Before next game, we gonna have a meeting and update the rules. 


Yes! All 50+ roles are supposed to be in our 22 players game!!!Just a quick noob question, are all the roles supposed to be in the game? I mean we've only got so many people
No I mean, we'd always handle it like this, we just didn't think we'd have to update the rules for it. The same we and my predecessors didn't put in that you can get penalty votes.Wait what? You did not think how you handle ties before game? WHAT?
I appreaciate you two hosting two big games so frequently, but isn't the major thing of hosting to think as many solutions before the actual problems come? How you handle ties is definetly one of the most common sequences.
Was thinking of lovers too.No, I guess a Mafia wouldn't.
But if Xnut was a Mentor and you were a Mentee, you would.
And also, if you were lovers, you would.
Check the Mason role one above Recruiting Mason, Gry. We had games in which Masons started as a group already, nothing new. It's why I don't want Xnut deaht to be in vain. if he dies and is Mason, you guys know I told the truth. If I told the truth the dets will believe (hopefully) and investigate me. And If the mafia won't kill me tonight then I will get lynched next day phase to avoid an important townie role death!Recruiting Mason (Townie Cult): A Recruiting Mason is a a Mason Group Leader that usually starts all by himself and tries to recruit one player each Night. He selects one player each night to try to recruit. If he picks a Pro-Townie Role, then that player joins the Group and is able to talk with other Group Members in the Group during the Nights. The Recruiting Mason dies if he attempts to recruit a Mafia Member or a Third Party. (GAME 6)
This small "usually" is heavily saving your ass right now James. Maybe you both already started together but...wtf is this shitfest?
did holt give any hint about his role?....james sounds very believableSo guys what now? Do we save xnut by trusting james? Who do we kill instead then? Holt?
No, only the ones the hosts want to use.Just a quick noob question, are all the roles supposed to be in the game? I mean we've only got so many people
James is right, there's no requirement for a recruiter or that there can't be Masons from the beginning.......but the claim is a bit crazy to do.This small "usually" is heavily saving your ass right now James. Maybe you both already started together but...wtf is this shitfest?
Yeah, I sort of wanted to bring this up after the last game due to stuff, but we went right back into sign-upsBefore next game, we gonna have a meeting and update the rules.![]()

iirc he didn't. But many didn't reveal anything either so I doubt that's a valid reason for killing him.did holt give any hint about his role?....james sounds very believable
Doesn't matter if he is believable or not.did holt give any hint about his role?....james sounds very believable
Sorry man, that was the only way I saw making some good out of Xnut death. Telling you something that only a Mason could know. No Mafia can know at day 1 who is Mason, only Masons. If Xnut dies and is Mason, voila you know I told you the truth. If I die and am Mason voila, you know I told you the truth. I would prefer to die next day phase though after all detectives have investigated me, or better get killed by Mafia tonight but I doubt they gonna do me the favor now maybe a third role party will to make things more interesting.I am sleepy and james you successfully fucked my head.You are acting so awkward,that claim was also suspicous wtf

Don't ask them to reveal them xD If anything, let mafia gamble on who could be the recruiter. As Gary said, it's not mandatory that there's one, but in case there is, it's better to let the dude alive.iirc he didn't. But many didn't reveal anything either so I doubt that's a valid reason for killing him.
I agree that james does sound believable now. If only xnut was here to confirm his story.
Is any of you a recruiter james? Or are you just two random stranded masons?
True, especially if Holt is detective or doctor. But if he is and he is in such a predictment and still haven't given any hitn regarding his role then he might be Mafia who was caught on his wrong feet.Doesn't matter if he is believable or not.
We had no reason whatsoever to kill Holt (none that was presented in this thread) up until the last second in which James locked on Holt to kill him.
And at this point, if it's between the two, I'd rather kill a regular mason in xnut than an absolute question mark in Holt.
I give a damn if they are more likely townies than Holt D:If they are both Masons, we need to know if either of them are a recruiter. If not, who gives a shit if one of them dies. James' gambit here doesn't really make much sense if both are just vanilla Masons.