you, because you don't know where you said it?

like I said...

Sorry I misunderstood your post, I thought you're saying I said there are 2 masons and I'm saying who they are (and those two are not being me and niichan)

The reason I said we could be masons was cause I was trying to explain why I'm getting along with him so well. Please don't twist my words
There have been also several ORs that would suggest I'm not Saying something conclusive.

And now I'm pointing out why I can't be a mason, that's because I have a different role

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

All I have to say is Wizzard is being really suspicious to me being all contadictory in a game where contradictions are a bad thing.

Vote_Kill: Wizzard

Do you have other suspicions besides him?

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

All I have to say is Wizzard is being really suspicious to me being all contadictory in a game where contradictions are a bad thing.

Vote_Kill: Wizzard

And I'm asking you what's your theory on the other mafia then...

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

It is possible to not have a Mafia Godfather.

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

It is possible to not have a Mafia Godfather.

Did not know that.

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

like I said...


The reason I said we could be masons was cause I was trying to explain why I'm getting along with him so well. Please don't twist my words
There have been also several ORs that would suggest I'm not Saying something conclusive.

And now I'm pointing out why I can't be a mason, that's because I have a different role

But you didn't misunderstand my post...and I'm not twisting your words...you suggested that you might be masons I didn't say you were saying something conclusive...after you hinted that you might have another role...which overall is a bad move IMO...and you can't really point out stuff to me, without backing it up, and as I've said before, there's no such thing as proof in this game...so you pointing out something is irrelevant...either your actions or posts support your claim, or they don't...and at the moment they don't...

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Do you have other suspicions besides him?

At this moment, no. Wizzard is the only person that is sticking out to me in a bad way right now.

And I'm asking you what's your theory on the other mafia then...

Hmm Not denying my accusations of you contradicting yourself. Also, read my response above to Bene.

 

[thornofcarrion]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Just got home from vacations...read last few posts.

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

It is possible to not have a Mafia Godfather.

Who sends the victim choice to the host then?

 

[Mazino]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

how long do we have left of the day ??

 

[kkck]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

well the reason I trust niichan is 'cause he's not acting like in the #18 mafia game (e.g. suspicious) also since we played then I have a remote idea what his thoughts are and am using some of them to base my assumptions on the same.
In my dictionary a person is not mafia unless proven otherwise, since I've played mafia with niichan I kinda know what he'd be if he was a mafia and comapred to that he's not even close right now.

Also last time both Imp and niichan didn't think highly of the masons so I kidna inherited that view and don't find them very important..

Anyway as we know the mafia has a Janitor and it needs a Boss this doesn't leave any other possibilities for different roles, hereby my role can't be a mafiotinisized one.

What? You know how he thinks? From a previous game? Which you played online? anonymously? I don't buy this at all, seems way too far fetched.


Well yeah, we know what the remaining mafia roles are. There is a boss and a janitor. Given the way the two of you have acted I get the feeling you might have taken the "boss" role too seriously. You put a front, get the townies to kill each other while nichan being the janitor conspicuously fulfills his role.

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Who sends the victim choice to the host then?

In the Case of no Godfather, anyone can send in the Kill, that's they way I've played on the other site, where Godfather was deemed Overpowered in a sense.

 

[digitaldude]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Spoiler

All I have to say is Wizzard is being really suspicious to me being all contadictory in a game where contradictions are a bad thing.

Vote_Kill: Wizzard

I apologize for not showing up earlier. Weekend got the better part of me this time around. Why did a bunch of people get hostkilled though?

Anyways, seeing a few of the posts the only person I really find suspicious is wizzard so votekill wizzard.

K, since I'm seeing some support against one of my suspects I'll go and votekill benelori

aniki, who do you think the mafia will waste tonight? you or me?

I'm not talking about the post count but actually discussing theories and suspects. All I see you do is throw one-liners around and suspect this one and that one. Again no offense, everyone has his playing style~ I just would like more of an actual discussion going on and not just that "that one is suspicious", "now I suspect you", "I am mafia "



I doubt anyone will get more suspicious on this day but I guess I can still change my vote if necessary, so votekill benelori

haha hard to say, it could get any of us. Other guys are no harm at the moment so if this goes on it's either me or you

benelori 2x(wizzard, niichan)

wizzard 2x(kkck, kdowns)

No vote(thorn)

5/10 voted.

18 hours left.

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

But here's one thing I can offer you, as I hinted to my role during the previous day...Hardy is definitely not the mafia boss, if I understood my role correctly...he can still be a janitor though, so my suspicion of him is still not completely 0...

I thought some of the roles through and if I'm right, then Hardy shouldn't be the janitor either...because, assuming of course that there's only one janitor, we would've known imp's role in the game...

So in my book Hardy is 100% clear...

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Ok, since this is getting too twisted:

I did hint yesterday My role has sane/insane variations. (even though I edited out that part later or I didn't don't remember anymore)

The only reason I seem to get along with niichan: I don't think he's mafia.

my role is either Detective or Doctor (won't say which one yet)

I'm posting a lot 'cause I like the game. I haven't been contradicting myself, but I may have used some bad English that've left others with that impression. (If so please as specific questions you want to be cleared I'll assume those who don't and are still suspicious of me are either mafia or some trolly players.

 

[Mazino]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

ive got to go to training and after that im maybe not at home ...so i have to vote now Votekill_Wizzard

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

In the Case of no Godfather, anyone can send in the Kill, that's they way I've played on the other site, where Godfather was deemed Overpowered in a sense.

I see...is there the chance that the mafia is just a regular mafia? No other special skills? It would suck to have a poisoner for instance