Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Leoat12]

Shokugeki no Soma anime is near... I can't wait!

Komi Naoshi proves that mangakas do take care of their health.
頑張って、古味直志先生!

There it is... World Trigger CP is taking a little longer.

 

[SharkBait]

Ultra Battle Satellite wasnt that good. Pure battle tournament manga are pretty dull as they offer little in the way of creative storytelling. Adding to that is a battle crazed lead character, Jin, who plays dirty and we have something that is just unsuitable for the magazine. To deal even more damage it is also too violent for the magazine. It just wont be able to survive.

Though what it did right is giving us a kind hearted friendly guy like Hayakawa. If the writer can keep him along in that role then it helps to balance out the lead character and would keep me reading.

BLack Clover was the best of this group for the first three chapters. [meaning I would buy it in print]. The rest I thought werent as good, so I would read in viz jump but not buy them. None were outright bad that I would drop.

 

[conankudo]

Ultra Battle Satellite wasnt that good. Pure battle tournament manga are pretty dull as they offer little in the way of creative storytelling. Adding to that is a battle crazed lead character, Jin, who plays dirty and we have something that is just unsuitable for the magazine. To deal even more damage it is also too violent for the magazine. It just wont be able to survive.

I guess you have never read Fist of the Northstar/Hokuto no ken or Jojo

 

[SharkBait]

I guess you have never read Fist of the Northstar/Hokuto no ken or Jojo

Artstyle looked bad. Wtching JJBA. Nothing seemed that violent so far imo.

 

[susanoo13]

I would advise you to read the manga first for Jojo if you want to see violent, there were things that were ommitted in the anime which are simply unacceptable by today's standards. BDs for Jojo look great.

BTW how was Roggy's 2nd chapter? I hope this one will get translated soon as well.

 

[SharkBait]

BLack Clover's chp 3 was pretty exciting. Wished it continued as I would love to see more of Yuno in a protective guardian role for his Asta. Also the guild Asta joined looks extremely fun. Really.

Roggy was the best chp 2 of the rest of these new jump series. I like emotional chapters with family drama (though the kids character designed looked inspired from the one kid in s1 of HeroBank...)

 

[xAsum0x]

I liked Ultra Battle Sattelite. Reminds me of Baki the Grappler

 

[RafaFedKilla]

I gotta say, I enjoyed all FOUR series. Man, this is going to be tough. My two preferences would be Kagamigami and Black Clover. And then you have World atrigger fighting for survival. Wow.

 

[Teeba]

Against my better judgement I just can't seem to outright hate Roggy. It has this charm to it. The second chapter was pretty cliche but I still liked it. I wonder if the doctor girl will stick around or if she's going to be a one-off character.

Kagamigami's chapter this week was better. Miyoshi continues to make me laugh and honestly I like her way too much. I want the series to stay just for her!

UBS has an interesting art style but I'm kind of so-so about the plot. I'm not sure how the author is going to keep the premise interesting.

I'm only reading Black Clover because Yuno sounds a bit too invested in Asta but its such a train of cliches I can only read it while turning my brain off.

 

[SharkBait]

I'm only reading Black Clover because Yuno is sort of husbando material but its such a train of cliches I can only read it while turning my brain off.

Sorry but Yuno is mines, not yours.

I thoughts its real good, if I was writing a manga then it would definitely be closest to one that has all the things on my checklist that make a manga really good.

Gakkyu Hotei was really amazing this week, its the best ninja in jump since Naruto.

Also One Piece best chapter since Sabo returned, Oda writes like two spectacular chapters a year and this was one that Im dying to see animated. Zoro keeps me reading.

 

[xAsum0x]

so with the end of this round imo

UBS > Cyborg Roggy = Kagamigami > Black Clover. I hope UBS succeeds I liked it alot

 

[Eru13]

For me it's
Clover>>>>UBS>=Kagami>>>>>...>>>Roggy
I think Roggy will go the Hi-Fi Cluster route, Kagami will probably do an Illegal Rare at best, UBS might even go Takamagahara or Judos if the next chapters fail to deliver but with one chapter it's really hard to say (then again, I didn't see anything that impressive in it)
As for Black Clover, it can pretty much do three things, go the HeroAca route and make it big (I mean, sure, it's full of clichés, but many of those are also included in series like Naruto, Fairy Tail, Nanatsu no Taizai, and Shingeki no Kyojin so those clichés might work well for it), go the World Trigger route and just barely survive for years, or just flop after the initial momentum is gone in 6 months (like 80+%of the new series in jump)

 

[rio poneglyph]

2ch:

164 ：39 ◆7zq1d2q4b2Is ＠転載は禁止：2015/03/03(火) 18:24:23.98 ID:UjzldmLt015
ドベ５
w鳥
亀
鰤
age
裁判

日の丸　５
ヒロ垢　８

16
案察　表紙&巻頭　Ｃカラー　ヒロ垢　再起　読み切り(椀比代原)

---------- Post added at 03:32 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:31 AM ----------

From 39:

127 ：39 ◆7zq1d2q4b2Is ＠転載は禁止：2015/03/03(火) 18:15:04.05 ID:UjzldmLt0おっす＾＾
ＵＳＢいいな！テンポいいよー　ももっちの飛びげりかますとこの刃牙顔がもうね
今週のチャンピオンがバチバチ巻頭で刃牙との分割表紙みたいだけど、これも相撲と格闘コンビで伸びればいいな

隠語とか大袈裟に考えんでね。
そのまんま転載されることの防止だから　住人が理解出来ればいいだろ

じゃ、ちょいまち＾＾

 

[Heiji]

#15 :
Hinomaru Zumô (5)
Boku no Hero Academia (8)

World Trigger
Kochi Kame
Bleach
Takujou no Ageha
Gakkyuu Houtei

#16 :
Ansatsu Kyôshitsu (Cover & Lead Color)
Boku no Hero Academia, PSI Kusuo Saiki, Oneshot (Color)

 

[Txapeldun]

Wonder why people were saying it was bad for Gakkyu Hotei when it is still standing strong in the middle of the pack. Far better than bringing up the rear.

World Trigger
Kochi Kame
Bleach
Takujou no Ageha
Gakkyuu Houtei

Now there's no excuses. It's not "ranked 10th" like last time. It's dead-last. It seemed pretty obvious that it was going the same way Illegal Rare did, it's not healthy to delude oneself, Sharkbait. Get over it, dude. Like you did countless times before. Stealth Symphony I'll be cheering on you.

 

[Leoat12]

I was really surprised for a moment seeing Boku no Hero Academia position, but then I remembered that it's getting color page. Alright although it's still low for such famous series...

Gakkyuu Houtei deserves this position, but the last chapters started an interesting story with a new interesting rival. I hope it gets out of the bottom with this.

 

[Pietro]

Boku no hero is not ranked this week

---------- Post added at 01:27 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:26 PM ----------

I'm so happy for Zumou!!Gakkyou hyoutei is dead last
I liked new series in this way:
Black clover=UBS>>>>>kagamigami>Roggy

 

[Xzone]

So , black clover confirmed for flop because sharkbait said it is good?

 

[SharkBait]

Once again another excellent series finds itself forgotten by the masses. I highly doubt BLack Clover will find itself forgotten as well.

 

[conankudo]

#15 :


#16 :
Ansatsu Kyôshitsu (Cover & Lead Color)
Boku no Hero Academia, PSI Kusuo Saiki, Oneshot (Color)

And One Piece is on break in issue #16