Games Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - END GAME

[Xadyu]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Shut up Kat.

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Lol... It was a joke because I "insulted" him in the discussion thread pre-game, so we both decided to vote on each other pre-game... Call it a random vote. I was going to change but I went out unexpectedly early and had no way to keep up to date in the thread.

Excuse me I'm pretty hangover and have 17 pages to read. But first I must make some food and coffee before my body dies.

that reminds me ... Im having a little partey at my place tonight so I dunno how much I will post then.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

what do you think about this night ?

As a sum up:
*If there is a Sickly Townie, Prostitute blocked him. Doctors cannot block poison action. Then Mafia kill failed because they targeted a Doctor-protected player.
*If there isn't a Sickly Townie, we can't be sure of which of the two happened. Chances of blocking Mafia's killer as Prostitute and protecting Mafia's target as Doctor are more or less equal. Not much to ponder on.
Assuming a third party scenario:
*If there was a Mentor with a Mentee initially, there is no way to rule it out. As unlikely as it is, "No Sickly Townie" scenario allows two kills to be prevented at one night. That said, I see it as a low percentage probability. If there is a Sickly Townie, that means Mentor just recruited this night.
*There is almost no way to get any info on Lovers. Skipping for now.

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

I understood some of that.

---------- Post added at 11:14 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:14 AM ----------

Also as dumb as it sounds maybe they target the hider?

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Also as dumb as it sounds maybe they target the hider?

haha that would be pretty stupid, no ?

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

haha that would be pretty stupid, no ?

Yeah it would.......unless gnut is lying about being hider.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Oh, right. On that note, by role definition, whoever Mentor possibly tried to recruit wasn't a Mafia member and he was successfully recruited, since no one died.
Going by numbers, probabilities would rank as:
Mentor getting blocked by Prostitute himself < Mentor recruiting a Mafia member and killing him < Mentor recruiting successfully. Second one already did not happen. So, the more likely scenario is the successful recruit, provided a Mentor exists.

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Yeah it would.......unless gnut is lying about being hider.

well we only can know if he is lying when he says the person whom he hid behind and IF there is spy he should know if he is lying or not

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

I think that when mentor recruits a mafia he only kills him on the second night. Not sure though.

---------- Post added at 11:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:19 AM ----------

well we only can know if he is lying when he says the person whom he hid behind and IF there is spy he should know if he is lying or not

Yeah but if he is a mafia then he just says who he targeted at night and spy confirms it...

Murphys law.

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Oh, right. On that note, by role definition, whoever Mentor possibly tried to recruit wasn't a Mafia member and he was successfully recruited, since no one died.
Going by numbers, probabilities would rank as:
Mentor getting blocked by Prostitute himself < Mentor recruiting a Mafia member and killing him < Mentor recruiting successfully. Second one already did not happen. So, the more likely scenario is the successful recruit, provided a Mentor exists.

But it could be that mentor was blocked and mafia targeted a doctor-protected person :/ too many possibilities

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Yeah it would.......unless gnut is lying about being hider.

Even if he is lying about his role, Mafia knows if gnut is not one of themselves. They wouldn't take a risk this way, when there are a ton of options to go for.

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Yeah but if he is a mafia then he just says who he targeted at night and spy confirms it...

Murphys law.

Then we would need doctors and prostitue results which would be too much for just knowing if gnut is lying or not right ?

 

[Hakuteiken]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Going by numbers, probabilities would rank as:
Mentor getting blocked by Prostitute himself < Mentor recruiting a Mafia member and killing him < Mentor recruiting successfully.

But it could be that mentor was blocked and mafia targeted a doctor-protected person :/ too many possibilities

^ Yeah, hence the bold part.
This might only happen at a "No Sickly Townie" scenario, unless there is a Sickly Townie, there is a Healthy Townie and the former targeted the latter.

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Then we would need doctors and prostitue results which would be too much for just knowing if gnut is lying or not right ?

Yeah too many roles exposed. gnut is one step ahead of us it seems.

 

[gnut]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Yeah it would.......unless gnut is lying about being hider.

i'm not lying....
i read 25pgs yesterday after work and could not post.....
i still feel xi0 is suspect....he did everything to make you guys think i'm of no use...claimed i could be lying or a plan would be fruitless
then,he let niichan die with out trying to say anything but...oh he may be lying too
he had like 60 post on 1st day...i know it was a long phase....but how often we see xi0 post that much....he is mafia
like falla said bout imp influencing the game...i think xi0 is doing this

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

Who did you hide behind?

 

[gnut]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

well we only can know if he is lying when he says the person whom he hid behind and IF there is spy he should know if he is lying or not

spectrum

 

[Kat]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

^ Yeah, hence the bold part.
This might only happen at a "No Sickly Townie" scenario, unless there is a Sickly Townie, there is a Healthy Townie and the former targeted the latter.

well then if there is a sickly townie he should tell us I guess so we would be closer to the result or is it stupid to reveal his role this early?

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

well then if there is a sickly townie he should tell us I guess so we would be closer to the result or is it stupid to reveal his role this early?

Nah Sickly townie is getting old as a role, evil doesn't like it much wouldn't be surprised if it's not in this game.

 

[gnut]

Re: Mafia Game 34 : Mangahelpers Theme - Day 2

i have to shower for work...brb