Games Mafia Game 47 - Gantz: Survival of the Fittest - END GAME

[Kat]

Also just the list update

Spoiler: Listto

Kat - (Witch)
TSPanda - (Plain Townie)
g01 - (Plain Townie)
Ustegius - (Bulletproof)
lawlett-kun - (Mortician) (Night action DD killed by mafia)
Master Piplup - boring role (Bomb)

Holt- night role, didn't have before, fairly important (had Bodyguard, Mafia Escort, Innocent child, Detective, Strongman)
GrySun- not a regular townie, never had before (had Death Miller)
Erinyes - never had the role before (had Unskilled Mafia, Innocent Child, Townie, Detective), no killing power
Farfalla - useless but with some power
Machi-tan - not a prostitute
desin24 - active role
Naomi- her role can backfire
Aonori- not a detective, his role doesnt have percentages involved in it
Hardy - semi-active
Lovemagi- never had the role, suits her but not in some ways -_- (had Mafia Detective, Strongman, Hider, Mafia Pirate,
xi0

RIP
Demonspeed (Bodyguard)
digitaldude (Mason Recruiter)
Hll (Noble)
Zasz- (Doctor)
Mazino - has a role (Detective)
James Rye- not a detective, useful (Bomb Diffuser)
Gnut- never had the role (Santa)

---------- Post added at 03:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:27 PM ----------

It was this one.

Well wasn't clear to me but I get what you mean now and I do agree. You coulda explained it better then tho

 

[GrySun]

Yeah I don't buy the plain townies being plain townies. There's probably a sleeper and/or a death miller among them if they speak the truth, if they're lying they could be anything.

 

[Farfalla]

Sorry coaching atm will reply in 1hr. Wording in a pm is diff ofc I will do a screenshot lol

I don't think you can post a screenshot and I don't see the difficulty in re-writing a sentence you got.

 

[Holt]

Votekill Ustegius (and lock). Why am I so certain in voting and locking on someone I didn't even suspect before? Go back over his last posts today and you'll see the one difference that could've made me completely change my mind. I won't spell it out though.

 

[Kat]

Yeah I don't buy the plain townies being plain townies. There's probably a sleeper and/or a death miller among them if they speak the truth, if they're lying they could be anything.

Well if the plain townies are recruited we will know as there will be 1 death less (we wont know for sure ofc since there are many factors why that could happen)

 

[g01]

Yeah so basically 'we should kinda take it into consideration but also not do it too much', right?

Exactly

 

[Kat]

Votekill Ustegius (and lock). Why am I so certain in voting and locking on someone I didn't even suspect before? Go back over his last posts today and you'll see the one difference that could've made me completely change my mind. I won't spell it out though.

Omg if you have something just say it wtf?

 

[GrySun]

I mean, I know you can, but you have no way of actually confirming whether you can or not. For now I trust the likes of you, Farf and Hardy as you seem to be actively contributing to the townie cause, rather than saying meaningless stuff (like Piplup and Goi), being defensive (like Gary and Ao) or simply being vague (Magi)

Come on Panda. It's because I can't know for sure which is why I ask. I can't go around suspecting every single player, so instead of going with "guilty until proven innocent", for some people like you and Farfs I want to go with "innocent until proven guilty". Or does that just make sense for me?
...I think I'm going with your guilt feeling about lying to me as the reason why you didn't answer before

 

[desin24]

Also just the list update

Spoiler: Listto

Kat - (Witch)
TSPanda - (Plain Townie)
g01 - (Plain Townie)
Ustegius - (Bulletproof)
lawlett-kun - (Mortician) (Night action DD killed by mafia)
Master Piplup - boring role (Bomb)

Holt- night role, didn't have before, fairly important (had Bodyguard, Mafia Escort, Innocent child, Detective, Strongman)
GrySun- not a regular townie, never had before (had Death Miller)
Erinyes - never had the role before (had Unskilled Mafia, Innocent Child, Townie, Detective), no killing power
Farfalla - useless but with some power
Machi-tan - not a prostitute
desin24 - active role
Naomi- her role can backfire
Aonori- not a detective, his role doesnt have percentages involved in it
Hardy - semi-active
Lovemagi- never had the role, suits her but not in some ways -_- (had Mafia Detective, Strongman, Hider, Mafia Pirate,
xi0

RIP
Demonspeed (Bodyguard)
digitaldude (Mason Recruiter)
Hll (Noble)
Zasz- (Doctor)
Mazino - has a role (Detective)
James Rye- not a detective, useful (Bomb Diffuser)
Gnut- never had the role (Santa)

---------- Post added at 03:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:27 PM ----------



Well wasn't clear to me but I get what you mean now and I do agree. You coulda explained it better then tho

So xiO is the only one with no hint so far. Not sure if it's because his hints were subtle and overlooked or there are just none.

What does a semi-active role mean? That Hardy can only use it when triggered?

 

[Farfalla]

I didn't think of Gary x Misho much before cause I didn't see much to support it, just something as an extra scenario, but the PM could be interesting xD

 

[Kat]

Anyway I rlly gtg now so I will try to log in when I come to my aunt see ya for now

 

[Aonori]

Well James and Gary doesn't have to be on the same mafia team ... obviously there is a 3rd party/2nd mafia since there are 3 aliens

We dont know almost anything relevant on the third boss, so it can be anything from 3rd party to 2nd mafia team, however mafia members at this point are more dangerous than a possible 3rd party (due to higher number of mafia members), if it's a 2nd mafia team then we might see some collateral damage between both parties at night phase but that will depend on a lot of luck of course.

Though if we know something is that james votekilled for xi0 and naomi in a scenario where he wasnt suspected so in his eyes they were townies, holt's case could have been a bit more debatable thus I'm not sure, but voting for naomi and xi0 now is waste of votes after james got killed off, if anything we need to take down james mafia buddies first and then focus on the 3rd boss or we will be having multiple double kill night phases.

 

[GrySun]

Well wasn't clear to me but I get what you mean now and I do agree. You coulda explained it better then tho

Yea reading it again my syntax was kinda crap.

Well if the plain townies are recruited we will know as there will be 1 death less (we wont know for sure ofc since there are many factors why that could happen)

I was suggesting that they aren't just normal townies even if they think they are, making them a good option to votekill to be honest. If they're hiding their 3rd party role or mafia allegiance as "plain townie", we scored big. If not, they were still most likely a role that should be removed beforehand, ie. sleeper.

 

[Holt]

Guys take out ustegius. He's not the BP

 

[Aonori]

Votekill Ustegius (and lock). Why am I so certain in voting and locking on someone I didn't even suspect before? Go back over his last posts today and you'll see the one difference that could've made me completely change my mind. I won't spell it out though.

His last post is on which page?

 

[Purity of Magi]

Yay another 20 pages I can read on this mobile.. brb, reading what you guys just discussed about

 

[GrySun]

Votekill Ustegius (and lock). Why am I so certain in voting and locking on someone I didn't even suspect before? Go back over his last posts today and you'll see the one difference that could've made me completely change my mind. I won't spell it out though.

Holt why not just tell us outright? Or at least quote us his posts so we have an easier time comparing and coming up with it.

 

[Holt]

Didn't you all see my last post? He's not the BP. I know that for sure

 

[GrySun]

but voting for naomi and xi0 now is waste of votes after james got killed of

Why???? Aonori I read many of your posts in many different sections(Magi, SnK, here), you usually always give your reasons when stating things like that. What gives?

 

[Farfalla]

Votekill Ustegius (and lock). Why am I so certain in voting and locking on someone I didn't even suspect before? Go back over his last posts today and you'll see the one difference that could've made me completely change my mind. I won't spell it out though.

Why can't you just share it with us tho? D: