Discussion Power/Abilities thread

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
Yeah right stabbing his hearts didnt weaken him. I wonder what manga have you been reading???? Jesus christ go back to the chapter and see how loyal the people were to zeldris when they were affected by his decree. Kindly read back the manga again to refresh your memory. U are telling me he hated them only when he used revenge counter?? Then fine, answer me why estarossa stepped in??? Even derrerie said estarossa stepping in saved their asses which means meliodas wasnt affected by their commandment. He already hated them when he defeat galan within 10 seconds but he still didnt succumb to their decree why??? U clearly misunderstood the dk words.. there is no such thing hating them suddenly when using revenge counter lol. No matter how caliber u are, the decree affection wil be the same. Look at galan and merlin. Their power level difference are about 20k+...... but still the decree affection is the same...
Drop the condescending tone.

Estarossa KILLED him, there was no debilitation there. That happened AFTER he was affected by the commandment.
So Meliodas ran away from Zeldris, the Demon King said Piety had affected him, and you're saying that I misunderstood the Demon King?
Zeldris' decree causes one to fall under a POWERFUL state of submission, not a definite one. Meliodas could've very well resisted it to some extent.
Yeah, because the others totally knew Love had affected Meliodas... it was indirectly and directly Estarossa who saved their asses.
I didn't see any hatred when Meliodas wrecked Galan, but have it your way, sir.

Galan's decree is a definite "you'll turn to stone" decree, whereas Zeldris' is "you'll not oppose me," which may very well vary in effectiveness.

Anyway, I suggest you re-read chapter 183.
> Demon King: "Even you, once stricken with the commandments of Piety and Love, had nothing to do but wait and die."
> Meliodas: "But thanks to that (meaning his death) I'm free of those now!"
> Demon King: "Indeed. There are two ways to lift the COMMANDMENTS I HAVE CREATED - one is to kill the Commandment who bestowed it upon you, and the other is death."

They were CLEARLY, INDISPUTABLY talking about the decrees.

Swoosh, boom.
 
Last edited:

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Meliodas does not need magic in order to use revenge counter because Revenge Counter doesn't require his magic, it requires the magical damage from others. The first thing Meliodas does is that he turns his powers off in order to truly charge his damage taken, then he takes the accumulated damage and just puts it into a blade. Meliodas could have -5000 magic, but as long as he can transfer damage from others into a blade and swing it, he can use revenge counter. The 10C noted this before they were going to die. Full counter requires magic in order to reflect attacks, Revenge Counter just requires him to use damage as a source of power since there's really nothing to it other than being a whipping boy. The only way Estarossa could've stopped the attack is by: A. Tanking it. Which is impossible because your average punch from Escanor at 10:00ish does more damage to him than the revenge counter x30 from the past. So unless Escanor punches harder than that, it's very unlikely
B. Using love
We already know Estarossa doesn't have counter vanish because he's the full counter opposite of Meliodas
 
Last edited:

Demonspeed

The Bull
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,829
Reaction score
61,582
Gender
Male
Country
France
Meliodas does not need magic in order to use revenge counter because Revenge Counter doesn't require his magic, it requires the magical damage from others. The first thing Meliodas does is that he turns his powers off in order to truly charge his damage taken, then he takes the accumulated damage and just puts it into a blade. Meliodas could have -5000 magic, but as long as he can transfer damage from others into a blade and swing it, he can use revenge counter. The 10C noted this before they were going to die. Full counter requires magic in order to reflect attacks, Revenge Counter just requires him to use damage as a source of power since there's really nothing to it other than being a whipping boy. The only way Estarossa could've stopped the attack is by: A. Tanking it. Which is impossible because your average punch from Escanor at 10:00ish does more damage to him than the revenge counter x30 from the past. So unless Escanor punches harder than that, it's very unlikely
B. Using love
We already know Estarossa doesn't have counter vanish because he's the full counter opposite of Meliodas
It's Magic but his own Magic stat is irrelevant, just like his normal Full Counter. If he had not awakened that Magic it would have been impossible. And the energy in his sword slash is definitely magical. It's a Full Counter technique, no one else can suppress his energy and release it like that besides maybe Estarossa.

There is no way a punch from Escanor can be as powerful than that. Estarossa stopped Revenge with Love so of course none of took damages.
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It's Magic but his own Magic stat is irrelevant, just like his normal Full Counter. If he had not awakened that Magic it would have been impossible. And the energy in his sword slash is definitely magical. It's a Full Counter technique, no one else can suppress his energy and release it like that besides maybe Estarossa.

There is no way a punch from Escanor can be as powerful than that. Estarossa stopped Revenge with Love so of course none of took damages.
I know it's magic, I was just stating that Meliodas does not need to have his magical reserves in use to use revenge counter because he turns them off so that he can take more damage and fire it back. And I know that Escanor did not punch as hard as a revenge counter, I stated that in my earlier post so that people would stop saying that he tanked it. It would make no sense for a punch from Escanor to drop Estarossa to his knees, but a revenge counter cannot faze him. In short, his commandment did the work.
 

Gaggen

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
574
Reaction score
385
Age
28
Country
Malaysia
Drop the condescending tone.

Estarossa KILLED him, there was no debilitation there. That happened AFTER he was affected by the commandment.
So Meliodas ran away from Zeldris, the Demon King said Piety had affected him, and you're saying that I misunderstood the Demon King?
Zeldris' decree causes one to fall under a POWERFUL state of submission, not a definite one. Meliodas could've very well resisted it to some extent.
Yeah, because the others totally knew Love had affected Meliodas... it was indirectly and directly Estarossa who saved their asses.
I didn't see any hatred when Meliodas wrecked Galan, but have it your way, sir.

Galan's decree is a definite "you'll turn to stone" decree, whereas Zeldris' is "you'll not oppose me," which may very well vary in effectiveness.

Anyway, I suggest you re-read chapter 183.
> Demon King: "Even you, once stricken with the commandments of Piety and Love, had nothing to do but wait and die."
> Meliodas: "But thanks to that (meaning his death) I'm free of those now!"
> Demon King: "Indeed. There are two ways to lift the COMMANDMENTS I HAVE CREATED - one is to kill the Commandment who bestowed it upon you, and the other is death."

They were CLEARLY, INDISPUTABLY talking about the decrees.

Swoosh, boom.
Thats is your way of belief but not mine. Once stricken with piety, one should be loyal to zeldris and hail him.... and for estarossa's love, mel shouldnt even initiate revenge counter in the first place and shouldnt even summon any strength cause howzer himself said it and they shouldnt even inflict damage to the others... thats a major plot hole. No one can resist the decree not even the commandments themselves. You are clearly creating your own story and u can keep your submission thingy to yourself. Mel resist it??? Come on he is no longer the representative of the demon king, if it was zeldris i will give in but this is mel, he has already been converted. Besides the demon king said even the likes of mel cant do anything when they are stricken they can only wait and die or defeat them. Kabooom!!! Yeah right mel was in love with galan when he fought him lol.... when he warn the commandments that the sins will crush them with all they got he definitely hated them at that very moment....
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I know it's magic, I was just stating that Meliodas does not need to have his magical reserves in use to use revenge counter because he turns them off so that he can take more damage and fire it back. And I know that Escanor did not punch as hard as a revenge counter, I stated that in my earlier post so that people would stop saying that he tanked it. It would make no sense for a punch from Escanor to drop Estarossa to his knees, but a revenge counter cannot faze him. In short, his commandment did the work.
Excuse me to turn people magic against themselves requires your own magic, like how estarossa engulf escanor's sun and render it useless..... to initiate any counter requires magic including counter vanish.
 
Last edited:

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
Thats is your way of belief but not mine. Once stricken with piety, one should be loyal to zeldris and hail him.... and for estarossa's love, mel shouldnt even initiate revenge counter in the first place and shouldnt even summon any strength cause howzer himself said it and they shouldnt even inflict damage to the others... thats a major plot hole. No one can resist the decree not even the commandments themselves. You are clearly creating your own story and u can keep your submission thingy to yourself. Mel resist it??? Come on he is no longer the representative of the demon king, if it was zeldris i will give in but this is mel, he has already been converted. Besides the demon king said even the likes of mel cant do anything when they are stricken they can only wait and die or defeat them. Kabooom!!! Yeah right mel was in love with galan when he fought him lol.... when he warn the commandments that the sins will crush them with all they got he definitely hated them at that very moment....
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Excuse me to turn people magic against themselves requires your own magic, like how estarossa engulf escanor's sun and render it useless..... to initiate any counter requires magic including counter vanish.
I just proved to you that he was stricken with the decrees, so anything you say is vacant, to be honest. It's the truth, and that's all there is to it.
Since I've provided proof that he was affected by them, the only logical explanation is that he felt hatred while he was launching RC. You very well know that the previous Meliodas didn't want to kill any of the TC, so he clearly didn't hate them when he attacked Galan. You can have "neutral" emotions in a fight.

I said he MAY have resisted Piety to some extent, not that he CAN. Even if he didn't become a slave, he probably was affected by it to the point that he couldn't harm Zeldris.
There are certainly inconsistencies here (and I see how all of us, even I, don't see the effects of Piety), but Meliodas was obviously affected by both, and you can't disprove that, since they're the Demon King's and Meliodas' words.
 

Gaggen

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
574
Reaction score
385
Age
28
Country
Malaysia
I just proved to you that he was stricken with the decrees, so anything you say is vacant, to be honest. It's the truth, and that's all there is to it.
Since I've provided proof that he was affected by them, the only logical explanation is that he felt hatred while he was launching RC. You very well know that the previous Meliodas didn't want to kill any of the TC, so he clearly didn't hate them when he attacked Galan. You can have "neutral" emotions in a fight.

I said he MAY have resisted Piety to some extent, not that he CAN. Even if he didn't become a slave, he probably was affected by it to the point that he couldn't harm Zeldris.
There are certainly inconsistencies here (and I see how all of us, even I, don't see the effects of Piety), but Meliodas was obviously affected by both, and you can't disprove that, since they're the Demon King's and Meliodas' words.
Just because demon king and meliodas said it i should believe??? Each decree has only one effect. There is no such thing that mel cant harm zeldris and all.... that look on mel's face when he slashed zeldris neck definitely he hated him..... and tell me where was the effect of charity then???? He shouldnt be able to even lift lostvayne if he was affected by it. If he could even resist it, demon king definitely will note it out. When there are inconsistencies in the characters, do you really expect me to believe their words for 100%???? I am sorry but i cant give in. He didnt harm zeldris,? U must be kidding me. No wonder zeldris had to release his arm and retreat when mel kicked him...
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
Just because demon king and meliodas said it i should believe??? Each decree has only one effect. There is no such thing that mel cant harm zeldris and all.... that look on mel's face when he slashed zeldris neck definitely he hated him..... and tell me where was the effect of charity then???? He shouldnt be able to even lift lostvayne if he was affected by it. If he could even resist it, demon king definitely will note it out. When there are inconsistencies in the characters, do you really expect me to believe their words for 100%???? I am sorry but i cant give in. He didnt harm zeldris,? U must be kidding me. No wonder zeldris had to release his arm and retreat when mel kicked him...
Yes, because it's canon and confirmed. If you're put into a state of submission, you won't harm the one whom you submit to, in this case Zeldris. Don't take everything literally - Love is not the only one which makes you unable to harm someone, it's the only one which does it DIRECTLY.
Nope, he cares about Zeldris to some extent (although he had no other option but to try to kill him in that instance). Mel is very hard to read, and I'm pretty sure he didn't hate Zeldris there.
I said this so many times: he was probably affected MIDWAY, while releasing his Revenge Counter - this is the only explanation there is, since we know that he'd been affected by it, and the RC completely vanished, it wasn't blocked. You should be aware how much damage that amount of magic should do, even when blocked.
And again, I said "may have resisted it to some extent", not "resisted" it.
He ran away from Zeldris after he tried to slash Zeldris' throat, so Piety would've activated after that. Of course he could oppose him before that.

Please feel free not to give in, but I'm simply quoting what has been established as a fact. None of us know what effects Piety had on him, but it was confirmed.
 
Last edited:

Gaggen

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
574
Reaction score
385
Age
28
Country
Malaysia
Yes, because it's canon and confirmed. If you're put into a state of submission, you won't harm the one whom you submit to, in this case Zeldris. Don't take everything literally - Love is not the only one which makes you unable to harm someone, it's the only one which does it DIRECTLY.
Nope, he cares about Zeldris to some extent (although he had no other option but to try to kill him in that instance). Mel is very hard to read, and I'm pretty sure he didn't hate Zeldris there.
I said this so many times: he was probably affected MIDWAY, while releasing his Revenge Counter - this is the only explanation there is, since we know that he'd been affected by it, and the RC completely vanished, it wasn't blocked. You should be aware how much damage that amount of magic should do, even when blocked.
And again, I said "may have resisted it to some extent", not "resisted" it.
He ran away from Zeldris after he tried to slash Zeldris' throat, so Piety would've activated after that. Of course he could oppose him before that.

Please feel free not to give in, but I'm simply quoting what has been established as a fact. None of us know what effects Piety had on him, but it was confirmed.
He didnt shade a tear when he was battling his brother or even talking to him. Its ridiculous to change your emotions in miliseconds. Come on where is the logic. It was barely a second when estarossa got in and stopped him. If he was really affected by charity at that very moment, Estarossa wouldnt even bother stepping in because his decree also works from a distance like it did to gilthunder and co. He also hated dolor and gloxinia and intend to finish them there but where is charity when the commandments came in??? Alright fine, where was charity when ban stepped in and holded estarossa??? Where was pacifist when merascylla was taken out??? Where was repose effect when meliodas was battling gloxinia??? Where was patience when he was taking dolor and gloxinia out one by one continously?? How are you gonna answer these questions???? If you are successful in giving me these answers then i will readily give in.... besides meliodas is no stranger to these commandments. I am pretty sure he knows how they work since he has been with them for quite a time....
 

oceanfrost

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2009
Messages
58
Reaction score
108
Gender
Hidden
Country
Singapore
He didnt shade a tear when he was battling his brother or even talking to him. Its ridiculous to change your emotions in miliseconds. Come on where is the logic. It was barely a second when estarossa got in and stopped him. If he was really affected by charity at that very moment, Estarossa wouldnt even bother stepping in because his decree also works from a distance like it did to gilthunder and co. He also hated dolor and gloxinia and intend to finish them there but where is charity when the commandments came in??? Alright fine, where was charity when ban stepped in and holded estarossa??? Where was pacifist when merascylla was taken out??? Where was repose effect when meliodas was battling gloxinia??? Where was patience when he was taking dolor and gloxinia out one by one continously?? How are you gonna answer these questions???? If you are successful in giving me these answers then i will readily give in.... besides meliodas is no stranger to these commandments. I am pretty sure he knows how they work since he has been with them for quite a time....
You're not even trying to make sense.

Meliodas didn't hate Gloxinia nor Dolor. He was just of the thought that if they could not be saved, then he would have to finish them off.

Ban obviously didn't hate Estarossa then, or he wouldn't be able to attempt a stranglehold. He was angry and desperate but not hateful; he only began to nurse his hatred for Estarossa after Meliodas was killed.

The upcoming chapter explains that if there is something else affecting one's time, such as it being frozen, then Pacifism cannot affect that person. Merlin's time was frozen by her ability and she was thus not affected, so it stands to reason that since Ban's time is eternal, Pacifism cannot affect him either. Alternatively, it just means that Merascylla isn't dead. On the contrary, why aren't you arguing about why Estarossa isn't affected by Pacifism? He clearly killed Meliodas, yet has none of the excuses Ban or Merlin has with regards to eternal time/life.

Why was Repose and Patience not activated? Simply because Meliodas did not break those Commandments. This argument of yours is particularly weak, since neither of their effects nor their triggers have been revealed. And precisely because Meliodas is no stranger to those commandments, he would know very well how to not fall for them. Until it is revealed what they do, no one needs to give you an answer.

Also, a possible answer to the conundrum of Meliodas's 'sudden' hatred for the 10 Commandments could be that he hates Estarossa and Estarossa only. It was barely a second when Estarossa came in and stopped him, yes. He went up to and touched his sword, and at that very moment the Love Commandment activated and dissipated the Revenge Counter. Meliodas has acknowledged and interacted with most of the 10 Commandments. All, except for Estarossa. You could argue that he barely interacted with Merascylla and Graylord too, but Estarossa is his own younger brother. He greets his youngest brother, but not the one who idolized him, who fought with him all the way up to his betrayal and who is known to have some sort of relationship with Elizabeth in the past that led to him appearing in her dream(as proven in his entry in the most recent fanbook)? Up until his death he did not speak to him, did not look at him in the eye, did not bother to acknowledge him, and Estarossa had to crush his ribcage just so he can hear his voice directed towards him again. If his forced avoidance was not Mel doing his very hardest to avoid being influenced by his own hatred and thus the Love Commandment, then I don't know why he wouldn't at least greet Estarossa the way he did Zeldris.
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
He didnt shade a tear when he was battling his brother or even talking to him. Its ridiculous to change your emotions in miliseconds. Come on where is the logic. It was barely a second when estarossa got in and stopped him. If he was really affected by charity at that very moment, Estarossa wouldnt even bother stepping in because his decree also works from a distance like it did to gilthunder and co. He also hated dolor and gloxinia and intend to finish them there but where is charity when the commandments came in??? Alright fine, where was charity when ban stepped in and holded estarossa??? Where was pacifist when merascylla was taken out??? Where was repose effect when meliodas was battling gloxinia??? Where was patience when he was taking dolor and gloxinia out one by one continously?? How are you gonna answer these questions???? If you are successful in giving me these answers then i will readily give in.... besides meliodas is no stranger to these commandments. I am pretty sure he knows how they work since he has been with them for quite a time....
You don't shed a tear when your fight against your brother decides your comrades' survival. Meliodas can very effectively hide his emotions, as stated by Dolor.
Like I said, why not have Estarossa go in and stop it like a badass? It was supposed to make him look powerful. He was also the one who thought he was supposed to slay Meliodas, as said by him himself, so why not enter and do it when the audience is expecting great things from him? This is a manga, it would be very anticlimactic to have him just stand there and watch RC vanish.
And again, like I've said multiple times, 53.000 strength is not enough to block something of that caliber, and RC vanished, it wasn't blocked.

1. He never hated Dolor and Gloxinia. He was clearly holding back, trying not to kill them like King said. Only after he realized how far they'd fallen into darkness did he decide to finish them off.
2. Ban probably didn't have any hatred back then, but what's the point? We saw him be affected later (implying he's not immune), so this has nothing to do with our discussion.
3. Ban's youth is eternal, so Pacifism didn't work on him when he killed Merascylla. Pretty obvious.
4. We don't know how Repose and Patience work, so I have no idea why you're bringing those up.

Galan, who himself has had that decree for ages, broke it. It's really, really hard to control ALL of your emotions and fall prey to none of them while battling against all of them. It's very understandable how Meliodas was affected by two, and it's even confirmed. Why are you arguing against facts?
 
Last edited:

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Thats is your way of belief but not mine. Once stricken with piety, one should be loyal to zeldris and hail him.... and for estarossa's love, mel shouldnt even initiate revenge counter in the first place and shouldnt even summon any strength cause howzer himself said it and they shouldnt even inflict damage to the others... thats a major plot hole. No one can resist the decree not even the commandments themselves. You are clearly creating your own story and u can keep your submission thingy to yourself. Mel resist it??? Come on he is no longer the representative of the demon king, if it was zeldris i will give in but this is mel, he has already been converted. Besides the demon king said even the likes of mel cant do anything when they are stricken they can only wait and die or defeat them. Kabooom!!! Yeah right mel was in love with galan when he fought him lol.... when he warn the commandments that the sins will crush them with all they got he definitely hated them at that very moment....
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Excuse me to turn people magic against themselves requires your own magic, like how estarossa engulf escanor's sun and render it useless..... to initiate any counter requires magic including counter vanish.
Estarossa didn't turn Escanor's magic against him though. He just engulfed his sun to render it useless. Not to mention Demon Hendricksok noted that Meliodas's magic reserves were depleted by the time he started charging up his revenge counter, and this was also after he shut them off. For Estarossa It's kinda like throwing a wet towel over a candle. Also those are two different abilities. Meliodas used revenge counter and Estarossa used black out. Comparing those two is like comparing a tomato to a gorilla.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Guys, I'm pretty sure Meliodas fell to piety when he was unable to get up or move by himself. There's no statement that Piety has to transform you immedialty or that it makes you a mindless zombie immediately, it could be gradual. In part one after using revenge counter, Meliodas hopped up instantly, but here, he fell and was growing lethargic. Estarossa's love only makes you unable to fight, so reasonably, it was Zeldris that was making him slowly lethargic.
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
Guys, I'm pretty sure Meliodas fell to piety when he was unable to get up or move by himself. There's no statement that Piety has to transform you immedialty or that it makes you a mindless zombie immediately, it could be gradual. In part one after using revenge counter, Meliodas hopped up instantly, but here, he fell and was growing lethargic. Estarossa's love only makes you unable to fight, so reasonably, it was Zeldris that was making him slowly lethargic.
He broke it when he ran away from Zeldris, but the effects appeared to show at that time, I assume. Meliodas, no matter the circumstances, never seems to lose his will to fight, but he seemed to have lost all of his will at that time. The expression on his eyes went kind of bland, and he had no spirit to even stand up, or so it seemed.
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
He broke it when he ran away from Zeldris, but the effects appeared to show at that time, I assume. Meliodas, no matter the circumstances, never seems to lose his will to fight, but he seemed to have lost all of his will at that time. The expression on his eyes went kind of bland, and he had no spirit to even stand up, or so it seemed.
It has to be that. Revenge counter has never damaged his body to the point where he was that powerless, and it's very possible that Zeldris just has a slow acting commandment. It probably affects stronger people at a slower rate, or just has a time frame.
 

HereNThere

Alive Ain't Always Livin'
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
8,395
Reaction score
12,212
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It probably affects stronger people at a slower rate, or just has a time frame.
Like Gowther's Blackout, it might depend on the opponents level of Spirit. It might take effect instantly if your spirit is less than 2100, going by Mel's stats. The higher your spirit, the longer you can fight the mind control. I have no proof of that though.
 

Gaggen

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
574
Reaction score
385
Age
28
Country
Malaysia
You don't shed a tear when your fight against your brother decides your comrades' survival. Meliodas can very effectively hide his emotions, as stated by Dolor.
Like I said, why not have Estarossa go in and stop it like a badass? It was supposed to make him look powerful. He was also the one who thought he was supposed to slay Meliodas, as said by him himself, so why not enter and do it when the audience is expecting great things from him? This is a manga, it would be very anticlimactic to have him just stand there and watch RC vanish.
And again, like I've said multiple times, 53.000 strength is not enough to block something of that caliber, and RC vanished, it wasn't blocked.

1. He never hated Dolor and Gloxinia. He was clearly holding back, trying not to kill them like King said. Only after he realized how far they'd fallen into darkness did he decide to finish them off.
2. Ban probably didn't have any hatred back then, but what's the point? We saw him be affected later (implying he's not immune), so this has nothing to do with our discussion.
3. Ban's youth is eternal, so Pacifism didn't work on him when he killed Merascylla. Pretty obvious.
4. We don't know how Repose and Patience work, so I have no idea why you're bringing those up.

Galan, who himself has had that decree for ages, broke it. It's really, really hard to control ALL of your emotions and fall prey to none of them while battling against all of them. It's very understandable how Meliodas was affected by two, and it's even confirmed. Why are you arguing against facts?
He hated dolor and gloxinia and that was obvious. How come ban didnt hate estarossa??? Lol estarossa must be dead thats why his commandment is off just like the demon king said, get killed or defeat them. Meliodas showed no love to zeldris like esta did nor did he even bother talking to him. I am bringing up the others up because he went against most of the commandments decree and only got affected by two of them??? Do i look like a kid??? Sorry to say but your tricks wont work here. You are the one arguing against truth, if u have a pair of eyes to see the fight, its obvious he wasnt affected... just because demon king and mel said it, it now becomes fact ok fine. By the way estarossa wouldnt give a shit to step in and finish mel off. If he was interested, he would have been the first one to attack him.
Estarossa didn't turn Escanor's magic against him though. He just engulfed his sun to render it useless. Not to mention Demon Hendricksok noted that Meliodas's magic reserves were depleted by the time he started charging up his revenge counter, and this was also after he shut them off. For Estarossa It's kinda like throwing a wet towel over a candle. Also those are two different abilities. Meliodas used revenge counter and Estarossa used black out. Comparing those two is like comparing a tomato to a gorilla.
--- Double Post Merged, ---
Guys, I'm pretty sure Meliodas fell to piety when he was unable to get up or move by himself. There's no statement that Piety has to transform you immedialty or that it makes you a mindless zombie immediately, it could be gradual. In part one after using revenge counter, Meliodas hopped up instantly, but here, he fell and was growing lethargic. Estarossa's love only makes you unable to fight, so reasonably, it was Zeldris that was making him slowly lethargic.
Gorilla tomato. Nah u dont understand the concept. U see both blackout and revenge counter requires opponent and self magic, its just that blackout render enemy's magic useless whereas revenge counter is used against the enemy themselves. What i am trying to tell is u still need magic to manipulate your enemy's magic. And now zeldris decree affects lower power level easily, proof?? Neither there are proof that mel was lethargic... By the way fraudrin himself said things about zeldris piety. Kindly read back the chapter....
 

MrSchmitty7

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 20, 2016
Messages
3,656
Reaction score
6,861
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United States
He hated dolor and gloxinia and that was obvious. How come ban didnt hate estarossa??? Lol estarossa must be dead thats why his commandment is off just like the demon king said, get killed or defeat them. Meliodas showed no love to zeldris like esta did nor did he even bother talking to him. I am bringing up the others up because he went against most of the commandments decree and only got affected by two of them??? Do i look like a kid??? Sorry to say but your tricks wont work here. You are the one arguing against truth, if u have a pair of eyes to see the fight, its obvious he wasnt affected... just because demon king and mel said it, it now becomes fact ok fine. By the way estarossa wouldnt give a shit to step in and finish mel off. If he was interested, he would have been the first one to attack him.

Gorilla tomato. Nah u dont understand the concept. U see both blackout and revenge counter requires opponent and self magic, its just that blackout render enemy's magic useless whereas revenge counter is used against the enemy themselves. What i am trying to tell is u still need magic to manipulate your enemy's magic. And now zeldris decree affects lower power level easily, proof?? Neither there are proof that mel was lethargic... By the way fraudrin himself said things about zeldris piety. Kindly read back the chapter....
Revenge counter doesn't require magic. Hendrickson said so and noted that Meliodas didn't even have any magic left to use his full counter abilities. The 10C also said he shut his magic off and wasn't using it. Meliodas did become lethargic, he needed ban to lift him to his knees despite the fact that Revenge Counter doesn't make him weak. Also we said Zeldris's piety effect acting slowly was a theory already. I don't need to refer back to the manga. However you saying that Meliodas needs magic to use Revenge counter goes against Hendrickson's own words and the words of the 10C. Saying Meliodas wasn't lethargic goes against the evidence of Ban having to lift him to his feet, despite the fact that he could stand fine seconds earlier.
 

Gaggen

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
574
Reaction score
385
Age
28
Country
Malaysia
You're not even trying to make sense.

Meliodas didn't hate Gloxinia nor Dolor. He was just of the thought that if they could not be saved, then he would have to finish them off.

Ban obviously didn't hate Estarossa then, or he wouldn't be able to attempt a stranglehold. He was angry and desperate but not hateful; he only began to nurse his hatred for Estarossa after Meliodas was killed.

The upcoming chapter explains that if there is something else affecting one's time, such as it being frozen, then Pacifism cannot affect that person. Merlin's time was frozen by her ability and she was thus not affected, so it stands to reason that since Ban's time is eternal, Pacifism cannot affect him either. Alternatively, it just means that Merascylla isn't dead. On the contrary, why aren't you arguing about why Estarossa isn't affected by Pacifism? He clearly killed Meliodas, yet has none of the excuses Ban or Merlin has with regards to eternal time/life.

Why was Repose and Patience not activated? Simply because Meliodas did not break those Commandments. This argument of yours is particularly weak, since neither of their effects nor their triggers have been revealed. And precisely because Meliodas is no stranger to those commandments, he would know very well how to not fall for them. Until it is revealed what they do, no one needs to give you an answer.

Also, a possible answer to the conundrum of Meliodas's 'sudden' hatred for the 10 Commandments could be that he hates Estarossa and Estarossa only. It was barely a second when Estarossa came in and stopped him, yes. He went up to and touched his sword, and at that very moment the Love Commandment activated and dissipated the Revenge Counter. Meliodas has acknowledged and interacted with most of the 10 Commandments. All, except for Estarossa. You could argue that he barely interacted with Merascylla and Graylord too, but Estarossa is his own younger brother. He greets his youngest brother, but not the one who idolized him, who fought with him all the way up to his betrayal and who is known to have some sort of relationship with Elizabeth in the past that led to him appearing in her dream(as proven in his entry in the most recent fanbook)? Up until his death he did not speak to him, did not look at him in the eye, did not bother to acknowledge him, and Estarossa had to crush his ribcage just so he can hear his voice directed towards him again. If his forced avoidance was not Mel doing his very hardest to avoid being influenced by his own hatred and thus the Love Commandment, then I don't know why he wouldn't at least greet Estarossa the way he did Zeldris.
Holy shit you out of your mind??? Mera isnt dead???? Esta said it himseld he would kill if ban didnt do it. What drugs you been taking????? I am sorry but ban hates the whole demon clan and that includes allthe commandments please improve your knowledge before bringing up your opnions.... For your information ban hated merascylla and called her a bitch before snapping a neck how come did fox hunt worked then???? Alright if meliodas knows much about the commandments, logically he shouldnt fall for their decree..... love suddenly appears from nowhere, how long are you gonna manipulate the truth??? It doesnt make sense....
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Revenge counter doesn't require magic. Hendrickson said so and noted that Meliodas didn't even have any magic left to use his full counter abilities. The 10C also said he shut his magic off and wasn't using it. Meliodas did become lethargic, he needed ban to lift him to his knees despite the fact that Revenge Counter doesn't make him weak. Also we said Zeldris's piety effect acting slowly was a theory already. I don't need to refer back to the manga. However you saying that Meliodas needs magic to use Revenge counter goes against Hendrickson's own words and the words of the 10C. Saying Meliodas wasn't lethargic goes against the evidence of Ban having to lift him to his feet, despite the fact that he could stand fine seconds earlier.
I am sorry but gowther said the otherwise. Grey hendrickson doesnt have power checking ability like gowther so i will stick to four eyes...
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
He hated dolor and gloxinia and that was obvious. How come ban didnt hate estarossa??? Lol estarossa must be dead thats why his commandment is off just like the demon king said, get killed or defeat them. Meliodas showed no love to zeldris like esta did nor did he even bother talking to him. I am bringing up the others up because he went against most of the commandments decree and only got affected by two of them??? Do i look like a kid??? Sorry to say but your tricks wont work here. You are the one arguing against truth, if u have a pair of eyes to see the fight, its obvious he wasnt affected... just because demon king and mel said it, it now becomes fact ok fine. By the way estarossa wouldnt give a shit to step in and finish mel off. If he was interested, he would have been the first one to attack him.

Gorilla tomato. Nah u dont understand the concept. U see both blackout and revenge counter requires opponent and self magic, its just that blackout render enemy's magic useless whereas revenge counter is used against the enemy themselves. What i am trying to tell is u still need magic to manipulate your enemy's magic. And now zeldris decree affects lower power level easily, proof?? Neither there are proof that mel was lethargic... By the way fraudrin himself said things about zeldris piety. Kindly read back the chapter....
How was it obvious? He clearly didn't hate them. Just re-read the chapter...
Estarossa isn't dead, Meliodas DIED and got rid of the two decrees. He was affected, but his death resulted in the removal of the curses.
Meliodas doesn't hate Zeldris, what even are you trying to say? Not showing love doesn't mean you hold hatred.
Okay, now you're changing your words. You firstly stated that Meliodas knows their decrees so he wouldn't be affected by them, and now you're asking why he was affected by "only" two of them... what? 2 is plenty.
What truth? It was confirmed, lol. He was affected, it doesn't matter if you wanted him not to. Please read your statement in bold and tell me you're not joking... If it's said by two people that Mel was affected, he WAS affected.
He would, as he was gonna kill Mera for interfering. He wanted to kill Meliodas.
 

Gaggen

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
574
Reaction score
385
Age
28
Country
Malaysia
How was it obvious? He clearly didn't hate them. Just re-read the chapter...
Estarossa isn't dead, Meliodas DIED and got rid of the two decrees. He was affected, but his death resulted in the removal of the curses.
Meliodas doesn't hate Zeldris, what even are you trying to say? Not showing love doesn't mean you hold hatred.
Okay, now you're changing your words. You firstly stated that Meliodas knows their decrees so he wouldn't be affected by them, and now you're asking why he was affected by "only" two of them... what? 2 is plenty.
What truth? It was confirmed, lol. He was affected, it doesn't matter if you wanted him not to. Please read your statement in bold and tell me you're not joking... If it's said by two people that Mel was affected, he WAS affected.
He would, as he was gonna kill Mera for interfering. He wanted to kill Meliodas.
I am saying he shouldnt get affected because he knows them well. if he got affected as you said then why two??? Its obvious estarossa was defeated or probably even dead by escanor's hands....
 
Top