Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2014] - Discussion and TOC Talk - Part 8

[Nasser]

If no one posted it... here's the OP popularity poll.

Bartolomeo!!

 

[Covers]

#4-5:

 

[Oberon]

4・5号掲载顺
ワンピ
暗杀
ヒロアカ
相扑　C
ソーマ
法廷
ワートリ
排球　C
斉木
エロ
アゲハ
トリコ
银魂　C
ニセ
亀
矶部
鰤
柔道
塩
Hi-fi
矶兵卫

6・7号　巻头C　暗杀
センターカラー　ソーマ・読切｢タイガー兄とドラゴン｣(田村隆平)

Jump #04・05 (22/12):
WSJ Cast (Cover)
One Piece (Lead Color Page, Popularity Poll Results)
Assassination Classroom
Boku no Hero Academia
Hinomaru Zumou (Color Page, 32 pg.)
Shokugeki no Souma
Gakkyuu Houtei
World Trigger
Hq!! (Color Page)
PSI Kusuo Saiki
E-Robot
Takujou no Ageha
Toriko
Gintama (Color Page)
Nisekoi
Kochikame
Isobe Isobee Monogatari
Bleach
Juudouzu
Sporting Salt
Hi-Fi Cluster
Hunter x Hunter (Absent)

#06・07:
Cover: WSJ Cast
Lead CP: Assassination Classroom
CP: Shokugeki no Souma, Tiger-ani to Dragon by Tamura Ryuuhei (One Shot)

 

[vampire killer]

World Trigger has very good position. The rank is for the last chapter of the Invasion ark. Next week will be interesting to see. PSI is still the best manga in jump btw.

Pure rank:
1.Assassination Classroom
2.Boku no Hero Academia
3.Shokugeki no Souma
4.World Trigger
5.PSI Kusuo Saiki
6.Toriko
7.Nisekoi
8.Kochikame
9.Isobe Isobee Monogatari
10.Bleach
11.Juudouzu
12.Sporting Salt
13.Hi-Fi Cluster

 

[bobop]

I hope someone will translate Tamura's one shot.

 

[vinceled]

Still no news of HxH return... I hope the hiatus won't last too long, it's been what 3-4 months now, I think?

 

[Leoat12]

The TOC was wrong after all, Gakkyu Houtei is a bit higher and I hope people are satisfied, although it is not ranked, but still...

Glad to see BnA and SnS in 2nd and 3rd places, along with Haikyuu they are the ones that deserve more the top. Of course, Assassination Classroom is not bad, but it is starting to be less interesting each chapter I read. I think the inevitable stretching in the series is starting to take its toll. Toriko already lose it is space to the "new negeration", it's clear, but it is too early to talk about cancellation and I think that it will never be cancelled anyway, it will only suffer lower positions than it was used.
Nisekoi is in 7th this time although it appears to be in the same place as last week, it always happens when there are many new unraked series in the magazine... The editors love to put them all above Nisekoi, but when they start to be ranked... Everything comes back to the normality. XD

 

[James Rye]

World Trigger has very good position. The rank is for the last chapter of the Invasion ark. Next week will be interesting to see. PSI is still the best manga in jump btw.

Pure rank:
1.Assassination Classroom
2.Boku no Hero Academia
3.Shokugeki no Souma
4.World Trigger
5.PSI Kusuo Saiki
6.Toriko
7.Nisekoi
9.Kochikame
10.Isobe Isobee Monogatari
11.Bleach
12.Juudouzu
13.Sporting Salt
14.Hi-Fi Cluster

Good to see that the final chapter of the Invasion Arc was good enough to make it to the top5 positions. I guess next chapter/week it will drop obviously, just hoping it manages to stay in the middle and stays the hell away from the bottom five.

Which reminds me, when is the next axe session where either Sporting Salt or Hi-fi Cluster or both will most likely get axed? January or february?

 

[Leoat12]

Which reminds me, when is the next axe session where either Sporting Salt or Hi-fi Cluster or both will most likely get axed? January or february?

When every series from this round reach 8 chapters, around February.

 

[kewl0210]

Feels weird seeing one of those "all the series in Jump" covers with no Naruto.

 

[James Rye]

When every series from this round reach 8 chapters, around February.

Okay, thanks. Guess Juudouzu gets to live some more time as I don't think they will axe three series at once.

Feels weird seeing one of those "all the series in Jump" covers with no Naruto.

Dunno, I for one find it refreshing.^^

 

[Leoat12]

Okay, thanks. Guess Juudouzu gets to live some more time as I don't think they will axe three series at once.



Dunno, I for one find it refreshing.^^

It can happen.

Same opinion. Actually, I only remembered Naruto because he talked. The life continues.

 

[vampire killer]

After whis cover it`s clear that jump see Toriko and One Pieceas it flagship mangas. And judoz can survive up to 50 chapter. I hope for it.

 

[Leoat12]

Haikyuu 2nd season confirmation page

[tweet]https://twitter.com/newsmangajapon2/status/545469462770503680[/tweet]

 

[SharkBait]

Cant wait for Bokuto, Tsukki, and Kuroo! best hq ot3. And Akaashi too, and animated Lev and Yaku. Best sports series since Free!/Oofuri continuing.

 

[Leoat12]

Haikyuu was always good, of course, but only after that match against Aobajousai, showed in the last episodes of the first season, that Karasuno started to train harder and look like a well structured team that could go against the best teams. Second season saves the best matches of the manga, I'm looking forward to watching them.

 

[justanotherone]

Cant wait for Bokuto, Tsukki, and Kuroo! best hq ot3. And Akaashi too, and animated Lev and Yaku. Best sports series since Free!/Oofuri continuing.

And don't forget the entrance of the best girl, Yachi Hitoka, let's not talk only about the boys

Since they adapted almost 70 chapters in the first season, to have enough material the second season needs to air in summer (spring is too soon IMO) if they are going to cover the same amount of chapters.

 

[Bigivelfhq]

And don't forget the entrance of the best girl, Yachi Hitoka, let's not talk only about the boys

Since they adapted almost 70 chapters in the first season, to have enough material the second season needs to air in summer (spring is too soon IMO) if they are going to cover the same amount of chapters.

First season adapted 71 chapters, there are already 139 chapters out, they only need 3 chapters to get 71 chapter to adapt again.
That said, I believe they will only air the 2nd season in fall season next year. To give 1 year of difference in adaptations, giving time for the animation staff to do a good job on it, and also to let chapters of a possible 3rd season pile up.

 

[Leoat12]

And don't forget the entrance of the best girl, Yachi Hitoka, let's not talk only about the boys

Since they adapted almost 70 chapters in the first season, to have enough material the second season needs to air in summer (spring is too soon IMO) if they are going to cover the same amount of chapters.

Personally, I prefer the experience and maturity that Kiyoko inspires, but Hitoka is good, too. She is learning well with her master.

I think that the second season contains part of the manga that can be stretched more easily than the first season without degrading the qaulity of the animation, it has many moments outside the court that could be detailed more and even the training. The matches are a bit hard to touch without losing the epic atmosphere.

I don't know when it is going to debut... Nisekoi 2nd season was announced before, but didn't have a date yet... Summer or Autumn, I think...

 

[Hunt]