Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[SharkBait]

Yeah, totally.
Like sport and battle manga without moviment. Or music manga without sound. Or cooking manga without taste and smell. These kind of manga are odd, and will never be good, never be famous.
Manga should stick only with stories that doesn't require any of that. Like... no story ever.

First I dont think you should really make my statement seem like I was saying it will not be good or famous...Odd does not equal "bad". And sorry but I think there is a huge difference between a dance manga and a sport manga and a cooking manga in which you can describe foods in great detail with words (food wars chapters get pretty wordy and food isnt moving), and a sport manga in which players can at least remain stationary and tricks with visuals like he does in Haikyuu!! be done to the ball to show its movement (but he never does that with players bodies, etc)

Additionally didnt one music manga at least provide what the music would sound like online? Clearly the writer thought the experience would be greatly enhanced if people could hear what it sounds like. And at times in Soul Catcher(s) you could just go online to try to find a clip of how a band would sound playing the songs, though it was challenging at times...

The reason I said a "hard sale" is that some readers probably will express the same concerns I have about a dance manga that would need visual cues as well as musical cues. I doubt most mainstream readers will give it as big a chance as people are imagining it to be. Using the currently airing Tribecoolcrew as an example, I honestly cant imagine how you would mangaize something like . I also dont see how the minor differences and mistakes in the music playing of something like Your Lie In April were able to be achieved in the manga, and only the manga, of that series...

 

[vinceled]

First I dont think you should really make my statement seem like I was saying it will not be good or famous...Odd does not equal "bad". And sorry but I think there is a huge difference between a dance manga and a sport manga and a cooking manga in which you can describe foods in great detail with words (food wars chapters get pretty wordy and food isnt moving), and a sport manga in which players can at least remain stationary and tricks with visuals like he does in Haikyuu!! be done to the ball to show its movement (but he never does that with players bodies, etc)

Additionally didnt one music manga at least provide what the music would sound like online? Clearly the writer thought the experience would be greatly enhanced if people could hear what it sounds like. And at times in Soul Catcher(s) you could just go online to try to find a clip of how a band would sound playing the songs, though it was challenging at times...

The reason I said a "hard sale" is that some readers probably will express the same concerns I have about a dance manga that would need visual cues as well as musical cues. I doubt most mainstream readers will give it as big a chance as people are imagining it to be. Using the currently airing Tribecoolcrew as an example, I honestly cant imagine how you would mangaize something like . I also dont see how the minor differences and mistakes in the music playing of something like Your Lie In April were able to be achieved in the manga, and only the manga, of that series...

Go read Ballroom e Yokoso and I guess you'll see what a dancing manga looks like. To be honest, we don't even know what kind of dance the manga will be about. If you want more examples as to how movements can be explained, take a look at Blizzard Axel. It might not be about dancing but ice-skating but I think the movements in a dancing manga will be quite similar.

 

[conankudo]

Haha Gorilla ownage. I m so glad Chitoge made it on the cover and we don't have to see Kosaki's stupid face (she is the typical Run-of-the-Mill Japanese Girl - does anyone even like her?). I m still hoping Marika is the one

 

[Pietro]

I would like to see a manga about poetry or literature,or Art in Jump.I'm sure they wouldn't be bad

 

[Mammo]

I would like to see a manga about poetry or litterature,or Art in Jump.I'm sure they wouldn't be bad

other than Bakuman you mean?

 

[Pietro]

other than Bakuman you mean?

No,not exactly that

---------- Post added at 06:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:22 PM ----------

I mean art about painting

---------- Post added at 06:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:22 PM ----------

Or literature.The protagonist want to be a writer of novels,and so...;or a poet

---------- Post added at 06:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:23 PM ----------

We italians are very tied to literature,and so you couldn't understand what I mean

 

[Leoat12]

With literature as a theme I could think of something like 1Q84 by Haruki Murakami or some kind of fantasy where the world the writer writes turns real or something.
With painting, the second option of literature would also work, I think...

 

[ElJin]

No,not exactly that

---------- Post added at 06:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:22 PM ----------

I mean art about painting

---------- Post added at 06:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:22 PM ----------

Or literature.The protagonist want to be a writer of novels,and so...;or a poet

---------- Post added at 06:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:23 PM ----------

We italians are very tied to literature,and so you couldn't understand what I mean

A manga of painting would be amazing. I still dream of reading a manga themed like the Ib game.

 

[Xzone]

I find very funny people talking about YOKO design are bad , are you guys read molester man or onani master kurosawa? His art is very good ,I put in the same/better level of the Tosh's first chapters of shokugeki.

 

[SharkBait]

I would like to see a manga about poetry or literature,or Art in Jump.I'm sure they wouldn't be bad

If Jump had an answer to Hyouka that would be splendid. Except please no Chitanda like character.

---------- Post added at 01:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:04 PM ----------

I find very funny people talking about YOKO design are bad , are you guys read molester man or onani master kurosawa? His art is very good ,I put in the same/better level of the Tosh's first chapters of shokugeki.

People want a writer that did something called Molester Man in JUMP? I dont even want to imagine what the translated title of the other series means. JUMP is not the avenue for people to push their lewd agenda and thrust it on others.

 

[jagman1x3]

If Jump had an answer to Hyouka that would be splendid. Except please no Chitanda like character.

---------- Post added at 01:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:04 PM ----------



People want a writer that did something called Molester Man in JUMP? I dont even want to imagine what the translated title of the other series means. JUMP is not the avenue for people to push their lewd agenda and thrust it on others.

He's already been published in Jump.

 

[Leoat12]

We can't even start talking about Onani Master Kurosawa at this hour of the afternoon (or morning for some places).

It is not like authors who did questionable series in the past will always do such a thing. Saeki Shun drew a lot of ****** before Shokugeki no Soma by what I heard.
Yokota Takuma is the author of Koganeiro, serialized in Jump and it is pure as angles playing harp in the heaven.
And of course, his drawing is indeed good, Koganeiro had a very good art.

 

[Drmke]

A manga of painting would be amazing.

I mean, if it doesn't have to be from Jump....I recommend Genkaku Picasso. It's by Furuya Usamaru so you can bet it will be fantastic yet weird as hell.

 

[G_I_A]

A manga of painting would be amazing. I still dream of reading a manga themed like the Ib game.

I personally would like to see a Le Parkour / Free Running manga

 

[jagman1x3]

I personally would like to see a Le Parkour / Free Running manga

If stuff made outside Japan counts, there was a Kickstarter for one a while ago.

 

[Googlez_kun]

People want a writer that did something called Molester Man in JUMP? I dont even want to imagine what the translated title of the other series means. JUMP is not the avenue for people to push their lewd agenda and thrust it on others.

Okay correct me if I'm wrong, but if my memory serves me right, the artist of Shokugeki No Soma drew ****** before he went to JUMP. The series you love so much is drawn by someone who drew sex manga.

Also, Molester Man is a great manga, which has nothing to do with molesting anyone.

 

[De La Croissant]

Okay correct me if I'm wrong, but if my memory serves me right, the artist of Shokugeki No Soma drew ****** before he went to JUMP. The series you love so much is drawn by someone who drew sex manga.

Also, Molester Man is a great manga, which has nothing to do with molesting anyone.

Yep. And Onani Master Kurosawa shows a great way to use a controversial topic in order to pass a more serious message.

 

[Xzone]

If Jump had an answer to Hyouka that would be splendid. Except please no Chitanda like character.

---------- Post added at 01:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:04 PM ----------
People want a writer that did something called Molester Man in JUMP? I dont even want to imagine what the translated title of the other series means. JUMP is not the avenue for people to push their lewd agenda and thrust it on others.

Never change bait , never change.
No one of the Jump fanbase would want Molester Man, the series was a VERY good adaptation of a 2ch thread and I don't think like this will published in a magazine .His series always have a incredible character development, and Kurosawa was a good Kira parody.
Yoko is a good writter , unlike for example Tabata (tell me 5 good point of black clover), and other shonen jump writers who serialized the last 3 years.

Okay correct me if I'm wrong, but if my memory serves me right, the artist of Shokugeki No Soma drew ****** before he went to JUMP. The series you love so much is drawn by someone who drew sex manga.

Also, Molester Man is a great manga, which has nothing to do with molesting anyone.

Also , The artist of medaka box drew ****** whit lolis. The past work means nothing to jump (same in the good way like YOKO or narita) but the art is objetive and YOKO is a good artist

PD:Sorry for my english

 

[Caiops]

Saeki Shun(Tosh) drew Harem Time, a excelent ****** who even had an anime.

 

[Stark700]

Oh the irony of loving the work of a former ****** artist while criticizing another artist, who made a suggestive sounding manga previously, whose new work hasn't even begun yet. I love how we speculate so hard on things that didn't even start.