Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015-2016] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[savethecat]

Argument is getting a bit annoying. just make up and call it a day

 

[Tamil]

Argument is getting a bit annoying. just make up and call it a day

You're right. It's getting tedious. I'll call it a day and end it with that.

 

[yonkouproductions]

 

[Varus]

I do not care that much since it is only Giga but shouldn't the order be HQ then SNS then BnHA then WT?
Yuki Tabata honestly does not deserve the support he is getting but that is what you get when you are the editor's puppet. The guy's art is good but he keeps fucking up his manga over and over again just read the latest chapter where he introduces characters from a spin-off like they've been there from the start. I would say this is the best chance he could've gotten from Jump and I doubt he'd make it on his own next time, maybe with someone who can write but I do not know.

 

[Ihore]

That hairclip looks strange.

 

[Gikiseima]

Another romcom by komi?
I'm done

 

[CuriousReborn]

Blonde Raku and long hair Tsugumi is all im seeing from that one shot.

 

[Leoat12]

Now I will have to have a magazine with Black Cover on the cover for the sake of Nisekoi and Komi Naoshi. Sometimes some sacrifices must be made...

 

[Mammo]

this is a wsj discussion thread right? so people that are discussing toriko (a wsj title) with walls of texts aren't doing anything wrong, let them be, if you're not interested in their argument just don't read it

But the real question is, will his manga make us cry more than an anime fan on prom night?

the real question is will there be pizza explosions

I do not care that much since it is only Giga but shouldn't the order be HQ then SNS then BnHA then WT?
Yuki Tabata honestly does not deserve the support he is getting but that is what you get when you are the editor's puppet. The guy's art is good but he keeps fucking up his manga over and over again just read the latest chapter where he introduces characters from a spin-off like they've been there from the start. I would say this is the best chance he could've gotten from Jump and I doubt he'd make it on his own next time, maybe with someone who can write but I do not know.

that doesn't have to the order of the covers since since Bnha >Sns

I agree about the stupidity of BC latest chapter
this entire thing is rubbing me the wrong way, I feel like he's extorting his readers into buying the light novel to get the full picture and how is that different from vidyagames industry bullsh*t?

I really hope this doesn't become a trend

 

[savethecat]

this is a wsj discussion thread right? so people that are discussing toriko (a wsj title) with walls of texts aren't doing anything wrong, let them be, if you're not interested in their argument just don't read it



the real question is will there be pizza explosions



all that he does is trolling, just ignore him



that doesn't have to the order of the covers since since Bnha >Sns

I agree about the stupidity of BC latest chapter
this entire thing is rubbing me the wrong way, I feel like he's extorting his readers into buying the light novel to get the full picture and how is that different from vidyagames industry bullsh*t?

I really hope this doesn't become a trend

It was mainly just the large walls of text. Got a bit tedious having to scroll so much everytime coming to this page on mobile

 

[xAsum0x]

Didn't believe it until I read the chap. Dude literally just slapped em in like they already existed lol

 

[Nayrael]

I agree about the stupidity of BC latest chapter
this entire thing is rubbing me the wrong way, I feel like he's extorting his readers into buying the light novel to get the full picture and how is that different from vidyagames industry bullsh*t?

I really hope this doesn't become a trend

Indeed. I tried my hand in Marvel comics by reading the new "Steve Rogers: Captain America" but... to follow the story you also have to read "Captain America: Sam Wilson", "Uncanny Avengers", "Civil War II", "Thunderbolts" and so on. So I gave up as I don't want to be a part of this crossover hell. Just imagine that, if you wanted to understand the story of Naruto, that you have to follow the main story in WSJ, it's spin-off in Young Jump, it's spin-off in Jump SQ, it's spin-off in Light Novels, and so on. A horror I tell 'ya, but both this and what Marvel is doing have a financial benefit (readers have to buy more stuff).

But on other hand, we have the Boruto issue where they are adapting the movie so that the readers would not need to watch a movie spin-off to understand the story. And people are annoyed by it.

 

[Tamil]

Is it just me or does anyone find Mangastream team's imitation of the WSJ author comments to be cringy?

I.E -> http://mangastream.com/r/wsjac/#18/3735/3

Also, how long do we have to wait for the BC OVA? Will we get it the same week or have to wait a lot longer?

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Number 1 looks like something out of Bakuman. Does Viz only put up the chapters for non subscribers n their website? Don't see the Jump Starts on their app.

 

[iceemperor]

I agree about the stupidity of BC latest chapter
this entire thing is rubbing me the wrong way, I feel like he's extorting his readers into buying the light novel to get the full picture and how is that different from vidyagames industry bullsh*t?

I really hope this doesn't become a trend

That was pretty much completely out of left field. Only the few 10k people that bought the light novel are going to know who they are and it wasnt even like their roles in the light novel are pretty much irrelevant to the main plot. If that was the case, then they can be brought in with little introduction but now they're going to play a huge part in the upcoming arc and Asta has a good history, being a pupil of the guy, so it will alienate a good amount of readers, especially those kids that only read weekly jump, which the story is written for.

 

[WyldViolet]

That was pretty much completely out of left field. Only the few 10k people that bought the light novel are going to know who they are and it wasnt even like their roles in the light novel are pretty much irrelevant to the main plot. If that was the case, then they can be brought in with little introduction but now they're going to play a huge part in the upcoming arc and Asta has a good history, being a pupil of the guy, so it will alienate a good amount of readers, especially those kids that only read weekly jump, which the story is written for.

Yeah... Honestly, it it wasn't for the art I wouldn't even be ironically reading Black Clover.
Reading a text only version of Black Clover sounds like literal torture.
Perhaps we'll end up getting a flashback arc that covers some of the light novel, or maybe Tabata will just be ultra hacky lazy and let whoever does the series adaptation adapt the light novel as an anime arc.

 

[iceemperor]

Random adaptation theorizations


Yeah... Honestly, it it wasn't for the art I wouldn't even be ironically reading Black Clover.
Reading a text only version of Black Clover sounds like literal torture.
Perhaps we'll end up getting a flashback arc that covers some of the light novel, or maybe Tabata will just be ultra hacky lazy and let whoever does the series adaptation adapt the light novel as an anime arc.

That honestly might happen only if Pierrot or Toei get the TV series. I still believe that Pierrot will get the series and it will get Twin Star Exorcists' evening timeslot. Pierrot gave that series that only has around 9 volumes of content released an over 2-cour adaptation.

 

[Hero Kage]

Didn't believe it until I read the chap. Dude literally just slapped em in like they already existed lol

I just thought I had already forgotten these character by the way I normally rush through Black Clover chapters. After coming here and hearing I wouldn't even be able to know them. At least I know my brain is functioning right but I have to ask why the editor didn't step in and told Tabata to not use characters that only fraction of readers would know or even care about,
It's like: "You know this guys we know since I don't know when" - 'cause we really don't KNOW(!) - "they are gonna help us for reasons I never told you about"

 

[WyldViolet]

Did Tabata even write the light novel or is he just including actual "filler" characters in canon because why not, he's Tabata?

 

[SharkBait]

Also, how long do we have to wait for the BC OVA? Will we get it the same week or have to wait a lot longer?

whenever they offer it on disc, usually with a future volume