Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015-2016] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[savethecat]

Please let Toriko's replacement be Galaxy Gangs

 

[Mammo]

since when do GFC losers get serialized before the winners?

and speaking of overrated oneshots, I'm so glad Minori is doing something new that isn't doing Gold or WWW cuz both sucked imo

 

[savethecat]

since when do GFC losers get serialized before the winners?

and speaking of overrated oneshots, I'm so glad Minori is doing something new that isn't doing Gold or WWW cuz both sucked imo

Haven't there been winners that didn't get serialized at all?

 

[Mammo]

no, every single winner have been serialized after its victory, the award have the word "future" in it
Takaya
Overtime
Nurarihyon no Mago
Beelzebub
Metallica Metalluca
Ikkyuu (what happen to the 2 authors?)
Hungry joker
Himedol
Devilyman
Toteko

 

[TyVip]

Haven't there been winners that didn't get serialized at all?

As far as GFC goes, no

Devily-man (2014) - flopped, 2 volumes
After School☆Idol (2012) - flopped, 2 volumes
Hungry Joker (2011) - flopped, 3 volumes

Kikai Tonchi Banashi Hanasaka Ikkyuu (2010) - flopped, 2 volumes
Metallica Metalluca (2009) - flopped, 3 volumes
Beelzebub (2008) - ran for 6 years (2009-2015)
Nurarihyon no Mago (2007) - ran for 4 years (2008-2012)

Usagi to Kame to Strike (2005) - flopped, 3 volumes
Takaya - Otonari-san no Panic!! (2004) - 5 volumes

2006 and 2013 have no official GFC. But Hinomaru Zumou is running 2 years strong.

and Sket Dance in 2006

 

[savethecat]

no, every single winner have been serialized after its victory, the award have the word "future" in it
Takaya
Overtime
Nurarihyon no Mago
Beelzebub
Metallica Metalluca
Ikkyuu (what happen to the 2 authors?)
Hungry joker
Himedol
Devilyman
Toteko

Aaaah. My mistake

 

[Ihore]

Muhyo & Roji didn't win in 2004 but it was serialized and managed to run for 18 volumes. it wasn't a bit hit though and never got an adaption.
2006 there was no GFC but 3 one-shots by Newcomers and Sket Dance came from that.

 

[WyldViolet]

Wow. I just realized that Mitsutoshi has all of his works end abruptly/cancelled.

1. Seikimatsu Leader Den Takeshi! was ended suddenly due to the sex scandal.
2. Ring never had a proper end and was cancelled (correct me if I'm wrong)
3. Toriko had a sudden end


Btw, just ignore Chibi or those anime YouTubers lol.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 2, 2016, Original Post Date: Nov 2, 2016 ---

Oh man King of lightning is going to rage.

Huh, it's almost like it's a fate shared by the overwhelming majority of mangaka serialized in Weekly Shonen Jump.

 

[Ravellino]

since when do GFC losers get serialized before the winners?

and speaking of overrated oneshots, I'm so glad Minori is doing something new that isn't doing Gold or WWW cuz both sucked imo

2011 Takamagahara loses the GFC and get serialized before Hungry joker

 

[Mammo]

well, I stand corrected

 

[WyldViolet]

2011 Takamagahara loses the GFC and get serialized before Hungry joker

Takamagahara, now that was a baffling serialization.
An example of why just because you try to pull of Gintama/Beelzebub/Medaka Box esque meta comedy doesn't mean it's necessarily going to be funny or good.

 

[G_I_A]

no, every single winner have been serialized after its victory, the award have the word "future" in it
Takaya
Overtime
Nurarihyon no Mago
Beelzebub
Metallica Metalluca
Ikkyuu (what happen to the 2 authors?)
Hungry joker
Himedol
Devilyman
Toteko

Regarding the 2 authors of Ikkyuu, they did Smoky B.B. (2 volumes flop)

Also, I'm just looking forward new works from Tamura, Iwamoto and Tadatoshi

 

[ChocoBar9]

Takamagahara, now that was a baffling serialization.
An example of why just because you try to pull of Gintama/Beelzebub/Medaka Box esque meta comedy doesn't mean it's necessarily going to be funny or good.

It didn't work for Beelzebub and Medaka Box either.

 

[AleTheSennin]

In how many chapters is red sprite going to end?

 

[savethecat]

In how many chapters is red sprite going to end?

I'm going on a limb and saying it'll end at chapter 16. If not then, probably chapter 20 or 21

 

[tirakai]

Jump likes its batches so if Toriko is genuinely ending next issue I expect Red Sprite will end somewhere from ch 13-15 (depending on what order it, Love Rush and potentially Dance Club end in).

 

[Tamil]

"Toriko doesn't have a sudden end" Where do you took that idea? The series is ending since 42 chapters and the final battle has been going for 24 chapters. There is no sudden in that.

For the little I know Ring was always thought out to be a short series.

I'm guessing you had a typo there. Toriko did have a sudden end. In the literal sense there was no announcement warning. In the context of the series, the whole adventure to space was omitted.

It was sudden ending. Also when you factor in the long battles it's still not sudden.

 

[Leoat12]

As far as I know, nobody said that an adventure to space should happen. O.o

For they dragged this battle a lot, it seems like it is in the same for ages...

 

[Mammo]

Regarding the 2 authors of Ikkyuu, they did Smoky B.B. (2 volumes flop)

my bad, I should have been more clear, I meant what happened to them after Smoky bb

I vaguely remember skimming through their Jump Next oneshot about the humanoid military weapon and the girl, and it was ok, there are oneshots that came after it and they are already serialized

 

[savethecat]

my bad, I should have been more clear, I meant what happened to them after Smoky bb

I vaguely remember skimming through their Jump Next oneshot about the humanoid military weapon and the girl, and it was ok, there are oneshots that came after it and they are already serialized

What ever series/one shot that is, t looks really cool