Games Mafia Game 55 - Overwatch - END GAME

[gnut]

Thanks for the experience everyone. It was fun

I looked at your actions...you played the hell outta that barkeep role
Had asia and demon nite 1

 

[Purity of Magi]

She was amazing, really. The other newbies were nice too, but Belserion was literally the highlight of them all. The second newbie player that I really admire (James was the first one ofc.. Never forget that GoT game lol)

 

[Hakuteiken]

Thats pretty low...lets face it.
There 2parts to the game....the figuring out and the lying.
Lets just say i got pretty good at lying.

I don't acknowledge people bullshitting their way through games, so, I will admit it's low.

 

[gnut]

How about asia tried to kill magi,failed then we killed her

If you guys wanted to frame me....shoulda poisoned magi nite2 lol xD

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 27, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 27, 2017 ---

I don't acknowledge people bullshitting their way through games, so, I will admit it's low.

How you mean?
You dont lie when you mafia?

 

[Demonspeed]

How about asia tried to kill magi,failed then we killed her

If you guys wanted to me....shoulda poisoned magi nite2 lol xD

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 27, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 27, 2017 ---

How you mean?
You dont lie when you mafia?

If I had been alive magi would have never been targeted.

You would have probably died.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 27, 2017 ---

I told her to target either you or Aonori but I guess she forgot or missed it. She wanted to get rid of confirmed townies too.

 

[Purity of Magi]

How about asia tried to kill magi,failed then we killed her

If you guys wanted to frame me....shoulda poisoned magi nite2 lol xD

You have made yourself a target again, you freaking old gramps faggot.

Spoiler

Still waiting for the day when we will be mafia together lol.

 

[Hardy]

I think that, in the last 10 games, 7 have been mafia victories, which is pretty huge. Is the game balance -not yours specifically Gry, but the rules themselves- to blame or just the general town's play minor some individualities?

Followed the game here and there, grats on the newbies for their great performances o/

Day 1 lynch list is getting massive though, even more considering greg is always mafia

 

[gnut]

Just wanna say @GrySun
I found the ult to be an easy troll from day 1.....but that from mafia perspective.guess town couldnt get away with lying about numbers

 

[Hardy]

gnut getting PotG literally sums up my entire OW experience.

At least it wasn't a toblerone fucking around while his turret did the job.

 

[gnut]

I think that, in the last 10 games, 7 have been mafia victories, which is pretty huge. Is the game balance -not yours specifically Gry, but the rules themselves- to blame or just the general town's play minor some individualities?

Followed the game here and there, grats on the newbies for their great performances o/

Day 1 lynch list is getting massive though, even more considering greg is always mafia

And when im town they suspect me.
Guess it will be a rule now.....
Like kdowns is always afk or demon is always mafia or zasz is afk

 

[Hakuteiken]

How you mean?
You dont lie when you mafia?

I don't lie about my allegiance.
I don't ever call myself a Townie, to begin with.

Part of the reason this game ended up being extra boring for me, since I got confirmed through my death and resurrection.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 27, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 27, 2017 ---

At least it wasn't a toblerone fucking around while his turret did the job.

Funnily enough, xnut was an excellent Torbjörn impersonation, as well.

 

[GrySun]

I think that, in the last 10 games, 7 have been mafia victories, which is pretty huge. Is the game balance -not yours specifically Gry, but the rules themselves- to blame or just the general town's play minor some individualities?

From 45(Magi game) to 54(JoJo game) are 10 games, where mafia won 6 games and town won 4 games if we don't count this one, if we do then it's 7-3 for mafia indeed. All 4 games I played I was town and town lost all of those 4, and from what I recall in those games I wouldn't call them badly balanced role-wise(except maybe the LoL game with the 2 mafia lovers).
If we disregard the games' role lists(which are usually fine I think) I would put the blame mostly on bad/afk-ish townplay.

As for the rules themselves, I'm not sure. Apart from the roles we're having this like any normal mafia game. There's the number of mafias per game to consider but that's fine I'd say, unless in some games there were more mafias than there should've been.

What do you think? Are some changes needed and which ones? I always thought that mafia is easier to win with in the mafia game so that checks out for me.
But I also think that if we analized the 7 games mafia won we'd find a lot of bad townplay at work or even townies sabotaging town. Like lawl did in some games. Not saying bad town was the only reason, some of these games could've been balanced in mafia's favor somehow, but I do recall at least 4 mafia-won games which were just huge town mistakes.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 27, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 27, 2017 ---

Just wanna say @GrySun
I found the ult to be an easy troll from day 1.....but that from mafia perspective.guess town couldnt get away with lying about numbers

Nobody actually lied about their % from what I could see, especially not on day 2 where everyone revealed. One could troll with theories on "what makes the ult charge go up" which is what I noticed you doing often to justify votes etc. And I think that's fine, they let themselves be played. Which isn't a hard thing apparently, since we had people bandwagoning someone(desin maybe) because he liked some posts...

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 27, 2017 ---

Also IMO it's easier to fuck up as a townie than as a mafia. But that's in the nature of the game more than anything else.

 

[Lady pompom]

Thanks for hosting the game, @GrySun and @WithYouInSpirit . I laughed a lot on this game.

gnut and SonOfDaws never expected it of you two Lambu was really the janitor.

I never lied about my "targets", then you can imagine my tension when my "target" blatantly asks me whom I targeted on N1 (Holt , yes, I'm talking about you).

Sorry @Erinyes and @Demonspeed , it was fun playing with you.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Congrats to the Mafia, especially Daws, that bandwagon catching onto life was quite surprising. Of course Lawl and Magi being their secret weapon.

PUWEEEAAAAAAAAZ TRUST YOUR DET NEXT MINNA_SAMA

 

[Lady pompom]

How about asia tried to kill magi,failed then we killed her

If you guys wanted to frame me....shoulda poisoned magi nite2 lol xD

Congrats! Mafia wins!

By the way, I did poison Magi on N2 (but it didn't work), but on N5 I had lost my patience and tried to kill her with a clean shoot (since my poison looked like water, it wasn't really killing anyone, it worked on the N4, though and killed Qixus and xnut )

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

@Lovemagi thank you for killing the demon scrub

 

[Purity of Magi]

@Asia Run In the end my comic really was fittable for you and Erin. Just like in game; Pharah and Mercy = best combo.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 27, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 27, 2017 ---

@Lovemagi thank you for killing the demon scrub

You're welcome buddy. I have avenged you in the end. Our mission has succeeded!

 

[Lady pompom]

@Asia Run In the end my comic really was fittable for you and Rin. Just like in game; Pharah and Mercy = best combo.

I panicked right on the 1st day when you said to me and Erin "I know your secret", I though you had figured out we were from the same mafia

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

still i was frankly suprised, how does one look at demon's posts and not think he is 100% mafia

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 27, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 27, 2017 ---

ok @GrySun put me on mafia side next time town needs to win once in a while

 

[gnut]

Congrats! Mafia wins!

By the way, I did poison Magi on N2 (but it didn't work), but on N5 I had lost my patience and tried to kill her with a clean shoot (since my poison looked like water, it wasn't really killing anyone, it worked on the N4, though and killed Qixus and xnut )

@GrySun
Kinda bullshit the hider dies when someone they hid behind was poisoned the night before....unless xnut was poisoned the nite before...no?