Discussion Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread

Which side are you on?

  • Team Spriggan 12

    Votes: 48 51.6%
  • Team Diabolos/Dragon Eaters

    Votes: 45 48.4%

  • Total voters
    93

Plutogrim

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2016
Messages
485
Reaction score
583
Age
27
Country
United States
1. Acnologia
2. Zeref
3. August
4. Irene
5. Dimaria
6. Brandish
7. God Serena
8. Jacob
9. Laxus
10. Jellal
11. Wahl
12. Mard
13. Azir
14. Jura
15. Erza
16. Gajeel
17. Gray
18. Mirajane
19. Kagura
20. Wendy
 

Talenel

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 28, 2016
Messages
692
Reaction score
789
Age
36
Country
United States
Notes:
*Pre GMG is fodder. After the 7 year timeskip, Max was powerful enough to mop the floor with Natsu...MAX!
*Spriggans can beat dragons (f*ck dragons btw)
*I ignored Dimaria's time stop power
*I ignored Brandish's ability to affect organs
*I ignored Jacob's hand clap thingy (how does that even work?)
*Gray is ranked pretty much solely off his portrayal next to Natsu in the Avatar arc as well as his potential future battles with E.N.D.


1 Acnologia
2 Zeref Dragneel
3 Igneel
4 Igneel-powered Natsu
5 August
6 Irene Belserion
7 DeS Gray Fullbuster
8 Natsu
9 Jellal Fernandes
10 Laxus Dreyar

11 Base Gray Fullbuster
12 DF Gajeel
13 God Serena
14 Wahl Icht
15 Ajeel Lamur
16 Brandish
17 Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
18 Ikatsunagi
19 Erza Scarlet
20 Base Gajeel Redfox
21 Ur
22 Mirajane Strauss
23 Third origin Chelia Blendy
24 Chronos Dimaria Yesta
25 Bradman
26 Neinhart
27 Jacob Lessio
28 Hyberion
29 Gildarts Clive
30 Wolfheim
31 Mard Geer Tartaros
32 Makarov Dreyar
33 Bluenote Stinger
34 Kyôka
35 Future Rogue
36 Kagura Mikazuchi
37 Wahl Icht Proxy
38 Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
39 Full Power Precht Gaebolg
40 Silver Fullbuster
41 DF Wendy Marvell
42 Juvia Lockster
43 Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun
44 Jura Neekis
45 Warrod Sequen
46 Minerva Orlando
47 Lyon Vastia
48 Meredy
49 Shaila

50 Lucy Heartfillia
51 Base Wendy Marvell
52 Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
53 Chelia Blendy
54 Freed Justine
55 Elfman Strauss
56 Evergreen
57 Marin Hollow
58 Bickslow
59 Cana Alberona

60 Azuma
61 Ikaruga
62 Mest Gryder
63 Levy Mcgarden
64 Lisanna Strauss
 
Last edited:

Plutogrim

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2016
Messages
485
Reaction score
583
Age
27
Country
United States
Fairy Tail Guild:

1. Natsu
2. Laxus
3. Gildarts
4. Erza
5. Gajeel
6. Gray
7. Makarov
8. Mirajane
9. Wendy
10. Lucy
 

Cosmicstar

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2013
Messages
1,288
Reaction score
1,793
Age
31
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
Woah there, I definitely agree that Mirajane is being drastically overrated but she's definitely a lot stronger then Pre-TS Kagura and Minerva as she is now. Her Alegria form is the culmination of all the power she absorbed from Tartarus, that's power from the likes of Mard and the 9DG (although its drawback is that its very temporary). That's a massive amount of power with which she could easily stomp the likes of Pre-TS Kagura/Minerva. As a matter of fact she can just turn into Mard himself and make quick work of them, she should be able to sustain Mard Geer Take-Over for longer. Current Kagura and Minerva are kinda featless so I have no comment on them. At the bare minimum current Mira is Mard Tiered, although with Alegria and the sheer versatility of powers she has at her disposal I would like to think she's a tier above him. Still, to say she's Laxus tiered is definitely stretching it a lot.

Also a note on Kaguras power. Its worth noting that she cuts, so its far more concentrated then Jupiter. While she could make a cut with the force of Jupiter, a cut wouldn't be anywhere near as dangerous/lethal as being burned by Jupiter itself. So technically Jupiter is still a vastly superior attack then Kaguras cuts, although it does need charging time.

LOL Marde Geer couldn't even make quick work of Base Sting and Rogue so in what world would Marde geer make quick work of Kagura or Minerva. Minerva and Kagura do have feats from the G<G and their feats are still more impressive then Mirajanes. All Mirajane have done so far is take out Irene's lackeys who feats aren't impressive. One used sticky glue and the other used streamers. How does any of that put her above Kagura and Minerva or even on their level? While yes it was an improvement for Mirajane I don't think it put her in a tier such as Kagura and Minerva who were dishing out those attacks during the GMG with ease. Also the attacks they did had higher AoE and didn't even exhaust their magical power. Mirajane could never defeat someone like Kagura and Minerva in battle.



My Top 10 Females would be:

1. Irene:




The only reason she is right here is because of her feat of rearranging Fiore. Otherwise the jury is still out. I know she was hyped to be the strongest but I mean so much stuff has been hyped in this manga just to be proven wrong. Curses being stronger than Magic, Jura being the strongest Human wizard, etc. I will give her the benefit of doubt though because she was able to push Acnologia back. Then again so was Makarov(Able to hold Dragon form Acnologia in place).

Waiting for more feats from her. Her transforming Hisui into a mouse was cool but I don't know if that feat would be enough to make her fiores number 1 female mage. I will keep her here for the time being.

2. Dimira:


The only reason I place her her is due to her age seal. Her takeover was cool but not powerful enough to make the top 5 list within the females of Fairy Tail.



Her God takeover does posses some pretty destructive power.




I will do the rest later I am super lazy right now.

3. Brandish

4. Lucy

5. Erza

6. Minerva

7. Kagura

8. Mirajane

9. Ur

10. Wendy
 
Last edited:

The President

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 18, 2016
Messages
785
Reaction score
2,437
Age
31
Country
Canada
LOL Marde Geer couldn't even make quick work of Base Sting and Rogue so in what world would Marde geer make quick work of Kagura or Minerva.
When he started trying he made quick work of Sting, Rogue AND Natsu without even resorting to his demon form. As a matter of fact he was beating them while sitting on a chair. Mirajane has his soul, she should have his base and demon form at her disposal.

Minerva and Kagura do have feats from the G<G and their feats are still more impressive then Mirajanes. All Mirajane have done so far is take out Irene's lackeys who feats aren't impressive. One used sticky glue and the other used streamers. How does any of that put her above Kagura and Minerva or even on their level? While yes it was an improvement for Mirajane I don't think it put her in a tier such as Kagura and Minerva who were dishing out those attacks during the GMG with ease. Also the attacks they did had higher AoE and didn't even exhaust their magical power. Mirajane could never defeat someone like Kagura and Minerva in battle.
Mira having Kyouka, Sayla and Torafusa take-overs at her disposal already puts her above Kagura/Minerva because those three characters are stronger then Kagura and Minerva. Then you have to factor in the fact that she has Mards soul as well, who is well above Kagura/Minerva. And then she has the cumulation of all these take-overs in the form of her Alegria take-over, which by her own admission is her strongest form (ie stronger then all the characters aforementioned and stronger then Kagura/Minerva by extension). There is no going around it mate, she is far stronger then GMG Kagura and Minerva. If you want to make a case for either of those two (or even those two combined for that matter) of being stronger then current Mira, you are going to have to prove why they are stronger then Kyouka first. And then Mard, cause Mira has both those souls at her disposal.
 

Cosmicstar

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2013
Messages
1,288
Reaction score
1,793
Age
31
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
When he started trying he made quick work of Sting, Rogue AND Natsu without even resorting to his demon form. As a matter of fact he was beating them while sitting on a chair. Mirajane has his soul, she should have his base and demon form at her disposal.



Mira having Kyouka, Sayla and Torafusa take-overs at her disposal already puts her above Kagura/Minerva because those three characters are stronger then Kagura and Minerva. Then you have to factor in the fact that she has Mards soul as well, who is well above Kagura/Minerva. And then she has the cumulation of all these take-overs in the form of her Alegria take-over, which by her own admission is her strongest form (ie stronger then all the characters aforementioned and stronger then Kagura/Minerva by extension). There is no going around it mate, she is far stronger then GMG Kagura and Minerva. If you want to make a case for either of those two (or even those two combined for that matter) of being stronger then current Mira, you are going to have to prove why they are stronger then Kyouka first. And then Mard, cause Mira has both those souls at her disposal.
We have yet to see any takeovers besides Algeria, Sayla, Sitri, and BSS. Until shown I refuse to even acknowledge she has any of them. The reason being is that just because she has thier soul doesn't make her as powerful as them. Plutogrim could destroy a town with a scream, Mirajane nuke is nowhere near town level. Sayla could control someone like Erza while Whal fodder ignored her commands. Also she doesn't have Marde Geer soul as Zeref destroyed him before everything with Tartarous was over. Mirajane didn't absorb Sayla until after the war. Meaning after Kyouka was defeated. Marde Geer and Mirjane never crossed paths.

Also it took Erza Nakagami(Most powerful) armor to take Minerva out. Kagura destroyed the same armors Kyouka destroyed and that is when Kagura sword was sheathed and Kyouka was in her etherious form with her power increasing every second.
 

The President

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 18, 2016
Messages
785
Reaction score
2,437
Age
31
Country
Canada
We have yet to see any takeovers besides Algeria, Sayla, Sitri, and BSS. Until shown I refuse to even acknowledge she has any of them. The reason being is that just because she has thier soul doesn't make her as powerful as them. Plutogrim could destroy a town with a scream, Mirajane nuke is nowhere near town level. Sayla could control someone like Erza while Whal fodder ignored her commands. Also she doesn't have Marde Geer soul as Zeref destroyed him before everything with Tartarous was over. Mirajane didn't absorb Sayla until after the war. Meaning after Kyouka was defeated. Marde Geer and Mirjane never crossed paths.
Just because she has not used them doesn't mean she does not have them, she outright states that she has consumed ALL the demon souls on Tartarus, she did not need to cross-paths with them on-panel, she just went around cleaning up souls. Refusing to acknowledge that she has them is literally going against canon itself. And yes it does, she is literally turning into them, she has their power. I do not recall Plutogrim ever busting a city or anything of the like, nor do I recall Alegria Mirajane using any nukes. Nor do I recall Wahl fodder countering Macro, in fact I specifically recall her commanding them to go to sleep and them doing so. Gonna have to ask you to support all three of these claims. Zeref destroyed Mards physical body, but he still has a soul (like the other demons), some of his themes are even prevalent in Miras Alegria design.

Also it took Erza Nakagami(Most powerful) armor to take Minerva out. Kagura destroyed the same armors Kyouka destroyed and that is when Kagura sword was sheathed and Kyouka was in her etherious form with her power increasing every second.
It a severally injured Erza her Nakagami armour to take Minerva out. FYI the Erza that Kagura was fighting was an Erza who had not activated her second origin yet, she did so against Minerva to use her Nagakami armour. In other words, the Erza that Kyouka fought was stronger then the one that Kagura fought, and Kyouka stalemated Erza whereas Erza decisively won once she got her resolve back on track. Kyouka is a hefty amount above both Kagura and Minerva. She actually defeated the latter when she was still a part of Succubus Eye.

Kyouka doesn't specialize in raw power, she has an insane curse ability. Kagura is all about raw power. The fact that Kagura is superior to Kyouka in that regard does not surprise me at all, that doesn't make her stronger though. In fact she is most certainly weaker.
 

Brandish μ

Taking notes
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Global Moderator
Joined
Oct 24, 2015
Messages
10,243
Reaction score
33,629
Gender
Male
Country
Kingdom of Fiore
I did the list sorter, it didn't take long. I think the top 32 were okay, but I really don't have much of a clue after that. (I didn't use DF for Natsu, otherwise I'd have him tied at 4th)

1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
4. Igneel-powered Natsu
4. Zeref Dragneel
7. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
7. August
7. Irene Belserion
9. Laxus Dreyar
9. Jellal Fernandes
9. Natsu
9. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
13. God Serena
13. Wahl Icht
13. DF Gajeel
16. Ajeel Lamur
17. Bradman
17. Jacob Lessio
17. Brandish
20. Neinhart
21. Erza Scarlet
22. DeS Gray Fullbuster
22. Mard Geer Tartaros
22. Hyberion
25. Full Power Precht Gaebolg
26. Future Rogue
26. Gildarts Clive
28. Warrod Sequen
28. Third origin Chelia Blendy
28. Wolfheim
28. Ikatsunagi
32. Base Gajeel Redfox
32. Makarov Dreyar
32. Mirajane Strauss
32. Jura Neekis
36. Base Gray Fullbuster
36. Minerva Orlando
36. Kagura Mikazuchi
39. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
40. Elfman Strauss
40. Lyon Vastia
40. Bluenote Stinger
43. Ur
44. DF Wendy Marvell
44. Wahl Icht Proxy
44. Kyôka
44. Lucy Heartfillia
44. Cana Alberona
44. Freed Justine
44. Meredy
51. Silver Fullbuster
52. Shaila
52. Azuma
54. Juvia Lockster
55. Levy Mcgarden
55. Base Wendy Marvell
55. Marin Hollow
55. Lisanna Strauss
55. Evergreen
55. Bickslow
55. Mest Gryder
55. Ikaruga
55. Chelia Blendy
64. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun
 

Crimson Ice

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2016
Messages
2,259
Reaction score
3,715
Country
Vandenreich
@Talenel, @SaberToothFan, @Crimson Ice, @Takuan, @Escanors Pride, @Jean Grey, @sharkai, @Kay3795, @NoHana, @Axiomus, @Daniel9dsi, @Cosmicstar, @Brandish, @Emperor Spriggan, @Shoutmon, @reesestl, @BluePegasus, @x777, @Asorx, @SirSamuel016, @Ice devil slayer, @THE ALMIGHTY CRYBABY, @Plutogrim, @Rain Cloud, @Ultimateasus, @Alvarez Princess, @EmberSpirit, @XXEliteXXAceXX, @PeanutButterJelly, @EmberSpirit, @Fox666
and anyone who’d like to join. You’re very welcome.

A few days ago, @Cosmicstar challenged us to provide a top5. This top5 should be carried out providing feats or justifying hype. Then we’d proceed for a top10, and so on.

I found it interesting since polls and the tournament in the Fairy Tail community in mangahelpers have certain limitations. After talking with @Brandish she suggested that I created a sorter, similar to the one in another thread, but shorter. So I did. It has 64 characters and took me 12 minutes to complete. It’s short and easy to do so please I urge you all to complete it. After this manual selection that took over 20 min lol, I expect participation!

Then we will post our rankings and we’ll proceed to compare them. When we’ve gathered a significant amount of them, results will be contrasted and a general ranking that encompasses the answers of the fandom will be provided. That is, of course, if people do participate.

Power ranking sorter:

http://charactersort.6te.net/custom/sorter.php?id=177

Rules:

-None of your picks can simply have hype behind them without any panels or feats to back it up. If you decide to go by hype, state where you think this hype comes from. Be consistant.

Ex: Meaning you can't say Wolfhiem is a city buster without any city busting feats to go along with that.

-If you use hype you must use all Hype or no hype.

Ex: If you defend that the GoI are above Jura because Ooba said so, then you also need to defend that all Spriggan12 belong to the same tier (except for August and Irene) because they’ve been hyped to be equals.

-Speculation is fine as long as there is some evidence to support or back you claim up. The evidence has to be relevant to you proposed speculation.


NO Bashing---Be Respectful

If you disagree with someone then you need to provide a counter argument with evidence. You can't just say you disagree. An argument must always be provided if you disagree with someone/something written.


If you decide to back up your ranking list or to criticize someone else’s, your post can't just be a wall of text consisting on baseless speculations.

You can choose to abide by NLF or not. Your choice.

Some characters do have "base" states and "powerup" states. Some like "Natsu", only have one powerup: Igneel-powered Natsu. Then there's just "Natsu". This "Natsu" stands for the strongest Natsu whose powerup depends on only himself: "BDKM Natsu". So, there's no "base Natsu" in this power sorter.


My ranking:

1. Acnologia

2. Igneel

3. Zeref Dragneel

4. Igneel-powered Natsu

4. Irene Belserion

6. August

7. Chronos Dimaria Yesta

8. Brandish

9. God Serena

10. Bradman

10. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)

12. Jacob Lessio

13. Laxus Dreyar

14. Jellal Fernandes

15. Ajeel Lamur

15. Wahl Icht

17. DF Gajeel

18. Natsu

19. DeS Gray Fullbuster

20. Erza Scarlet

20. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)

22. Neinhart

22. Full Power Precht Gaebolg

22. Mirajane Strauss

22. Gildarts Clive

26. Hyberion

26. Third origin Chelia Blendy

26. Kagura Mikazuchi

29. Base Gray Fullbuster

29. Mard Geer Tartaros

31. Wolfheim

31. Ikatsunagi

33. Warrod Sequen

34. Jura Neekis

34. Bluenote Stinger

36. Ur

37. Minerva Orlando

37. Marin Hollow

37. Freed Justine

37. Lyon Vastia

37. Shaila

42. Base Gajeel Redfox

42. DF Wendy Marvell

44. Makarov Dreyar

45. Future Rogue

46. Lucy Heartfillia

46. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney

48. Juvia Lockster

48. Kyôka

48. Silver Fullbuster

51. Cana Alberona

51. Evergreen

51. Mest Gryder

51. Azuma

51. Meredy

56. Bickslow

57. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun

57. Elfman Strauss

57. Ikaruga

60. Chelia Blendy

61. Levy Mcgarden

61. Base Wendy Marvell

61. Wahl Icht Proxy

64. Lisanna Strauss
1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
4. Igneel-powered Natsu
5. Zeref Dragneel
6. August
7. Irene Belserion
8. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
9. Laxus Dreyar
10. Jellal Fernandes
11. DF Gajeel
12. Wahl Icht
13. Bradman
14. Jacob Lessio
15. God Serena
16. DeS Gray Fullbuster
16. Natsu
18. Ajeel Lamur
19. Brandish
20. Neinhart
21. Base Gray Fullbuster
22. Base Gajeel Redfox
23. Erza Scarlet
24. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
25. Third origin Chelia Blendy
26. Mirajane Strauss
27. Hyberion
28. Wolfheim
29. Ikatsunagi
30. Mard Geer Tartaros
31. Full Power Precht Gaebolg
32. Makarov Dreyar
33. Silver Fullbuster
34. Future Rogue
35. DF Wendy Marvell
36. Ur
37. Minerva Orlando
38. Gildarts Clive
39. Warrod Sequen
40. Jura Neekis
41. Kagura Mikazuchi
42. Wahl Icht Proxy
43. Kyôka
44. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
45. Shaila
46. Bluenote Stinger
47. Azuma
48. Lyon Vastia
49. Juvia Lockster
50. Meredy
51. Freed Justine
52. Elfman Strauss
53. Lucy Heartfillia
54. Marin Hollow
Got sloppy half way through.
 

Ebony Maw

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 8, 2016
Messages
1,995
Reaction score
8,124
Gender
Male
Country
Sabertooth
@Char I think you'll find my answers interesting, I don't even understand these rankings because my actual scale is quite different.

1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
4. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
5. Igneel-powered Natsu
5. Zeref Dragneel
7. August
7. Irene Belserion
9. Laxus Dreyar
9. Jellal Fernandes
11. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
12. God Serena
12. Wahl Icht
14. Bradman
15. Jacob Lessio
16. Brandish
17. DeS Gray Fullbuster
18. Natsu
19. Gildarts Clive
20. Mard Geer Tartaros
21. DF Gajeel
22. Base Gray Fullbuster
23. Ajeel Lamur
24. Ikatsunagi
25. Neinhart
26. Full Power Precht Gaebolg
27. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
27. Wolfheim
29. Base Gajeel Redfox
29. Erza Scarlet
29. Warrod Sequen
32. DF Wendy Marvell
33. Lucy Heartfillia
34. Wahl Icht Proxy
35. Shaila
36. Hyberion
37. Future Rogue
38. Mirajane Strauss
39. Jura Neekis
40. Minerva Orlando
40. Marin Hollow
42. Ur
43. Juvia Lockster
43. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun
43. Third origin Chelia Blendy
46. Silver Fullbuster
47. Kyôka
48. Makarov Dreyar
49. Freed Justine
49. Lyon Vastia
49. Meredy
52. Azuma
53. Kagura Mikazuchi
54. Bickslow
55. Bluenote Stinger
56. Elfman Strauss
56. Cana Alberona
56. Chelia Blendy
59. Evergreen
60. Base Wendy Marvell
61. Mest Gryder
62. Levy Mcgarden
63. Lisanna Strauss
64. Ikaruga
 

Yunkers

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2016
Messages
676
Reaction score
790
Age
32
Country
Poland
1. Acnologia
2. Zeref Dragneel
3. Igneel
4. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
5. Full Power Precht Gaebolg
6. Future Rogue
6. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
8. August
8. Irene Belserion
10. Mard Geer Tartaros
11. Shaila
12. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
12. God Serena
12. Bradman
12. Jacob Lessio
12. Brandish
12. Wahl Icht
18. Kyôka
19. Silver Fullbuster
20. Igneel-powered Natsu
21. Gildarts Clive
22. Jellal Fernandes
23. Laxus Dreyar
23. DeS Gray Fullbuster
25. Mirajane Strauss
26. Ikatsunagi
27. Third origin Chelia Blendy
28. Ajeel Lamur
28. Wahl Icht Proxy
30. Erza Scarlet
31. Hyberion
32. Wolfheim
33. DF Gajeel
34. Natsu
35. Neinhart
36. Jura Neekis
37. Minerva Orlando
38. Base Gray Fullbuster
39. Base Gajeel Redfox
40. DF Wendy Marvell
41. Ur
41. Bluenote Stinger
43. Kagura Mikazuchi
44. Azuma
45. Juvia Lockster
45. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
47. Makarov Dreyar
48. Evergreen
48. Bickslow
48. Freed Justine
51. Cana Alberona
52. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun
53. Marin Hollow
54. Lucy Heartfillia
55. Base Wendy Marvell
56. Lyon Vastia
57. Levy Mcgarden
58. Meredy
59. Chelia Blendy
60. Ikaruga
61. Elfman Strauss
62. Mest Gryder
63. Warrod Sequen
64. Lisanna Strauss
 

Char

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
689
Reaction score
1,963
Age
33
Country
Spain
Mira having Kyouka, Sayla and Torafusa take-overs at her disposal already puts her above Kagura/Minerva because those three characters are stronger then Kagura and Minerva.
I don't agree with your statement saying that Kagura/Minerva are weaker than Kyoka, Sayla and Torafusa. Remember GMG Kagura/Minerva are close to GMG Erza who beat Kyouka who's above Shaila and Torafusa.

I could see Kagura and Minerva losing to Kyoka or Shaila but not to Torafusa. I do agree, however, that current Mira is far stronger than any GMG female.

@Char I think you'll find my answers interesting, I don't even understand these rankings because my actual scale is quite different.
Hahaha remember that although the sorter is based off your scale, it's not always consistant. Sometimes we make a mistake in one vs and it automatically changes the scale. So please, remember to rearrange it. You can edit your post and change it to the scale you find more accurate according to your parameters.

So far I've got...

Mine
1. Acnologia

2. Igneel

3. Zeref Dragneel

4. Igneel-powered Natsu

4. Irene Belserion

6. August

7. Chronos Dimaria Yesta

8. Brandish

9. God Serena

10. Bradman

10. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)

12. Jacob Lessio

13. Laxus Dreyar

14. Jellal Fernandes

15. Ajeel Lamur

15. Wahl Icht

17. DF Gajeel

18. Natsu

19. DeS Gray Fullbuster

20. Erza Scarlet

20. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)

22. Neinhart

22. Full Power Precht Gaebolg

22. Mirajane Strauss

22. Gildarts Clive

26. Hyberion

26. Third origin Chelia Blendy

26. Kagura Mikazuchi

29. Base Gray Fullbuster

29. Mard Geer Tartaros

31. Wolfheim

31. Ikatsunagi

33. Warrod Sequen

34. Jura Neekis

34. Bluenote Stinger

36. Ur

37. Minerva Orlando

37. Marin Hollow

37. Freed Justine

37. Lyon Vastia

37. Shaila

42. Base Gajeel Redfox

42. DF Wendy Marvell

44. Makarov Dreyar

45. Future Rogue

46. Lucy Heartfillia

46. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney

48. Juvia Lockster

48. Kyôka

48. Silver Fullbuster

51. Cana Alberona

51. Evergreen

51. Mest Gryder

51. Azuma

51. Meredy

56. Bickslow

57. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun

57. Elfman Strauss

57. Ikaruga

60. Chelia Blendy

61. Levy Mcgarden

61. Base Wendy Marvell

61. Wahl Icht Proxy

64. Lisanna Strauss
@Jko
1. Acnologia
2. Zeref Dragneel
3. Igneel
4. Irene Belserion
5. August
6. Igneel-powered Natsu
7. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
8. Brandish
9. Wahl Icht
10. Laxus Dreyar
11. Natsu
12. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
13. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
13. Ikatsunagi
15. Mirajane Strauss
16. Third origin Chelia Blendy
17. DF Gajeel
18. Bradman
19. Ajeel Lamur
20. Gildarts Clive
21. Jacob Lessio
61. Mest Gryder
62. Lisanna Strauss
63. Levy Mcgarden
64. Ikaruga
@Jean Grey
1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Zeref
4. Irene Belserion
5. August
6. Natsu - Igneel's power
7. Chronos Dimaria Vesta
8. Brandish
9. Jacob Lession
10. God Serena
11. Laxus Dreyar
12. Wahl Ich
13. Natsu Dragneel
14. Ajeel Lamur
15. Erza
16. Gajeel
17. Brandman
18. DeS Gray
19. Base Gray
20. DF Wendy Marvel
21. Lucy Heartfilia
22. Base Wendy
@Plutogrim
1. Acnologia
2. Zeref
3. August
4. Irene
5. Dimaria
6. Brandish
7. God Serena
8. Jacob
9. Laxus
10. Jellal
11. Wahl
12. Mard
13. Azir
14. Jura
15. Erza
16. Gajeel
17. Gray
18. Mirajane
19. Kagura
20. Wendy
@Yunkers
1. Acnologia
2. Zeref Dragneel
3. Igneel
4. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
5. Full Power Precht Gaebolg
6. Future Rogue
6. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
8. August
8. Irene Belserion
10. Mard Geer Tartaros
11. Shaila
12. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
12. God Serena
12. Bradman
12. Jacob Lessio
12. Brandish
12. Wahl Icht
18. Kyôka
19. Silver Fullbuster
20. Igneel-powered Natsu
21. Gildarts Clive
22. Jellal Fernandes
23. Laxus Dreyar
23. DeS Gray Fullbuster
25. Mirajane Strauss
26. Ikatsunagi
27. Third origin Chelia Blendy
28. Ajeel Lamur
28. Wahl Icht Proxy
30. Erza Scarlet
31. Hyberion
32. Wolfheim
33. DF Gajeel
34. Natsu
35. Neinhart
36. Jura Neekis
37. Minerva Orlando
38. Base Gray Fullbuster
39. Base Gajeel Redfox
40. DF Wendy Marvell
41. Ur
41. Bluenote Stinger
43. Kagura Mikazuchi
44. Azuma
45. Juvia Lockster
45. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
47. Makarov Dreyar
48. Evergreen
48. Bickslow
48. Freed Justine
51. Cana Alberona
52. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun
53. Marin Hollow
54. Lucy Heartfillia
55. Base Wendy Marvell
56. Lyon Vastia
57. Levy Mcgarden
58. Meredy
59. Chelia Blendy
60. Ikaruga
61. Elfman Strauss
62. Mest Gryder
63. Warrod Sequen
64. Lisanna Strauss
@SaberToothFan
1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
4. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
5. Igneel-powered Natsu
5. Zeref Dragneel
7. August
7. Irene Belserion
9. Laxus Dreyar
9. Jellal Fernandes
11. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
12. God Serena
12. Wahl Icht
14. Bradman
15. Jacob Lessio
16. Brandish
17. DeS Gray Fullbuster
18. Natsu
19. Gildarts Clive
20. Mard Geer Tartaros
21. DF Gajeel
22. Base Gray Fullbuster
23. Ajeel Lamur
24. Ikatsunagi
25. Neinhart
26. Full Power Precht Gaebolg
27. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
27. Wolfheim
29. Base Gajeel Redfox
29. Erza Scarlet
29. Warrod Sequen
32. DF Wendy Marvell
33. Lucy Heartfillia
34. Wahl Icht Proxy
35. Shaila
36. Hyberion
37. Future Rogue
38. Mirajane Strauss
39. Jura Neekis
40. Minerva Orlando
40. Marin Hollow
42. Ur
43. Juvia Lockster
43. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun
43. Third origin Chelia Blendy
46. Silver Fullbuster
47. Kyôka
48. Makarov Dreyar
49. Freed Justine
49. Lyon Vastia
49. Meredy
52. Azuma
53. Kagura Mikazuchi
54. Bickslow
55. Bluenote Stinger
56. Elfman Strauss
56. Cana Alberona
56. Chelia Blendy
59. Evergreen
60. Base Wendy Marvell
61. Mest Gryder
62. Levy Mcgarden
63. Lisanna Strauss
64. Ikaruga
@Crimson Ice
1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
4. Igneel-powered Natsu
5. Zeref Dragneel
6. August
7. Irene Belserion
8. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
9. Laxus Dreyar
10. Jellal Fernandes
11. DF Gajeel
12. Wahl Icht
13. Bradman
14. Jacob Lessio
15. God Serena
16. DeS Gray Fullbuster
16. Natsu
18. Ajeel Lamur
19. Brandish
20. Neinhart
21. Base Gray Fullbuster
22. Base Gajeel Redfox
23. Erza Scarlet
24. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
25. Third origin Chelia Blendy
26. Mirajane Strauss
27. Hyberion
28. Wolfheim
29. Ikatsunagi
30. Mard Geer Tartaros
31. Full Power Precht Gaebolg
32. Makarov Dreyar
33. Silver Fullbuster
34. Future Rogue
35. DF Wendy Marvell
36. Ur
37. Minerva Orlando
38. Gildarts Clive
39. Warrod Sequen
40. Jura Neekis
41. Kagura Mikazuchi
42. Wahl Icht Proxy
43. Kyôka
44. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
45. Shaila
46. Bluenote Stinger
47. Azuma
48. Lyon Vastia
49. Juvia Lockster
50. Meredy
51. Freed Justine
52. Elfman Strauss
53. Lucy Heartfillia
54. Marin Hollow
@Brandish
1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
4. Igneel-powered Natsu
4. Zeref Dragneel
7. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
7. August
7. Irene Belserion
9. Laxus Dreyar
9. Jellal Fernandes
9. Natsu
9. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
13. God Serena
13. Wahl Icht
13. DF Gajeel
16. Ajeel Lamur
17. Bradman
17. Jacob Lessio
17. Brandish
20. Neinhart
21. Erza Scarlet
22. DeS Gray Fullbuster
22. Mard Geer Tartaros
22. Hyberion
25. Full Power Precht Gaebolg
26. Future Rogue
26. Gildarts Clive
28. Warrod Sequen
28. Third origin Chelia Blendy
28. Wolfheim
28. Ikatsunagi
32. Base Gajeel Redfox
32. Makarov Dreyar
32. Mirajane Strauss
32. Jura Neekis
36. Base Gray Fullbuster
36. Minerva Orlando
36. Kagura Mikazuchi
39. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
40. Elfman Strauss
40. Lyon Vastia
40. Bluenote Stinger
43. Ur
44. DF Wendy Marvell
44. Wahl Icht Proxy
44. Kyôka
44. Lucy Heartfillia
44. Cana Alberona
44. Freed Justine
44. Meredy
51. Silver Fullbuster
52. Shaila
52. Azuma
54. Juvia Lockster
55. Levy Mcgarden
55. Base Wendy Marvell
55. Marin Hollow
55. Lisanna Strauss
55. Evergreen
55. Bickslow
55. Mest Gryder
55. Ikaruga
55. Chelia Blendy
64. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun
@NoHana
1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
4. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
5. Igneel-powered Natsu
6. Shaila
7. Laxus Dreyar
8. Mirajane Strauss
8. DF Gajeel
10. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
11. God Serena
12. Natsu
12. Bradman
12. Lucy Heartfillia
15. Kagura Mikazuchi
16. Gildarts Clive
17. Future Rogue
17. Minerva Orlando
19. Jacob Lessio
20. Brandish
20. Neinhart
22. Third origin Chelia Blendy
23. Jellal Fernandes
23. Full Power Precht Gaebolg
25. Wahl Icht
25. Kyôka
25. Makarov Dreyar
28. Base Gajeel Redfox
28. Erza Scarlet
28. DeS Gray Fullbuster
31. Azuma
32. Zeref Dragneel
33. August
34. Ajeel Lamur
34. Irene Belserion
36. Base Gray Fullbuster
36. Warrod Sequen
36. Jura Neekis
39. Silver Fullbuster
39. Bluenote Stinger
41. Mard Geer Tartaros
42. Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
42. Hyberion
44. Wolfheim
45. Elfman Strauss
45. Ikatsunagi
47. DF Wendy Marvell
48. Ikaruga
49. Meredy
50. Chelia Blendy
51. Ur
52. Juvia Lockster
52. Wahl Icht Proxy
54. Marin Hollow
54. Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun
54. Lyon Vastia
57. Base Wendy Marvell
58. Levy Mcgarden
59. Lisanna Strauss
59. Cana Alberona
59. Freed Justine
62. Evergreen
62. Bickslow
62. Mest Gryder
@Talenel
1 Acnologia
2 Zeref Dragneel
3 Igneel
4 Igneel-powered Natsu
5 August
6 Irene Belserion
7 DeS Gray Fullbuster
8 Natsu
9 Jellal Fernandes
10 Laxus Dreyar

11 Base Gray Fullbuster
12 DF Gajeel
13 God Serena
14 Wahl Icht
15 Ajeel Lamur
16 Brandish
17 Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
18 Ikatsunagi
19 Erza Scarlet
20 Mirajane Strauss
21 Ur
22 Neinhart
23 Base Gajeel Redfox
24 Third origin Chelia Blendy
25 Chronos Dimaria Yesta
26 Bradman
27 Jacob Lessio
28 Hyberion
29 Gildarts Clive
30 Wolfheim
31 Mard Geer Tartaros
32 Makarov Dreyar
33 Bluenote Stinger
34 DF Wendy Marvell
35 Kyôka
36 Future Rogue
37 Kagura Mikazuchi
38 Wahl Icht Proxy
39 Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
40 Full Power Precht Gaebolg
41 Silver Fullbuster
42 Juvia Lockster
43 Heine Lunacy or Juliet Sun
44 Jura Neekis
45 Warrod Sequen
46 Minerva Orlando
47 Lyon Vastia
48 Meredy
49 Shaila

50 Lucy Heartfillia
51 Base Wendy Marvell
52 Sting Eucliff or Rogue Cheney
53 Chelia Blendy
54 Freed Justine
55 Elfman Strauss
56 Evergreen
57 Marin Hollow
58 Bickslow
59 Cana Alberona

60 Azuma
61 Ikaruga
62 Mest Gryder
63 Levy Mcgarden
64 Lisanna Strauss

Thanks to the ones who've already participated. I'm expecting way more participation! Also, if any of the ones who've participated want to change their post, please, edit your scale and then let me know.
 

Ebony Maw

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 8, 2016
Messages
1,995
Reaction score
8,124
Gender
Male
Country
Sabertooth
Hahaha remember that although the sorter is based off your scale, it's not always consistant. Sometimes we make a mistake in one vs and it automatically changes the scale. So please, remember to rearrange it. You can edit your post and change it to the scale you find more accurate according to your parameters.

Thanks to the ones who've already participated. I'm expecting way more participation! Also, if any of the ones who've participated want to change their post, please, edit your scale and then let me know.
Honestly my scale isn't that bad until the lower levels so I'll keep it how it is for now and then alter it if I feel I need to. Good idea btw Char, also I'm liking the new profile pic.
 

Char

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
689
Reaction score
1,963
Age
33
Country
Spain
Honestly my scale isn't that bad until the lower levels so I'll keep it how it is for now and then alter it if I feel I need to. Good idea btw Char,
That's fine! Let's see how the communitary mangahelpers final ranking looks when it's done!

also I'm liking the new profile pic.
Yeah, there are a couple of photoshop hours in there, but I'm proud of the result, thanks :hearts
 

Takuan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
1,839
Reaction score
7,564
Age
33
Country
France
Thanks @Char for your work. =)

Alright here's my to 20:

1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Zeref Dragneel
4. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
5. Irene Belserion
6. Igneel-powered Natsu
7. August
8. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
9. Brandish
10. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
11. God Serena
12. Laxus Dreyar
13. Jellal Fernandes
14. Gildarts Clive
15. Mirajane Strauss
16. Wahl Icht
17. Hyberion
18. Jacob Lessio
19. Ajeel Lamur
20. DeS Gray Fullbuster

I'd like to congratulate Lisanna for finishing last in my list, which proves if needed that she is indeed the "embodiment of uselessness".
 

Shoutmon

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 21, 2016
Messages
754
Reaction score
1,483
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Antarctica
Well that took a while XD. There's a lot people who tied in my list because I was honestly unsure of who would win in a lot of the matchups, but at least I tried XD.
1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
4. Igneel-powered Natsu
4. Zeref Dragneel
6. August
7. Irene Belserion
8. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
8. Bradman
8. Jacob Lessio
11. Laxus Dreyar
12. Jellal Fernandes
12. Natsu
12. God Serena
12. DF Gajeel
16. Wahl Icht
17. Ajeel Lamur
18. Mirajane Strauss
18. Gildarts Clive
20. Ikatsunagi
 

Char

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
689
Reaction score
1,963
Age
33
Country
Spain
Thanks @Char for your work. =)

Alright here's my to 20:

1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Zeref Dragneel
4. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
5. Irene Belserion
6. Igneel-powered Natsu
7. August
8. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
9. Brandish
10. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
11. God Serena
12. Laxus Dreyar
13. Jellal Fernandes
14. Gildarts Clive
15. Mirajane Strauss
16. Wahl Icht
17. Hyberion
18. Jacob Lessio
19. Ajeel Lamur
20. DeS Gray Fullbuster

I'd like to congratulate Lisanna for finishing last in my list, which proves if needed that she is indeed the "embodiment of uselessness".
Thanks for the list :) Also if you've still got the results of the 64 characters list, you can post it!

I laughed hard at your comment on Lisanna xDD

@Shoutmon thanks!! A top20 is good but I say to you the same I say to everybody, if you want to enlarge or change your list, you've got time to do so but let me know!
 

Demon Hunter

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jun 16, 2016
Messages
4,434
Reaction score
12,850
Gender
Male
Country
Croatia
Thanks for the list :) Also if you've still got the results of the 64 characters list, you can post it!

I laughed hard at your comment on Lisanna xDD

@Shoutmon thanks!! A top20 is good but I say to you the same I say to everybody, if you want to enlarge or change your list, you've got time to do so but let me know!
I added Jellal to my list. I forgot about him :)
1. Acnologia
2. Igneel
3. Zeref
4. Irene Belserion
5. August
6. Natsu - Igneel's power
7. Chronos Dimaria Vesta
8. Brandish
9. Jacob Lession
10. God Serena
11. Laxus Dreyar
12. Wahl Ich
13. Jellal Fernandes
14. Natsu Dragneel
15. Ajeel Lamur
16. Erza
17. Gajeel
18. Brandman
19. DeS Gray
20. Base Gray
21. DF Wendy Marvel
22. Lucy Heartfilia
23. Base Wendy
 

Alvarez Princess

Banned
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jul 1, 2016
Messages
148
Reaction score
450
Country
New Zealand
Just did top 20, it was a nice site to sort things out :)

1. Acnologia
2. Zeref Dragneel
3. Igneel
4. Parent Dragons (Metallicana, etc.)
5. Other dragons (Zirconis, etc.)
6. August
7. Igneel-powered Natsu
8. Irene
9. God Serena
10. Laxus Dreyar
11. Chronos Dimaria Yesta
12. Wahl Icht
13. Jellal Fernandes
14. DeS Gray Fullbuster
15. Natsu
16. Ajeel Lamur
17. DF Gajeel
18. Brandish
19. Bradman
20. Jacob Lessio
 

Takuan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
1,839
Reaction score
7,564
Age
33
Country
France
@Char damn, i don't have my full list anymore :S
Well i'll do it again if you want, in an hour or so. =)
 
Top