Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2017] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[De La Croissant]

Golem Hearts 1: Meh...diocre. The one shot was more spontaneous, now it seems they wanted to put the idea into that old established formula. I still have hopes because it is an adventure and the worldbuilding can be cool when new elements and characters come up, but the first chapter lacks personality.

 

[ElJin]

I just read Goleam Hearts 01 and it's very, very... Ok. I was expecting more "magic", a cool fight and some nice double pages, but I didn't see these things. I loved the world, it looks very expansable, but... That's it, that was the good point for me.

The main character it's really simple and kinda boring, he doesn't have self personality. And the girl's kidnap... Come on, BC's level of cliché. It was ridiculously obvious that Noah and his grandfather would save the girl and the people would love them for that.

 

[xAsum0x]

One piece was hilarious this week but I can see it triggering some folks

 

[Halloween]

Where are you guys reading Golem Hearts? Or, are you referring to the raw?

 

[ElJin]

Where are you guys reading Golem Hearts? Or, are you referring to the raw?

It's out in Brazilian Portuguese, that's why some of us have read.

 

[Aipom626]

Stone isn't a battle manga, if I had to describe it, it's like if someone made a manga about the farming part in rpgs

That's good to hear. Not really a fan of battle manga, so I think I'll check out the first few chapters.

 

[Leoat12]

eh, how do you know they're low quality if you just said you don't read them?

also, Stone isn't a battle manga, if I had to describe it, it's like if someone made a manga about the farming part in rpgs

I read World Trigger until chapter 110. You know I read 10 chapters or so of Dr. Stone before dropping.
Black Clover I don't need to read to see that it is bad quality. I don't think an entire community can get it wrong and yes, I'm talking about you guys.

 

[WyldViolet]

I read World Trigger until chapter 110. You know I read 10 chapters or so of Dr. Stone before dropping.
Black Clover I don't need to read to see that it is bad quality. I don't think an entire community can get it wrong and yes, I'm talking about you guys.

But this entire community is wrong about Yuragi?

 

[Leoat12]

But this entire community is wrong about Yuragi?

Boobs flying around hinder the judgement. XD
It is just personal preference, I know that heavy ecchi will make me dislike Yuragi, so it is another one that it is evident I will not like.

 

[Ninjaz]

A lot of brilliant chapters in this issue. One Piece had an excellent chapter this week too. I'm interested in seeing where RoboX is heading from here on.
I think I'm gonna wait for the translations of Golem Hearts ch1 at this point. I hate attempting to read raws of long chapters, the chapters usually release by the time I'm halfway through coherently reading the chapter anyways, lol.

 

[shoyoboyo]

Yeah, just finished reading the RxL chapter. Seems like they're pushing the least interesting club members to the side in favor of the more interesting members. Interested to see how this turns out.

 

[Caiops]

Great chapter of RxL, but i want more Suzaku ;-;

 

[savethecat]

With We Never Learn getting the cover next week, do you think Dr.Stone and RxL will have the covers for the following weeks

 

[Caiops]

With We Never Learn getting the cover next week, do you think Dr.Stone and RxL will have the covers for the following weeks

It will probaly be One Piece or Boku no Hero who will get the cover in 2 weeks, Jump love to give One Piece covers.

 

[SharkBait]

With We Never Learn getting the cover next week, do you think Dr.Stone and RxL will have the covers for the following weeks

BLack Clover hasnt had a cover in awhile, so one of them will be it. RxL is on its last legs, I cant see it getting another cover.

 

[savethecat]

BLack Clover hasnt had a cover in awhile, so one of them will be it. RxL is on its last legs, I cant see it getting another cover.

Black Clover got one right before the new series started, to celebrate the anime. I can't see it getting another this year

 

[Caiops]

I doesn't look like RobotxLasebeam will be ending soon after that chapter, there's so much to introduce and show yet.

 

[SharkBait]

Black Clover got one right before the new series started, to celebrate the anime. I can't see it getting another this year

Believe it, it will.

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

With We Never Learn getting the cover next week, do you think Dr.Stone and RxL will have the covers for the following weeks

I think Dr. Stone and RxL will only receive covers after issue 1.
There are several manga that do not receive covers for a long time.
Shokugeki (who can win the birthday cover), Gintama, BNHA, Haikyuu and of course One Piece.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 28, 2017, Original Post Date: Oct 28, 2017 ---

I doesn't look like RobotxLasebeam will be ending soon after that chapter, there's so much to introduce and show yet.

I saw a comment from a LiveJournal user saying that the English editor of RxL has confirmed that the series will not end soon.
I can not tell if it's true, but I hope it's real and that RxL does not end.

 

[razerxs]

The Saiki Kusuo movie made $1,704,686 its opening weekend.
For comparison, Jojo only made 1.5 million, Kuroko's Basketball made 1.7 million and Gintama opened at $6 million.

With We Never Learn getting the cover next week, do you think Dr.Stone and RxL will have the covers for the following weeks

Nah. WNL was left out when the others were pushed a while back.

3 covers left in the year. One Piece is probably getting the No 1 issue again.
I'l guess: MHA poll results, Kimetsu's full reprint, and Yuragi anime annonuncement.