Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[iceemperor]

Well Level E and Hatsukoi Limited can get an anime even though their sales is not that high, so Sesuji might have a chance.

Level E and Sesuji have a huge difference in sales. Level E only seems like it didn't sell much because it was only 3 volumes but its total copies in print is over 2.2 million. Sesuji unfortunately has gotten no where close to that.

 

[raikou]

Level E and Sesuji have a huge difference in sales. Level E only seems like it didn't sell much because it was only 3 volumes but its total copies in print is over 2.2 million. Sesuji unfortunately has gotten no where close to that.

Wait, it's that high? I got the wrong information then.

Still, if there's a chance, more dance anime couldn't be bad.

 

[Newkerzy]

I have this bomb for you people:

Straighten Up! Tops Anime!Anime!´s Poll of Complete Mangas that fans wat an anime more
https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/in...akagi-san-top-poll-of-anime-fans-want/.113360

I'm actually honestly hoping for a Psyren anime.... Honorable mention goes to Grand Blue, though. Of which I have been hoping for an anime, but sadly, the author has flat-out rejected any idea of one....

 

[Leoat12]

Those who voted for Dance-bu should have supported the series in Jump. Now it is too late, it was cancelled and no anime studio would spend a lot of money in a cancelled series.

 

[Mammo]

>total of 1,171 readers

even if everyone who voted bought 30 copies it still wouldn't do anything for it

anyway, I still think Yoko finished his work on his own

all his previous manga were short too

 

[G_I_A]

Too little too late... After HZ ends it will be this hupla all over again. I called it.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Ever since stumbling across it yesterday, I've become enamored with The Snack World. I want it all.

Excited for Robot x Laserbeam this week. Hopefully it doesn't disappiont like some of the others from this batch.

 

[G_I_A]

Ever since stumbling across it yesterday, I've become enamored with The Snack World. I want it all.

Excited for Robot x Laserbeam this week. Hopefully it doesn't disappiont like some of the others from this batch.

Really, rafa? Did you really not like any of them? :/

 

[Doughboy]

Read Yuragi 54 & 55. Last 3 covers (53-55) all butt ass naked Yuuna and Chisaki (no issue of course). Chisaki seemingly gets better and better when she's shown or gets screentime, she's hard not to like. I'm liking the focus on the best 4 girls recently (Yuuna, Sagiri, Chisaki, Oboro). Hibari sorta but that's cause she's most recent. The other girls can get screentime but honestly these 4 I'm fine with getting the most character development, harem ending has to happen or I'll never read another harem again.

Spoiler

Also good to see Yuuna's plot moving with the fortune teller and orb thing showing her alive body. I've been enjoying the slice of life but we haven't got plot since they went to the seaside beach thing during the summer.

 

[RafaFedKilla]

Really, rafa? Did you really not like any of them? :/

I enjoyed Dr. Stone a good amount. But i was supremely disappointed in U19. I knew We Can't Study wouldn't be enjoyable. Poro is fated to be another member of the 30K club, with not as enjoyable of a premise as the GFC winner. And Hungry Marie's second and third chapters were amateurish.

 

[G_I_A]

I was reading Viz when I realized Jaimin's Box skipped 2 pages from Hungry Marie

the 2 pages are mostly Taiga and Sagimiya's father arguing and nothing important is revealed in them so you don't miss anything if you don't read them

Fixed. Thank you.

 

[TyVip]

Excited for Robot x Laserbeam this week. Hopefully it doesn't disappiont like some of the others from this batch.

I'm in the same boat.

Read Yuragi 54 & 55. Last 3 covers (53-55) all butt ass naked Yuuna and Chisaki (no issue of course). Chisaki seemingly gets better and better when she's shown or gets screentime, she's hard not to like. I'm liking the focus on the best 4 girls recently (Yuuna, Sagiri, Chisaki, Oboro). Hibari sorta but that's cause she's most recent. The other girls can get screentime but honestly these 4 I'm fine with getting the most character development, harem ending has to happen or I'll never read another harem again.

Spoiler

Also good to see Yuuna's plot moving with the fortune teller and orb thing showing her alive body. I've been enjoying the slice of life but we haven't got plot since they went to the seaside beach thing during the summer.

This may come off as a shocker but I didn't like the last few chapters of Yuuna. It looks like Tadahiro lost his magic. He shifts from the huge casts to just 4 characters.

Also, I didn't sign up for romance

 

[Nakura]

Also, I didn't sign up for romance

Pretty much how I feel as well, although I'm still enjoying it a fair amount.

 

[Tanzo]

I'm in the same boat.


This may come off as a shocker but I didn't like the last few chapters of Yuuna. It looks like Tadahiro lost his magic. He shifts from the huge casts to just 4 characters.

Also, I didn't sign up for romance

The romance was foreshadowed since the beginning, dude. Dunno what you were expecting. Maybe it's the big amount at one time you didn't like?
I would like more comfy just SOL chaps though. He does need to utilize more of his cast, I agree.
No more Oboro chapters please though, hers are the most boring

 

[SkerllyFC]

In another topic, which training arc you found out to be the best in a Jump series? And why it has a good significance in the story? I may have watched the Kenshin movies, but the training arc in the third one felt more like a moral test for Kenshin, as well as the self-discovery of his purpose with his oath to not kill people, which I find very significant for Kenshin´s character.

 

[savethecat]

Naruto learning the Rasengan was a pretty awesome training arc. It felt really satisfying when he was finally able to do it.

And I really like when Hinata trained at old Ukai's house in Haikyuu because of how laid back it was

 

[TyVip]

The romance was foreshadowed since the beginning, dude. Dunno what you were expecting. Maybe it's the big amount at one time you didn't like?
I would like more comfy just SOL chaps though. He does need to utilize more of his cast, I agree.
No more Oboro chapters please though, hers are the most boring

probably that, the past 10 chapters were all Hibari, Chisaki, Yuuna with a little bit of Sagiri sprinkle on top. Only 1 shenanigan chapter (Wunderkammer). Bring back that Ojou-sama from chapter 20

Heck, even Japanese readers agree with me.

In another topic, which training arc you found out to be the best in a Jump series? And why it has a good significance in the story? I may have watched the Kenshin movies, but the training arc in the third one felt more like a moral test for Kenshin, as well as the self-discovery of his purpose with his oath to not kill people, which I find very significant for Kenshin´s character.

Nothing beat Dragonball Kid Goku/Gohan training montage.

Master Roshi, Korin and later Piccolo.

 

[G_I_A]

Should we expect jump raws to come earlier this week?

Edit: we should, march 20 is spring equinox and this week's release is supposed to go out next week.

 

[Tanzo]

Should we expect jump raws to come earlier this week?

Next Jump issue releases officially on the 18th (Sat) so yes.

 

[Nakura]

Weekly WSJ Manga Sales Rankings
1. Haikyu!! 25
2. Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Souma 23
5. World Trigger 18
9. Black Clover 10
25. Kimetsu no Yaiba 5
62. Samon the Summoner 8
97. Chronicle of Isobe ~Life is Hard~ 13