Games MAFIA GAME 19 END!

[Nii]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Well, votekilling someone is already a form of contribution. Anyways, its not that you post too much but rather that your posts seem kinda off from my point of view. Given that, nichan seems suspicious as he seems to be working in tandem with you.

This is just how wizz is kk you probably don't know that much about him yet

and who else is there to talk to? at least wizz provides some thoughts, I don't see anything from the other guys here so who am I supposed to talk with? XD

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

This is just how wizz is kk you probably don't know that much about him yet

and who else is there to talk to? at least wizz provides some thoughts, I don't see anything from the other guys here so who am I supposed to talk with? XD

Me XD

pelase explain kkcks' behavior :d (Indeed I haven't heard much about him/her)

---------- Post added at 05:18 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:18 PM ----------

lets take turns presenting an idea and discussing it?

 

[Mazino]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

It would be so perfect if you were a prostitute ^^

---------- Post added at 04:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:41 PM ----------

well since we're almost certain about bene and that one of us is getting killed tonight, lets discuss the other people. Aside form Mazino I'm thinking Hardy, but would definitely go for in order Mazino>Hardy although I doubt I'm wrong.

Ive always been good in sensing patterns in the big picture. And Mazino matches the pattern for newbie mafia very well. Still I'm not perfect and I'd like to hear what he has to say to defend himself.

Now that's what I call a random vote,... I bet you just found the last daybreak results and voted for the 2nd one with most votes, e.g. me...


No explanation why suspicious, no nothing...
You have something against people posting much?

like u suspect me,i suspect u as much as bene and hardy,and i think u try to distract attention from u by putting other ppl in the center of attention,thats kinda dangerous,hardy acts too angelic,i dont like that attitude cuz such things can turn the other way....niichan doesnt seem suspicious and gumi well yeah same as faust for me,all talk but i think townie so one of us,from the other ones i havent seen much so i cant say much....

 

[Nii]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Me XD

pelase explain kkcks' behavior :d (Indeed I haven't heard much about him/her)

---------- Post added at 05:18 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:18 PM ----------

lets take turns presenting an idea and discussing it?

I have to say I don't know kk that well yet, despite him being quite famous on MH

you have that much ideas? I honestly don't have that much else to say and would prefer some other guys sharing their thoughts, we won't get anywhere if it's just the two of us.

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

lol I have ideas, but they have no content, (just speculating) there is a saying here 'Truth is born in an argument/discussion'
so I aways have some conversation starters, but people rarely bite/get hooked on any of them..

---------- Post added at 05:26 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:24 PM ----------

most of my ideas are from the type 'if something,...something'

casuality in other words

 

[Nii]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Well feel free to share your thoughts but for now I would like to focus on a few people and especially bene. I'm curious what he will say.

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

well My questions are like "If he is indeed mafia, who do you think his teammates are" or "If he isn't mafia, where did we go wrong"

 

[kkck]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

or we could be masons who got the chance to talk a bit more or we already played once before and know a bit how each one of us thinks.

only votekilling can't be described as contribution, but as a way to ensure your survival in the game.. the only positive side of you doing that would be if you were a townie and were voting against the mafia..


Please read the whole thread before saying my comments are 'off' or at least specify what's the 'off' part in them...

I wouldn't go as far as to say you're suspicious 'cause I already have my suspicions against 2 other participants and you're definitely not on the same level as them (yet)

So the two of you are in contact. That is good to know. Maybe you mentioned it earlier and I missed that but that is definitely something we all need to pay attention to. Of course, suggesting at this point you might be a mason is extremely convenient. The mafia mason got killed so technically masons are safe bets however from a probability point of view the actual odds of you being a mason are on the slim side. Is the number of masons fixed though? Xio is out and tatsugoi was the mafia mason... So how many masons can we get in a game of 16 people? tops 3 or maybe in the game went insane 4(game would get too easy if 25% of the members were together to begin with). So even if you were a mason it is extremely likely you would be the last one which makes it even weirder that you are working or trusting nichan.

Reading the whole thread is a bit of a pain though, I just went through posts which seemed interesting and honestly yours were quite frequently among them. I am not going to deny it could be because of the sheer numbers of posts you have however the way you act seems consistent with a few mafias in past games. You seem like the usual mafia member who gets people to vote for another townie.

 

[Mazino]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

You seem like the usual mafia member who gets people to vote for another townie.

exactly my thoughts,but still too early to vote for him though,i still need to see bene and hardy

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

There is a role Recruiting Mason, but I'm no mason (telling you from now) (at least I haven't been recruited yet (and Am hoping not to be)) (I was only giving an example why it looks as you described.)(not to mention we're the only active members who're actually discussing the game and compared to the rest we'll always look like mafia..)
I'm telling you from now I'm either a Doctor or a Detective, but wont say more.

---------- Post added at 05:38 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:37 PM ----------

exactly my thoughts,but still too early to vote for him though,i still need to see bene and hardy

Hmm you're starting to make sense finally, maybe you're not mafia after all

 

[kkck]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

There is a role Recruiting Mason, but I'm no mason (telling you from now) (at least I haven't been recruited yet (and Am hoping not to be)) (I was only giving an example why it looks as you described.)(not to mention we're the only active members who're actually discussing the game and compared to the rest we'll always look like mafia..)
I'm telling you from now I'm either a Doctor or a Detective, but wont say more.

---------- Post added at 05:38 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:37 PM ----------



Hmm you're starting to make sense finally, maybe you're not mafia after all

So why exactly did you just now suggested you were a mason and were in contact with nichan? That does not make sense at all, specially once we take in consideration the numbers. You seem extremely suspicious right now.

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Like I said I was giving an example why me and niichan might be playing mafia/talking outside here...
I was just naming possibilities.


Another exampel would be my suspicion of you dying out 'cause you're sounding more and more like a paranoid (gun owner) townie, who liek Evil last game is jumping on whomever they deem suspicious/dangerous.

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Yo o/

It seems like my activity yesterday put me in a bind today...how convenient for the mobsters...

I didn't defend anyone per se yesterday...if you look carefully at my posts, the only definite thing I said is that there are no grounds to vote for anybody...and the only suspicions I had yesterday was Tata and Hardy...so there was no such thing as throwing suspicion around...as for why was my vote random...I think I explained that well enough yesterday...there was no way someone other than Faust to be voted out and the vote got pretty locked down after Tata and Gary were hostkilled...why evil and Lala jumped for the jugular I think it's clear...well I think it's more clear in evil's case...if evil suspected that the other lover was a mafia, then he would've taken down a mafia with him, which can be a considered a worthy sacrifice...

So it was more than locked so my vote and its randomness is pretty irrelevant I think...I could've just tossed a coin, but that would've been boring...

Now it's also funny how my "throwing suspicion around" and random voting, which is basically just inquisitive gameplay in the end is questioned, but it's not questioned in wizzard's case, who posted a lot more, but with the same idea behind...that there's no info to rely on...but he was doing the same thing, but with much more fervor as our post counts can attest...

But here's one thing I can offer you, as I hinted to my role during the previous day...Hardy is definitely not the mafia boss, if I understood my role correctly...he can still be a janitor though, so my suspicion of him is still not completely 0...

However the tandem in which niichan and wizzard work is interesting as well...and we know there's at least another mason in the group, so it's not a stretch to say there are 2 and you guys are the ones...

Now if I read correctly wizzard tells us that he doesn't know if his role is insane or not? But then he suggests that you two might be masons? Doesn't that ring a bit of suspicious behaviour? Just sayin'...

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

I never suggested anyone is a mason and I explicitly said I'm not a mason myself.
Please add quotes?

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

or we could be masons who got the chance to talk a bit more or we already played once before and know a bit how each one of us thinks.

Here.

 

[kkck]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Like I said I was giving an example why me and niichan might be playing mafia/talking outside here...
I was just naming possibilities.

But it is such a bad move all around. Even if the two of you were in fact masons by saying it you would only put yourself in the eyes of the mafia. Of course, if you are not a mason then the supposed contact the two of you have is even weirder. Why would you trust each other? You were just naming possibilities? You basically retracted from what you originally said. And I bet you did it once you realized how bad a move that was. The whole thing stinks even if you were given a detective role. You seem to be working in tandem with nichan BEFORE the first night when you would hypothetically be able to use your ability. And even if you did use your ability how would you know you are not the insane or naive detective? I mean, to begin with there would be a 66% chance that you are the wrong kind of detective.

 

[wizzard]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Sorry I misunderstood your post, I thought you're saying I said there are 2 masons and I'm saying who they are (and those two are not being me and niichan)

 

[kkck]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

I never suggested anyone is a mason and I explicitly said I'm not a mason myself.
Please add quotes?

or we could be masons who got the chance to talk a bit more or we already played once before and know a bit how each one of us thinks.

only votekilling can't be described as contribution, but as a way to ensure your survival in the game.. the only positive side of you doing that would be if you were a townie and were voting against the mafia..


Please read the whole thread before saying my comments are 'off' or at least specify what's the 'off' part in them...

I wouldn't go as far as to say you're suspicious 'cause I already have my suspicions against 2 other participants and you're definitely not on the same level as them (yet)

Enough said.

 

[Mazino]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Now it's also funny how my "throwing suspicion around" and random voting, which is basically just inquisitive gameplay in the end is questioned, but it's not questioned in wizzard's case, who posted a lot more, but with the same idea behind...that there's no info to rely on...but he was doing the same thing, but with much more fervor as our post counts can attest...

it is questioned,thats why im suspicious of him,same with u...only hardy left

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Sorry I misunderstood your post, I thought you're saying I said there are 2 masons and I'm saying who they are (and those two are not being me and niichan)

That's what you said wtf...or we could be masons...we is plural, and it was obvious you were referring to yourself and niichan...so yeah I was saying exactly that...but I said that you suggested it, which overall is a bad move according to your previous post about the possibility of you being insane or not...

So yeah...my problem with you is what kkck is saying...first you say that you have a role that could be insane, but then you go and suggest how you could be mason with niichan(and that alone is a huuuge stretch), and while you are talking to kkck exactly on this topic, you tell me to go back and quote you, because you don't know where you said it?