Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Leoat12]

Boku no Hero Academia Vol.1 when it release after 3 week-157,439
Boku no Hero Academia Vol 2 when it release after 2 or 3 week- 239,566
Boku no Hero Academia Vol.3 when it release after 3 week-254,111

And we don't know the Black clover sales,until Black clover don't sale 200k and BnH sales droped than 100K I don't say BC is canivalizing anithing.

Seriously, let him talk. Let it be... We know what will happen after this.

 

[DeidaraGrimmjow]

Boku is still in the top 5 technically. Nothing is cannabalizing anything. That said, Kagamigami and UBS are done next round looks like. Geez

 

[Gah]

Shonen Jump will come on Saturday this week?

 

[cue1996]

Kagamigami will be in 8th or 7th place since Kochikame and Assassination Classroom having color pages and Naruto in its 2nd chapter. (though I'm not sure if Naruto will be ranked since people are saying it will be 10 chapters long.)

 

[Leoat12]

Shonen Jump will come on Saturday this week?

If we have luck... The TOC is already leaking, so it is possible...

 

[DeidaraGrimmjow]

Kagamigami will be in 8th or 7th place since Kochikame and Assassination Classroom having color pages and Naruto in its 2nd chapter. (though I'm not sure if Naruto will be ranked since people are saying it will be 10 chapters long.)

Still, it's likely to be in the bottom 5 from now on

 

[Ryosuke Uchiha]

Boku is still in the top 5 technically. Nothing is cannabalizing anything. That said, Kagamigami and UBS are done next round looks like. Geez

Well, it's 6th... Unless AssClass's color page is above.

 

[Asclepius]

Shonen Jump will come on Saturday this week?

The official release for next issue is on May 11th, a monday. We are on Golden Week break this week.

 

[Bigivelfhq]

Well, it's 6th... Unless AssClass's color page is above.

Naruto Gaiden is not ranked and is probably at the top. I wouldn't even be surprised if it is in 1st place.
With that Boku no Hero is still in Top 5.

 

[susanoo13]

How is Kagamigami likely to be in the bottom 5 as of now or end next? It's the first time WT outdid it, we don't know how good are the upcoming batch, Gintama is about to end and next batch for sure Naruto spinoff is ending, not to mention AC's possible end this year. Up till now it had ranks of 5th-7th and so did Haikyuu at it's beginning and look at it now.

 

[Leoat12]

My bets

Pin! to ~Shikako Kyogi Dance-bu e Yokoso (Cover and Lead CP)
One Piece
Naruto Gaiden
Assassination Classroom (CP)
Haikyuu
Black clover (CP)
Shokugeki no Soma
Boku no hero academia
Toriko
Hinomaru Zumou
Nisekoi
Kochikame (CP)
PSI
Kagamigami
Gintama
Ultra Battle Satellite
PSI
BLEACH
Gakkyu Hottei (END)
Roggy (END)
Isobee

 

[cue1996]

How is Kagamigami likely to be in the bottom 5 as of now or end next? It's the first time WT outdid it, we don't know how good are the upcoming batch, Gintama is about to end and next batch for sure Naruto spinoff is ending, not to mention AC's possible end this year. Up till now it had ranks of 5th-7th and so did Haikyuu at it's beginning and look at it now.

World Trigger is absent in this issue.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Yeah, that really isn't a Kagamigami is doomed position. Several un ranked series, plus the new batch will make it worse than it is. Not worried in the slightest.

 

[SharkBait]

I think it is time to start raising the yellow flags for Kagamigami, it could very well be the next Illegal Rare.

 

[Unok]

It's quite likely that Kagamigami will go in the bottom 5-7 starting from next week. But that won't be due to "very bad" reception. Considering 2 of the bottom series end now, bottom will usually have UBS, Bleach, Trigger, Kochikame & Isobee, with occasional entries from Gintama, Kagamigami, Nisekoi, Toriko & Saiki. Naruto + the 3 new series will always be placed at the middle and up (at least until they reach chapter 5). Once the new series start ranking, it will be more clear what will go. I don't remember a recent case were all 3 new survived. At least 1 or 2 will go + Naruto + very likely UBS + possible ending of some of the bigger series -> if continue like it's now Kagami may survive and establish a fanbase.

Waited 5 years for Iwashiro's return, if they cancel it, I will curse them a lot XD I started to really love Kagamigami, can't wait to get my hands of the first volume in June XD

 

[Leoat12]

I think it is time to start raising the yellow flags for Kagamigami, it could very well be the next Illegal Rare.

It is funny how partial you are. When it is a favorite series of yours in WORSE CONDITION you say this: "The series is a masterpiece and therefore it will rise up next week.", when it is not... You say this in the quote.

 

[DeidaraGrimmjow]

How is Kagamigami likely to be in the bottom 5 as of now or end next? It's the first time WT outdid it, we don't know how good are the upcoming batch, Gintama is about to end and next batch for sure Naruto spinoff is ending, not to mention AC's possible end this year. Up till now it had ranks of 5th-7th and so did Haikyuu at it's beginning and look at it now.

Pretty much what someone already said. The bottom 5 from now on will be Bleach, UBS, Kochikame, Kagamigami, Gintama/WT/Nisekoi/Zumo/Toriko. And Kochikame isn't really ranked (and if it is, it doesn't matter). I'd love to be wrong of course. But I don't see it beating out One Piece, AC, Boku, etc on a weekly basis to take the top spots. There's no where else for it to go honestly. Until the new series start to get ranked. But living on that isn't the best strategy for long term success. Better it just go now rather than last a year or two and get the same fate as Psyren.

 

[Caiops]

Shokugeki no Soma selling really well

2015 Manga Series Ranking thread updated:
http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1373137&show=0

Weekly Manga Series from Oricon Youtaiju
*1　327,994　Nanatsu no Taizai (七つの大罪)
*2　194,728　Magi (マギ)
*3　194,061　Shingeki no Kyojin (進撃の巨人)
*4　165,589　Detective Conan (名探偵コナン)
*5　141,446　Kingdom (キングダム)
*6　137,912　GIANT KILLING
*7　130,433　ONE PIECE
*8　128,588　Ansatsu Kyoushitsu (暗殺教室)
*9　123,336　Kamisama Hajimemashita (神様はじめました)
10　122,541　Shokugeki no Souma (食戟のソーマ)

Spreadsheet with calculations updated:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...J6iqDo2FcouN79dg0Vc/edit?pli=1#gid=1549866658

Good anime boost.

 

[xAsum0x]

Seems like Hero is taking a slight dip

 

[kobester11]

I really like to see that dancing manga by YOKO. Acadamia's still going strong but its slowly entering the jump phase.