Crazy Theories and Predictions

Finale

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2007
Messages
527
Reaction score
100
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Haven't posted in ages. My theory is that Gol D Roger is Katakuri's father. Katakuri has an insane observation haki and might have a suppressed conqueror's haki from serving under BM. BM has shown a tendency to beat and assault children she doesn't like or that remind her of something painful. What if Roger was able to get the ponegylph info cause him and BM had a thing? Roger wouldn't have to worry about Kata being targeted by the marines since he is protected by BM unlike the situation with Rouge and Ace.We see Kata covers his face and has scars on each side of his face. What if BM saw him smile and it sent her into a batshit rage and she gave her own son a Glasgow Smile to make it so he wouldn't want to show his face or smile again because it reminded her too much of Roger? If the scarf comes off Luffy might see the resemblance between him and Ace thats when the info will drop.
 

keeper1h

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
732
Reaction score
702
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
Surely there's something odd about Katakuri, and is its loyalty towards BM.
He has also old eyes and he's cold, plus the scarf.
I believe that BM saved him as a kid when he was captured, tortured and nearly killed, and this explains why he's going to certain extents to protect the crazy old hag, and also explains the whole "i've seen horrible things" glare.
Chiffon was treated badly and planned to kill BM, not to protet her "no matter what".
 

I Am Atomic

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2014
Messages
2,377
Reaction score
3,208
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
I do not know if anyone else brought this up, if so I apologise.

Did Oda use Duval to foreshadow Sanji's past?

1. When Duval was born he was marked as a cursed child. When Sanji was born, he was human unlike his other siblings, therefore a unwanted/cursed child in the eyes of his father, Judge.
2. Duval had to wear an iron mask to hide from bounty hunters and marines. Sanji was forced to wear an iron mask by Judge for many reasons.
3. Duval hatred for Sanji was high since he was forced to wear the iron mask because of him. Sanji's hatred towards his father is high as well since he was forced to wear the iron mask.

That's all I could think of right now. If anyone else know more then feel free to tell me.

P.S. I got this idea when I was going to sleep. I play OPTC, where Duval was the next raid boss, so when I was thinking about how to beat it this idea popped up.
 

hokageji

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 7, 2007
Messages
4,976
Reaction score
3,744
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Now here's the theory...
Shanks was in Roger's opinion the next big pirate, possibly do what he couldnt... But Shanks not being a D couldnt fulfill the unknown prophecy (assuming the man Roger's waiting for like WB said). So Shanks decides to search for the next person.

He guesses about Roger's kid surviving and ends up in GOa kingdom looking for Garp and bringing Roger's DF gomu gomu no mi...He ends up never meeting Ace, but puts his faith of Garp's son, who is also a D. After Luffy speaks the same words Roger spoke, he passes the torch to him, giving the strawhat...

THe world saw Ace as the real Golden boy and thought his execution would do it, but Luffy poses as a serious contender now. Shanks literally bets it on him even with the knowledge Ace is around.... just a theory, a crazy theory :D
 

keeper1h

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
732
Reaction score
702
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
The government will try to offer the shichibukai position to one of the SH's, to subsequently take a crewmember away as "hostage" and keep the crew in line.
Usopp will receive the call, of course he'll refuse the position.
 

Deleted member 169696

初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Vegapunk (or one of his predecessors) experimented on kids long before Caesar. He succeeded and then Big Mom was born. However, there was a downside to VP's method. Basically, almost the same as in Caesar's case — addiction (to sweet stuff) and probably a much shorter lifespan than that of a regular human being.

Normally, Big Mom should have died long ago, but she has a very special DF power, that allows her to gather lifespan from all kinds of living creatures. So she lives, but her mental disorder is still in place.

Don't know if this has been speculated before...
 

hokageji

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 7, 2007
Messages
4,976
Reaction score
3,744
Gender
Male
Country
United States
@Pea
That is actually quite plausible.... Except it wouldn't be Vegapunk who did that. Vegapunk is expected to be much younger by age so I doubt he'll have performed the surgery.
It could be the doctor who had the ope ope no mi fruit before Law, but the fact that Big Mama is still aging puts it against that thought...

Nevertheless, the kids do act like her...
 

I Am Atomic

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2014
Messages
2,377
Reaction score
3,208
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Is there a mink traitor on Zou?

Credit: Joy_Boy Theories

What do you guys think?
 

hokageji

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 7, 2007
Messages
4,976
Reaction score
3,744
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Yea I heard the theory yesterday..... Its a discussion that deserves its own thread...
 

I Am Atomic

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2014
Messages
2,377
Reaction score
3,208
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Yea I heard the theory yesterday..... Its a discussion that deserves its own thread...
When I get time I will make a thread later unless someone else want to do it. It seems like a good theory to discuss
 

keeper1h

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
732
Reaction score
702
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
Soon it will be revealed that Kaido invaded Wano just after Gol D. Roger's execution, and our dear Momo was somehow saved from that madness by turning him into a common object... but then someone lost that thing, and he disappeared from this world until recently.
This could explain why Momo has met Roger despite his age...
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
We know from ch.876 that BM's crew wants to make a new Wedding Cake and this will involve Sanji, right?

Big Mom's power over her crew is absolute, but right now she's not using the brain.
On the other hand Sani is smart.
What if he trick a "Finally got the cake, happy happy ^W^ " BM into thinking that the cake is so delicious that a banquet must be celebrated, and all her crewmembers must sit and eat the cake?
Imagine the scene, the whole crew angrily eating the cake while everyone escapes... this would be the heaven of comedy!
 

Carabbaggio

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Sep 29, 2017
Messages
2
Reaction score
2
Age
38
Country
Mariejoa
Everyone is missing how will they be saved from big mom.
No fishmen, no jimbe, no aokiji, no shanks.

Dragon will come.

Robin is separated form the crew, she was contacted by the revolutionary army after BB destroyed Baltigo (no main casualities tho), she told dragon that his son went to Tottland, Dragon realizes how dangerous this is and how much Luffy understimated his enemy.
Next chapter we gon see a tornado wiping the sea clean (Wind Logia), then when luffy hears they all good the real 1v1 between luffy and katakuri can begin so luffy can prove to be new world worth. He will one shot him awakening
After that, since its the 20th one piece annyversary, it'll be time for luffy to meet his dad and for us to get some long awaited explanations on what the revolutionary stand for, the void century, the WG (not everything, just a little explaination).
Then luffy, after he saw with his own eyes the strenght of a Yonko, whit his new-found powers (he will destroy katakuri with his awakaning) will be realizing he can go toe to toe with Kaido and will head to Wano to get his ponygliph.
 

Deleted member 169696

初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Name Elbaf is inspired by Italian island Elba. Napoleon I was actually exiled to the island back in 1814, so I assume there could be a connection between Big Mom's hat and the aforementioned fact.
 

MOYcano 0.23

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Messages
325
Reaction score
190
Gender
Male
Country
Mexico
Shanks was in Roger's opinion the next big pirate... but Shanks, not being a D, couldn't fulfill the unknown prophecy
I wonder if you guy's would like this actual quote from Chavela Vargas:

Chavela V.: Yes, I'm Mexican.
Interviewer: But, Doña Chavela, you were born in Costa Rica.
Chavela V.: We Mexicans born wherever the #$%& we want!

Change Doña Chavela for Shanks and Mexicans for The Clan of D,
and you have my working theory for Shanks.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
My current crazy prediction:

Paramecia is the category for anything that is not Zoan nor Logia, right?

Katakuri's devil-fruit is special not because he turns into an element nor because
he is able to create said element, being both characteristics generally associated
with Logia-type users. Physical characteristics of mochi and awakening explain
both abilities as far as we known.

My guess is Katakuri in fact never ate a devil-fruit; he might be born that way and
that may be the reason why his devil-fruit power is a special paramecia.
 
Last edited:

keeper1h

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
732
Reaction score
702
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
D's are referred as "Natural Enemy of God" (神の天敵, Kami no Tenteki).

In OP world the vast sea is the result of a man-made Great Flood, created by WG to counteract the effects of the latest weapon of the lost civilization ruled by the D... the D.'s fruits. (later rebranded as "Devil's" fruits)
Then both sides built ships, but WG made Pluton.
As the soldiers of the lost civilizations were killed, their fruits scattered around the world... and since no one knows how to destroy a DF, that weapon simply went out of control, so you can find and use one just as you would do with an ak-47 in a war zone.
 

I Am Atomic

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2014
Messages
2,377
Reaction score
3,208
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
D's are referred as "Natural Enemy of God" (神の天敵, Kami no Tenteki).

In OP world the vast sea is the result of a man-made Great Flood, created by WG to counteract the effects of the latest weapon of the lost civilization ruled by the D... the D.'s fruits. (later rebranded as "Devil's" fruits)
Then both sides built ships, but WG made Pluton.
As the soldiers of the lost civilizations were killed, their fruits scattered around the world... and since no one knows how to destroy a DF, that weapon simply went out of control, so you can find and use one just as you would do with an ak-47 in a war zone.
From what I understood I thought that the Ancient Kingdom had the three ancient weapons and not WG. It's because of these weapons the Ancient Kingdom was considered the strongest. However, about 19 Kingdoms did not like the Ancient Kingdom because the King (Joy Boy) was planning on changing how the world works, such as bringing the fishmen to the surface.

Luckily for them, people from the moon came to the earth. These guys brought the devil fruits with them which had to no weakness at that time. The rebels were winning but Joyboy learned haki. Joy Boy taught others haki and they started winning, until the Marshal D family betrayed the Ancient Kingdom. This betrayal caused AK to lose. When they were sure that they would lose, the people of Wano created Poneglyphs which wrote the true history.

Why I believe the people from the moon brought DF with them? When Enel went to Fairy Vearth, he found a city of automation. With his DF he was able to turn the city on. His ship Maxim (run by his df) has the same design as the automation city. So i think that the people who built the city designed it so that it could only be run by someone who has the thunder df.

I also believe that there is DF tree. Maybe that is the national treasure Joker mentioned in the Dressrosa arc.

In the cover story of Enel we see that people from the moon has indeed travelled to the One Piece world. Drawn on the glyphs were, shandians, birkans and skypeans leaving the city because resources has run out. They travel to the One Piece world by balloons (I am not joking - there is no gravity in One Piece world). Shandians land on earth, while skypeans and birkans land on Sky Island. From what I see, Birkans had the thunder df, so when Enel grew up, he stole the df and killed all birkans except his followers.

The one who invaded and helped WG are different species, maybe space pirates, who knows. Anyway we know space travel is possible. We have also seen during the enel cover story that travelling from earth to moon you only need one helium balloon.

Most are ideas i got from reading other theories online. I cannot reference them because i do not where i read them from because these memories span across a couple of years at least.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,285
Reaction score
24,919
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
Regarding OP, at the very least the story has gone out of its way to proof it exists and to boot it is of crucial important to the story's metaplot so to speak. And not only because it is luffy's objective and finding it makes him pirate king (... for reasons) but also because it is intrinsically connected to the world government and the true history.

What is interesting here is that roger and his crewmates found this place however upon finding it they did not feel the need or at the very least did not find it appropriate to act on this. Well, either that or it turns out they are pirates and actually lied about getting to OP. I mean, in theory roger's crew made it to OP. That wasn't a handful of people, it was something like at least 20 and out of them there were a bunch whose strength would shake the world. roger was a monster, rayleigh could take an admiral in his old age... Shanks seems to have taken after roger in a way however buggy does not seem like the type to keep quiet. Can you imagine buggy being familiar with OP and keeping it quiet? Of course, it could also be the case that they are pirates, not heroes and acting on whatever they found on OP was simply not something they give two consecutive shits about and simply forgot about it.

Now, the only reason the idea that roger and co not caring about OP does not have too much ground is that roger in his dying moments basically sent every pirate in the world after OP. Which knowing what we know now seems more or less like a huge middle finger for the world government. Which is also, probably not by accident of course, what WB did. On his dying breath he told sengoku that the world government was afraid of OP and that someone that would carry the weight of centuries will find that treasure and shake the world. I am not sure if roger told WB what was in OP however depending on what WB actually did know we could make the case that just pissing of the WG would be motivation enough for them. I guess that based on this we can also make the case that roger thought he was not the man to shoulder the weight of centuries over his shoulders and thus didn't act on what he found there.

Also, going over this I got an idea. Normally we think of OP as an endgame thing. Basically that finding it will be just about the last thing that happens in the manga. Well, short of the strawhats getting to reverse mountain and climbing to complete their trip around the world. However knowing what we learned at mink country and hearing WB's words I get the impression that OP isn't the endgame but rather what triggers the endgame. WB spoke, almost prophetically, that once OP is found the world will be engulfed in a huge conflict. We have known for a while that the manga is headed for a yet bigger conflict than the WB great war. However based on this the trigger for the next conflict will definitely be OP being found.

One thing that I can't quite make sense of is how exactly luffy plays into this. Because while luffy cares about his friends, he is not quite the type to shoulder the weight of centuries. For this to play out this way luffy would have to specifically aim for the world governments final destruction. Which wouldn't make sense to me. Luffy didn't fight any of the people he fought because of their history or inherent evilness. He fought them because they screwed with him. He fought arlong over nami, crocodile over vivi, enel over sky island, lucci over robbin and so on. But if luffy was asked to bear the burden of centuries I can clearly see him telling whoever asked this to suck the fattest of rubbery dicks. Now. it is not impossible that luffy more or less ends up playing into this role however it would have to be because the world government screwed with him specifically and his friends. Not because of history and whatnot. In context it would make a fair bit more sense that dragon is the one to shoulder weight of history because he has made this his business. And that would be a perfectly reasonable endgame to be fair.
 

keeper1h

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
732
Reaction score
702
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
Luffy slow transformation into a yonko-level fighter.

Recently, we learned in the manga that Luffy heals himself at inhuman speed through food, and that he needs large amounts of it to sustain his body.

We also know that in the anime there are some scenes that are made after asking Oda's advice.
In episode 811 we're shown Luffy being repeatedly stabbed by regular blades wielded by strong fighters, without suffering any consequences at all.
Again, again, and again.
This is a killer move and normally this would kill even Luffy, so there's no point to animate something like this, without a specific reason.

To me, this is comparable to Luffy vs Motobaro - pure foreshadowing.
 

Raven

Registored User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Mar 8, 2016
Messages
3,107
Reaction score
12,870
Age
32
Gender
Female
Country
Joker
Onepiece at some point in my life was my favorite manga but it's no longer that. Now I read the manga casually, I read a chapter in a month or so, I'm not planning to catch up with my manga at all, The reason is i don't like the heading course of the manga D.Flamingo and the current arc are just a huge mess. I will just wait for the final chapter and see how it goes if it's worth it i will read it all in one go.

Since Law's fruit allows him to bring back a dead person i think he will sacrifice himself for this matter, This fruit potential exists for a reason and i think Oda will use it's special powers later on when an important character die, That person would be Luffy, We all know that gear 2 is eating up his life time plus Ivan cut 10 years of his life time that's a pure foreshadowing for Luffy's future death. I predicted this theory long time ago so maybe things have changed i don't really know.

Luffy's mother?! we don't know anything about her but i believe that i read somewhere that Oda said that she will appear soon maybe she did but i don't know. Monkey. D. Dragon, I don't think it's an actual name. Monkey and Dragon in one name is a bit absurd and can't be taken seriously, I think it's a cover up name, For that reason i think Luffy's mother is a celestial dragon and dragon wants to fight her. Oh yes! Dragon vs celestial dragon. :e3

Thank you, come again :cookiehand
 
Last edited:
Top