Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015-2016] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[ShenGao]

Well, i must have missed that. But seriously, the mouths and noses are like a copy paste thing.

 

[SharkBait]

Why does it matter? They are great character designs so Im pleased. Leo and Dorksta are a perfect duo.

 

[Mammo]

it's makes it hard to differentiate the characters apart from each other + ruins your suspension of disbelief

 

[SharkBait]

it's makes it hard to differentiate the characters apart from each other + ruins your suspension of disbelief

How? No one has ever gotten them mixed up when on panel together, outfits differ, hairstyle differ, height differs, personalities differ too

 

[Mammo]

i don't know about " No one has ever gotten them mixed up" i mixed them up a lot of time

& i seen many people on bato, 4chan, reddit , etc... getting confused by the designs too, so it's not a personal issue

 

[Hatedmaincharacter]

i don't know about " No one has ever gotten them mixed up" i mixed them up a lot of time

& i seen many people on bato, 4chan, reddit , etc... getting confused by the designs too, so it's not a personal issue

Me too. Some panels are really hard.

 

[Soul Soul Brigade]

Different eye shapes, different eye brow shapes, different hair styles, different clothes. I never got Asta and Leo confused because they don't look similar, like, at all...

 

[Mammo]

my confusion have nothing to do with these 2 characters in particular

can you tell Noelle's 3 brother from each other? or Noelle from every other female character her age in this manga

 

[SharkBait]

my confusion have nothing to do with these 2 characters in particular

can you tell Noelle's 3 brother from each other? or Noelle from every other female character her age in this manga

Yes, she cant use magic properly and has a unique personality, and rarely calls Dorksta his name. So I can always tell when its Noell.

 

[Mammo]

ok tell me which one of these character is her

Spoiler

hint: none of them, btw these are 4 different characters from 4 random chapters

 

[vampire killer]

Can't we just argue when world trigger will be cancelled?

 

[SharkBait]

ok tell me which one of these character is her

Spoiler

hint: none of them, btw these are 4 different characters from 4 random chapters

Im not seeing how the characters look the same. Sorry.

 

[Mammo]

Im not seeing how the characters look the same. Sorry.

hmph..whatever man, i already argue this 3 times in this thread already & i don't feel like arguing it again

Can't we just argue when world trigger will be cancelled?

when it start ranking below bleach.

this gave me an idea though, Beelzebub already ended & KnB in will end soon right? they will need something to replace them in Next right? maybe WT is a good candidate

 

[Soul Soul Brigade]

Ok then, lets discuss when World Trigger became bad. For me it was when the rank wars arc started. Way to kill the hype of the previous arc. Also, am I the only one really bothered by how Border functions? They're supposed to be an independent agency, but that would never work. The Japanese government would never approve a 3rd party organization with significant advancements in technology that far exceed the JSDF's own, and they would certainly never approve child soldiers. The Japanese government would only allow the existence of Border if Border was a subsidiary of the JSDF. Also, child soldiers. I don't care if triggers act as doubles and that the agents are never in any physical danger, the public would still highly look down upon the use of child soldiers. And you can't really defend the child soldier aspect by saying "oh well the younger the kid the more trion sensitive they are" because even with that being true the public would still never allow that. Their is just so much wrong with World Trigger that I'm surprised it's still around.

 

[Lehran]

Ok then, lets discuss when World Trigger became bad. For me it was when the rank wars arc started. Way to kill the hype of the previous arc. Also, am I the only one really bothered by how Border functions? They're supposed to be an independent agency, but that would never work. The Japanese government would never approve a 3rd party organization with significant advancements in technology that far exceed the JSDF's own, and they would certainly never approve child soldiers. The Japanese government would only allow the existence of Border if Border was a subsidiary of the JSDF. Also, child soldiers. I don't care if triggers act as doubles and that the agents are never in any physical danger, the public would still highly look down upon the use of child soldiers. And you can't really defend the child soldier aspect by saying "oh well the younger the kid the more trion sensitive they are" because even with that being true the public would still never allow that. Their is just so much wrong with World Trigger that I'm surprised it's still around.

But... it's a fantasy shounen manga, of course you won't enjoy it if you overthink things like that. If the manga's heroes weren't children, it wouldn't even be running in WSJ...

 

[Soul Soul Brigade]

Gintama, Toriko, Fist of the North Star, Dragon Ball Z, Kinnikuman, Cat's Eye, Jojo, City Hunter, Otokojuku, Black Cat, Rurouni Kenshin to name a few with main characters beyond the age of 18.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

hmph..whatever man, i already argue this 3 times in this thread already & i don't feel like arguing it again



when it start ranking below bleach.

this gave me an idea though, Beelzebub already ended & KnB in will end soon right? they will need something to replace them in Next right? maybe WT is a good candidate

It's a better fit for Jump Plus, it would sooner go there before being cancelled or Jump Next. That's what my Side Effect tells me.

 

[Soul Soul Brigade]

Is it just me, or does it look like Yuki Tabata uses color pencil for his color works?

 

[WyldViolet]

Rather than see World Trigger get cancelled, I'd rather see it moved to Jump+ quite soon before it's popularity inevitability falls even further.
It would attract more attention to the service and then we could start seeing the actual successes come out of Jump.

 

[phiophill]

This had been bothering me a while but why do people complain about Jump editors in a general sense? Good Editors are able to make changes that have a positive effect on the popularity and quality of the manga. Not to mention that they are needed to get the full potential out of the Mangaka. Everyone should complain about the bad ones that cant do those things.