Shounen Naruto by Masashi Kishimoto

Rikudou King

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
11,634
Reaction score
6,367
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It doesn't work like that. It's you who has to prove he could've dealt with Obito. As far as the Manga shown, he was defeated by Hashirama. If Obito wasn't down by then, he would've lost. You have to prove otherwise.

You're just going to fall on that translation? Matters not, even that one he says he can't move. The other two also say he can't. In the first place, why does this have to be a trusted translation? Because it doesn't look that trusted to me.
And that's achieved by the present of Black Zetsu. It was both shown in the series that he was always meant to take over Obito and that Madara had it planned well before the fight had even begun. So the fact is, that even if you ignore the implication that Madara took control of Obito again, we are shown that Madara could have escaped at any time had he truly been in trouble.

No, it has the top half saying that, and as previously pointed out, the bottom one saids nothing and is the one that ended up escaping. And only trusted translators are allowed to put up chapter translations on this site, and in this case we're talking about a translator of over several hundred chapters.
 

KingOfNight

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
2,314
Reaction score
694
Gender
Male
Country
Fire Nation
And that's achieved by the present of Black Zetsu. It was both shown in the series that he was always meant to take over Obito and that Madara had it planned well before the fight had even begun. So the fact is, that even if you ignore the implication that Madara took control of Obito again, we are shown that Madara could have escaped at any time had he truly been in trouble.

No, it has the top half saying that, and as previously pointed out, the bottom one saids nothing and is the one that ended up escaping. And only trusted translators are allowed to put up chapter translations on this site, and in this case we're talking about a translator of over several hundred chapters.
And his presence being of any use is due to luck. Save it already. It was luck that Obito was defeated and wasn't killed, trying to argue against that is utmost ridiculous.

Your arguments are becoming asinine. Top half, low half, it doesn't matter. It's the exact same Zetsu. And he was pwned. And there's also Madara's words that you keep on ignoring. Comparing this translation to many others, I'm not about to trust it that much.
 
Last edited:

Rikudou King

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
11,634
Reaction score
6,367
Gender
Male
Country
United States
As repeatedly pointed out, Obito living is moot. Madara, thanks to the Rinnegan, would have made use of Obito regardless. Twice we have witness Madara controlling the living Obito thanks to it, and there's literally no reason he wouldn't be capable of the same with a dead Obito, especially given the Rinnegan's power over the dead.

It's matters quite a bit since you're trying to claim what the top half says also factors to the bottom half, despite us literally being shown that not to be the case. We have actual, literal panel proof showing him moving, leaving the scene. So to continuously try to claim that he couldn't move is just ridiculous. Two translations vs one, with one of the former done by someone who has translated plenty of Naruto chapters. The only reason you don't want to trust it is because it disproves your argument. So I'm not the one ignoring Madara's words, or what we were actually shown.
 

Jammin

Androssi Worshiper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Mar 16, 2006
Messages
16,849
Reaction score
23,519
Age
43
Gender
Male
Country
United States
So, one of my worst fears was realized this morning. I read an article on a Kishimimoto designed mecha-Naruto...

​

I find that absolutely terrifying. Your thoughts?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Rarhyx

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2009
Messages
1,208
Reaction score
333
Gender
Male
Country
Winterfell
It's just for one game, so what?
what fears exactly?
 

Jammin

Androssi Worshiper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Mar 16, 2006
Messages
16,849
Reaction score
23,519
Age
43
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It's just for one game, so what?
what fears exactly?
The fact that Kishi's mind even went there, sends chills down my spine. That's his concept drawing. An idea so awful that it eclipses anything filler-Naruto ever did, but his brain is the place it came from this time.

Just thinking about that...
 

Rikudou King

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
11,634
Reaction score
6,367
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I find that absolutely terrifying. Your thoughts?
I find it hilarious. It has become more and more clear that Kishi has grown tired of the "stealthy ninja" manga and desires to do something far more flashy. Giant mechas are right up his alley. Totally expect that he has a couple more already designed.
 

REN KOUEN

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 20, 2012
Messages
5,480
Reaction score
1,292
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Lmao at mecha naruto

:lmao
 

BurnSchulz

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2009
Messages
942
Reaction score
581
Age
40
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
So, one of my worst fears was realized this morning. I read an article on Kishimimoto a designed mecha-Naruto...

​

I find that absolutely terrifying. Your thoughts?
I think this design fits into all the Naruto games.
*coug*sucks*cough*
 
Last edited by a moderator:

REN KOUEN

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 20, 2012
Messages
5,480
Reaction score
1,292
Gender
Male
Country
United States
this is a parody of the "what does the fox say" song with naruto cosplay

:lmao
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Googlez_kun

MH's Best Artist
九千以上だ! / Kyuusen Ijou Da! / It's Over 9000!
Joined
Oct 22, 2008
Messages
9,744
Reaction score
8,510
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
I kinda like it. It's so trashy, it amuses me. Especially the trailer.
 

Rikudou King

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
11,634
Reaction score
6,367
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Because he was down on his knees. Allowing such a thing to happen solely relying on Zetsu's intervention would've been immensely risky. And the guy made a gigantic deal about facing Hashirama. These things in conjunction with the position he found himself in would suggest that he had lost, again. Is there any reason to believe that after making such a big deal for so long that he'd just allow himself to be trapped like that.
Down on his knees without a care, which is the key issue. You mention what a big deal he made about fighting Hashirama, yet seemingly see no problem in him not showing any kind of reaction to "defeat"? Really? What about Madara's personality that we have seen would support the belief that he would willingly accept being defeated and not make any kind of fuss or attempt at escape? And Madara's entire plan has been one big risk. Having Black Zetsu there as back-up help is by far the least risky part of his planning.

He obviously wasn't too much. And he had the backing of Minato and Tobirama, and the others showed up as soon as they were needed. Monumental because he's doing it to nine bijuus, whereas Kushina with her exceptional ability did it with one that was pretty much hers already. And if you refer to the chapters, you'd see that they were exhausted, even Tsunade isn't an endless battery. And Perfect Susanoo and regular Susanoo are fundamentally the same, except one's a lot bigger.

As for Hashirama, see above. And he didn't take on a good portion of the alliance with just his Sharingan, he took on about a division, of which there are quite a few. Let's not overstate it.
The other didn't show up until after Naruto and Sasuke had been knocked down a few times. Unless you can show that Kushina would have had issue with multiple Bijuus, it's not that monumental, especially since Obito basically did the same thing with nearly just as many. And as said, they weren't any worst off then they had been. It is hardly as if they suddenly ended up exhausted after being perfectly fine. Onoki began the fight basically that way. The versions of Susanoo have all shown different defensive properties. Just look at the difference between Sasuke's Skeletal version and Complete version.

The Alliance army was made up of five main divisions, meaning Madara took on one-fifth of their total forces with just his Sharingan. That's what I would call a good portion.
 

Impossibility

MH Senpai
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 5, 2012
Messages
4,545
Reaction score
1,195
Gender
Male
Country
Bahamas
Down on his knees without a care, which is the key issue. You mention what a big deal he made about fighting Hashirama, yet seemingly see no problem in him not showing any kind of reaction to "defeat"? Really? What about Madara's personality that we have seen would support the belief that he would willingly accept being defeated and not make any kind of fuss or attempt at escape? And Madara's entire plan has been one big risk. Having Black Zetsu there as back-up help is by far the least risky part of his planning.
The manga shows him defeated. I don't know what else to say. You're suggesting I'm saying something unusual. But for you to argue as such against something that's been shown, you've got to provide more than this. It simply doesn't make sense for Madara to simply allow Hashirama to bring him down. It would be a great increase in risk without any benefit, whatsoever.

The other didn't show up until after Naruto and Sasuke had been knocked down a few times. Unless you can show that Kushina would have had issue with multiple Bijuus, it's not that monumental, especially since Obito basically did the same thing with nearly just as many. And as said, they weren't any worst off then they had been. It is hardly as if they suddenly ended up exhausted after being perfectly fine. Onoki began the fight basically that way. The versions of Susanoo have all shown different defensive properties. Just look at the difference between Sasuke's Skeletal version and Complete version.

The Alliance army was made up of five main divisions, meaning Madara took on one-fifth of their total forces with just his Sharingan. That's what I would call a good portion.
It required immense effort on Kushina's part. And Obito struggled to do so much with six that were already under his control. This isn't a stretch here. In fact, it's pretty obvious. As for Susanoo, they're just bigger, and thus thicker. That's it. Susanno doesn't change, it remains Susanoo.

And the numbers we saw him take on don't amount to even close to 1/5th of their total forces.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,007
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
I find it hilarious. It has become more and more clear that Kishi has grown tired of the "stealthy ninja" manga and desires to do something far more flashy. Giant mechas are right up his alley. Totally expect that he has a couple more already designed.
Because the current fights with Bijuus and Susano'os are totally different from mechas.
 

Rikudou King

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
11,634
Reaction score
6,367
Gender
Male
Country
United States
The manga shows him defeated. I don't know what else to say. You're suggesting I'm saying something unusual. But for you to argue as such against something that's been shown, you've got to provide more than this. It simply doesn't make sense for Madara to simply allow Hashirama to bring him down. It would be a great increase in risk without any benefit, whatsoever.
No, the manga showed him being held. Like I pointed out at that time, we have seen a bunch of times a character being held without it resulting in a defeat, like the case of Naruto being held by Hungry Path. In that situation too we saw the one being held not saying anything, but merely thinking before they sprung their counter-trick. Naruto even did the same (.....) thought as Madara.

What you're suggesting is unusual. You're trying to say that the egotistic and megalomaniac Madara would just accept defeat like nothing, with is contrary to not only his personality, but past portrayals too. If he was such a gracious loser, he wouldn't have ran off after not becoming Hokage and came back trying to destroy everything. Anyway, I'm not arguing against what was shown, which is the entire point. In addition to it being shown that Madara wasn't panic or worried about his predicament, it was also shown that he had previously called Black Zetsu to be on hand for the very reason of taking over Obito and it was implied that he had once again taken control of Obito to preform the Rinne Tensei. That's not even pointing out that the way he was being held didn't prevent fighting back as we had seen before. And there wasn't any risk to being brought down by Hashirama as we were shown. Hashirama was incapable of doing anything to Madara, and required outside assistance which still didn't fully help. There would have been more risk attempting to take down Obito, who could have actually killed Madara permanently. At the very worst case, Madara had Black Zetsu on hand to rescue him if he had actually posed a threat.

It required immense effort on Kushina's part. And Obito struggled to do so much with six that were already under his control. This isn't a stretch here. In fact, it's pretty obvious. As for Susanoo, they're just bigger, and thus thicker. That's it. Susanno doesn't change, it remains Susanoo.

And the numbers we saw him take on don't amount to even close to 1/5th of their total forces.
She was near death and did it without missing a blink. Even when just some chakra, she was capable of chaining the Kyuubi without issue. And when did Obito struggle pulling them in? And Susanoo does change, we have literally seen it gain new abilities as it advances.

He took on, as of canon, Gaara's whole division, which was a fifth of the main force.
 

Impossibility

MH Senpai
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 5, 2012
Messages
4,545
Reaction score
1,195
Gender
Male
Country
Bahamas
No, the manga showed him being held. Like I pointed out at that time, we have seen a bunch of times a character being held without it resulting in a defeat, like the case of Naruto being held by Hungry Path. In that situation too we saw the one being held not saying anything, but merely thinking before they sprung their counter-trick. Naruto even did the same (.....) thought as Madara.
Being held, being defeated, this seems like semantics, at this point. He was unable to overcome Hashirama, and Hashirama was able to contain him, and that only changed with outside influence.

What you're suggesting is unusual. You're trying to say that the egotistic and megalomaniac Madara would just accept defeat like nothing, with is contrary to not only his personality, but past portrayals too. If he was such a gracious loser, he wouldn't have ran off after not becoming Hokage and came back trying to destroy everything. Anyway, I'm not arguing against what was shown, which is the entire point. In addition to it being shown that Madara wasn't panic or worried about his predicament, it was also shown that he had previously called Black Zetsu to be on hand for the very reason of taking over Obito and it was implied that he had once again taken control of Obito to preform the Rinne Tensei. That's not even pointing out that the way he was being held didn't prevent fighting back as we had seen before. And there wasn't any risk to being brought down by Hashirama as we were shown. Hashirama was incapable of doing anything to Madara, and required outside assistance which still didn't fully help. There would have been more risk attempting to take down Obito, who could have actually killed Madara permanently. At the very worst case, Madara had Black Zetsu on hand to rescue him if he had actually posed a threat.
Yes, I'm pointing out his personality. Your description of his personality would suggest that he wouldn't allow himself to be put into that situation unless it was beyond his control. I don't think he was a gracious loser, I think he simply was forced to respond as he did because there wasn't a practical alternative. If he didn't act as he did, he'd be finished.

She was near death and did it without missing a blink. Even when just some chakra, she was capable of chaining the Kyuubi without issue. And when did Obito struggle pulling them in? And Susanoo does change, we have literally seen it gain new abilities as it advances.

He took on, as of canon, Gaara's whole division, which was a fifth of the main force.
She stuggled to do it, and even so she didn't manage to contain him entirely. And she's supposed to be uniquely qualified for the task. Obito struggled to keep a hold on six of the bijuus. And what new abilities has Susanoo gained when it gets bigger, or advances as you put it?

And what is canon is him taking on what appeared to be a few hundred compared to the tens of thousands that make up the forces.
 

Rikudou King

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 6, 2009
Messages
11,634
Reaction score
6,367
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Being held, being defeated, this seems like semantics, at this point. He was unable to overcome Hashirama, and Hashirama was able to contain him, and that only changed with outside influence.
They are quite different. Being held is not being defeated, as I already pointed out. I even gave an example showing that, Hungry Path holding Naruto. Another example would be when Sasuke was being held by Naruto and Sai, or when Kabuto was being held by Yamato. The fact is that holding someone has never meant defeat. And the presumption that he couldn't overcome Hashirama doesn't work without any evidence to back it up. Defeating Madara is no simple feat, as their history has shown.

Yes, I'm pointing out his personality. Your description of his personality would suggest that he wouldn't allow himself to be put into that situation unless it was beyond his control. I don't think he was a gracious loser, I think he simply was forced to respond as he did because there wasn't a practical alternative. If he didn't act as he did, he'd be finished.
Um, not really. We have seen Madara feint several times: he feinted not having a Sharingan when he was a child, feinted not being able to move when trying to see how devoted Hashirama was, feinted accepting the lost of the Hokage title, and feinted being dead for several decades. Madara's whole history is full of pretending one way when he intends another. And as pointed out, there was a practical alternative already in play: Black Zetsu. He had an ace up his sleeve to help him if he had truly needed help. There wasn't any need for him to wait there if he didn't want to do that. And how would he have been finished? Hashirama was in capable of hurting him. None but Obito really had the means to hurt him. he had more to gain letting the Alliance deal with Obito and take all the risk then doing it himself.

She stuggled to do it, and even so she didn't manage to contain him entirely. And she's supposed to be uniquely qualified for the task. Obito struggled to keep a hold on six of the bijuus. And what new abilities has Susanoo gained when it gets bigger, or advances as you put it?

And what is canon is him taking on what appeared to be a few hundred compared to the tens of thousands that make up the forces.
When did she struggle with it? You're gonna have to link that, because I don't recall her having any issues. Half dead and almost drained she was still capable of detaining the whole Kyuubi without effort. Even when she was a mere shadow of herself, she had no problem keeping the Kyuubi down so she could talk with Naruto. Are you talking about when she started coughing when it got shrunk? And when did Obito struggle? Obito had no problem pulling the six Bijuus back into the statue. Madara's Susanoo has granted him new techniques and Sasuke's Susanoo has gained the ability of his Enton.

Um, the total number of the Alliance is 80,000, meaning a division of it would only been 16,000 at most. So there wouldn't have been "tens of thousands"...
 

Impossibility

MH Senpai
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 5, 2012
Messages
4,545
Reaction score
1,195
Gender
Male
Country
Bahamas
They are quite different. Being held is not being defeated, as I already pointed out. I even gave an example showing that, Hungry Path holding Naruto. Another example would be when Sasuke was being held by Naruto and Sai, or when Kabuto was being held by Yamato. The fact is that holding someone has never meant defeat. And the presumption that he couldn't overcome Hashirama doesn't work without any evidence to back it up. Defeating Madara is no simple feat, as their history has shown.
For all intents and purposes Madara was defeated. I'm not debating semantics. The entire reason this was brought up was to point out that moments before Hashirama could still outmatch Madara. And the evidence that he couldn't bring down Hashirama is the fact that he was on his knees, trapped, and Hashirama was the one that put him there. Defeating Madara is no simple feat, but Hashirama has done it on multiple occasions, I don't see why this was any different.

Um, not really. We have seen Madara feint several times: he feinted not having a Sharingan when he was a child, feinted not being able to move when trying to see how devoted Hashirama was, feinted accepting the lost of the Hokage title, and feinted being dead for several decades. Madara's whole history is full of pretending one way when he intends another. And as pointed out, there was a practical alternative already in play: Black Zetsu. He had an ace up his sleeve to help him if he had truly needed help. There wasn't any need for him to wait there if he didn't want to do that. And how would he have been finished? Hashirama was in capable of hurting him. None but Obito really had the means to hurt him. he had more to gain letting the Alliance deal with Obito and take all the risk then doing it himself.
What do any of those things have to do with his battle against Hashirama? I wonder if you realise that most of those 'feints' as you put them came at the tail end of some sort of defeat, and when he couldn't do much about it. His ace presumed a lot. And if he could defeat Hashirama without it, he would've. And I've little clue where this argument about Obito being the only one able to hurt him comes from.

When did she struggle with it? You're gonna have to link that, because I don't recall her having any issues. Half dead and almost drained she was still capable of detaining the whole Kyuubi without effort. Even when she was a mere shadow of herself, she had no problem keeping the Kyuubi down so she could talk with Naruto. Are you talking about when she started coughing when it got shrunk? And when did Obito struggle? Obito had no problem pulling the six Bijuus back into the statue. Madara's Susanoo has granted him new techniques and Sasuke's Susanoo has gained the ability of his Enton.
It was pretty obvious through the chapter, the fact that the Kyuubi was even able to break loose and attack should make it clear that her hold wasn't certain. As for Obito, I was referring to his difficulty in keeping control of the bijuu, for example when Kokuo tried to attack Obito. What you're showing is Tobi taking in six bijuus that are already under his control through the rods and their revived jins. As for Susanoo, what new techniques has Madara's Susanoo granted him? And Sasuke's Enton has nothing to do with an advancement in Susanoo. It's one of his MS abilities. I know you know better than that.

Um, the total number of the Alliance is 80,000, meaning a division of it would only been 16,000 at most. So there wouldn't have been "tens of thousands"...
And I'm sure if you'd though about it for a second you would've realised that I was referencing the entirety of the allied forces when I mentioned tens of thousands, I didn't say 80,000 because by the time Madara popped up I'm certain a lot of them were already out of action. The mere fact that you tried to deflect on that rather than the fact that we only saw Madara take on a few hundred shinobi says enough.
 

Roman

Banned
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
May 29, 2011
Messages
4,052
Reaction score
1,048
Age
37
Gender
Male
Country
Croatia
Being held, being defeated, this seems like semantics, at this point. He was unable to overcome Hashirama, and Hashirama was able to contain him, and that only changed with outside influence.
It's not semantics if Madara defied the meaning of words contained, restrained and immobilized. How did he defy it? By being able to make a seal. If he could make a seal, he could "escape" it or simply just move. Even without the actual evidence I just pointed out, he was also depicted as confident and waiting for Obito in that situation, which was also proved by the manga at a later time.

If someone believes that Hashirama actually took Madara down this time, they're simply ignoring manga evidence and facts. There's no denying it.
 
Top