Luffy vs Ace - who is stronger?

Who is stronger?

  • Luffy

    Votes: 14 63.6%
  • Ace

    Votes: 8 36.4%

  • Total voters
    22

lawlord

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2009
Messages
529
Reaction score
348
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
Current Luffy from Manga vs Ace, who would win or is stronger? Ace 550m Luffy 400m.

Personally I think Luffy would win without much trouble. Ace was getting manhandled by Teaches hand to hand and I think Luffy's is far stronger than BB's h2h was at the time. I think Luffy would be fast enough to dodge everything Ace used on BB. I have other reasons I'll mention later. Please leave your thoughts.
 

DutchPhoenix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
651
Reaction score
86
Gender
Hidden
Country
Netherlands
mihawk would slice them both in 2v1
 

Pigov

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2010
Messages
158
Reaction score
26
Age
40
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
I think ace was never thaaaat strong to begin with, at least not as strong as his bounty suggests. His high bounty clearly served the purpose of showing how strong logias are, early in the manga (edit: and maybe because the gouvernment knew his relation to roger). But then again, we all know that bountys arent always a measurement of power levels.
Afaik, we havent been shown a single sign of haki from ace, he wasnt even able to defeat smoker who ( i suppose ) was a lot weaker back then, compared to now.
Additionally, aces strenght does not seem to be endurance, since he was in a pretty bad shape from direct BB hits, while luffy is at least equal to ace in terms of speed, with a much higher endurance/staminia. I´d say, one elephant gun and ace would be done for.

edit: Iam not saying that BBs h2h skills are bad...certainly not. And luffys real bounty cant be judged since his 400mio are 2 years old. He´s either much stronger and more worth than 400mio... or he is now powerful enough to deserve 400 mio, since his bounty was just pushed because of his actions, not his actual strenght. And since its the main protagonist we´re talking about, we will never know how strong he really is, until the end, when he´ll be the strongest.
 
Last edited:

lawlord

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2009
Messages
529
Reaction score
348
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
mihawk would slice them both in 2v1
Not saying this might not happen but consider that Luffy was dodging Mihawk at the War. Now his speed has increased dramatically to the point where he can dodge Kuma lasers and call them slow. He has speed blitzed almost every enemy he has faced post time-skip. I think Luffy could easily avoid Mihawk but when he engages he will lose. I think Ace and Luffy vs Mihawk have a shot. 30-40% chance fighting together I'd say.

I think Zoro probably got to the point in his training where he could make Mihawk go 80% at least. Zoro probably still has a while to go but I don't think he is miles off Mihawk. Maybe he is though. Just my thoughts.

I saw a lot of people who would state Ace was stronger than Luffy without really providing reasons in some chapter discussion threads as well.
 

Sproumfch

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2013
Messages
358
Reaction score
130
Gender
Male
Country
France
My opinion about this is that in the OP world, Luffy's DF is really THE strongest.
-First, you have to be STRONG to use well this DF, because of the stretching. Without strenght, Luffy could never use his skills like Elephant Gun or Red Hawk.
-Secondly, thanks to the Gear 2, it gives you an unbelievable speed. I'd say that now, maybe only Borsalino & Ener could be faster than this.
-Third, it's ONE OF THE DF that fits the most with the power of HAKI.
All of the DF users can use Haki if they are able to. But the Gomu Gomu power oblige you to hit with your body (not like the Mera Mera for example). The hardening provided by Haki sure is usefull with a DF that oblige you to punch to win.
Also, it's possible that Defensive & Offensive Haki are the same, that would be why Luffy's fist goes on fire when he stretches it back fast enough : Haki allows Luffy's arm to burn without bunring his skin and creates heat then explosion.

Back to Ace vs Luffy now.
In term of physical strenght, Ace is maybe stronger than Luffy. They trained together for years and Ace is two years older.
But it seems that the DF he had didn't make him use this physical strenght.
So now, Luffy use Haki well and can hit the Logias.
With his speed and his power, I'm sure Ace wouldn't hit him at all and might be destroyed soon by the Elephant Gun :O

And I'd say that now Luffy and Mihwak would get a tie. Just, Luffy would have to be the fastest as he can.
 

DutchPhoenix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
651
Reaction score
86
Gender
Hidden
Country
Netherlands
Luffy and mihawk a tie? that would mean luffy would destroy shanks in his current state according to you.
 

lawlord

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2009
Messages
529
Reaction score
348
Gender
Male
Country
Australia
My opinion about this is that in the OP world, Luffy's DF is really THE strongest.
-First, you have to be STRONG to use well this DF, because of the stretching. Without strenght, Luffy could never use his skills like Elephant Gun or Red Hawk.
-Secondly, thanks to the Gear 2, it gives you an unbelievable speed. I'd say that now, maybe only Borsalino & Ener could be faster than this.
-Third, it's ONE OF THE DF that fits the most with the power of HAKI.
All of the DF users can use Haki if they are able to. But the Gomu Gomu power oblige you to hit with your body (not like the Mera Mera for example). The hardening provided by Haki sure is usefull with a DF that oblige you to punch to win.
Also, it's possible that Defensive & Offensive Haki are the same, that would be why Luffy's fist goes on fire when he stretches it back fast enough : Haki allows Luffy's arm to burn without bunring his skin and creates heat then explosion.

Back to Ace vs Luffy now.
In term of physical strenght, Ace is maybe stronger than Luffy. They trained together for years and Ace is two years older.
But it seems that the DF he had didn't make him use this physical strenght.
So now, Luffy use Haki well and can hit the Logias.
With his speed and his power, I'm sure Ace wouldn't hit him at all and might be destroyed soon by the Elephant Gun :O

And I'd say that now Luffy and Mihwak would get a tie. Just, Luffy would have to be the fastest as he can.
I agree with everything but the last part. Mihawk is still above Luffy. When we see Luffy against the Yonkou then I may reconsider. I don't think Mihawk is at Yonkou level. I don't think Mihawk can beat a serious Shanks.
 

HereNThere

Alive Ain't Always Livin'
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
8,395
Reaction score
12,211
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Okay, a couple of you are starting to get a bit ridiculous with the strength measurements here.

First, let's get this Mihawk talk out of the way. Mihawk would most likely slaughter Luffy and Zoro. They would lose. If they were strong enough to tie with him or push him to use 80% of his ability, that would mean they are nearing Yonkou levels of strength which would be a bit ridiculous at this point in time. Luffy's speed is a pretty moot point for this fight, since Observation Haki exist and we've seen plenty of people keep up with Kizaru. I'm pretty sure it's a safe bet to say Mihawk could keep up with Luffy's speed. For Zoro, it would depend on how Mihawk trained him, but I would like to assume that Mihawk didn't show Zoro his all and wanted Zoro to do his own thing so their fight would be much more interesting. Long short, Luffy and Zoro should still be quite a ways off from facing someone like Mihawk. As they are now, they probably wouldn't die, but I can't honestly say I think they'd push him to use a good portion of his ability. Mihawk is one of a few Shichibukai who could go toe to toe with a Yonkou.

Now onto Luffy vs. Ace. As it stands now, Luffy is most likely around Ace's level, but might still be a bit weaker. The biggest and only thing against Ace in this fight is his lack of Haki demonstration. It's probable that he can use Busoshoku Haki, considering the other top Commanders in WB's crew could, but we still can't say he did as he didn't show it. If Ace demonstrated Haki use, it would be a fairer match. The two are most likely equal when it comes to physical abilities. Even endurance wise. BB is quite the monster and his strength is well known, I don't think we should knock Ace for feeling the blows of a strong man like that. Especially since Ace got back up and continued fighting. Ace is a much more experienced pirate than Luffy as well. He was a New World Pirate that was one of the top commanders on a Yonkou's crew.

Ace is a pretty strong pirate. He managed to make it to the New World rather quickly, was asked to become a Shichibukai rather early(similar to Boa and Crocodile), fought Jinbe to a stand still for five days, and managed to fight and survive against WB, prompting the latter to recognize his strength and ask him to join his crew. I'm pretty sure Ace's bounty is a fair measure of his strength and ability.
 
Last edited:

Razh

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Nov 27, 2007
Messages
7,302
Reaction score
3,580
Age
41
Gender
Male
Country
Croatia
Afaik, we havent been shown a single sign of haki from ace, he wasnt even able to defeat smoker who ( i suppose ) was a lot weaker back then, compared to now.
They never really fought. Ace just held him off a little so his bro can escape. Anything else is just imagining things.

Problem is, Oda has never really shown Ace fighting properly against a strong opponent. Yeah, we heard he fought Jinbei for 5 days (if I remember correctly) and his fight with BB was just poorly made, in my opinion. Fucking Worf effect. Made it look like he was really weak, instead of showing BB's brutal strength.
Still, all of his fights were mostly off panel.

How should I say it. I think Luffy is stronger now, but I think Ace could beat him if he used his power properly. I mean without the plot-induced stupidity. There are plenty of ways in which fire can be used. And one of them is not very much unlike CC's ability to remove oxygen. Lot of unused potential with Ace's abilities. But then again, he wasn't the main character.
 

DutchPhoenix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
651
Reaction score
86
Gender
Hidden
Country
Netherlands
I agree with everything but the last part. Mihawk is still above Luffy. When we see Luffy against the Yonkou then I may reconsider. I don't think Mihawk is at Yonkou level. I don't think Mihawk can beat a serious Shanks.
shanks & mihawk = old rivals
Current = Mihawk stated by oda most powerfull swordsman in the world.
Shanks isnt stated to be the strongest swordsman in the world.

Shanks = younko pirate with a big crew
Mihawk = forever alone


About ace vs Luffy.

Luffy would win handsdown after time-skip, since ace is a corpse, like brook :D
 
Last edited:

takneeque

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2012
Messages
242
Reaction score
175
Gender
Male
Country
India
Problem is, Oda has never really shown Ace fighting properly against a strong opponent. Yeah, we heard he fought Jinbei for 5 days (if I remember correctly) and his fight with BB was just poorly made, in my opinion. Fucking Worf effect. Made it look like he was really weak, instead of showing BB's brutal strength.
Still, all of his fights were mostly off panel.

How should I say it. I think Luffy is stronger now, but I think Ace could beat him if he used his power properly. I mean without the plot-induced stupidity. There are plenty of ways in which fire can be used. And one of them is not very much unlike CC's ability to remove oxygen. Lot of unused potential with Ace's abilities. But then again, he wasn't the main character.
what's worf? anyways i agree that the fight between ace and bb was poorly shown.bb is strong(he scarred shanks without a df) so strength wise the fight would have been interesting but ace would have lost.again,bb was trying his new df and ace had no clue what to do with it.(he was losing both fronts(df wise and strength wise.)atleast that's how i would see it.
now,to the point of luffy and ace.i agree that ace would win.now that luffy is stronger,maybe he would give ace a good fight and maybe luffy's strength would be little greater than ace's pretimeskip strength,ace would still come top in a fight against luffy.(he obviously is more smarter.:)
 
Last edited:

KingOfNight

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
2,314
Reaction score
694
Gender
Male
Country
Fire Nation
Ace. Easy.
 

llaubacher

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
567
Reaction score
439
Age
31
Gender
Male
Country
Czech Republic
I will go for Luffy.

Comparing their bounties will gain me nothing, but comparing feats.

What do we know of Ace's power? He showed less of an endurance than Luffy has done so far, and he will get better (yeah, Ace is dead and can't improve..). But as it is now, Luffy's stamina is about what Ace's was. Then again, same problem. Ace was said to have all kinds of Haki, right? But was he ever shown using any? Only Haoshoku and that was not out of his will, he did not control it freely. Luffy outmatches Ace in speed, bravely. Try to set him on fire then. Also, he would dodge the fire with his Busoshoku, I assume. Not to mention that his Busoshoku would cause Ace some serious troubles. Luffy's Haki won't cover all, he will get burnt, but he will win this fight with a margin.
 

Anduren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
575
Reaction score
376
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I don't understand why some people keep claiming that Mihawk is as powerful as a Yonkou. If Mihawk was relatively equal to Shanks almost 20 years ago when they were both rising to power, then that just means Shanks at that time wasn't powerful enough to be called a Yonkou. Back in those days, Whitebeard's equal was Roger not Roger's cabin boy. Assuming that they're equal in power now would've meant the Marineford war should've been one sided seeing how the Marines had its 3 admirals and Mihawk as well as other Shichibukai and Vice Admirals on their side against Whitebeard and his fleet.

Anyways, back on topic.... I think Luffy would win against Ace with some minor effort considering his mastery of haki. The only way Ace could beats Luffy is by experience and using Luffy's sheer stupidity against him. At least, based on what was shown of Ace, up to the Marineford War and what Luffy has shown since the time skip, that's the feeling I get.
 

TheLuffySmile

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2013
Messages
886
Reaction score
336
Age
31
Gender
Male
Country
Sweden
Ace. He is an experienced NW pirate and Second Division Commander under the strongest Yonko. Luffy's Haki doesn't guarantee an insta-win like some people seem to assume. Even if Luffy has Haki, Ace is still a fire Logia and will be able to dogde/let Luffy's attacks go trough to a certain degree. And Luffy will risk getting burned with every punch.

Ace is also extremely fast at performing his various attacks, and does it almost by reflex depending on what kind of attack is thrown at him. Many of Ace's attacks also have a very large AOE (Area of effect). He could potentially trap Luffy in a sea of flame where he would be neither able to move freely nor escape.

Unfortunately Oda-Sensei really limited Ace's use of Haki, it was pretty much non-existent in his fight with BB. But since he was as stated a very high-ranked member of the Whitebeard pirates I am going to assume that he was proficient at using Haki.

If Luffy and Ace were having a duel on Banaro Island, I'll only say this, DAI ENKAI: ENTEI :ace
 
Last edited:

Keeper of Jericho

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2010
Messages
229
Reaction score
242
Age
35
Gender
Male
Country
Belgium
People seem to forget that Haki =/= instant win against a Logia. Blackbeard had the advantage that his DF allowed him to take away Ace's power. Haki doesn't do that. Meaning that, if you hit Ace with Haki, Ace will still be fire. Fire burns. Fire hurts you. Every time you land a hit, you risk getting burnt in the process. (Akainu in that way is even worse.) I'm sure Haki can protect one against fire up to some degree, but I'm not convinced Luffy's haki is at the level already where he can fully protect himself against getting burnt (his haki wasn't strong enough yet to block Hodi's teeth, so I doubt his haki is strong enough to offer complete immunity against a Logia). Hell, remember, Vergo got burnt despite his Haki by Sanji. I doubt Luffy would be any different.

Added on top of that is that the Mera Mera no Mi gives Ace a much wider variety of attacks. Yes, Luffy can use the Gomu Gomu no Mi and his haki in creative ways. But, he still has to hit his opponent physically in order to damage them. Luffy has no projectile attacks. Ace doesn't have that problem. He can pelt Luffy from afar with all kinds of fire attacks, and he is no weaker in close range either, since the Mera Mera no Mi allows him to enhance his physical attacks with the added burning effect. Sanji has demonstrated enough how effective that is against even the strongest defences. In terms of strength, I think Luffy and Ace are pretty equal. Both have incredible physical strength, in fact, Ace demonstrated this trait much earlier than Luffy did (remember how he carried Dadan).

Finally, what do you suppose Luffy can do when Ace uses something like "Dai Enkai: Entei"? Against a massive, super-bomb like that, there isn't much Luffy can do. It's not like Enel's Raigou, where his rubber immunity allowed him to distabilise the attack. Entei would burn Luffy to a crisp, simple as that, unless he managed to get away in time before Ace launches the attack. But given that Entei could have swallowed all of Banaro Island if Blackbeard's power hadn't stopped it halfway, Luffy would have to get very far away.

Haki isn't the big godmode cheatcode against Logia's some people here are making it out to be. Haki allows you to touch a logia user, nothing more. It doesn't do anything to take away the destructive power of a logia fruit like the Mera Mera no Mi. Blackbeard got lucky because he won the DF lottery and got the sole fruit that does take away DF powers. Luffy does not have this advantage against Ace.
 

DutchPhoenix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
651
Reaction score
86
Gender
Hidden
Country
Netherlands
I don't understand why some people keep claiming that Mihawk is as powerful as a Yonkou. If Mihawk was relatively equal to Shanks almost 20 years ago when they were both rising to power, then that just means Shanks at that time wasn't powerful enough to be called a Yonkou. Back in those days, Whitebeard's equal was Roger not Roger's cabin boy. Assuming that they're equal in power now would've meant the Marineford war should've been one sided seeing how the Marines had its 3 admirals and Mihawk as well as other Shichibukai and Vice Admirals on their side against Whitebeard and his fleet.
then you'd have to assume mihawk went 100% all out during the war.
check this page http://www.mangareader.net/103-2109-12/one-piece/chapter-50.html
also after the war, mihawk didnt have a single scratch on him ;)
 

Anduren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2010
Messages
575
Reaction score
376
Gender
Male
Country
United States
@DutchPhoenix
Not going to keep going off topic here :^_^.

@Keeper of Jericho
I agree with most of your points about haki not being an instant win and your reasons behind it. However, you're conveniently leaving out the fact that Luffy's ability to use haki nullifies the intangibility of Ace being made of fire. Just because he can turn into fire doesn't mean Luffy can't hit him. Naturally, Luffy will get burned for touching fire; but it won't be one way damage going to Luffy if he gets burned while smacking Ace. If Luffy loses in this way, its simply because of his own stupidity since he gets himself in trouble like that in the middle of battle often even after the timeskip.

What it comes down to is if Ace can actually use armament haki better than Luffy. I don't think Ace's ability to use armament/observation haki was shown adequately in the manga to compare with. Its just that if he can use armament haki better than Luffy then Luffy's attack will do as much damage to him as Marco and Vista did when they attacked Akainu. Otherwise, it will turn out more like Pekoms attacking Caribou. (Not saying the Luffy vs. Ace battle would turn out like that; but the effect of stronger haki user affecting logia user will be similar)
 

Deus Machina

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2013
Messages
50
Reaction score
13
Gender
Male
Country
New Zealand
Despite Ace's Logia being superior Luffy wins this fight.

Luffy has upgraded his DF into gear two and three. His G2 allows him to increase his blood supply which in turn boost his attack speed and strength. I am sure after the TS his threshold for the ability has also improved. His G3 on the other hand looses speed but it compensates by having immense damage potential.
He is can also use Haki; BH would let him land hits on Ace and KH to predict and dodge Ace's attack patterns.

Ace on the other hand only has HH and his devil fruit. He was a good hand to hand brawler and was proficient at his DF. The damage potential of all his attacks was just incredible. Every single one of his moves caused immense damage.

However, his downfall would be his lack of speed and KH. There is no way Ace could keep up with Luffy's G2. Unless he has learnt KH his best chances for winning would be to attack Luffy on the get go before he uses any of his gears.
 
Top