That's the problem. I don't want assumptions. I want some actual evidence. We don't know what erza could or could not do because she was in no state to do anything anyway.
I missed your post of the results. Thanks for all your work!!
I would say Brandish is actually the most overrated, for someone who has no fighting feats. She has no business being above Jellal imo.
In that case what would be accurate? What do you propose in order to make an accurate list ?
Laxus blitzed him 4 times. He kicked him, then punched him, then smashed him into the floor and then smashed him into the floor again later on. Laxus missed him once with a punch and once with a roar. Laxus fell to knees but he was far from done in, he still had plenty of MP left, and he then proceeded to endure one of Hades blasts with none of it.
Laxus did not loose, he temporarily fell to his knees. He did not utilize most of his MP because he wanted to give the honours of beating Hades up to Natsu. Falling to your knees for a second =/= defeated.
She's also overrated.
Its never been overly up. The strongest she has frozen was Kagura, and even she was implied to have seen through to an extent. I refuse to believe it works on Spriggan level characters until it does. As of now nothing there to suggest it would, especially given that she considers her God Soul her Spriggan level trump card. We'll hopefully see in due time. If it works perfectly on a Spriggan level character then I concede (though then there is still characters like Irene and August who are leagues above the other Spriggan and Acnologia who is leagues above them), but I'm having doubts that's what's going to happen (cause I doubt DiMaria is going to win the war here).
Agreed. If Hyberion and Wolfheim go on to solo a Spriggan then Serena is something else (at least as far as attack power goes) but I'm finding it hard to believe.
First of all, thank you!!
if you ask Mashima, his bae Natsu would be at the top of the food chain no matter what manga says.
With Erza coming second? :P
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Dude don't worry i agree with you =)
That's highly inaccurate. Lucy's never had high amounts of MP thus she's very, very, very far from reaching Natsu, Erza or Gray in terms of MP. This gap hasn't been closed after the timeskip because, although Lucy has improved enormously, so have the others.
well, if she can use the power of CSK then she would most likely be a top tier. she can't do that yet(I hope she does in the future). he/she probably means because of that.People are too salty. I've been polite when giving my opinion. You cannot even properly explain why you dislike the word accurate when it totally represents the communal ranking. The communal list might definetely differ a lot from yours but your list was included. If you don't agree with the result it's your problem, but it's accurate.
You're biased, you cannot defend your arguments and to top it off, you're disrespectful. It's the attitude when someone feels cornered :P
If you want to debate politely I suggest you learn some manners!
Can you please provide me with an argument that defends that Lucy should have more MP than any in Natsu's team? Oh, without bashing please, I'll be offended
I was actually surprised at how high Bradman was lol, looks like my Bradman crusade was received well. I was also pleasantly surprised that the GoI were so high in the rankings, I thought they'd end up victims of hype. I'm definitely looking forward to doing this again, I'll see if I can get Bradman and ST higher, muahahahaha....
Isn't the CSK just on Mard Geer's level? Unless he grew stronger himself I don't see how Lucy wielding that power would put her on top tier level, at the best she would be top 15 and thats pushing it even..
well, CSK is slow as fuck. if one of his attacks connected with Mard Geer then he would have been one shotted. I don't remember that battle but I don't think any of his attacks actually connected but they were massive. I also think that CSK was restricted because of Lucy' MP.
