Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[WyldViolet]

Here's a fun game.
What do you think Jump's lineup will look like in 4 years in order of popularity?
Here's what I'm thinking.

One Piece- Eiichiro Oda
Boku no Hero Academia- Kouhei Horikoshi
New Manga- New Mangaka
Black Clover- Yuki Tabata
New Series- Kei Monri
Haikyuu- Haruichi Furudate
New Manga- Toshinori Takayama
Kagamigami- Iwashiro Toshiaki
New Manga- New Mangaka
New Manga- Hiroshi Shiibashi
New Manga- Daijiro Nonoue
New Manga- Shibata Yousaku
New Manga- Hirakata Masahiro
Shokugeki no Soma- Tosh
New Manga- New Mangaka
Hinomaru Zumou- Kawada
*fodder series*
*fodder series*
*fodder series*
*Isobe Isobe Monogatari- Ryou Nakama

 

[Txapeldun]

Here's a fun game.
What do you think Jump's lineup will look like in 4 years in order of popularity?
Here's what I'm thinking.

One Piece- Eiichiro Oda
Boku no Hero Academia- Kouhei Horikoshi
New Manga- New Mangaka
Black Clover- Yuki Tabata
New Series- Kei Monri
Haikyuu- Haruichi Furudate
New Manga- Toshinori Takayama
Kagamigami- Iwashiro Toshiaki
New Manga- Hiroshi Shiibashi
New Manga- Daijiro Nonoue
New Manga- Shibata Yousaku
New Manga- Hirakata Masahiro
Shokugeki no Soma- Tosh
Hinomaru Zumou- Kawada
*other series*
*other series*
*other series*
*other series*
*other series*
*other series*
*Isobe Isobe Monogatari- Ryou Nakama

Hunter x Hunter - (back after two more hiatus)
Kochikame

 

[WyldViolet]

Hunter x Hunter - (back after two more hiatus)
Kochikame

I'm hoping that Kochikame's mangaka retires in the next few years to leave an extra free space in the magazine.

 

[De La Croissant]

I'm hoping that Kochikame's mangaka retires in the next few years to leave an extra free space in the magazine.

Then, One Piece will be the new Kochikame.

 

[G_I_A]

I'm hoping that Kochikame's mangaka retires in the next few years to leave an extra free space in the magazine.

We will all die before Kochikame finishes. Even if the author is gone they will have somebody else to keep drawing.

 

[Ecchi Boy]

One Piece- Eiichiro Oda
Boku no Hero Academia- Kouhei Horikoshi
New Manga- New Mangaka
Black Clover- Yuki Tabata
New Series- Kei Monri
Haikyuu- Haruichi Furudate
New Manga- Toshinori Takayama
Kagamigami- Iwashiro Toshiaki
New Manga- New Mangaka
New Manga- Atsushi Nakayama
New Manga- Tatsuya Endou
New Manga- Mitsuki Nagata
New Manga- Ishiyama Ryou
Shokugeki no Soma- Tosh
New Manga- New Mangaka
Hinomaru Zumou- Kawada
Hunter x Hunter- Togashi
*fodder series*
*fodder series*
*Isobe Isobe Monogatari- Ryou Nakama

 

[Txapeldun]

We will all die before Kochikame finishes. Even if the author is gone they will have somebody else to keep drawing.

I don't think so. Jump series are very personal. It's like those people who think that HxH should (and will) be drawn by someone else in the future. But it will never happen. When Akimoto retires, Kochikame will end.

 

[Xzone]

I think meaningless discuss here about the success of Black Clover, he still had only two ranked chapters. All of us here have seen mangas that started extremely well and fell over time, as well as mangas that started badly and went up to the top. So, if Black Clover will be a huge success or not will depend on their future positions and sales, end of story. We need to have a little of patience.

/Thread

Here's a fun game.
What do you think Jump's lineup will look like in 4 years in order of popularity?
Here's what I'm thinking.

One Piece- Eiichiro Oda
Boku no Hero Academia- Kouhei Horikoshi
New Manga- New Mangaka
Black Clover- Yuki Tabata
New Series- Kei Monri
Haikyuu- Haruichi Furudate
New Manga- Toshinori Takayama
Kagamigami- Iwashiro Toshiaki
New Manga- New Mangaka
New Manga- Hiroshi Shiibashi
New Manga- Daijiro Nonoue
New Manga- Shibata Yousaku
New Manga- Hirakata Masahiro
Shokugeki no Soma- Tosh
New Manga- New Mangaka
Hinomaru Zumou- Kawada
*fodder series*
*fodder series*
*fodder series*
*Isobe Isobe Monogatari- Ryou Nakama

One Piece- Eiichiro Oda
Boku no Hero Academia- Kouhei Horikoshi
New Manga- Yūdai Kimura
Haikyuu- Haruichi Furudate
New Series- Kei Monri
New Manga- Shibata Yousaku (Probably with Enma Gavel )
Shokugeki no Soma- Tosh
Golf manga- Tadatoshi Fujimaki
New manga- Ryūhei Tamura
New manga- Naoki Iwamoto
New manga - Tadahiro Miura

Maybe:
Hinomaru Zumou- Kawada
Kagamigami- Iwashiro Toshiaki
Black Clover- Yuki Tabata
New manga-Ashihara Daisuke
New manga- ikezawa haruto

 

[Leoat12]

It's just their choice of wording, there's isn't a genre I know of called "true fantasy"

Bad choice of word. It was exactly what I said in my first post of the discussion, it doesn't exist.

 

[WyldViolet]

We will all die before Kochikame finishes. Even if the author is gone they will have somebody else to keep drawing.

No they won't.

 

[susanoo13]

One Piece- Eiichiro Oda
Boku no Hero Academia- Kouhei Horikoshi
Shokugeki no Soma- Tosh
Kagamigami- Iwashiro Toshiaki
New manga- Sorachi Hideaki
New sports manga- new author
New manga- new author
New manga- Tamura Ryuuhei
World Trigger- ending
New romcom manga- Naoki Iwamoto

Maybes

Black Clover- Yuuki Tabata
New manga- Hiroshi Shiibashi
New Manga- Shibata Yuusaku
Some manga- Yuu Miki

 

[meeedoooz]

i have an unpopular opinion ( though i don't know why ) but i really like haihyuu better than BnH and i hope it sells a lot more by that time, but i haven't caught up to the manga yet so i'm a bit sad a lot of you ranked it a bit lower. any estimates as how long it may last ( judging by the manga itself and the life expectancy of sports manga ) ?

 

[susanoo13]

I didn't write Haikyuu at all simply since I expect it to end by that time. I would say the manga is past half it's life and now is 3 years old.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Yes. Black Clover!!! His magic is never giving up.

 

[De La Croissant]

The next week will be very important: UBS will surprise us in his first rank? BC will remain on top? Btw, when the magazine will take a break?

 

[Bigivelfhq]

i have an unpopular opinion ( though i don't know why ) but i really like haihyuu better than BnH and i hope it sells a lot more by that time, but i haven't caught up to the manga yet so i'm a bit sad a lot of you ranked it a bit lower. any estimates as how long it may last ( judging by the manga itself and the life expectancy of sports manga ) ?

I have that same opinion!

Though there is the thing about Sports titles in WSJ until now only living for a short time, max around 30 volumes(Yep, I know 30 is not literally a short running :P), with only Prince of Tennis getting 42 volumes(and even continuing later in Jump Square). This means that a popular sport series average life span in the magazine is around 6 years. Haikyuu!! has right now 3 years, so only 3 more years.

Now, by how the story of Haikyuu!! is going it can easily be a long running sport series like Hajime no Ippo, Major or others. I hope that Haikyuu!! is the big exception and it goes for a long long time in the magazine.

 

[SharkBait]

3 years left for Haikyuu!! Seems too little. Current match can last us until 2016, half next year for the next training arc, and then mid 2016 to 2019 for the next tourney.

 

[G_I_A]

No they won't.

It was a joke dude. Self implied by "we will all die".

---------- Post added at 07:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:08 PM ----------

The next week will be very important: UBS will surprise us in his first rank? BC will remain on top? Btw, when the magazine will take a break?

Golden Week will be on April 29th through May 5th.

 

[RubyR91]

Yes. Black Clover!!! His magic is never giving up.

I thought I was playing a Kingdom Hearts game when I heard that line.

 

[DoctorApollo]

It was a joke dude. Self implied by "we will all die".

But the fact we will all die isn't a joke at all.

It's quite unfortunate, actually.