Discussion Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread v.9

[Spectrum]

No one enjoyed because of the spam, that's the reason why we're trying to limit the posts per day, you're the only one against it. I can't see why you're so against it, we could have a better game with that rule.

 

[Faust]

But with this incentive to post less spam - plus shorter day phases, I actually see this being a less spamy game. So give it a shot!

How many hours per day phase this upcoming game? If it's less than 12 Hours it would be troublesome especially in my timezone.

@Spam Post Overload in Mafia Game.
Player Limit per game rather than Post Limit would be a more effective solution IMO.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Honestly, if the influence is what worries you about it, meh. It was more of an aberration, not a routine.
I believe the Town has to play in a way that doesn't force a person to make 250 posts to defend himself, anyway.

And what's personal about it, lol. All games I've played in have been spammy and I have mostly been amongst top posters. If you will feel better, let us call it Haku rule, instead of Hardy rule, so that I don't spam that much.

 

[Evil3ye]

A lot of your posts were game unrelated. For instance, when you were discussing how unfair a combination of Doc-Bodyguard would have been, etc. That had nothing to do with the game. And there were a lot of such things, which you could have either saved for after the game or discuss in an other thread. You have to lern to distinguish of important material and game unrelated spam. If you don't get this, then accept at least criticism.

---------- Post added at 05:41 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:41 PM ----------

How many hours per day phase this upcoming game? If it's less than 12 Hours it would be troublesome especially in my timezone.

@Spam Post Overload in Mafia Game.
Player Limit per game rather than Post Limit would be a more effective solution IMO.

18h for days, 12h nights.

Player limit sounds stupid to me though.

 

[Hardy]

A lot of your posts were game unrelated. For instance, when you were discussing how unfair a combination of Doc-Bodyguard would have been, etc. That had nothing to do with the game. And there were a lot of such things, which you could have either saved for after the game or discuss in an other thread. You have to lern to distinguish of important material and game unrelated spam. If you don't get this, then accept at least criticism.

I accept it, that's why I'm out ^^

The Doc-Bodyguard discussion got deleted anyway, didn't it? And in any case it was somehow game relevant, as it was a play that could give us 2 invincible townies, but I get what you're saying.

@Spam Post Overload in Mafia Game.
Player Limit per game rather than Post Limit would be a more effective solution IMO.

We were like 18 in the last game, no biggie.

 

[Evil3ye]

Such a drama queen lol.

GAME 35
Starting sunday, 26-Jan.

01. [user]3c[/user]
02. Hardy
03. [user]Josef K.[/user]
04. [user]Xadyu[/user]
05. [user]Mazino[/user]
06. [user]BBB Banana[/user]
07. [user]Kat[/user]
08. [user]Farfalla[/user]
09. [user]digitaldude[/user]
10. [user]wizzard[/user]
11. [user]MidoBan[/user]
12. [user]Imperium[/user]
13. [user]FaustXIII[/user]
14. [user]Spectrum[/user]
15. [user]naruto-niichan[/user]
16. [user]gnut[/user]
17. [user]Hakuteiken[/user]
18. [user]Organizized[/user] (maybe)

Sign up.

 

[Imperium]

So shall we try the post restriction thing this time? Whaddaya think?

Ooooh, so my idea gets shot down, and then repacked again. Hmph.


I'm totally against post restrictions.

 

[digitaldude]

So shall we try the post restriction thing this time? Whaddaya think?

Taking our freedom piece by piece, DICTATOR!

 

[Faust]

18h for days, 12h nights.

Fair enough.

Player limit sounds stupid to me though.

31-40 Player Game with no hostkills (all players are active) would be hell.

30 as the Maximum Player Limit per game would be good IMO.

Anyway, How about 2 Games simultaneously played at the same time?
Rather than a single game with 30 Players. Two Games with 15 Players each!
Two Games with Different Hosts, Different Players, and Different Themes played at the same time!
I would like to see that!

It would be a good way to test and study the mafia game and improve it by comparing the two games at the end.
Why did Game 36 ended faster than Game 35?
Why did Game 35 have more posts than Game 36? etc. etc.

 

[Imperium]

I feel like Tesla. Robbed.

 

[Hardy]

Going to a second mountaing training, sensei will be mad!

30 as the Maximum Player Limit per game would be good IMO.

We never had anything like that though, and if we did it would be a nice or at least new experience, lol.

Anyway, How about 2 Games simultaneously played at the same time?
Rather than a single game with 30 Players. Two Games with 15 Players each!
Two Games with Different Hosts, Different Players, and Different Themes played at the same time!
I would like to see that!

It would be a good way to test and study the mafia game and improve it by comparing the two games at the end.
Why did Game 36 ended faster than Game 35?
Why did Game 35 have more posts than Game 36? etc. etc.

What are we, lab rats now?

 

[Evil3ye]

Fair enough.



31-40 Player Game with no hostkills (all players are active) would be hell.

30 as the Maximum Player Limit per game would be good IMO.

Anyway, How about 2 Games simultaneously played at the same time?
Rather than a single game with 30 Players. Two Games with 15 Players each!
Two Games with Different Hosts, Different Players, and Different Themes played at the same time!
I would like to see that!

It would be a good way to test and study the mafia game and improve it by comparing the two games at the end.
Why did Game 36 ended faster than Game 35?
Why did Game 35 have more posts than Game 36? etc. etc.

Not enough interested parties for that here. On other forums might work, here we're a small squad with few dozens frequent players. I seen +50 games on NF though, I think they solved it by putting in lot of roles with killing abilities and after two days of random votes and spam the real game begun with half of the players.

 

[Nii]

I won't be keeping up with spam Hardy or whoever talks a lot as much as I did in the last game, but still in. Will be playing the lurker role.

lol 3rd party confirmed

 

[Hakuteiken]

I accept it, that's why I'm out ^^

That's not how you "accept" criticism, but okay.

lol 3rd party confirmed

I have already discussed my ideal game scenario with you, onii-san

 

[Nii]

I accept it, that's why I'm out ^^

I have already discussed my ideal game scenario with you, onii-san

Well it's definitely going to be a memorable game if that happens

 

[Josef]

wtf you got a hard on for him or something?

To be almost the same as the previous game.

 

[Evil3ye]

Pls review.

MH Specific Game Rules​

ACTIVITY RULES

• Be active in every day phase and post at least three times. If you don't do that, you will be hostkilled and banned from future games (Hall of Shame). If you are going to miss out a period of time due to real life events make sure to inform the host, who is going to judge each situation individually and decide whether or not taking the player out of the game is necessary.
  
• Place at least one vote every day phase. If you forget to place a vote you will get a Penality Vote on the next day phase.
  
• Don't post more than 100 times per day phase. This is to reduce spam and the volume of posts per game. Nobody has time to go through hundreds of one liner posts with the same content over and over again (Imperium Copyright Rule). If you hit the volume restriction, you will get a Penality Vote per 10 additional posts you make.
  
• Dead people can't talk. So don't post once your character is dead; do not help others once you are dead. You can however, lurk the thread. If you post regardlessly, you will be banned from future games (Hall of Shame).

OUTER THREAD RULES

• Absolutely DO NOT discuss the game outside of the game thread (unless you are Mafia members discussing it with other mafia through pms/piratepad). This is so that people do not reveal their roles and ruin the game. Players violating this rule will be instantly hostkilled and banned from future games (Hall of Shame).
  
• Do not directly comment on the current game, once you are dead. This is so you don't influence the players that are still playing. Violator of this rule will be banned from future games (Hall of Shame).

OTHER GAME RULES

• You are not allowed to post any screenshots, PMs or anything similar that can reveal your role, or the role of others. If you do, you will be hostkilled and banned from future games (Hall of Shame).
  
• You are not allowed to pretend being a Daytime Vigilant, Cowboy, or other roles, that have Day Commands. If you do that regardlessly, you will get a Penality Vote.

RULE BREAKING, PUNISHMENT & HALL OF SHAME

• If you disobey the roles above that are resulting with you being host killed and/or banned from future games, you will get registered in the Hall of Shame.
  
• One violation bans you from the upcoming game.
  
• A second violation of the same kind will ban you from the next three game.
  
• A third violation and you are out from all upcoming games.
  
• No amnesty or prescription until further notice.

---------- Post added at 08:35 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:31 PM ----------

I'll also work out some 'MH specifiy host rules' before the game starts, which is supposed to clear all grey zones we have had so far, such as Tie - coin flip - no coin flip - double kill? etc. dunno. lol.

 

[Organizized]

I'll wait and see if I can play. During the weekend I have close to no time on my hands at all, really, but we'll see...

 

[Spectrum]

Evil, I'll paint my room on monday 27 so i'll be afk, i'll try to come and make some posts, but i really need to paint it lol

People, don't lynch me because of that, please

 

[wizzard]

Fair enough.



31-40 Player Game with no hostkills (all players are active) would be hell.

30 as the Maximum Player Limit per game would be good IMO.

Anyway, How about 2 Games simultaneously played at the same time?
Rather than a single game with 30 Players. Two Games with 15 Players each!
Two Games with Different Hosts, Different Players, and Different Themes played at the same time!
I would like to see that!

It would be a good way to test and study the mafia game and improve it by comparing the two games at the end.
Why did Game 36 ended faster than Game 35?
Why did Game 35 have more posts than Game 36? etc. etc.

I'd sign up for both then